Key takeaways
- Most sellers weigh an agent's community reputation heavily, and most consumers read reviews first[1][2].
- Ask every client at the moments they feel your value, with a direct link and a short script.
- No incentives, no fake or insider reviews and no asking only happy clients[3][4].
- Reply to every review; Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking[5].
Why reviews decide who gets the call
Reviews are the first proof a stranger sees. In Zillow's 2026 seller survey, 74% of agent-using sellers rated an agent's positive reputation in the community as very or extremely important[2]. Pew found that 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, and 40% nearly always rely on them[1]. A seller comparing three agents will often call the one with recent, specific reviews.
Younger clients lean on reviews most. That matters as first-time buyers become your next sellers.
Source: Pew Research Center, 2016[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Ages 18 to 29 | 53% |
| Ages 30 to 49 | 47% |
In Pew's data, 53% of adults aged 18 to 29 and 47% of those aged 30 to 49 always or almost always read reviews before a first-time purchase[1].
Where reviews matter
| Platform | Who sees it | How to ask | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | Anyone searching your name or agents nearby | Direct review link from your profile | Feeds local search results |
| Zillow agent profile | Buyers and sellers on Zillow | Review request from your Zillow profile | Often tied to transactions |
| Realtor.com profile | Buyers and sellers on Realtor.com | Request from your profile | Some reviews tied to verified deals |
| Facebook page | Your sphere and their friends | Recommendation link | Good for social proof |
| Your website | Visitors already considering you | Ask permission to quote reviews from other platforms | Quote accurately with the source |
Pick one primary platform per client rather than sending three links. For most agents that is Google, because it shows up in the most searches, with a portal profile second.
The rules you can't break
The FTC's 2024 rule bans creating or selling fake reviews and testimonials, including AI-generated ones, prohibits offering compensation or incentives conditioned on writing consumer reviews, and restricts reviews by company insiders that don't disclose the connection[3]. The FTC can seek civil penalties against knowing violators[3].
Google's policy adds its own limits: no reviews paid for directly or in kind, no incentives such as discounts or free services for a review, and no discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive ones; it also treats content based on a conflict of interest, which may include current or former employment, as a violation[4].
- No gift cards, discounts, raffles or donations in exchange for reviews.
- No reviews from your family, your team, your assistant or your broker.
- No writing reviews for clients to post, even if they agree with the words.
- No asking only the clients you expect to be happy.
- No contract clauses that restrict honest reviews; the Consumer Review Fairness Act bars form contracts that restrict reviews or penalize people for them[6].
When to ask
- The day after closing, when relief and gratitude are highest.
- After a win during the deal, such as an accepted offer in a competitive situation, asking them to review once the deal closes.
- At the 30-day check-in after the move, when the client has settled in.
- When a past client thanks you for a referral you handled well.
Build the first ask into your closing checklist so it never depends on remembering.
How to ask
In person, at closing: “I loved working with you both. Would you be willing to write a short, honest review about what it was like? I'll text you the link tonight so it's easy.”
Text: “Thanks again for trusting me with your sale, Dana. Here's the link for a quick review if you're willing. Honest feedback helps the next family decide and helps me improve. [link]”
Email follow-up a week later: “Just a gentle reminder in case it got buried. If you have two minutes, a short review would mean a lot. If anything about our work together could have been better, I'd like to hear that too.”
Ask once, remind once and stop. Pressure produces short, generic reviews and annoyed clients.
Make it easy to write a useful review
- Send the direct review link, not the profile page, and test it on a phone first.
- Suggest what readers find helpful, without writing it for them: the neighborhood, what was hard, how you communicated.
- Offer to walk them through posting if they aren't comfortable with the platform.
- Have a QR code on your closing gift card that opens the review link.
Reviews for teams and brokerages
Teams face extra questions: whose profile gets the review, and how do you keep the request consistent across agents? Decide once and write it into the team's closing checklist.
- Ask the client to review the agent who did most of the work, on that agent's profile, and add the team name in the reply.
- If the team has one shared profile, ask clients to mention the agent by name so readers see who helped them.
- Give every agent the same scripts and links, so the experience doesn't depend on who closed the deal.
- Have the team leader or a coordinator check weekly that every closing received a request.
- Never let agents review each other or post on behalf of clients.
Brokerages can support this with a shared list of review links, a monthly report of new reviews by agent and a policy on replies, especially to negative reviews, so tone stays consistent.
Ask everyone, not only the happy ones
Review gating, meaning sending a survey first and asking only happy clients to post publicly, is against Google's policy[4]. It is also a missed chance: a client who had a rough experience and is asked for honest feedback often softens once they feel heard. If you think a client is unhappy, call them before the review request and ask what went wrong. Then send the same request you send everyone.
Reply to positive reviews
Reply to every review within a few days. Thank the client by first name, mention one specific detail from the deal that they already shared publicly, and stop there. Never add private information they didn't mention, such as price, financing or why they moved.
Reply: “Thank you, Marcus! Finding a home with room for the workshop took patience, and it was a pleasure to see you get the keys. Enjoy the new place.”
Replies matter for search too. Google says that more reviews and positive ratings can help a business's local ranking, and that replying to reviews shows customers you value their feedback[5].
Put reviews to work
Reviews are useful well beyond the platform where they were posted. With the client's permission, and quoted accurately with the source and date, they can support the rest of your marketing.
- Add two or three recent reviews to your listing presentation and your seller guide.
- Quote a review on the neighborhood page for the area where that client bought or sold.
- Use a short quote in an email newsletter or a social post, linking to the original.
- Read reviews aloud at team meetings so agents hear what clients value most.
Keep a simple file of every review with the date, platform, client and whether you have permission to quote it. When a client asks you to remove their quote from your marketing, take it down promptly and note it in the file.
Build the habit into every closing
Closing day
Ask in person and send the link the same evening.
Day 7
One reminder if no review has appeared.
Day 30
Check-in call about the move; if they posted, thank them again.
Monthly
Reply to every new review and log the count and average rating.
Quarterly
Read all reviews for themes and fix the issues they raise.
Measure progress
Track requests sent, reviews received, average rating and how many new clients mention reviews as a reason they called. A request-to-review rate tells you whether your ask works.
Example: an agent closes 24 deals in a year but has only 6 reviews from the previous three years. She adds the closing-day ask and a single reminder to her checklist. Over the next year 17 of 24 clients leave reviews, and 5 new sellers say reviews were why they called. For handling the occasional bad review, see responding to negative reviews.
Frequently asked questions
Can I offer a gift card for a review?
No. The FTC's 2024 rule prohibits incentives conditioned on writing reviews, and Google's policy bans incentives such as payment, discounts or free services for reviews.
Can my team members or family review me?
No. The FTC restricts undisclosed insider reviews, and Google treats conflict-of-interest content, including from current or former employees, as a violation.
Is it okay to ask only happy clients for reviews?
No. Google prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews. Ask every client the same way.
Which review site matters most for agents?
Usually Google, because it appears in local searches for agents. Add one portal profile where your buyers and sellers search.
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Maps User Generated Content Policy Help (2026). Prohibited and restricted content (Maps user-generated content policy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Tips to improve your local ranking on Google (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2017). Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know (opens in a new tab) ↑