Key takeaways
- A December 2021 count found rebate bans in nine states, and the list has been shrinking; confirm your state's current rule before offering one[2].
- Lenders treat an agent's credit as an interested party contribution: capped by loan-to-value and never more than the buyer's closing costs[3].
- A rebate paid outside closing and not shown on the settlement statement can make the loan ineligible for sale to Fannie Mae[3].
- Whoever answers the phone should give one approved answer about rebates and pass the details to an agent, never a number.
Why callers ask about rebates now
The question used to come from the occasional engineer with a spreadsheet. Now it comes on ordinary inquiry calls: “Do you give anything back at closing?” About 22% of buyers in Zillow's 2026 consumer survey said their agent rebated at least some of the commission, and 78% of buyers who used an agent still called the commission fair for the service[1]. Rebates are common enough that buyers expect a straight answer, and the office that fumbles it loses the caller to one that doesn't.
22%
of buyers said their agent rebated at least part of the commission[1]
The settlement-era paperwork made the topic easier to raise. Since August 17, 2024, many buyers working with a REALTOR sign a written buyer agreement, and the compensation in it must be clearly defined, is negotiable and is not set by law[4]. Once a buyer has seen a number on a form, asking whether part of it comes back is a short step. The fee conversation itself is covered in buyer agent compensation conversations after the settlement; this article is about where a rebate is legal, how the lender sees it and how to answer the phone.
Where rebates are banned or restricted
The bans that exist are state rules, so the answer depends on where you are licensed and where the property sits. The most recent public count we could verify is the Consumer Federation of America's from December 2021, which said rebate bans continued to exist in nine states: Alabama, Alaska, Iowa, Kansas, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, Oregon and Tennessee[2]. The same release reported that Louisiana's Attorney General had reversed an earlier reading and concluded in October 2021 that state law does not prohibit consumer commission rebates, and that a federal court had dismissed a challenge to Oregon's ban that month[2].
Statutes are worth reading in full because the wording varies. Kansas, for example, bars a licensee from accepting, giving or charging “any rebate or undisclosed commission”, and separately bars paying a referral fee that the licensee knows will produce a rebate[5]. The Kansas statute's annotations also list a 2018 Attorney General opinion finding no violation when part of a commission was used to buy a gift card for the licensee's client[5]. The line between a banned rebate and a permitted closing gift can be finer than agents assume; closing gifts and their tax rules covers the gift side.
| States | What the sources say | What to check before you offer anything |
|---|---|---|
| Alabama, Alaska, Iowa, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, Oregon, Tennessee | Listed as banning rebates in December 2021[2] | Whether the ban still stands and how non-cash items are treated |
| Kansas | Statute bars giving any rebate or undisclosed commission[5] | The gift card opinion and any commission guidance since |
| Louisiana | Attorney General opinion in 2021: rebates not prohibited[2] | Commission rules, broker policy and lender limits |
| All other states | Not on the 2021 list of bans[2] | Commission rules on disclosure, broker approval and lender limits |
Referrals deserve their own check. Kansas does not only bar a licensee from giving a rebate; it also bars paying a referral fee when the licensee knows that fee will result in a rebate[5]. A broker in a state with a ban who refers a relocating buyer to an agent elsewhere, and is paid a referral fee out of a commission that is partly rebated, should read that language closely. Agents licensed in two states face the same question twice: the rule that governs is not always the one where the agent lives, so check with both commissions before a cross-border deal includes any credit.
Where rebates are allowed, the brokerage still decides whether it offers them. Commission belongs to the broker, so an agent who promises a buyer money back without the broker's approval is promising something that is not theirs to give. Any advertising of a rebate also has to be accurate and complete; see Article 12 on truth in advertising.
How lenders see an agent's credit
A rebate the buyer is happy about can still unsettle the loan. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide lists the real estate agent or broker as an interested party, alongside the seller and builder[3]. Money from an interested party toward the buyer's costs is an interested party contribution, and its limits depend on occupancy and loan-to-value: 3% of value above 90% LTV, 6% from 75.01% to 90% and 9% at 75% or less for a principal residence or second home, and 2% for an investment property[3]. Seller credits and agent credits count against the same limit.
Source: Fannie Mae, 2025[3]
Show the data
| Occupancy and LTV/CLTV | Maximum contribution |
|---|---|
| Primary or second home, above 90% | 3% |
| Primary or second home, 75.01–90% | 6% |
| Primary or second home, 75% or less | 9% |
| Investment property, any LTV | 2% |
Two further rules catch people out. Financing concessions can never exceed the buyer's actual closing costs; anything above that is treated as a sales concession[3]. And rebates from real estate agents or brokers that are not credited towards the transaction, such as a check handed over after closing, are listed as sales concessions, which must be deducted from the sales price before LTV is recalculated[3]. Mortgages with undisclosed contributions are not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae at all[3]. FHA, VA and portfolio loans set their own rules, so the buyer's loan officer should see any planned credit before the offer is written.
Example (illustrative; lenders add their own overlays): a buyer purchases at $500,000 with 10% down, a $450,000 loan at 90% LTV, inside the 6% band. The seller credits $9,000 and the buyer's agent credits $7,500, for $16,500 in total. Closing costs and prepaids come to $14,000, so $2,500 is excess and becomes a sales concession. Deducted from the price, it leaves $497,500, and the same loan is now about 90.5% LTV, in the 3% band. Keeping total credits at or below the $14,000 of closing costs from the start would have avoided the problem.
Before anyone writes a credit into an offer, five questions to the loan officer settle most of it: which loan program the buyer is using and what its contribution limit is; the current estimate of closing costs including prepaids; how much the seller is already expected to credit; how the agent's credit will appear on the settlement statement; and whether the lender adds its own limits on top of the investor's. The answers take five minutes by phone and save a renegotiation in week four. Agents who already make pre-approval handoffs to a lender can add the question to that first introduction.
| Check after closing | Credit at closing | |
|---|---|---|
| On the settlement statement | Not unless separately disclosed | Yes, as a credit to the buyer |
| Fannie Mae classification | Sales concession, deducted from price | Financing concession within IPC limits |
| Limit | Lowers the price used for LTV | 3%, 6% or 9% of value, never above closing costs |
| Lender sees it in time | Often not | Yes, when disclosed before the offer |
| Risk if hidden | Loan not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae | Low when disclosed and within limits |
Based on Fannie Mae's interested party contribution rules for conventional loans.
Paying it the clean way
Confirm it is allowed
Check your state's current rule[2] and your brokerage's written policy. Get the broker's approval in writing for each transaction.
Write it into the buyer agreement
Compensation in the agreement must be clearly defined[4]. State the rebate the same way: a fixed amount or a stated share, credited at closing, subject to lender approval.
Tell the lender before the offer
The loan officer checks the credit against the contribution limits and the buyer's estimated closing costs[3]. Adjust before the purchase contract fixes the numbers.
Put it on the settlement statement
A credit shown at closing is visible to everyone who needs to see it. Money passed outside closing invites the undisclosed-contribution problem[3].
Keep other providers' money out of it
Never fund a rebate with a payment from a lender, title company or other settlement provider. RESPA bars fees or things of value for referring settlement-service business[6]; see lender co-marketing under RESPA and affiliated business arrangements.
When a caller asks “Do you give rebates?”
The question rarely reaches the agent first. It lands on the front desk, an inside sales agent, a colleague on floor time or whoever covers the line at night. None of them should quote a figure, promise a credit or improvise a reason why not. A number given on a call becomes the buyer's expectation, and in a state with a ban it is an offer the office cannot lawfully make.
- Where your brokerage offers rebates: “Any credit back to you is set out in the written agreement with the agent you work with, and it has to fit your lender's rules. I'll have an agent call you today to go through it.”
- Where your state or brokerage does not allow them: “We don't offer commission rebates, but the agent can walk you through exactly what's included and how compensation works. Can I have them call you this afternoon?”
- Either way, take the details that make the callback useful: name, best number, the area and price range, timeline, and whether the caller is already talking to a lender.
- Give every caller the same answer. A rebate offered to some callers and not others on the strength of how they sound is a policy problem waiting to happen; the call script fair housing rules apply here too.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Caller asks about rebates
A buyer calls about a listing and asks whether the office gives money back at closing.
02SI Employee
Approved answer, no numbers
The brokerage's policy line is read as written; anything beyond it goes to an agent.
03SI Employee
Details for the callback
Area, price range, timeline, lender status and whether the buyer already has an agent.
04System
Summary to the agent
An email summary notes the rebate question; the recording and transcript are saved.
05Your team
Agent calls back
Explains compensation, writes any credit into the agreement and loops in the lender.
Example call path. The policy wording is the broker's, approved before any call is forwarded.
An SI Employee on the overflow or after-hours line handles this well precisely because it does not improvise: it reads the approved line, collects the same callback details every time and routes anything else to the agent with a written summary. The front desk routing example shows how a brokerage might set that split, and AssistCall's real estate team lead response example follows the callback side. When the conversation turns to objections about the fee itself, buyer agreement objections and how to respond has the agent's side of the script.
Questions your rebate policy should settle
- Is it allowed in every state where we practice, and who rechecks that each year?
- Who approves a rebate on a given deal, and is there a ceiling as a share of the buyer-side commission?
- Is it always paid as a credit at closing, never as a check, gift card or transfer afterwards?
- At what point is the lender told, and who confirms the credit fits the closing costs?
- What exact words may the front desk, inside sales agents and after-hours coverage use on the phone?
- Who signs off on any advertising that mentions a rebate, and where are those approvals kept?
Answer those once, in writing, and the phone answer, the buyer agreement and the closing all say the same thing. For the wider market context, commission trends after the NAR settlement tracks how buyer-side fees have moved.
Frequently asked questions
Which states ban real estate commission rebates?
The Consumer Federation of America listed nine in December 2021: Alabama, Alaska, Iowa, Kansas, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, Oregon and Tennessee[2]. Rules change, so confirm the current position with your state's real estate commission.
Can a rebate be larger than the buyer's closing costs?
Not as a financing concession on a Fannie Mae loan. Concessions must not exceed the borrower's closing costs, and any excess is treated as a sales concession deducted from the price[3].
Can we pay the rebate by check after closing?
It creates lender problems. Fannie Mae treats agent rebates not credited towards the transaction as sales concessions, and loans with undisclosed contributions are not eligible for sale to it[3]. A disclosed credit at closing is the cleaner route.
Can a lender chip in toward the rebate?
No. RESPA bars giving or accepting anything of value for referring settlement-service business[6]. Keep lender money out of any credit you give a client.
Is a closing gift the same as a rebate?
Not always. In Kansas, which bans rebates, an Attorney General opinion listed in the statute's annotations found no violation when part of a commission bought a gift card for a client[5]. Check your own state's guidance before assuming either way.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Buyers: Results from the Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Federation of America (2021). State Support For Anti-Rebate Prohibitions Weakens (December 15, 2021) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Fannie Mae (2025). Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, Interested Party Contributions (IPCs) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes (2026). Kansas Statutes § 58-3062, Prohibited acts (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑