Key takeaways
- A call asking an expired or FSBO seller to list with you is a telephone solicitation, so registered numbers are off limits without an exemption.
- You have no established business relationship with an expired seller: that relationship was with the previous listing brokerage.
- A genuine call about a specific buyer you represent is treated differently from a listing pitch, but asking the seller to pay you changes it.
- For registered numbers, use letters, door knocking where local rules allow, and invitations for the seller to contact you.
Why these two lists carry the most risk
Expired listings and for-sale-by-owner sellers are the oldest prospecting lists in real estate. They are attractive because the owner has already shown an intention to sell. They are also where most Do Not Call trouble starts, because the lists are assembled from public or MLS data rather than from the owner's request to hear from you, and many of the numbers are registered.
The National Do Not Call Registry held about 259 million active registrations in 2025[1], and those registrations must be honored indefinitely or until the consumer cancels[2]. Complaints are not only about robocalls: in fiscal year 2025 the FTC received 802,144 Do Not Call complaints about live callers[1]. A human agent dialing by hand is still a telemarketer under the rules when the call is a sales pitch.
Expired listings: no relationship carries over
Agents sometimes assume that a homeowner who listed with a brokerage has a business relationship with the real estate industry, or that MLS access gives them a reason to call. Neither is true. The established business relationship exemption is based on a purchase or transaction with your business within the previous 18 months, or an inquiry or application to your business within the previous three months[3]. The expired seller's relationship was with their old listing brokerage, and it does not transfer to you.
- Scrub every expired list against the national registry, any state list and your internal do-not-call list before calling.
- Do not call a registered number unless you hold another exemption, such as a genuine personal relationship or written permission from the owner.
- If the expired listing was with your own brokerage, the seller may have an established business relationship with you, but only within the time limits and only until they ask you to stop.
- Treat any request not to be called as permanent for your whole brokerage.
Unregistered numbers can be called by hand within calling hours, with a clear introduction and respect for any request to stop. Automated dialers, prerecorded messages and AI voices bring in written-consent requirements on top of that; see TCPA rules for real estate agents.
FSBOs: the sign is for buyers, not agents
A for-sale-by-owner sign or online listing invites buyers to call. It does not invite agents to pitch their services. A call asking the owner to list, or offering marketing help for a fee, is a telephone solicitation like any other. FSBO sellers are a small group, a historic low of 5% of sellers in NAR's 2026 profile, and 62% of them already knew their buyer[4]. That means most FSBO listings you see are owners testing the market, often with strong feelings about agents.
A call made on behalf of a real buyer you represent, to ask about the home or arrange a viewing, is generally treated as outside the telephone solicitation definition, because you are not trying to sell the owner anything. That changes if the call becomes a pitch: asking the owner to sign a listing agreement, or to pay your buyer-side compensation, is encouraging the purchase of your services. Keep the buyer call about the buyer, and have counsel review your practice if you rely on this distinction.
Script for a buyer inquiry to a FSBO: 'Hi, my name is [your name] with [brokerage]. I'm calling about your home on Elm Street. I represent a buyer who is interested in the area and I'd like to ask a few questions about the house, and whether you'd be open to a showing. I'm not calling to list your home.' If the owner raises compensation, answer their question and follow up in writing; do not turn the call into a listing pitch.
Decision guide by list and registry status
| Situation | Number on a DNC list? | Reasonable approach |
|---|---|---|
| Expired seller, no prior relationship with you | No | Manual call within calling hours, clear introduction, honor any stop request |
| Expired seller, no prior relationship with you | Yes | Do not call; send a letter or visit where local rules allow |
| Expired seller who listed with your brokerage | Yes | Call only within the established business relationship window and if they have not asked you to stop |
| FSBO, calling to ask for the listing | No | Manual call within calling hours; no automated tools without written consent |
| FSBO, calling to ask for the listing | Yes | Do not call; use mail, a visit or a written invitation to contact you |
| FSBO, calling about a specific buyer you represent | Either | Call about the buyer only; no listing pitch or request for payment |
| Anyone who asked you to stop | Either | Do not call; keep on the internal list for at least five years |
The five-year minimum for internal do-not-call requests and the ten-business-day deadline to honor them come from the FCC rules[3]. State laws can add limits, such as narrower calling hours and caps on repeated calls; see state mini-TCPA laws.
Getting through to unregistered numbers
Even legal calls are hard to complete. In Pew's survey, 80% of Americans said they do not generally answer calls from unknown numbers, but 67% check voicemail if a message is left[5]. A short, honest voicemail does more work than repeated redials, which also risk crossing state call-frequency caps.
Voicemail script for an expired seller: 'Hi, this is [your name] with [brokerage]. I noticed your home on Elm Street came off the market, and I have a few thoughts on why some homes in your area are not selling right now. If that's useful, call or text me at the number on your screen. If you'd rather not hear from me, just say so and I'll take your number off our list.'
The last sentence is not only courteous. It gives the owner an easy way to opt out, and it shows that your brokerage takes requests seriously, which matters if the call is ever questioned.
Lawful alternatives for registered numbers
- Letters and postcards: a personal letter that explains your view of why the home did not sell, with a reply card or a simple way to contact you.
- Door knocking: check city and county solicitation ordinances and any no-soliciting signs, and keep visits short and respectful.
- Email: if you have a lawful address, follow federal commercial email rules, including a working unsubscribe.
- An invitation to call you: ask in writing for permission to call, and keep any written permission you receive as your exemption record.
- Referrals and networks: the owner's neighbors, friends or past agent may introduce you, creating a real personal connection.
Keep perspective on the size of the prize. With 92% of sellers using an agent or broker in NAR's 2026 profile[6], most owners who are serious about selling will choose an agent. The one they choose is often the one who treated them with respect when they were frustrated.
A compliant daily routine for expireds
Agents who work expireds well tend to follow the same routine every morning. Building compliance into the routine means it does not depend on remembering the rules under pressure.
Pull the new expireds
Export yesterday's expired and withdrawn listings from the MLS, with owner names and any phone numbers from your data provider.
Scrub before anything else
Run the list through your brokerage's scrub against the national registry, state lists and your internal do-not-call list, using registry data no older than 31 days.
Split the list
Unregistered numbers go to the call list. Registered numbers go to the letter list, unless the CRM shows a documented exemption such as a past transaction with your brokerage.
Call by hand within hours
Dial manually, within the federal window and any narrower state window, and leave one clear voicemail rather than repeated redials.
Record outcomes the same day
Log every conversation, voicemail and stop request in the CRM. Stop requests go straight to the internal list.
Send the letters
Mail a personal letter to every owner you could not or did not call, with an easy way to contact you.
The routine takes the same time as calling everyone on the raw list, and it leaves a record that shows exactly why each call was made.
Texting expireds and FSBOs
Cold texts to expired and FSBO sellers carry more risk than cold calls. Marketing texts are treated as calls under federal rules, automated text platforms bring in written-consent requirements, and carriers filter unsolicited real estate texts heavily. A text to a registered number is a solicitation to a registered number.
If you want to text, earn the right first: get written consent through a reply card, a website form or a conversation where the owner agrees to receive texts from you. Then keep the consent record. The consent wording that holds up is covered in express written consent for real estate texts and calls.
What a violation can cost
The TCPA allows recovery of actual losses or $500 per violation, and a court may treble the award for willful or knowing violations[7]. Agents calling dozens of expireds a day can build up exposure quickly if their list was never scrubbed. Brokers share the risk, because the calls are made for the brokerage's business.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Prospecting rules vary by state and change over time, so have counsel review your scripts, lists and tools.
Frequently asked questions
Can I call an expired listing that is on the Do Not Call list?
Not for a listing pitch unless you hold an exemption, such as a genuine personal relationship or the owner's written permission. Your brokerage has no established business relationship with a seller who listed elsewhere.
Can I call a FSBO on the Do Not Call list if I have a buyer?
A call genuinely about a specific buyer you represent is generally treated differently from a solicitation. Keep the call about the buyer, do not pitch a listing or ask the owner to pay you, and have counsel review your practice.
Is door knocking an alternative to calling registered numbers?
It can be. The Do Not Call rules cover calls and texts, not visits, but many cities and counties regulate door-to-door solicitation and owners may post no-soliciting signs. Check local rules first.
What should I do if an owner says 'take me off your list'?
Stop the pitch, confirm you will add their number to your brokerage's do-not-call list, end the call and record the request the same day so every agent and tool honors it.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200(d) and (f)(5) - company-specific do-not-call lists and established business relationship (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑