Key takeaways
- Read the market before choosing levers: inventory, days on market and pending sales tell you how hard to push[1][2][3].
- Price is only one lever. Certainty, timing and clean terms often matter as much to a seller.
- Many buyers already compete on terms: in September 2026, 20% waived the inspection contingency and 27% paid cash[4].
- Every concession request, including help with your fee, changes how the offer looks, so discuss it with the buyer first[5].
Start with the market, not the house
A competitive offer in a slow market looks different from one in a bidding war. Before you discuss price, look at three numbers for the buyer’s area and price band: months of supply, days on market and the trend in pending sales. Nationally, inventory stood at 1.60 million homes in September 2026, a 4.8-month supply[2], and the median existing home sold in 33 days[1]. Pending home sales fell 7.3% from August and 11.3% from a year earlier[3].
National numbers set the backdrop; your local data decides the strategy. A well-priced home in a popular school zone can draw multiple offers in a soft national market, and an overpriced listing can sit for months in a hot one. Pull the local figures for the specific neighborhood and price range, and compare the listing’s days on market with its peers.
The levers a buyer can pull
| Lever | What it signals to the seller | Cost or risk to the buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Most visible; sets the headline number | Paying more than needed; appraisal risk |
| Escalation clause | Willingness to compete up to a cap | Reveals the buyer’s ceiling if poorly drafted |
| Earnest money | Seriousness; money at stake | More money at risk if the buyer defaults |
| Financing strength | Certainty of closing | Larger down payment ties up cash |
| Inspection terms | Fewer renegotiation risks | Less protection against defects |
| Appraisal terms | Less risk if the appraisal is low | Buyer may need cash to cover a gap |
| Closing date and possession | Fits the seller’s move | Less flexibility for the buyer |
| Concession requests | Fewer requests look cleaner | More cash needed at closing |
No buyer should pull every lever. The job is to find the two or three that matter most to this seller and that the buyer can afford to use.
What other buyers are doing
It helps to know what your buyer is competing against. NAR’s Realtors Confidence Index for September 2026 found that 20% of buyers waived the inspection contingency, 18% waived the appraisal contingency and 27% paid cash[4]. All-cash sales were down from 30% a year earlier[6], but a financed buyer still meets a cash buyer in many multiple-offer situations.
Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Paid cash | 27% |
| Waived the inspection contingency | 20% |
| Waived the appraisal contingency | 18% |
These figures are not targets. They show that some buyers accept more risk to win, which is why your buyer needs to decide, in advance, how much risk they are willing to take. For inspection alternatives short of a full waiver, see inspection contingency options in competitive markets.
Call the listing agent first
The best information about what a seller wants usually comes from a two-minute call. Ask open questions and listen more than you talk.
- Are you expecting multiple offers, and is there a deadline?
- What matters most to the seller besides price: timing, certainty, possession, a rent-back?
- Is the seller working with a particular closing date in mind?
- Will the seller consider requests for credits, including toward buyer broker compensation?
- How would the seller like offers presented, and what should accompany them?
Script: “I’m likely bringing an offer on your listing. Before we write it, is there anything about timing or terms that would make an offer easier for your seller to say yes to?”
Matching levers to the seller’s situation
Different sellers value different things, and the listing agent’s answers usually point to one of a few common situations. Use them to choose your levers.
- A seller who has already bought elsewhere usually wants speed and certainty: offer a firm closing date, strong financing and short contingency periods.
- A seller who has not found their next home may value flexibility: offer a rent-back or a closing date that waits for their purchase.
- An estate or relocation sale often prioritizes simplicity: fewer repair requests and an as-is approach with an inspection for information only.
- A seller whose listing has sat for weeks may care most about price and net proceeds, so concessions and fee requests become easier.
- A first-time seller may be anxious about the process: a clear, well-organized offer package and a calm call from you can carry real weight.
Write down the situation you think applies and test it on your call with the listing agent. If you are wrong, adjust before the offer goes out, not after it is rejected.
Protecting the buyer while competing
Competitive offers create pressure to give away protections. Your job is to make sure every trade-off is a decision the buyer made with the facts, not one they drifted into at 11 p.m.
- Put the walk-away price and any waived or shortened contingencies in an email to the buyer before submitting.
- Explain in writing what the buyer risks with each lever, such as earnest money at stake or a possible appraisal gap.
- Confirm the buyer has the cash to cover any gap they have agreed to cover.
- Keep the buyer agreement and the offer consistent on fee and concessions.
Building the offer, step by step
Confirm financing
Get an underwritten approval or a strong lender letter, and confirm the lender can meet the closing date.
Set the walk-away number
Agree with the buyer the highest price they will pay, before emotions run high, and write it in your notes.
Choose the levers
Pick the two or three terms that matter most to this seller and that the buyer can accept.
Decide on concessions
Decide whether to request seller help with closing costs or your fee, and how that request affects competitiveness[5].
Price with the appraisal in mind
If the offer may exceed likely appraised value, agree how the buyer would handle a gap.
Package it cleanly
Complete forms carefully, attach the lender letter and proof of funds and send a short cover note summarizing the key terms.
Follow up
Confirm receipt and ask when the seller will decide. Keep the buyer updated.
The fee question inside the offer
Since the settlement, many offers include a request that the seller pay some or all of the buyer broker’s compensation. NAR’s FAQ confirms a buyer can always ask their broker to make that a term of the offer[5]. In a multiple-offer situation, though, a large request can make an offer less attractive than a competitor’s, even at the same price.
Treat the request as one of the levers and let the buyer decide with full information. Show them the net effect: a higher price with no fee request may net the seller the same as a lower price with one, but the two read very differently. For how to write the request, see seller concessions toward buyer broker fees.
Things that weaken offers
- A lender letter that is out of date or does not name the property price range.
- A closing date the lender cannot meet.
- Vague or missing terms that force the listing agent to call with questions.
- A long inspection period in a market where sellers expect a short one.
- Personal letters to the seller; many brokerages discourage them because they can invite decisions based on characteristics protected by the Fair Housing Act[7].
Example: winning without the highest price
Example. A fictional buyer, Aisha, competes for a three-bedroom listed at $415,000, close to the national median of $417,500[8]. The listing agent says the seller needs a 45-day close and is worried about a deal falling through. Aisha offers $418,000 with a conventional loan, a 10-day inspection period, a lender letter with direct contact details, a 45-day close and no request for broker compensation from the seller. Another buyer offers $422,000 with a 30-day close the seller cannot use and a request for $8,000 in credits. The seller accepts Aisha’s offer.
Example, continued. Aisha did not win by waiving everything. She won because her agent found out what the seller needed and used the levers that answered it.
After the offer is accepted
- Send the executed contract to the lender, title company and inspector the same day.
- Put every contract deadline in a shared calendar with the buyer.
- Confirm the earnest money delivery and keep proof.
- Repeat the wire fraud warning in writing.
- Schedule inspections immediately to protect the inspection period.
Escalation clauses are another lever in multiple-offer situations; see escalation clauses: how they work and when to use them.
Frequently asked questions
What makes an offer competitive besides price?
Certainty and fit: strong financing, a closing date that suits the seller, reasonable contingency periods and few requests. In September 2026, some buyers also competed by waiving contingencies or paying cash[4].
Should my buyer waive the inspection to win?
Only after weighing the risk. Consider options short of a full waiver, such as a shorter inspection period or an informational inspection.
Can the offer ask the seller to pay the buyer agent’s fee?
Yes. NAR’s FAQ says a buyer can ask their broker to make seller-paid compensation a term of the offer[5]. It may affect how competitive the offer looks.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Realtors Confidence Index, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). NAR Settlement FAQs (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑