Key takeaways
- HUD must notify a respondent within 10 days of a complaint, and the respondent may answer within 10 days of receiving notice[2].
- Put a hold on call recordings, texts, emails and showing records the day the notice arrives; investigators can subpoena them[3].
- Any reaction that looks like pressure on the complainant is a separate violation[4]; retaliation complaints doubled in 2024[5].
- Most HUD and FHAP cases closed in 2024 ended with no cause or a conciliation or settlement[6].
- Investigations are meant to finish in 100 days but often run longer[2][7]; plan for months.
The first 48 hours
A fair housing complaint usually reaches a brokerage as a letter from HUD or a state or local civil rights agency, naming the firm, one of its agents or both, and setting out what the complainant says happened. The clock is already running. HUD must serve notice on a respondent within 10 days of the complaint being filed, and the respondent may file an answer within 10 days of receiving that notice[2]. Ten days goes quickly when the agent involved is at a closing and the managing broker is learning about the call for the first time.
Log and calendar
Record the date the notice arrived, the agency, the case number and the answer deadline. Put the deadline on the broker's and counsel's calendars.
Call counsel and your insurer
Send the notice to the brokerage's attorney and ask whether your errors and omissions policy requires notice of claims or regulatory complaints. Many policies do, and late notice can cost coverage.
Issue a written hold
Tell everyone involved, in writing, not to delete or edit any call recording, text, email, CRM note, showing record or ad version connected to the complainant or the property.
Hear the agent's account
Get the agent's account of events in writing while memory is fresh, with dates and times, before anyone has seen the brokerage's draft response.
Stop contact about the complaint
No one from the brokerage contacts the complainant about the complaint except through counsel or the agency.
That last step matters more than it looks. The Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful to coerce, intimidate, threaten or interfere with anyone exercising fair housing rights[4], and a friendly call to “clear things up” can read as pressure. Retaliation complaints reported by private fair housing groups more than doubled from 234 in 2023 to 472 in 2024[5]. Check your errors and omissions coverage as part of step two; E&O insurance for agents explains what it usually covers.
How a complaint moves through the system
A complainant has one year from the alleged practice to file with HUD[2]. If the conduct falls within the jurisdiction of a state or local agency HUD has certified as substantially equivalent, HUD refers the complaint to that agency before taking any action itself[8], which is why many brokerages hear from a state civil rights division rather than from HUD. The steps are broadly similar either way.
- Caller
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Complaint filed
Within one year of the alleged practice, with HUD or a certified state or local agency.
02System
Notice served
The respondent is notified within 10 days of filing.
03Your team
Answer filed
The brokerage may answer within 10 days of receiving notice.
04System
Investigation
Interviews, document requests and sometimes subpoenas; 100 days is the target.
05System
Conciliation offered
The agency tries to settle the complaint while it investigates.
06System
Finding or closure
No cause, a charge, a settlement, a withdrawal or an administrative closure.
07Your team
Hearing or court
After a charge, either side may elect federal court within 20 days.
Simplified sequence under 42 U.S.C. §§ 3610 to 3612. State and local agencies follow their own procedures.
The law asks HUD to complete the investigation within 100 days unless that is impracticable[2], and to decide within the same window whether there is reasonable cause[8]. In practice many cases run past that mark. In fiscal 2024, 1,385 new HUD cases and 3,526 new cases at state and local agencies passed 100 days without completion[7]. Plan for months, keep the hold in place throughout, and keep the agent's file current as new requests arrive.
A complainant can also sue directly. A private fair housing lawsuit may be filed up to two years after the alleged practice, whether or not a HUD complaint was filed, with time spent in an administrative proceeding not counted[9].
Who files, and about what
Fair housing groups, HUD, state and local agencies and the Justice Department received 32,321 complaints in 2024, down from 34,150 in 2023. Private nonprofit fair housing organizations processed 74.12% of them, state and local agencies 20.90% and HUD 4.85%[1]. That spread suggests how many brokerages first meet the process: through a private group's testers, or a rental applicant's call to a local organization that then files or refers the complaint.
Rentals dominate. Rental complaints made up 83.56% of the 2024 total, 27,007 complaints, while real estate sales accounted for 659[10]. A brokerage with a leasing desk or a property management arm carries most of its exposure there, which is also where phone scripts get the least attention. If testing is new to you, how brokerages prepare for fair housing testing explains how test calls are run.
Preserve the call records before anyone asks
Investigators work from documents, and they can compel them. HUD may issue subpoenas and order discovery in fair housing investigations, and willfully failing to produce evidence under subpoena, or falsifying or mutilating records to mislead, can bring a fine of up to $100,000, a year in prison, or both[3]. The practical lesson is simpler than the penalty: collect the records early, keep them exactly as they were, and let counsel decide what is produced.
| Record | Where it usually lives | Why investigators want it |
|---|---|---|
| Call recordings and transcripts | Phone system, answering service or answering account | What was actually said, in the caller's own words |
| Texts and emails with the complainant | Agent phones, email, CRM | Tone, timing and what information was offered |
| Showing requests and schedules | Showing service, calendar, CRM | Whether the complainant was offered the same access as others |
| Listing ads and versions | MLS history, portals, social posts | Wording, photos and any change after the contact |
| Applications and screening criteria | Leasing software, written policy | Whether criteria were written and applied the same way |
| Comparison callers | Same sources, same period | How other callers about the same property were treated |
| Training records | Brokerage files, association records | Whether staff were trained before the event |
The comparison set is the record brokerages most often forget. A complaint alleging that a caller with children was told a unit was taken is answered best by showing what every other caller was told that week. That only works if the calls were recorded, the recordings were kept and the state's recording consent rules were followed when they were made. Agents' fair housing training is part of the picture too: REALTORS must complete at least two hours of fair housing training in each three-year cycle running from 2025 through 2027[11].
If an SI Employee answers your listing or rental lines, each call is already in the account with a recording, transcript and summary. Identify the calls in the complaint's date range, including comparison callers, and list them in the hold notice so nobody deletes them. Brokerages that send call summaries into their CRM through webhooks or Zapier (integrations) will also have them alongside the rest of the client record.
Managing the agent named in the complaint
The agent at the center of a complaint is usually anxious, sometimes angry and often keen to explain. Give them one channel for that: a written account to the broker and counsel, not a text to the complainant, a post in an agents' group chat or a call to the other side's agent. Remind them in writing of the hold and of the rule against contact about the complaint.
Keep supervision proportionate. Unless the facts are already clear, the agent can usually keep working other files while the broker reviews their rental and showing calls more closely for a few weeks. Decisions about discipline belong to the broker and counsel, made on the record rather than in the heat of the first day.
Plan for the agent leaving before the case ends. Their texts, voicemails and call logs may sit on a personal phone, and they walk out with it. A BYOD policy that requires term-bearing messages to be copied into brokerage files, and suspends deletion under a hold, keeps the evidence with the firm.
Writing the answer
The answer is the brokerage's first chance to tell its side, and investigators read it alongside everything else they collect. Counsel should write or review it. These habits make it more useful.
- Lead with a dated chronology: every contact with the complainant, who made it, how, and what was said or sent.
- State facts, not adjectives. “The agent offered two showing times by text at 4:12 p.m.” beats “the agent was always professional.”
- Explain the business reason for each decision, such as a written screening criterion or the listing's status that day, and attach the document that shows it.
- Show consistency: the same script, the same information and the same criteria for other callers about the same property.
- Do not comment on the complainant's character or motives, and do not speculate about who might have been a tester.
- If something went wrong, say so plainly and describe what has changed. A credible correction helps more than a defense that the records contradict.
Example: a fictional rental applicant alleges she was told a two-bedroom was no longer available after mentioning a housing program. The brokerage's answer attaches the listing's status history, the recording of her call, recordings of the three other calls about the unit that day, the written screening criteria and the agent's training certificate. The chronology fits on one page.
Conciliation, findings and penalties
HUD must try to conciliate a complaint during the investigation to the extent feasible[8]. A conciliation agreement is made public unless the complainant and respondent agree otherwise[2], while what is said or done during conciliation cannot be made public or used as evidence later without written consent[8]. Settling is often the sensible business decision, but it is a decision for the broker and counsel, not for the agent alone.
Most cases end before a hearing. Of 8,188 cases completed by HUD and state and local agencies in 2024, 4,308 closed with a no-cause finding and 1,755 with a conciliation or settlement; 471 were charged or found to have cause[6].
When a charge is issued, any party may elect to have the claims decided in federal court instead of before an administrative law judge, and the election must be made within 20 days of receiving service[12]. If the case stays administrative, the maximum civil penalty per discriminatory practice is currently $26,262 with no prior violation, $65,653 with one prior in five years and $131,308 with two or more in seven years[13], on top of any damages and orders to change practices.
After the case closes
Whatever the outcome, treat the complaint as a free audit. Read the recordings again with the managing broker and ask what a tester would have heard. Rewrite any script line that depended on the agent's judgment about who the caller was; fair housing rules for call scripts and intake has wording that asks every caller the same questions.
Then make the record easier to defend next time. Keep recordings and showing logs under a written retention schedule, review a sample of rental calls each month, and if any automated tool answers your phones, read the compliance risks of AI in real estate before you change its script. The front desk routing example shows a modelled setup in which every call to the main line ends with a written summary and a named owner, which is the kind of record that answers a complaint quickly.
Frequently asked questions
How long does someone have to file a fair housing complaint?
One year from the alleged practice for a complaint to HUD[2], and two years for a private lawsuit, not counting time an administrative case was pending[9]. Keep related records at least that long, and longer under a hold.
Can we call the complainant to sort it out?
Not about the complaint, except through counsel or the agency. Interfering with someone exercising fair housing rights is itself unlawful[4]. If you want to resolve it, conciliation through the agency is the route[8].
Does the agent respond, or the brokerage?
Often both are named. The broker supervises the agent and usually coordinates one response through counsel, with the agent's written account and documents attached. The agent should not send a separate answer without the broker and counsel seeing it.
What if the investigation runs past 100 days?
That is common. The statute sets 100 days unless completion is impracticable[2], and in fiscal 2024 HUD had 1,385 new cases pass that mark[7]. Keep the hold in place and respond promptly to each new request.
Do we have to hand over call recordings?
If they are requested or subpoenaed, generally yes, through counsel. HUD can subpoena evidence, and failing to produce it or altering records carries criminal penalties[3]. Preserve recordings and transcripts the day the notice arrives.
References
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3610: Administrative enforcement; preliminary matters (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3611: Subpoenas; giving of evidence (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3617: Interference, coercion, or intimidation (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report: complaints by basis (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report: 2024 HUD and FHAP case completion types (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report: aged cases (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3610: conciliation, referral to certified agencies and reasonable cause (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3613: Enforcement by private persons (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report: complaints by transaction type (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Fair Housing Training Requirement (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code § 3612: Enforcement by Secretary (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 24 CFR § 180.671: Assessing civil penalties for Fair Housing Act cases (opens in a new tab) ↑