Key takeaways
- Ask early whether a lead has an exclusive agreement; the REALTOR Code of Ethics requires reasonable efforts to find out[1].
- If they are under an exclusive agreement, help with listing information and step back gracefully.
- Written buyer agreements are now common, so many “I have an agent” answers are literally true[2].
- A respectful exit protects your reputation, and the lead may return when their agreement ends.
Why this answer is more common now
Almost every buyer and seller now works with an agent. NAR's 2026 Profile found that 90% of buyers used a real estate agent or broker, the highest share in four decades, and 92% of sellers did, an all-time high[3][4]. When a new lead says “I already have an agent,” it is often simply true.
Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Buyers | 90% |
| Sellers | 92% |
The relationship is also more likely to be in writing. Since August 17, 2024, many buyers working with a REALTOR are asked to sign a written buyer agreement, a requirement from NAR's settlement of commission litigation[2]. NAR's consumer guide says a written agreement is needed before touring a home with an agent, while visiting an open house alone or asking about services does not require one[5]. A buyer who has toured homes with someone has probably signed something.
What the Code of Ethics says
For REALTORS, the 2026 Code of Ethics sets the boundaries[1]. In plain terms:
- Article 16: REALTORS must not take any action inconsistent with the exclusive representation or exclusive brokerage agreements other REALTORS have with clients.
- Standard of Practice 16-9: before entering a representation agreement, a REALTOR must make reasonable efforts to find out whether the prospect is already subject to a current, valid exclusive agreement for the same type of service.
- Standard of Practice 16-13: before providing substantive services, such as writing an offer or presenting a CMA, a REALTOR must ask prospects whether they are party to any exclusive representation agreement.
- Standard of Practice 16-6: if another REALTOR's client contacts you about creating an exclusive relationship and you did not initiate it, you may discuss terms for a future agreement or sign one that takes effect when the existing agreement expires.
State license law and your brokerage's policies may add rules. When a situation is unclear, ask your managing broker before acting. This article explains common practice, not legal advice.
Ask the question early
The simplest way to avoid trouble is to ask before you do any real work. Make it part of every first conversation, phrased so it does not sound like a test:
- “Before we go further, are you working with an agent already, or have you signed an agreement with anyone?”
- For sellers: “Is your home listed with anyone right now, or have you signed with an agent?”
- If they hesitate: “No wrong answer. I just want to make sure I'm not stepping on anyone's toes.”
Record the answer in your CRM along with the date. If the situation later turns into a dispute, a dated note that you asked is useful.
What to do in each situation
| What the lead says | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| “I signed an agreement with my agent.” | Exclusive buyer representation | Answer listing questions, suggest their agent books the showing, step back |
| “I've been talking to someone, but nothing's signed.” | No exclusive agreement yet | You may proceed; avoid criticizing the other agent |
| “My cousin is an agent.” | Unclear; may be informal | Ask whether they plan to work with their cousin; respect the answer |
| “My agent is selling my house, I'm looking to buy elsewhere.” | Listing agreement only, possibly not buyer side | Ask if the agreement covers buying; check with your broker |
| “I had an agent but it's ending.” | Agreement may be expiring | Ask when it ends; you may discuss a future agreement if they initiated |
| “I'm not sure what I signed.” | Unknown | Suggest they check the document or ask their agent; do not interpret it for them |
Scripts for the respectful exit
When a lead is under an exclusive agreement, the goal is to help without interfering and to leave a good impression.
- On a listing inquiry: “Thanks for letting me know. I'm happy to answer anything about the home itself. Your agent can contact me directly to book a showing or ask for disclosures.”
- By text: “Thanks, that's helpful to know. Your agent can reach me at this number about 14 Grove Street anytime.”
- If they want to see your listing today: “Your agent can set that up with me. If they're unavailable, they can let me know and we'll find a time that works.”
- If they complain about their agent: “I'm sorry it's been frustrating. The best step is to talk with your agent or their broker about it. I can't get involved while you have an agreement with them.”
Do not ask about the terms of their agreement, offer a better deal, or suggest they could get out of it. Those are exactly the actions Article 16 is meant to prevent.
When the lead wants to switch agents
Sometimes the buyer or seller raises it: “I'm not happy with my agent. Can I work with you instead?” The Code allows a response if you did not start the conversation[1].
Confirm they initiated it
Note in your CRM that the client contacted you and raised the switch.
Ask when the agreement ends
Do not ask to see it or interpret its terms. Suggest they read it or ask their agent or the agent's broker how it can end.
Discuss future terms only
You may explain how you work and what a future agreement would look like, or sign one that takes effect when the current agreement expires.
Do not provide substantive services yet
No showings, offers or pricing reports while the existing agreement is in force.
Involve your broker
Ask your managing broker to review before anything is signed.
Special cases you will meet
A few situations come up often enough to plan for. Agree the approach with your broker once, then train everyone who answers the phone or staffs open houses.
- Open house visitors with an agent. Welcome them, answer questions about the home and ask them to have their agent contact you with any offer. Do not ask them to sign your sign-in sheet as a buyer lead without noting that they are represented.
- Sign calls from represented buyers. Give the facts the listing sheet supports and offer to arrange a showing through their agent. Note the agent's name if they share it.
- A seller whose listing has expired with another agent. Once the listing has truly ended, you may contact them, but check your MLS status and your local rules first, and never criticize the previous agent.
- A buyer represented on a different type of service. A buyer agreement for purchases in one county may not cover a rental search or a different area. Ask the buyer to check, and ask your broker before proceeding.
- Friends and family. If a lead's relative is an agent, ask openly whether they plan to work with that relative. Many people mention a relative out of politeness and then choose someone else; let them decide.
In every case, the safest habit is the same: ask, write down the answer, and when in doubt, check before you provide substantive services.
Why stepping back pays off
It is tempting to see every “I have an agent” as a lost lead. In practice, a graceful exit often earns more than a push would. The other agent remembers that you were professional. The buyer may need you later, for a future purchase or when a relative needs an agent.
Loyalty to agents is high once a relationship forms. Zillow's 2026 research found that 81% of seller-buyers who used an agent hired the same agent to sell their old home and buy their new one[6]. That works in your favor with your own clients, and it is a reason not to waste effort trying to pry clients away from others.
Example: a fictional listing agent gets a portal inquiry from a buyer who says she has signed with another agent. He answers her questions about the HOA, sends the disclosures to her agent and books a showing through that agent the next day. The buyer does not purchase the home, but a year later refers her parents, who are selling, to him.
Set up your process
- Add “working with an agent?” as a required field in your lead form or first-call notes.
- Write the respectful-exit scripts into your templates so every team member uses them.
- Train inside sales agents and assistants on Article 16 basics, since they often take the first call.
- Route callers who are represented to the listing agent or showing coordinator, not into a buyer rotation.
For more on early-stage objections, see what to say when a lead is just looking, and for team response rules, see setting lead response standards.
Frequently asked questions
Can I keep talking to a lead who says they have an agent?
You can answer factual questions about your listing and arrange showings through their agent. Do not provide substantive services, such as writing an offer or a pricing analysis, or do anything inconsistent with their exclusive agreement.
Am I required to ask whether a lead has an agent?
Under the REALTOR Code of Ethics, you must make reasonable efforts to find out before entering a representation agreement, and ask before providing substantive services such as writing an offer or presenting a CMA.
What if the lead says they want to switch to me?
If they started the conversation, you may discuss terms for a future agreement or one that takes effect when their current agreement expires. Involve your managing broker and avoid providing services in the meantime.
What if the lead isn't sure whether they signed anything?
Suggest they check their documents or ask their agent. Do not interpret the agreement for them, and wait to provide substantive services until it is clear.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). 2026 Code of Ethics & Standards of Practice (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑