Key takeaways
- With sellers staying a median of 12 years[1], a client may have a dozen home anniversaries before they move again. Each is a natural reason to reconnect.
- Life events drive moves: 77% of sellers cite one, most often a change in household size (47%)[2]. Anniversary calls are where you hear about them first.
- Vary the touch each year: a card, a value update, a maintenance reminder, a visit. Never send the same template twice.
- Make calls at reasonable hours; federal rules bar telephone solicitations before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time[3].
Why the home anniversary works
Most follow-up feels like marketing because it has no reason to exist. A home anniversary does. It is the client's date, not yours, and it marks something they are proud of. A short note on that day reads as remembering them, not selling to them.
The gap between transactions is long. Sellers had owned their homes for a median of 12 years before selling, an all-time high[1]. That is a dozen anniversaries. An agent who marks each one well is the agent the client calls when the time comes, and the one they mention when friends ask in between. NAR reports that agents are leaning more on repeat and referral business[4], and anniversaries are one of the most reliable ways to keep those relationships warm.
Life events are what move people
People rarely move because of the market. They move because life changes. In Zillow's 2026 seller research, 77% of sellers said a life event influenced their move, most often a change in household size (47%), a new job (30%) or remote work (27%)[2]. Those events often show up in conversation months before anyone calls an agent.
The decision also builds slowly: the median seller thought seriously about selling for three to four months before listing[2]. An anniversary call that lands in that window, and listens well, gives the client a trusted person to think out loud with.
A year-by-year anniversary plan
| Anniversary | Touch idea | What to share |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | Handwritten card and a call | Thanks, a short market note for their street |
| Year 2 | Home maintenance gift, such as new air filters or a smoke detector set | A seasonal maintenance checklist |
| Year 3 | Home value update with a call to walk through it | Recent nearby sales and what drives value |
| Year 4 | Local experience, such as a coffee shop card or event tickets | What is new in the neighborhood |
| Year 5 | Visit or video call | Equity and value review, renovation ideas that pay back |
| Years 6 to 12 | Rotate cards, small gifts, value updates and visits | Life stage topics: space, schools, downsizing |
What every anniversary touch should include
- Their names, the address and how many years it has been. Get these right; a wrong year undoes the gesture.
- One personal line from your CRM notes: the garden they planned, the baby on the way, the dog that loved the yard.
- One useful thing: a checklist, a local tip, a market fact about their street.
- An easy, low-pressure way to reply, such as “Write back anytime if you want a fresh value estimate.”
- Your name and the same number they saved when they bought or sold.
Leave out the sales pitch. “Thinking of selling?” on an anniversary card feels transactional. The value update, offered as information, does the job without asking.
Ideas that cost little and land well
Anniversary touches do not need a big budget. What makes them work is fit and timing. A few ideas agents use:
- A photo of the house from the listing or move-in day, printed and framed, on the first anniversary.
- A seasonal item tied to the date: bulbs to plant in autumn, a sprinkler timer in spring, an ice scraper in winter.
- A local voucher from a small business near the home, such as a bakery, garden center or hardware store.
- A short, handwritten list of three things happening in their neighborhood that month.
- A family-friendly invitation, such as a pumpkin patch or a park event your team sponsors, if the household has children.
- For long-time owners, a note on what their street looked like in the year they bought, using old sales data.
Mistakes that make anniversaries feel automated
- Getting the year, the names or the address wrong. Check before anything is sent.
- Sending the same card design and message every year.
- Mailing to the old address after the client has moved, which shows the list is not maintained.
- Leading with a request for a listing or a referral.
- Attaching an automated value estimate with no explanation, which can alarm owners if the number is low.
- Never calling. A card alone, year after year, slowly becomes junk mail.
Review your past-client list once a year to remove anyone who has moved or asked not to be contacted, and to fix names after marriages, divorces and deaths.
Home value updates, done honestly
Clients love to know what their home might be worth, but an automated estimate sent without context can mislead. Prepare value updates the same way you would for a listing consultation, in a lighter form: three to five recent nearby sales, the current number of competing listings and a range rather than a single number. Say clearly that it is an estimate, not an appraisal, and offer to walk through it.
Timing can help. Seller activity tends to build from the start of the year, and by the end of June new sellers have historically reached nearly 1.4 times their level at the start of the year[5]. If a client's anniversary falls in winter, a value update with a short note on what spring usually brings is especially useful to anyone who has been wondering.
The anniversary call
Open with the date
“Hi Mark, it is Jen. I realized it has been three years since you got the keys to Cedar Lane. How is the house treating you?”
Ask about the house
“Did you ever finish the basement you were planning?” Use your notes.
Ask about life
“How are the kids? Still enjoying the school?” Listen; do not rush to the market.
Offer one useful thing
“I put together a quick note on recent sales near you. Want me to send it?”
Note what you heard
After the call, record any life events, plans or concerns in the CRM, and set a reminder if something is likely to change soon.
Owners at later life stages
Repeat buyers are older than many agents expect: the median repeat buyer is 62, up from 36 in 1981[1]. For long-time owners, anniversaries often bring different questions: whether the house still fits, whether stairs are becoming a problem, whether to help a grown child buy nearby. Approach these gently. Offer information on aging-in-place updates and on downsizing options without assuming which way they will go.
When the client wonders about renting it out
Some anniversary conversations turn to renting rather than selling. In Zillow's research, 66% of sellers at least thought about renting out their home before selling, and 24% seriously considered it[2]. If a client asks, give them a fair picture: likely rent for similar homes, the work and costs of being a landlord and when to talk to a tax professional. If you do not work with rentals, refer them to someone who does. Being helpful when there is no sale for you is what clients remember.
Call at sensible hours
Anniversary calls are personal, but they can still be treated as marketing contacts. Federal rules bar telephone solicitations to residential subscribers before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the called party's location[3], and many states add their own rules. Keep calls to daytime and early evening, use the channel the client chose, and remove anyone who asks you to stop contacting them.
Run it as a system
- Store the closing date, address, household names and personal notes for every past client in your CRM.
- Run a report at the start of each month listing next month's anniversaries.
- Decide each client's touch for the year from the plan above, and order cards or gifts in one batch.
- Block an hour a week for anniversary calls and notes.
- After each touch, update the notes, and mark any life event that could lead to a move or a referral.
Example: year four for a past client
Example: a fictional agent in Colorado sees that the Okafor family's fourth anniversary is next month. Her notes say they had a second child last year and that the parents work from home. She sends a card with a local bakery voucher and a short note about two recent sales on their street. When she calls a week later, the family mentions they are running out of space. She does not pitch; she offers to send a few examples of what larger homes nearby have sold for. In this Example, the family lists with her the following spring and refers a neighbor.
The first year sets the pattern, so start with the post-closing follow-up plan. For a gift that fits each anniversary, see closing gifts ideas and tax rules.
Frequently asked questions
What should I send clients on their home anniversary?
A personal touch that changes each year: a handwritten card, a small useful gift, a home value update or a visit. Always include one personal line and one useful piece of information.
Should I include a home value estimate?
Every few years, yes, prepared from recent nearby sales and presented as a range, not an appraisal. Offer to walk through it on a call.
How do I keep track of past clients' anniversaries?
Store each closing date in your CRM and run a monthly report of the next month's anniversaries. Batch the cards and calls so it takes an hour a week.
Is a home anniversary call considered marketing?
It can be. Call at reasonable hours, use the channel the client prefers and stop contacting anyone who asks you to.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Realtor.com Economic Research (2026). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) ↑