Key takeaways
- A stage is only useful if two agents looking at the same lead would put it in the same place; that takes written entry and exit rules.
- Define Hot by facts, such as a timeline under 90 days plus financing or a signed agreement, never by how keen a lead sounded.
- Nurture is not a graveyard: 27% of sellers think about selling for six months or more before listing[1].
- Leads under contract can fall back: 47% of sellers had at least one offer fall through in 2026, so plan a route back to Hot[1].
Why stages need written definitions
Ask five agents what a “hot lead” is and you will get five answers. One means anyone who replied, another means a buyer who is pre-approved, a third means anyone who sounded excited. When stage labels mean different things to different people, pipeline reports become fiction and follow-up becomes uneven: some leads are chased too hard, others not at all.
This is a team problem as much as a process problem. In NAR’s 2026 member profile, 21% of REALTORS worked as part of a team, with teams averaging four members[2]. As soon as more than one person touches a lead, stages have to be defined in writing, with clear criteria for moving in and out. The model below uses six stages. You can rename them, but keep the rules.
The six stages
- New: the lead exists, but you have not yet had a two-way conversation.
- Hot: the lead has a near-term timeline and has taken a concrete step toward a transaction.
- Nurture: you have spoken, the lead is real, but the timeline is more than 90 days away or unknown.
- Under contract: an offer has been accepted, or a listing is under contract.
- Closed: the transaction closed. The contact now becomes a past client.
- Lost: the lead will not transact with you, with a recorded reason.
| Stage | Enter when | Leave when | Follow-up rhythm |
|---|---|---|---|
| New | Lead is created from any source | Two-way conversation happens, or 14 days of attempts pass | Several attempts in the first week |
| Hot | Timeline under 90 days and one concrete step: pre-approval or proof of cash, a signed buyer agreement or a listing appointment | Contract accepted, timeline slips past 90 days or lead is lost | At least weekly, usually more |
| Nurture | Conversation happened; timeline over 90 days or unknown | Timeline comes within 90 days, or the lead takes a concrete step | Every two to six weeks |
| Under contract | Accepted offer or listing under contract | Closing, or the contract is cancelled | Per transaction milestones |
| Closed | Transaction closed | Moves to past-client care | Past-client schedule |
| Lost | Bought or listed with another agent, stopped plans, bad data | Lead reappears with new plans | None, or a yearly check-in if appropriate |
New: the clock is running
A lead stays in New until a real conversation happens, by phone, text or email, in which the lead tells you something about their plans. An automated reply or a one-word “thanks” does not count. New is the only stage measured in hours rather than weeks: every New lead should have attempts on record the same day.
Give New a time limit. After 14 days of varied attempts with no response, move the lead to Nurture with a timeline tag of unknown. Leaving leads in New indefinitely hides your real contact rate and makes the stage useless as a work queue.
Hot: facts, not feelings
Hot should be the smallest stage, because it is the one that gets your best hours. A lead becomes Hot only when two things are true: the timeline is under about 90 days, and the lead has taken at least one concrete step. For buyers, that might be a pre-approval or proof of cash, or a signed written buyer agreement, which REALTORS need before touring a home with a buyer in person or virtually[3]. For sellers, it is a booked listing appointment or a signed listing agreement.
A lead who says “we want to buy next month” but has not spoken to a lender, will not book a consultation and has not signed anything is Nurture with a short timeline tag, not Hot. Enthusiasm is a reason to call again, not a stage.
Nurture: where next year’s clients wait
Nurture is where most of your database lives, and it deserves more respect than the word “cold” suggests. In Zillow’s 2026 seller survey, the median seller thought seriously about selling for three to less than four months before listing, about 6% for less than a month and 27% for at least six months[1]. Many sellers you meet will spend months in Nurture before they are ready, and the agent who stays in touch through that period is usually the one they call.
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Less than a month | 6% |
| At least six months | 27% |
Leave Nurture in two ways only: the timeline comes within 90 days, or the lead takes a concrete step such as requesting a valuation or a showing. Either moves the lead to Hot. Set a reminder for the date the lead gave you, a few weeks early, so the move happens on time.
Under contract and Closed
An accepted offer moves the lead to Under contract, but it is not the finish line. In the same Zillow survey, 47% of sellers reported having at least one offer fall through, down from 54% a year earlier[1]. Your stage rules need a route back: if a contract is cancelled, the lead returns to Hot automatically, with a task to call within a day.
Pending contracts are also an early signal for the months ahead. NAR notes that monthly pending sales activity parallels closed existing-home sales over the following two months[4], and the median existing home spent 33 days on the market in September 2026[5]. Count your own Under contract stage each week to forecast closings.
Closed means the transaction is done. Move the contact into a past-client plan rather than leaving them in the pipeline, so they receive anniversary calls and useful updates instead of buyer follow-up.
Lost: always record the reason
- Bought or listed with another agent.
- Decided not to move.
- Not a real lead: wrong number, spam or a vendor.
- Outside your area and referred elsewhere.
- Asked not to be contacted.
Make the reason a required field when a lead moves to Lost. Over a year, the reasons tell you more about your follow-up than any other report. A high share of “bought with another agent” in the first month usually points to slow first replies; a high share of “not a real lead” points to a lead source problem.
Stage age: how long is too long
Every stage has a natural lifespan, and a lead that overstays it needs attention. Track how many days each lead has spent in its current stage and set warning levels: more than one day in New without an attempt, more than 30 days in Hot without a showing or appointment, more than 90 days in Nurture without any touch. These are starting points; adjust them once you have a few months of your own data.
Stage age is often more revealing than stage counts. A pipeline with plenty of Hot leads looks healthy until you see that half of them have sat there for two months. Those leads are not hot; they are stuck, and the stage label is stopping anyone from asking why.
Common stage mistakes
- Using stages and tags for the same thing, so a lead can be tagged “hot” while its stage says Nurture.
- Letting agents skip stages, such as moving a lead from New straight to Under contract without recording the steps in between.
- Never moving leads out of Hot, which inflates the forecast and hides the leads that truly need attention.
- Deleting Lost leads instead of keeping them with a reason, which throws away the most useful data you have.
- Changing definitions without telling the team, so last quarter’s report and this quarter’s cannot be compared.
Rolling the stages out to a team
Write the definitions on one page
Use the table above as a starting point and adjust the thresholds to your market.
Map current leads
Run a bulk update so every lead has exactly one stage. Anything doubtful goes to Nurture.
Lock the stage field
Make stage a single-choice field, not a free-text tag, so nobody can invent new stages.
Review together for a month
In the weekly meeting, pick five random leads and ask each agent where they would put them. Disagreements show where the definitions need tightening.
Report weekly
Count leads by stage, the age of leads in New and the moves from Nurture to Hot.
Example: a team finds 40 leads marked Hot, but only nine meet the written rules. The other 31 go back to Nurture with timeline tags. Agents spend the next month on the nine, and two of the Nurture leads come back to Hot on their own schedule.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a real estate lead hot?
A timeline under about 90 days plus at least one concrete step, such as a pre-approval, proof of cash, a signed buyer agreement or a booked listing appointment. Enthusiasm alone is not enough.
How long should a lead stay in the New stage?
Only until a two-way conversation happens, or about 14 days of varied attempts. After that, move it to Nurture so the New stage stays a real work queue.
When should I move a lead to Nurture?
When you have spoken but the timeline is more than 90 days away or unknown. Record the date they gave you and set a reminder a few weeks before it.
What happens if a contract falls through?
Move the lead straight back to Hot with a task to call within a day. Offers do fall through often enough that your stage rules should plan for it.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑