Key takeaways
- A pending sale is not a closed sale: 47% of sellers had at least one offer fall through in 2026, so the home may come back[1].
- Lead with empathy and a plan in the first minute, not with “sorry, it’s sold”.
- Ask what they loved about the home; the answer is a better search than any portal filter.
- The market gives you options: existing-home supply stood at 4.8 months and new-home supply at 8.4 months in September 2026[2][3].
The call that decides whether you keep the buyer
A buyer finds the home: the right street, the kitchen they wanted, a yard for the dog. They call you, excited, and you check the MLS. It went under contract yesterday. What you say in the next minute decides whether that buyer stays with you or drifts off to keep scrolling on their own.
Most agents say some version of “Sorry, that one’s gone,” then offer to send other listings. The buyer hears that the home they wanted is lost and that you are moving on. A better response treats the moment as information: it tells you exactly what this buyer wants, and it gives you a reason to stay in close contact over the next few weeks.
Pending is not closed
Start with the facts. An accepted offer is not a finished sale. In Zillow’s 2026 seller survey, 47% of sellers reported having at least one offer fall through, down from 54% the year before[1]. Inspections, appraisals and financing all give buyers and sellers ways out, and some deals do not survive them.
Status labels vary by MLS. Some markets distinguish between “active under contract”, “contingent” and “pending”, and each may signal a different stage. Know what your local labels mean and explain them simply. A home that is under contract with an inspection contingency still open is a very different prospect from one that has cleared every contingency and is days from closing.
Be accurate, not hopeful. Do not tell a buyer a deal is likely to fall apart unless you have real information. Say that some contracts do not close, that you will watch this one and that you will act quickly if it comes back.
The first 60 seconds
Script: “Oh, I know. That one went under contract yesterday. I’m sorry, it really did look like a great fit. Here’s what I’d suggest. First, I’ll keep a close eye on it, because some contracts don’t make it to closing, and I can ask the listing agent whether the seller is taking backup offers. Second, tell me what you loved most about it, because I’d like to find you two or three homes with the same things. Do you have five minutes now?”
That script does three jobs. It acknowledges the disappointment, it offers a concrete plan rather than a vague promise and it asks a question that keeps the conversation going. Notice what it does not do: it does not pressure the buyer to look at something else immediately.
Backup offers: when they make sense
Ask the listing agent
Find out whether the seller will accept backup offers, how far the current contract has progressed and which contingencies remain open.
Check the buyer is ready
A backup offer needs the same preparation as a primary one: a current pre-approval or proof of funds, and a written buyer agreement in place. Buyers working with a REALTOR must sign one before touring a home with that agent[4].
Explain the trade-offs
A backup offer may tie up the buyer’s plans or deposit, depending on its terms. Walk through what happens if the first deal closes, and whether the buyer can keep looking meanwhile.
Write it carefully
Use your state’s backup or contingent addendum and make sure the buyer can withdraw on reasonable terms before the backup becomes primary.
Keep searching
A backup offer is a hedge, not a plan. Keep sending alternatives so the buyer has options either way.
What the market tells you
The broader market is less frantic than in recent years, which works in your favor. US housing inventory reached 1.60 million units in September 2026, a 4.8-month supply[2]. Pending home sales fell 7.3% from August and 11.3% year over year in September[5]. Multiple-offer situations are less common too: the median seller still received two offers, but 16% received four or more, down from 21% in 2025[1].
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2025 | 21% |
| 2026 | 16% |
Use this to reassure, not to pressure. The message to the buyer is that there are other homes, that competition for many of them is not as intense as it was, and that the next good fit may come with more room to negotiate.
Do not forget new construction
8.4 months
supply of new homes for sale at the September 2026 sales rate[3]
Buyers who fell for a specific style or a newer home may find more choice in new construction. The Census Bureau estimated 476,000 new houses were for sale at the end of September 2026, an 8.4-month supply[3], far more than the supply of existing homes. If the buyer is open to it, visit a builder’s community with them. Go with them on the first visit and register as their agent according to the builder’s rules, which often require the agent to be present the first time.
Find out what they loved
Three questions turn disappointment into a sharper search:
- “What made you stop scrolling when you saw it?”
- “If you could keep only two things about that home, which would they be?”
- “Was there anything about it you weren’t sure of?”
| What they loved | How to search for it | Alternatives to suggest |
|---|---|---|
| The street or school area | Draw a tight map boundary around the area | Homes in adjacent streets, or a slightly higher price band |
| The updated kitchen | Keyword search for “renovated” or “updated kitchen” | Homes with good layouts that need cosmetic work |
| The yard | Filter by lot size | Homes on corner lots or with usable side yards |
| The price | Set a strict maximum and a 90-day price-drop alert | Homes that have been on the market longer |
| The feel: light, layout, character | Hard to filter; review photos yourself | A personal shortlist with notes on why each matches |
When the inquiry comes from a new lead
Sometimes the buyer asking about the pending home is not your client yet. They saw it on a portal that had not updated, and you are the listing agent or the agent who answered the inquiry. This is one of the most common first conversations in real estate, and one of the most often wasted. Treat it exactly as you would for a client: acknowledge, explain the status, ask what drew them to the home and offer alternatives the same day.
Do not hide the status to get a meeting. Telling a new lead a home is available when it is not is the fastest way to lose their trust. Instead, give them a reason to talk to you: you know the home, you know why it sold quickly and you can find them something similar before the next one goes.
Mistakes that push the buyer away
- Sending a dozen automated listings that ignore what they loved about the lost home.
- Telling them they should have moved faster. They know; it does not help.
- Promising the deal will fall through, then going quiet when it does not.
- Showing homes well above their budget to “make up for it”, which leads to a second disappointment.
- Forgetting to cancel the pending-listing alert after the home closes, so they get a confusing notification weeks later.
A 48-hour plan
- Same day: the call above, plus a status alert on the pending listing so you know immediately if it returns to active.
- Next morning: a text with two or three homes that match what they loved, with one line on why each fits.
- Next evening: a call to hear their reaction and offer showings for the weekend.
- Every few days: a short update on the pending home if anything changes, and a weekly check even if nothing does.
Example: a buyer loses a craftsman bungalow to another offer. Her agent sets a status alert, finds out the seller will accept backups and helps her submit one with a clear withdrawal clause. He also learns that the porch and the walk to the park mattered most, and two days later shows her a bungalow three streets away that needs a new kitchen. She does not buy it, but she trusts his eye and keeps looking with him. Three weeks later the first contract ends over financing, her backup becomes the primary offer and she is under contract by the weekend.
Frequently asked questions
Can a buyer still see a home that is pending?
Sometimes. It depends on the seller, the listing agent and whether backup offers are being taken. Ask the listing agent, and make sure your buyer agreement is in place before any tour.
What is a backup offer?
An offer the seller accepts in second position, which becomes primary only if the current contract ends. Its terms should let your buyer withdraw on reasonable terms while waiting.
How often do pending sales fall through?
Often enough to watch. In Zillow’s 2026 survey, 47% of sellers had at least one offer fall through, down from 54% the year before.
How do I keep a buyer engaged after losing a home?
Acknowledge the disappointment, offer a plan, ask what they loved about the home and send two or three close matches within a day.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Monthly New Residential Sales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑