Showings and Scheduling

Private Showings vs Open Houses for Sellers

When an open house helps a listing, when private showings are better, and how listing agents can explain the trade-offs to sellers honestly.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Two tools with different jobs
  2. How they compare
  3. When an open house helps the listing
  4. When private showings are the better choice
  5. Security for either format
  6. What sellers should expect
  7. Previews for agents: the third option
  8. How to tell whether it worked
  9. A decision guide for the listing appointment
  10. Example: two listings, two answers
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Showings and Scheduling: Private Showings vs Open Houses for SellersArticle coverSHOWINGS AND SCHEDULINGPrivate Showings vsOpen Houses for SellersAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsShowings and Scheduling: Private Showings vs Open Houses for SellersArticle coverSHOWINGS AND SCHEDULINGPrivate Showings vsOpen Houses forSellersAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Private showings bring buyers who already have agents and are usually further along; most buyers now work with an agent[1].
  • Open houses reach buyers who are early in their search or not yet represented; visiting one alone does not require a buyer agreement[2].
  • Open houses help most in a new listing’s first weekends and in the busy spring weeks[3].
  • Be honest with sellers that open houses also generate leads for the agent, and plan security either way.

Two tools with different jobs

Sellers often ask a simple question: “Are you going to do an open house?” The honest answer is that it depends on what the listing needs. A private showing is an appointment for one buyer, usually with their own agent, booked through the showing system. An open house is a published window when anyone can walk in. They reach different people, carry different risks and put different demands on the seller.

Most buyers arrive with representation. In NAR’s 2026 Profile, 90% of buyers used an agent or broker, the highest share in four decades[1]. That means private showings are the main channel for most listings. Open houses add something different: buyers who are not yet working with anyone, neighbors who know someone looking, and people early in their search.

How US buyers and sellers transactNAR 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers
How US buyers and sellers transactBar chart. Buyers who used an agent or broker: 90%; Sellers who used an agent or broker: 92%; Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO): 5%.Buyers who used an agent or brokerBuyers who used an agent or broker: 90%90%Sellers who used an agent or brokerSellers who used an agent or broker: 92%92%Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO)Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO): 5%5%How US buyers and sellers transactBar chart. Buyers who used an agent or broker: 90%; Sellers who used an agent or broker: 92%; Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO): 5%.Buyers who used an agent or brokerBuyers who used an agent or broker: 90%90%Sellers who used an agent or brokerSellers who used an agent or broker: 92%92%Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO)Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO): 5%5%

Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Buyers who used an agent or broker90%
Sellers who used an agent or broker92%
Sellers who sold by owner (FSBO)5%

How they compare

Private showings and open houses compared for a typical occupied listing.
FactorPrivate showingsOpen house
Who comesBuyers with agents, usually pre-approved and actively lookingAnyone: represented buyers, early browsers, neighbors
Buyer agreementRequired before a REALTOR tours with the buyerNot required for a buyer who visits alone
Seller disruptionMany short visits spread over daysOne or two longer blocks
SecurityEach visit tied to a named, confirmed agentVisitors unknown unless signed in; harder to supervise
FeedbackFrom each buyer’s agent after the showingFrom conversations on the day; often less structured
MomentumBuilds steadilyCan create a sense of competition in a single afternoon
Benefit to the agentMostly to the saleThe sale plus new buyer and seller contacts

That last row deserves to be said out loud. Open houses are a lead source for agents, because unrepresented visitors can walk in without an agreement[2], and many will need an agent later. That is not a reason to avoid them, but sellers deserve to hear it from you rather than work it out themselves.

When an open house helps the listing

  • The first weekend on the market, when interest is highest and many buyers want to see it at once.
  • Busy spring weeks. Realtor.com’s analysis found that the strongest listing week has drawn more views per listing than a typical week[3], and that crowd can be handled in one block.
  • A price point with broad appeal, where neighbors and early-stage buyers may become real buyers.
  • Homes on streets with steady foot or car traffic, where signs bring people in.
  • A home that photographs poorly but feels good in person, so word of mouth matters.
  • A seller who prefers one busy afternoon over a week of short interruptions.

When private showings are the better choice

  • Tenant-occupied homes, where every visit needs notice and the tenant’s cooperation.
  • High-value homes or homes with collections, artwork or other valuables that are hard to secure.
  • Sellers with health concerns, young children or pets that cannot easily leave.
  • Unusual properties with a narrow buyer pool, where qualified, prepared buyers matter most.
  • Rural or gated properties where open-house traffic is unlikely and access is hard to manage.
  • Any situation where the seller has privacy or safety concerns they have shared with you.

Many listings use both: private showings throughout, with an open house in the first weekend or two. The choice is not permanent. Review it after each weekend using feedback and showing numbers.

Security for either format

Both formats bring strangers into the seller’s home. Open houses do so without the verification a confirmed showing provides, so they need more preparation. Many people are rightly wary of impersonation, with nine in ten Americans saying people often or sometimes pretend to be someone else to steal personal information[4].

  1. Ask the seller to remove or lock away valuables, medicines, keys, mail and documents before any visit.
  2. For open houses, have a second person attend, and require every visitor to sign in.
  3. Keep groups small at busy times; ask visitors to wait outside if the home is crowded.
  4. Walk the home before and after, checking windows, doors and rooms for anyone remaining.
  5. For private showings, release access only to confirmed agents through the showing system.

See the open-house sign-in options in open house sign-in options and lead capture for ways to record visitors without collecting more data than you need.

What sellers should expect

Set expectations before the first weekend so the seller judges the result fairly.

  • Do not judge an open house only by whether an offer arrives that weekend; many visitors who become buyers come back for a second, private look with their agent.
  • Open-house turnout depends on weather, price, competing listings and the time of year more than on the agent’s effort.
  • Many visitors will be early in their search or neighbors; that is normal and can still lead to buyers.
  • Feedback from open houses is less structured, so the agent should summarize what they heard in writing the same day.
  • Either format can be stopped or changed; nothing is locked in by the listing agreement.

Previews for agents: the third option

Between private showings and a public open house sits a format sellers often forget: an agent preview, sometimes called a broker open. Local agents tour the home in a set window, usually on a weekday, before or just after the listing goes live. It does not reach buyers directly, but it puts the home in front of the people who are about to book showings for their clients.

  • Useful for unusual homes that are easier to explain in person than in photos.
  • Helpful when the price is likely to be questioned, because agents can see what justifies it.
  • A good source of early, structured feedback; ask attending agents for their view on price and condition.
  • Low disruption for sellers, since it is a single short window when buyers are not present.

How to tell whether it worked

Decide in advance what success looks like so the review after each weekend is not a matter of opinion. For private showings, count requests, completed showings, second showings and feedback on price. For open houses, count visitors, how many were already working with an agent, how many asked for a second look and what they said about price and condition. Write the numbers into the weekly seller update, next to what sold or cut price nearby. If an open house brings few visitors and no second looks two weekends in a row, it is probably not the right tool for this home, and the seller will accept that more easily because you agreed the measure up front.

A decision guide for the listing appointment

  1. Ask the seller’s constraints first

    Pets, children, health, work from home, tenants and privacy. These often decide the answer.

  2. Look at the buyer pool

    Price point, property type and how many recent buyers in the area were first-timers or local movers.

  3. Check the calendar

    Season, local events and competing open houses on the same weekend.

  4. Propose a plan

    For most listings: private showings throughout plus an open house on the first weekend, reviewed after each weekend.

  5. Agree security and sign-in

    Who attends, what is locked away and how visitors are recorded.

  6. Report and adjust

    After each weekend, share numbers and feedback, then decide together whether to continue.

Example: two listings, two answers

Example: a fictional agent takes two listings in the same week. The first is a three-bedroom home near a school, priced near the middle of the local market, with sellers who are happy to leave for an afternoon. She plans private showings throughout and open houses on the first two Saturdays. The second is a large home on acreage, owned by a retired couple with a dog and a collection of paintings. She recommends private showings only, accompanied by her for the first visit of each buyer, and a professional video tour to reduce the number of visits. Both sellers understand why, because she explained the trade-offs instead of offering a default.

If you go ahead with an open house, use how to plan and promote an open house. For occupied rentals, read scheduling showings for tenant-occupied listings, and for remote buyers, live virtual showings.

Frequently asked questions

Do open houses sell homes?

Some buyers do find their home at an open house, and many visitors who become buyers return for a private second look. Treat it as one part of the plan, most useful early in a listing and in busy weeks.

Does a buyer need an agreement to attend an open house?

Not if they visit on their own. A buyer who tours with a REALTOR, in person or virtually, needs a written agreement first[2].

Are open houses safe for sellers?

They carry more risk than confirmed private showings. Lock away valuables and documents, have two people attend and require sign-in.

Can I stop holding open houses partway through a listing?

Yes. Review after each weekend with your agent and change the plan if the open houses are not adding qualified buyers.

References

  1. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Realtor.com Economic Research (2026). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo