Brokerage Operations and Staffing

Commission Split Models Compared

Graduated, capped, 100 percent and team splits side by side, with a worked example at three production levels and the questions to ask before signing.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the split model matters more than the headline number
  2. The four models in plain terms
  3. Side-by-side comparison
  4. Worked example: three agents, three models
  5. Decision criteria for agents
  6. Decision criteria for brokers and team leaders
  7. Questions to ask in the recruiting meeting
  8. How the 2024 settlement changes the math
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Brokerage Operations and Staffing: Commission Split Models ComparedArticle coverBROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGCommission Split ModelsComparedAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsBrokerage Operations and Staffing: Commission Split Models ComparedArticle coverBROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGCommission SplitModels ComparedAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • The typical REALTOR grossed $59,200 in 2025 and spent $9,530 on business expenses, so the split model shapes take-home pay more than most agents assume[1].
  • Graduated and fixed splits favor newer, lower-volume agents; capped and 100 percent models favor agents who close consistently.
  • Model the full year, not the headline split: desk fees, transaction fees, caps and E&O change the answer.
  • Commission paid by clients is negotiable, so agent income is less predictable than it was before 2024[2][3].

Why the split model matters more than the headline number

Agents compare brokerages by the split they hear in the recruiting meeting: 70/30, 80/20, 100 percent. That number is only one input. What an agent actually keeps depends on how many sides they close, the size of their average commission, and every fee that sits around the split.

The margins are thin for most agents. The median gross income of REALTORS was $59,200 in 2025, while total median business expenses rose to $9,530, with vehicle costs the largest category[1]. The typical member reported nine transaction sides for the year[1]. The Bureau of Labor Statistics puts median pay for brokers and sales agents at $57,400 a year[4]. On income like that, a few percentage points of split, or a monthly fee charged in a slow quarter, decides whether the year feels workable.

Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025NAR 2026 Member Profile, income for 2025
Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025Comparison. All REALTORS: $59,200; 16+ years of experience: $88,500.$59,200All REALTORSAll REALTORS: $59,200$88,50016+ years of experience16+ years of experience: $88,500Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025Comparison. All REALTORS: $59,200; 16+ years of experience: $88,500.$59,200All REALTORSAll REALTORS: $59,200$88,50016+ years of experience16+ years of experience: $88,500

Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All REALTORS$59,200
16+ years of experience$88,500

Experience changes the picture. REALTORS with 16 or more years in the business reported a median gross income of $88,500[1]. An agent at that level usually closes more sides at a steadier pace, which is exactly the profile that benefits from a cap or a flat-fee model. A new licensee with two or three sides a year often benefits from a richer split of a smaller pie, because the brokerage is carrying training, leads and supervision.

The four models in plain terms

  • Fixed or graduated split: the agent keeps a set share of each commission, such as 60, 70 or 80 percent. Graduated plans step the agent's share up as annual production passes thresholds, then reset on the anniversary date.
  • Capped split: the agent pays the company dollar share (for example 20 percent) until a yearly cap is reached, then keeps close to 100 percent for the rest of the year, usually minus a small per-transaction fee.
  • 100 percent or flat-fee: the agent keeps the full commission and pays a fixed monthly desk fee, a per-transaction fee, or both. The brokerage earns the same amount whether the agent closes one deal or thirty.
  • Team split: a team inside a brokerage takes its own share before or after the brokerage split, in exchange for leads, administrative support and a brand. Team splits sit on top of whichever brokerage model the team lead has negotiated.

Revenue share and attraction models are a separate layer some brokerages add, paying agents a portion of company dollar generated by agents they recruit. They change recruiting incentives rather than the basic split, and are covered in our guide to revenue share and attraction models.

Side-by-side comparison

How the common split models trade services for share of commission
ModelWho it suitsWhat the brokerage providesMain risk for the agentMain risk for the brokerage
Fixed or graduated splitNew and part-time agentsTraining, leads, office, broker supportPays heavily on big yearsTop producers leave once they outgrow it
Capped splitSteady mid to high producersBrand, compliance, some toolsPaying full split in a slow year without reaching capRevenue plateaus once most agents cap
100 percent / flat feeSelf-sufficient, high-volume agentsCompliance, licensing umbrella, minimal servicesFixed fees continue when deals stallThin margin, little budget for support
Team splitAgents who want leads and admin helpLeads, ISA or admin support, systemsLead quality may not justify the splitTeam lead carries lead and payroll costs

Ask every brokerage for the full fee schedule in writing: split, cap, desk fee, transaction fee, E&O, technology fee, franchise or royalty fee, and what happens to each on the anniversary date.

Worked example: three agents, three models

Example (fictional figures). Three agents at the same office compare a fixed 70/30 split, an 80/20 capped plan with a $16,000 annual cap, and a 100 percent plan with a $500 monthly fee plus $300 per closed side. Their average gross commission per side is $8,000.

Example: what each agent pays the brokerage in a year under each model (fictional figures)
Agent (Example)Sides closedGross commissionPaid under 70/30Paid under 80/20 capped at $16,000Paid under 100% plan
Agent A5$40,000$12,000$8,000$7,500
Agent B15$120,000$36,000$16,000$10,500
Agent C30$240,000$72,000$16,000$15,000

In this example, Agent A pays least on the 100 percent plan, but only by $500, and carries $6,000 of fixed monthly fees whether or not the five deals close. If two of those deals fall through, Agent A pays $6,900 on the 100 percent plan against $4,800 on the capped plan, because the monthly fees do not shrink with production. Agent B saves $20,000 or more by leaving the fixed split, which is why mid-producers are the most frequently recruited group. Agent C barely notices the difference between the cap and the flat fee, so the decision rests on services, brand and culture rather than arithmetic.

The lesson is to model a bad year as well as a good one. Zillow found that 47 percent of sellers had at least one offer fall through in its latest survey[5]. Pipelines shrink without warning, and fixed fees do not.

Decision criteria for agents

  1. Count your last 24 months honestly

    Use closed sides and actual gross commission, not listings taken. Average the two years to smooth out a lucky or unlucky spell.

  2. Model three scenarios

    Run your average year, a year 30 percent lower and a year 30 percent higher through every plan you are considering, including all fees.

  3. Price the services you would lose

    List what the current brokerage provides that you would have to buy elsewhere: transaction coordination, marketing design, leads, office space, E&O, training.

  4. Check the cap reset date

    A cap that resets on your anniversary date rather than January can help or hurt depending on when your busy season falls.

  5. Read the exit terms

    Find out who keeps pending deals, listings and referral fees if you leave, and whether any unpaid fees are deducted from final commissions.

Decision criteria for brokers and team leaders

For the brokerage, the split model is a pricing decision for a service business. A fixed split funds training and leads but invites your best producers to leave once they do the arithmetic above. A cap keeps them but limits how much you earn from them. A flat fee only works if your cost to serve each agent is low and predictable.

  • Know your cost to serve an agent: compliance review, broker supervision hours, technology, office space and errors and omissions coverage.
  • Offer more than one plan, but price each plan so it covers that cost at a realistic production level.
  • Tie richer splits to things you can measure, such as closed sides or attendance at training, not to tenure alone.
  • Review plans once a year against retention. NAR reports the median REALTOR has been with their current firm for 6 years[1], so an agent who leaves usually decided over many months.

Remember that the agent is usually an independent contractor. NAR reports 86 percent of REALTORS work as independent contractors at their firms[1], and the compensation plan should be written in a way that keeps pay tied to sales output rather than hours, which matters for tax classification. See independent contractor vs employee classification.

Questions to ask in the recruiting meeting

  1. What is the full list of fees I will pay in a year, and which ones continue in a month when I close nothing?
  2. When does the cap reset, and which fees still apply after I cap?
  3. Which services are included in the split, and which are billed separately (transaction coordination, signs, photography, marketing design)?
  4. Who provides errors and omissions coverage, and what is my deductible if a claim is made on one of my files?
  5. If a lead comes from the company or the team, what split applies, and does it change on a referral or a repeat client?
  6. How are referral fees paid in and out, and does the company take a share of referral income?
  7. What happens to my pending deals, active listings and unpaid fees if I leave?

Write the answers down next to your three-scenario model. A plan that looks generous on the headline split can be the most expensive one once you add the answers to questions one, two and three, and a plan that looks expensive can be good value if it replaces costs you are paying elsewhere.

How the 2024 settlement changes the math

Since August 2024, buyers working with a REALTOR typically sign a written buyer agreement before touring, and the compensation in it must be a clearly defined amount, such as a flat fee or a percentage, that is negotiable and not set by law[3]. On the listing side, Zillow found that 44 percent of agent-using sellers negotiated their agent's commission, while 76 percent still said the commission they paid was fair[2].

For split planning this means average commission per side is less stable than it used to be. Agents should use their own recent average rather than a market rule of thumb, and brokerages should check whether caps and flat fees still make sense if gross commission per side drifts down. Many teams now also track how often their agents defend their fee and at what rate, alongside the split itself.

If you are building a team on top of a brokerage plan, the next questions are structure and lead flow. Our guides to building a real estate team and mentorship programs and mentor splits pick up from here, and cap and split math for agents goes deeper on the formulas.

Frequently asked questions

What is a typical real estate commission split?

There is no single standard. Fixed or graduated splits for newer agents commonly start around 50/50 to 70/30, capped plans often use 80/20 or similar up to a yearly cap, and 100 percent plans replace the split with fixed fees. Always compare the full fee schedule.

Is a 100 percent commission brokerage always cheaper?

No. It is usually cheaper for agents who close consistently, but the monthly and per-transaction fees continue in slow months. Low-volume agents can end up paying more than under a split, especially if deals fall through.

When does a capped split make sense?

When your annual company dollar under the split would clearly exceed the cap in an average year, and the brokerage still provides services you value. Check when the cap resets and what fees apply after capping.

Do teams take a split on top of the brokerage split?

Usually yes. The team lead negotiates a plan with the brokerage and then pays team members a share of commission, often higher on self-generated leads and lower on team-provided leads. Get it in a written team agreement.

References

  1. National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo