Key takeaways
- Quotes in cents per minute, per call and flat fees only compare when you bill the same month of your own calls under each.
- Counting rules move the bill more than the rate: in the example month, rounding and after-call work add $437 at the same per-minute rate.
- Ask whether robocalls and hang-ups are billed; consumers filed 1.6 million robocall complaints with the FTC in fiscal 2025[2].
- Size a flat plan for your busy season, not January, and read the night and weekend surcharges before the headline rate.
Three quotes that cannot be compared
Ask three answering services for a quote and you will usually get three answers that cannot be compared: one in cents per minute, one per call and one as a monthly fee with an allowance and an overage rate. Each looks reasonable on its own. The only fair test is to run the same month of your calls through all three and see where each bill grows.
This guide does that with one example month for a mid-sized brokerage line. The call mix is invented and so are the rates, chosen to keep the arithmetic easy rather than to match any provider. The mechanics are what carry over to your own quotes: rounding, what counts as a billable minute, which calls are billed at all, and what happens in a busy month.
Minutes Γ rate
Per minute: grows with call length, rounding, hold time and after-call work
Calls Γ rate
Per call: grows with call count, ten-second hang-ups included unless excluded
Fee + overage
Flat: fixed until the allowance runs out, then billed at the overage rate
Hours Γ rate
Staffed hours, as with a virtual receptionist: grows with the hours you book, busy or quiet
Many quotes combine two of these, such as a monthly fee with per-minute overage.
The example month
Example: a brokerage main line serving about 20 agents takes 410 calls in a month. Lead calls run longest, because a good operator asks six or seven questions. Agent, lender and vendor calls are short. A slice of every month is junk: robocalls, solicitors, wrong numbers and callers who hang up before the greeting ends.
| Call type | Calls | Average length | Talk minutes |
|---|---|---|---|
| New buyer and seller leads | 110 | 3.4 min | 374 |
| Showing requests | 80 | 2.6 min | 208 |
| Agents, lenders, title and vendors | 70 | 1.5 min | 105 |
| Past and current clients | 60 | 2.2 min | 132 |
| Robocalls, solicitors and wrong numbers | 60 | 0.6 min | 36 |
| Hang-ups under 10 seconds | 30 | 0.1 min | 3 |
| Total | 410 | 2.1 min | 858 |
Your own version of this table takes about an hour. Most phone systems export call detail records with a start time and a duration; estimating brokerage call volume walks through it, and peak call times for real estate offices shows where the volume tends to bunch.
What actually gets billed
The talk minutes in the table are not what a per-minute service bills. Several things push the billable number up, and quotes rarely show them side by side.
- Rounding. Some plans round each call up to the next full minute; others bill in 30-second or 6-second increments. In the example, rounding every call up to a full minute turns 858 talk minutes into about 1,069 billable ones, roughly a quarter more. Six-second billing gives about 879.
- After-call work. Some services bill the time an operator spends writing and sending the message. In the example, 30 seconds for each of the 320 calls that leave a message adds 160 minutes.
- Hold and transfer time. Ask whether the meter runs while a caller waits on hold, or while a transfer rings an agent's mobile and nobody picks up.
- Junk calls. A robocall answered is a call billed unless the plan says otherwise. In the example, 90 of the 410 calls are junk or hang-ups.
- Outbound minutes. If the service returns missed calls or rings callers back to confirm details, ask whether those outbound minutes are metered at the same rate.
- Seats and lines. Some plans charge per agent in the directory or per forwarded number, a cost that grows with the team rather than with the calls.
- Surcharges. Night, weekend and holiday rates, per-call minimums, setup fees and charges for changing the script.
Junk is not shrinking on its own. Consumers filed 1,601,611 robocall complaints with the FTC's Do Not Call program in fiscal 2025, up from 1,099,229 a year earlier[2]. Business lines get their share of robocalls and solicitors, and under per-minute or per-call billing you pay for every one the service answers. How to screen spam, robocalls and solicitor calls covers filtering them before anyone picks up.
Source: Federal Trade Commission, 2025[2]
Show the data
| Fiscal year | Robocall complaints |
|---|---|
| FY2021 | 3,427,949 |
| FY2022 | 1,844,210 |
| FY2023 | 1,157,748 |
| FY2024 | 1,099,229 |
| FY2025 | 1,601,611 |
The same month, billed six ways
Now price the example month. The rates are example figures picked for round numbers: $1.25 a minute, $2.50 a call, or a $750 monthly fee covering 600 minutes with overage at $1.40 a minute. Swap in real quotes once you have them; the structure of the comparison stays the same.
| Billing model | What is billed | Example bill |
|---|---|---|
| Per minute, each call rounded up to a full minute | 1,069 minutes at $1.25 | $1,336 |
| Per minute, 6-second increments | 879 minutes at $1.25 | $1,099 |
| Per minute, rounded, plus 30 seconds of after-call work per message | 1,229 minutes at $1.25 | $1,536 |
| Per call, every call | 410 calls at $2.50 | $1,025 |
| Per call, junk and hang-ups not billed | 320 calls at $2.50 | $800 |
| Flat $750 for 600 minutes, rounded minutes, $1.40 overage | $750 plus 469 overage minutes | $1,407 |
In the example, the headline rate barely matters; the counting rules do. The same $1.25 per-minute rate produces bills $437 apart depending on rounding and after-call work. Per-call pricing looks good here because lead calls are long, and better still once junk is excluded. The flat plan does worst because it was sized for a quieter month than this one.
Example: in a quiet month of 200 calls with the same mix, rounded minutes fall to about 522. The flat plan still bills $750, while rounded per-minute billing comes to about $652 and per-call billing to $500. A flat plan pays off only when usage sits close to its allowance month after month: below it you pay for minutes you never used, above it you pay overage.
Where each model breaks
Each model has a call mix that makes it expensive. Match the model to the calls you actually get, not to the month the salesperson used.
- Per minute breaks on long calls. If most of your volume is new leads and your intake script is thorough, every good question adds to the bill, and the intake is the last thing you should cut.
- Per call breaks on short calls. A line heavy with agents checking on showings, lenders chasing documents and ten-second hang-ups pays full price for each of them.
- Flat breaks on seasonality. A plan sized on January runs into overage by spring. New sellers have historically climbed to nearly 1.4 times their start-of-year level by the end of June[3], and listing calls tend to rise with them.
- Staffed hours break on idle time. A booked block of receptionist hours costs the same whether the phone rings twice or forty times.
Some plans also charge more for nights and weekends, which is exactly when real estate clients are free: only 30% of employed people work on an average weekend day[4]. If your call log shows Saturday as your busiest day, read the surcharge schedule before the rate card.
Why a minute costs more than the wage
Per-minute prices can look steep next to a wage. O*NET puts the 2025 median for switchboard operators, including answering service, at $18.57 an hour[1], about 31 cents for each paid minute. But a service also pays for the minutes between calls, plus benefits, supervision, software and the extra operators it needs on a Saturday morning. Private employers paid an average of $36.73 per hour worked for office and administrative support staff in June 2026[5], before any of that overhead.
That is the real comparison when you weigh a service against handling the phones in-house. A per-minute plan bills talk time. A person staffing your line is paid for every hour the phone might ring. The calculator below prices only the talk time of the example month at in-house cost, which flatters the in-house option; the waiting between calls is what it leaves out. How much staff time phone calls take measures that side in more detail.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls a weekday | 19 |
| Average talk minutes per call | 2.1 |
| Share of calls counted | 100% |
| Employer cost per staffed hour | $36.73 |
| Calls a month | 412 |
| Staff hours on these calls | 14 |
| Hours handed off | 14 |
| Monthly value of that staff time | $530 |
How it is worked out: Calls a day Γ 21.7 working days Γ minutes per call Γ· 60 Γ share handled = hours; hours Γ hourly cost.
Assumptions
- Hourly cost is what private employers paid per hour worked for office and administrative support staff in June 2026, wages plus benefits.[5]
- Calls a weekday and minutes per call come from the example month: 410 calls and 858 talk minutes spread over 21.7 weekdays.
Example. Talk time only: a staffed desk is also paid for the time between calls, so compare quotes with the hours you would have to cover.
Example: about 14 hours of talk a month at that rate is roughly $530. Covering the same line from 9 to 6 on weekdays alone would take about 195 staffed hours, around $7,160 at the same rate. Even at the $25.20 an hour private employers paid part-time workers in June 2026[6], those 195 hours come to about $4,900, and evenings and weekends are still uncovered.
Make every quote answer the same questions
Send them your month
Give each provider your call log, or a summary table like the one above with durations, and ask for the bill that month would have produced under their plan.
Ask how calls are rounded
Full minute, 30 seconds or 6 seconds, and whether rounding applies to each call or to the monthly total.
Ask what the meter includes
Hold time, transfer ringing, after-call work, outbound callbacks and time spent retrieving voicemail.
Ask which calls are free
Robocalls, wrong numbers, hang-ups under a set number of seconds and calls transferred straight back to you.
Ask about the busy month
The overage rate, whether unused minutes roll over, and what the bill looks like in a month 40% busier than your quietest, for example.
Read the exit terms
Minimum term, notice period, setup fees, and what happens to recordings, messages and any phone number they issued if you leave.
Line the answers up in the six-row table and the cheapest plan for your call mix is usually obvious. Then check it against coverage, because a low bill from a service that sends vague messages is still the wrong choice. What a real estate phone answering service should handle and whether an answering service is worth it for a real estate team help you judge that side. For staffed hours, see virtual receptionist vs answering service.
An SI Employee shifts which questions matter. It answers forwarded calls on the schedule you set, follows your routing rules, and leaves the same recording, transcript and summary after every call, so the evaluation moves from counting minutes to checking coverage and handoff. assistcall.ai sets out what it covers.
The 40-agent brokerage example models about 60 main-line calls a weekday plus roughly 90 a week in the evenings and at weekends. Run a volume like that through the six billing rows and the gap between plans widens quickly.
Frequently asked questions
Is per-minute or per-call pricing cheaper for a real estate office?
It depends on call length. A line dominated by long lead calls often does better per call; a line with many short agent and vendor calls often does better per minute, especially with 6-second billing. Bill one month of your own calls both ways to find out.
Do answering services charge for spam and robocalls?
Many count every answered call unless the contract excludes junk or calls under a set number of seconds. Ask for that exclusion in writing; robocalls remain common, with 1.6 million robocall complaints filed with the FTC in fiscal 2025[2].
What is a billing increment?
The unit each call is rounded up to. With full-minute increments a 70-second call bills as two minutes; with 6-second increments it bills as 1.2 minutes. Over hundreds of calls the difference adds up to hours.
How do we estimate minutes before signing with anyone?
Export four weeks of call detail from your phone system, total the durations of the calls that would go to the service, and add a margin for rounding. Then ask each provider to bill that log under its plan.
Should we prefer a flat monthly plan?
Only if your volume is steady or the allowance covers your busiest month. A plan sized for winter can run well into overage in spring, when new listings and buyer calls pick up[3].
References
O*NET OnLine, U.S. Department of Labor (2025). 43-2011.00 - Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service (Summary Report) (opens in a new tab) β
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book FY 2025 (opens in a new tab) β
Realtor.com Economic Research (2026). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey - 2025 Results (news release) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4. Private industry workers by occupational and industry group (June 2026) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (news release) (opens in a new tab) β