Key takeaways
- Contract-to-close ratio = closings ÷ contracts accepted in the same cohort; track the reasons for every deal that fails.
- 47% of US sellers had at least one offer fall through in Zillow's 2026 survey, and financing was the top reason (44%)[1].
- Mortgage rates rose to 7.18% in early November 2026 from 6.22% a year earlier[2], so recheck buyer financing during escrow.
- Real estate fraud complaints to the FBI rose to 12,368 in 2025[3]; a wire-fraud script belongs in every transaction.
What the ratio tells you
The contract-to-close ratio measures how many accepted offers become funded, recorded sales. Everything before it in the funnel is about winning business; this ratio is about keeping it. A brokerage can be excellent at listing appointments and still lose a large share of income in the weeks between acceptance and closing.
Contract-to-close ratio = closings from contracts accepted in a period ÷ contracts accepted in that period. Fall-through rate = 1 minus the ratio.
Count by the date the contract was accepted, not the date it closed or failed. Otherwise a strong month of closings can mask a run of cancellations that will only show up later. Include every accepted contract, even ones that fail in the first week; early terminations during the inspection period are still fall-throughs, and they are often the easiest to prevent.
How often deals fall apart
Fall-through is common enough that every seller should hear about it before they accept an offer. Zillow's 2026 survey found 47% of US sellers had at least one offer fall through during their sale, down from 54% the year before[1]. Financing problems were the most common reason, cited by 44% of those sellers[1]. This is a seller-level figure, so it counts sellers who lost at least one buyer rather than the share of contracts that failed, but it shows how routine the problem is.
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2025 survey | 54% |
| 2026 survey | 47% |
Calculate your own ratio
List every accepted contract
Pull all contracts accepted in a quarter, buyer and listing side, with the agent, lead source, price band and financing type.
Record the outcome
Closed, terminated, or still pending. Leave pending deals out of the ratio until they resolve, and recalculate when they do.
Assign one primary cause
For every termination, choose a single primary cause from a fixed list and add a sentence of detail.
Split the ratio
Calculate it by agent, by side, by financing type and by price band. Patterns rarely show in the total.
Compare quarters
Watch the trend and the mix of causes. A stable ratio with a rising share of financing failures is an early signal.
Sort fall-throughs by cause
| Cause | Typical trigger | Early warning | Prevention |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financing | Loan denial, rate lock expiry, job change, new debt | Lender slow to issue conditional approval | Fully underwritten pre-approval; lender check-ins at fixed points |
| Appraisal | Value below contract price | Price well above recent comparable sales | Agree an appraisal-gap plan before signing |
| Inspection and repairs | Major defect, repair negotiation breaks down | Older systems, no pre-listing inspection | Pre-listing inspection; realistic repair expectations |
| Title, HOA or legal | Liens, boundary issues, HOA approval, estate problems | Probate or recent refinance on title | Order title early and read the commitment |
| Buyer change of mind | Cold feet, life event, found another home | Buyer hesitates at every step | Clear expectations at consultation; frequent updates |
| Sale contingency | Buyer's own home fails to sell | Contingent offer on a slow-moving home | Check the buyer's listing status and pricing |
| Fraud or wire problems | Spoofed email with new wiring instructions | Late changes to payment instructions | Verbal verification by a known phone number |
Financing: the biggest single risk
Financing failures often start with a payment that grew. Freddie Mac's survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.18% on November 5, 2026, against 6.22% a year earlier[2]. A buyer approved months ago at a lower rate may now face a payment the lender will not approve or the buyer will not accept. The earlier you know, the more options exist.
- Ask for a pre-approval based on a full credit and income review, not a quick pre-qualification, before submitting offers.
- Confirm the rate lock date and expiry in writing, and compare it with the closing date in the contract.
- Schedule lender check-ins after the appraisal is ordered, when conditional approval is due, and a week before closing.
- Tell buyers in writing not to change jobs, open new credit or make large purchases until the deal closes.
Cash deals carry less financing risk but are not risk-free. All-cash sales made up 27% of existing-home transactions in September 2026[4]. Verify proof of funds before acceptance, and make sure the funds will actually be available on the closing date.
Appraisal and inspection: agree the plan up front
Appraisal and inspection failures are rarely surprises in hindsight. An offer written well above the recent sales in the neighborhood invites a low appraisal, and an older home with original systems invites a long repair list. The fix is to discuss the likely problem before the contract is signed, while both sides still want the deal.
- Before writing an offer above recent sales, ask the buyer how much of a gap between appraisal and price they could cover in cash, and write the answer into your notes.
- For listings, suggest a pre-listing inspection on older homes, so the big items are known and priced in rather than discovered in week two.
- When the inspection report arrives, separate safety and structural items from cosmetic ones before you call the other agent. Negotiations that try to fix everything tend to fail.
- Put every deadline in a shared calendar on the day the contract is accepted, with reminders two days before each one.
Wire fraud: the cause that costs the client
Most fall-throughs cost time and commission. Wire fraud can cost a client their down payment. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, up from 9,359 in 2024, with reported losses of about $275.1 million[3]. One case in its 2025 report involved buyers at closing who received an email impersonating their attorneys[3].
Script for every new client: “Our office and the title company will never change wiring instructions by email. If you get a message that does, don't reply. Call me or the title company on the number in your contract before you send anything.”
Repeat the warning in writing when the contract is signed and again a few days before closing, when fraud attempts are most likely to land.
Use pending sales as your early warning
The national pattern applies to a single brokerage too. NAR notes that monthly pending sales activity parallels closed existing-home sales over the following two months[5], and in September 2026 pending sales fell 7.3% from August[5]. Your pending list, adjusted for your contract-to-close ratio, is the best forecast of income for the next 60 days.
Prepare sellers before they accept
Sellers who expect a smooth ride take a failed contract personally, and some blame the agent. Sellers who were told in advance that deals often wobble tend to stay calm and keep the backup buyer warm. Raise it during the listing appointment and again when offers arrive, and use it to compare offers on strength, not just price.
Seller script: “Nearly half of sellers lose at least one buyer before closing, most often over financing. So when we compare offers, I'll look at the price and at how likely each one is to close: the loan type, the lender, the size of the deposit and any contingencies.” Source for the figure: Zillow's 2026 seller survey[1].
Keep backup offers documented, with the buyer agent's consent to stay in touch. A strong second offer turns a fall-through from a relisting into a short delay.
Run a monthly fall-through review
- List every termination in the month with its primary cause and the agent involved.
- For each one, ask what the earliest warning sign was and when the team noticed it.
- Agree one process change, such as a lender check-in rule or an earlier title order.
- Check last month's change: did the cause it targeted appear again?
- Share the anonymized lessons with all agents in a short note.
Example: one quarter's numbers
Example: a fictional brokerage accepts 48 contracts in the second quarter. By August, 42 have closed and 6 have terminated, a contract-to-close ratio of 87.5%. Three terminations are financing (two rate-related payment increases and one job change), one is an appraisal gap, one is an inspection negotiation that broke down and one is a buyer who backed out after a family move.
Example response: the team adds a lender check-in on day 10 of every financed deal and asks agents to confirm rate lock expiry against the closing date. In the next quarter, financing terminations fall from three to one. The broker also notes that two of the six failed deals came from offers written well above recent comparable sales, and adds an appraisal-gap discussion to the offer checklist.
Watch the ratio alongside the stages before it. A brokerage that improves its appointment-to-signed-client rate but lets the contract-to-close ratio slip has only moved the losses later. Both belong on the same KPI page.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good contract-to-close ratio?
There is no single national benchmark for brokerages, because markets and deal types vary. Track your own ratio by quarter and by cause, and focus on reducing the causes you can prevent, such as financing surprises and late title problems.
What is the most common reason real estate deals fall through?
Financing. Among US sellers who had an offer fall through in Zillow's 2026 survey, financing issues were the top reason[1].
Should pending deals be counted in the ratio?
No. Leave them out until they close or terminate, then add them to the cohort for the month the contract was accepted.
How do we protect clients from wire fraud at closing?
Tell every client, early and in writing, that wiring instructions will never change by email, and that they must confirm any instructions by phone using a number from the contract. Real estate fraud complaints to the FBI rose sharply in 2025[3].
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Freddie Mac (2026). Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑