Key takeaways
- Expired sellers are motivated but frustrated; lead with a specific diagnosis, not a pitch.
- Scrub every number against the Do Not Call Registry and call only within permitted hours[1][2].
- Letters reach everyone legally and set up the call; make them specific to the home.
- TCPA violations carry statutory damages per call, so compliance is not optional[3].
Why expired listings, and why most outreach fails
An expired listing is an owner who wanted to sell and did not. That makes it one of the clearest seller signals in real estate. It also makes the owner a target: on the day a listing expires, many owners hear from several agents, most saying the same thing. Generic letters, scripted calls promising a quick sale and unannounced visits blur together, and the owner stops answering.
Timing often makes things worse. Realtor.com's seasonal research shows price reductions peak in the fall[4], and many listings that expire late in the year were overpriced in spring and chased the market down. The owner is tired, possibly upset with their previous agent and wary of anyone promising a different result. The agents who win these listings are the ones who show they understand what went wrong.
Research before any contact
- Price history: the original list price, each reduction and the final price.
- Days on market and whether the listing was relisted or changed brokerage before.
- Photos and description: quality, number of photos, missing rooms, dated images.
- Competition: similar homes that sold while this one sat, and at what prices.
- Showing access: restrictive instructions can kill a listing.
- Ownership: who is on title, and whether the home is occupied, vacant or tenanted.
From that research, write two or three sentences on the likely reasons the home did not sell. That diagnosis is the core of every letter, call and visit that follows.
Be careful with what you say about the previous marketing. You can describe facts visible to anyone, such as the number of photos or the price history. Avoid guessing at what the previous agent did or did not do behind the scenes, and never suggest they were negligent. Owners often liked their agent personally, and criticism tends to make them defensive rather than receptive.
Compliance comes first
Most expired outreach is unsolicited, so telemarketing rules apply. Registrations on the National Do Not Call Registry must be honored indefinitely or until cancelled[2], and there were 259 million active registrations as of September 30, 2025[5]. FCC rules bar telephone solicitations to residential subscribers before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the called party's location[1].
| Channel | Rules to check | Best use |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy, no misleading claims, brokerage identification | First contact for every owner, including those on Do Not Call lists | |
| Phone calls | National and state Do Not Call lists, internal do-not-call list, calling hours | Owners not registered, or who have given consent |
| Prerecorded or AI-voice calls | Prior express written consent required | Generally avoid for expired outreach |
| Text messages | Consent requirements, opt-out handling | Only where the owner has given consent |
| Door visits | Local solicitation ordinances, “no soliciting” signs, safety | Follow-up after a letter, where permitted |
| CAN-SPAM requirements, accurate sender information | Owners whose email you have lawfully obtained |
The stakes are real. Under the TCPA, a person can recover actual losses or $500 in damages per violation, and a court may treble the award for willful or knowing violations[3]. Artificial or prerecorded voice telemarketing calls to residential lines require prior express written consent[6].
Source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text), 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Per violation | $500 |
| Maximum if willful or knowing (trebled) | $1,500 |
A ten-day multi-channel plan
Day 1: send a specific letter
Mail a short, personal letter with your diagnosis and one useful insight, such as a comparable home that sold and why.
Day 2 or 3: call if permitted
Only to numbers cleared against Do Not Call lists, within calling hours. Refer to the letter.
Day 4 or 5: visit if appropriate
Where local rules allow and there is no “no soliciting” sign, drop off a one-page market sheet. Keep it brief and leave if they are not interested.
Day 7: second letter
Send something new: a short analysis of the competition now, or a preparation idea that would change buyers' first impression.
Day 10: final follow-up
A short note or call offering a no-obligation review meeting. Then move the owner into a monthly nurture if they are not ready.
Letters drive callbacks, often at evenings and weekends. Make sure your number is answered whenever owners call; an SI Employee such as Ava can pick up those calls, take the address, timeline and plans, and book a listing consultation for you.
Letter template
Example: a fictional letter for an expired listing reads:
“Dear Mr. and Mrs. Patel, I noticed your home on Birch Road came off the market this week. I'm sorry it didn't sell; I know that's frustrating after months of showings. I looked at the listing history and the homes that sold nearby. Two things stood out: the photos didn't show the renovated kitchen, and the price stayed above two similar homes that sold in August. If you still want to sell, I'd be glad to share a short review of what I'd do differently, with no obligation. My direct number is below. Jordan Lee, Example Realty.”
Keep it to one page, sign it by hand and include your brokerage details as your state requires. Do not criticize the previous agent by name or imply misconduct.
Call and visit scripts
On the phone, if the number is cleared and it is within permitted hours:
“Hi, is this Mr. Patel? This is Jordan Lee with Example Realty. I sent you a letter about your home on Birch Road. I'm not calling to pressure you. I wondered whether you still plan to sell, and if so, whether you'd like a short review of why it might not have sold and what could change. Is now a bad time?”
At the door, briefly and respectfully:
“Hello, I'm Jordan Lee, a local agent. I sent you a letter last week about your home. I've brought a one-page summary of recent sales nearby. I won't take your time now, but if you'd like to talk, my number is on it.”
If an owner asks not to be contacted again, apologize, add them to your internal do-not-call list immediately and stop all outreach channels.
Special situations
- Vacant homes: the owner may live elsewhere. Use the mailing address from tax records rather than the property address, and do not leave materials at an empty house where they signal vacancy.
- Tenanted homes: the tenant is not the seller. Never pitch the tenant; write to the owner, and if you list it, plan showings around the lease and the tenant's rights.
- Listings that already changed agents: an owner on their second or third expired listing has heard every promise. Lead with evidence and a smaller, specific commitment, such as a pricing review.
- Owners still under contract with their previous brokerage: check that the listing has actually expired or been released before soliciting, and follow your MLS and Code of Ethics rules on contacting owners with an active listing.
Nurture the owners who say “not yet”
Many expired owners decide to wait, rent the home out or take a break. That is not a lost lead. Ask permission to keep in touch, then send something useful every month or two: a note when a similar home sells, seasonal timing data for their area, or a short preparation idea. When they are ready, the agent who stayed helpful without pressure is usually the first call.
Record the reason they gave for waiting and a sensible date to check in. An owner who said “after the holidays” should hear from you in early January, not in the middle of December.
The review meeting: what you would change
- Start by listening. Ask what they think went wrong and how the experience felt.
- Share your diagnosis, with the evidence: price history, competition, photos and access.
- Show a specific plan: new price strategy, better photography or staging, revised showing access, and a launch date.
- Agree review points in writing, so the owner sees how this time will be different.
- Ask for the decision, and respect the answer if they want to wait.
Sellers rarely shop around: 67% of agent-using sellers contacted only one agent in Zillow's 2026 research[7]. An expired seller who has already been disappointed once is looking for one agent they can trust. Specific, honest and compliant outreach is how you become that agent.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to call expired listings?
Yes, if you follow telemarketing rules: scrub numbers against the National Do Not Call Registry and state lists, honor your internal do-not-call list, call only between 8 a.m. and 9 p.m. local time, and avoid prerecorded or AI-voice calls without prior express written consent.
What should an expired listing letter say?
Keep it short and specific: acknowledge the frustration, give a brief diagnosis of why the home may not have sold, offer one useful insight and invite a no-obligation review. Do not criticize the previous agent.
How soon should I contact an expired listing?
Soon, but with substance. A specific letter on the first day, followed by a permitted call and a respectful visit where allowed, stands out more than being the first of many generic calls.
Can I knock on doors of expired listings?
In many places, yes, but check local solicitation ordinances and respect “no soliciting” signs. Keep visits brief, leave information and stop if the owner asks.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑
Realtor.com Economic Research (2026). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑