Brokerage Operations and Staffing

Recruiting Experienced Agents vs New Licensees

Experienced agents or new licensees? Compare production, training load, culture risk and true cost, with a scorecard and interview questions.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What each hire brings on day one
  2. The production gap in numbers
  3. Side-by-side comparison
  4. What sellers notice in your agent mix
  5. The true cost of each hire
  6. A six-step recruiting scorecard
  7. Interview questions that separate the two
  8. Red flags to watch for in each profile
  9. When a blended model works best
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Brokerage Operations and Staffing: Recruiting Experienced Agents vs New LicenseesArticle coverBROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGRecruiting ExperiencedAgents vs New LicenseesAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsBrokerage Operations and Staffing: Recruiting Experienced Agents vs New LicenseesArticle coverBROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGRecruitingExperienced Agents vsNew LicenseesAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • The typical REALTOR has 13 years in the business and a median 6 years at their current firm, so experienced recruits arrive with habits and a history of moving[1].
  • Experience shows up in income: REALTORS with 16 or more years reported a median gross income of $88,500 in 2025, against $59,200 for all members[1].
  • New licensees cost less to attract but more to train. Price broker hours and early file errors, not just signing incentives.
  • Pick the profile that fills a named gap: listings and local credibility favor veterans; capacity and a future bench favor new agents.

What each hire brings on day one

Recruiting debates in brokerages usually start with splits. A better starting point is the problem the hire is meant to solve. An experienced agent brings a sphere of past clients, a listing presentation that already works and a feel for local pricing. A new licensee brings time, coachability and fewer habits to undo. Either can be right. The expensive mistake is recruiting one profile into a brokerage that is built to support the other.

National data shows how much experience sits in the existing agent pool. The typical REALTOR has 13 years of experience, up from 12 a year earlier, and 75% say they are very certain they will stay active for at least two more years[1]. The pool is stable but older: the typical REALTOR is 57[1]. At the same time, the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects about 40,400 openings a year for brokers and sales agents over the decade, while total employment grows only 2%[2]. Most of those openings replace people who leave or retire, which is the space new licensees fill.

13 years

Experience of the typical REALTOR in 2026[1]

The production gap in numbers

Income is the closest proxy for production that national data offers. In 2025 the median gross income for all REALTORS was $59,200, while members with 16 or more years of experience reported $88,500[1]. Federal wage data covers a narrower group, wage-and-salary agents only, and put the median annual wage for real estate sales agents at $52,830 in May 2025[3].

Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025NAR 2026 Member Profile
Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025Comparison. All REALTORS: $59,200; 16+ years of experience: $88,500.$59,200All REALTORSAll REALTORS: $59,200$88,50016+ years of experience16+ years of experience: $88,500Median gross income of REALTORS, 2025Comparison. All REALTORS: $59,200; 16+ years of experience: $88,500.$59,200All REALTORSAll REALTORS: $59,200$88,50016+ years of experience16+ years of experience: $88,500

Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All REALTORS$59,200
16+ years of experience$88,500

Transaction counts tell the same story. The typical REALTOR reported nine transaction sides in 2025, while team-based brokerage specialists reported a median of 32[1]. A veteran with a strong referral base can close in one quarter what a new licensee closes in a year. That gap narrows when the new agent joins a team that supplies leads and reviews every file.

Treat national medians as a sanity check, not a forecast. Ask every experienced candidate for closed sides, volume and source of business for the last 24 months, then confirm against MLS records before you build an offer around those numbers.

Side-by-side comparison

How the two recruiting profiles usually compare inside a US brokerage
FactorExperienced agentNew licensee
Time to first closingOften weeks, if their pipeline and sphere follow themUsually several months; depends on lead supply
Broker time neededLow on contracts; moderate on learning your systemsHigh: contract training, role play, shadowing, file review
Split expectationsHigher split or cap; may ask for marketing supportStandard split; values training and leads more than split
Culture riskBrings habits and loyalties from the previous firmLearns your standards first
Retention riskHas moved before and recruiters keep callingMay leave the business without early wins
Compliance riskFewer paperwork errors; may resist new proceduresMore early errors; easier to coach
Best fit whenYou need listings, local credibility or mentorsYou have lead flow and a working training system

What sellers notice in your agent mix

Your recruiting mix is visible to clients. In Zillow's 2026 seller research, 75% of agent-using sellers rated market or neighborhood knowledge as very or extremely important, and 77% said the same about an agent's initial impression of responsiveness[4]. Veterans tend to win on the first measure. New licensees can win on the second if you give them a response standard and a backup when they are in training.

Sellers also rarely shop around. Among sellers who used an agent, 67% contacted only one[4]. The agent who answers first and sounds credible usually gets the listing appointment. A roster of veterans who call back the next day loses that race as surely as a roster of rookies who cannot answer a pricing question.

The true cost of each hire

The cost of a recruit is more than the incentive in the offer letter. Count broker hours, desk and technology costs, marketing support and the cost of mistakes on early files. REALTORS' own median business expenses rose to $9,530 in 2025 from $8,010 a year earlier[1], and new agents often expect the brokerage to carry more of that load while they ramp up.

Example: a fictional 18-agent brokerage in Ohio compares two plans for next year. Plan A recruits two veterans who each closed about 20 sides at their old firm, on a higher split. Plan B hires five new licensees on the standard split and gives a managing broker six protected hours a week to train them. In this Example, Plan A adds production faster but depends on two people staying. Plan B produces less in year one but builds a bench, and the broker's training hours are the real cost to price in.

  • Broker or mentor hours per week for the first 90 days, valued at what that time would otherwise earn.
  • Onboarding costs the firm absorbs: license transfer, MLS and association dues, technology seats.
  • Marketing promised in the offer, such as photography, signs and listing launches.
  • Error cost: file corrections, delayed commission disbursements and the exposure of a poorly supervised first deal.
  • Lead cost, if you plan to feed the recruit company-generated buyer or seller leads.

A six-step recruiting scorecard

  1. Name the gap

    Write down whether this hire is for listings, buyer capacity, a language or neighborhood you do not cover, or a future team leader. One gap per hire keeps the decision honest.

  2. Check training capacity

    If nobody has protected weekly hours for new agents, a new-licensee program will stall. Count the hours before you place the job ad.

  3. Verify production claims

    Pull MLS history for experienced candidates and ask which business will follow them. Pending deals and active listings usually stay with the old brokerage, so model only what is portable.

  4. Score culture fit

    Ask how they handled a lost deal, a dispute over a lead and a compliance correction. Listen for blame, and for whether they followed the process or worked around it.

  5. Write a 90-day plan

    Set activity targets, file reviews and check-ins for both profiles. Veterans need a plan too: the median REALTOR stays with a firm for 6 years[1], and the first quarter decides whether they settle.

  6. Review at six months

    Compare actual sides, file quality and broker hours against your estimate, then adjust next year's recruiting mix.

Interview questions that separate the two

Use different questions for each profile. Experienced agents should prove what they have done; new licensees should show how they will work.

  • Experienced: “Walk me through your last ten closings: source, price point and who handled the paperwork.”
  • Experienced: “What did your last broker do that you want to keep, and what made you leave?”
  • Experienced: “Which tools will you refuse to give up?” The answer tells you how much integration work to expect.
  • New licensee: “How many hours a week can you give to prospecting in your first 90 days?”
  • New licensee: “Tell me about a job where you had to follow a checklist exactly.”
  • New licensee: “Name people who would take your call this week and might move in the next year.”

Be candid about learning curves with both groups. In NAR's 2026 technology survey, 63% of REALTORS named the learning curve as their biggest challenge in adopting new technology[5]. New licensees are learning the business and your tools at the same time, so keep their stack small for the first months. The standard operating procedures for teams guide covers how to document the basics once so every recruit learns the same way.

Red flags to watch for in each profile

Most failed recruits show warning signs in the interview or the first month. Watch for these before you sign, and again at the 30-day check-in.

  • Experienced agent who cannot name the source of most of their recent business. Production built on a previous firm's leads rarely moves with them.
  • Experienced agent who wants an exception to file review or your compliance process before they have closed a deal with you.
  • Experienced agent whose last two moves each followed a better incentive offer. They will likely move again on the same terms.
  • New licensee who has no list of people to contact and expects the brokerage to supply all of their business.
  • New licensee who skips role play or shadowing because it feels basic. Those sessions are where contract mistakes get caught cheaply.
  • Either profile treating response time as optional. Clients judge the brokerage by how fast the newest agent calls back.

When a blended model works best

Many brokerages get the best result by recruiting a few experienced agents who want to mentor, then hiring new licensees into their orbit. Team data shows why: 21% of REALTORS work on a team, and team-based specialists close several times as many sides as the typical member[1]. The veteran gets leverage and the new agent gets supervised repetitions.

Make the arrangement explicit. Put in writing who mentors whom, what the mentor earns on supported deals, which files the mentor must review and the point at which the new agent graduates to working alone. Track output against the agent productivity benchmarks you already use, and revisit the split structure in your revenue share and attraction model if mentors start recruiting on your behalf.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to recruit new licensees than experienced agents?

Usually cheaper in upfront incentives and splits, more expensive in broker time, training and early file corrections. Estimate both before deciding which profile fits your budget.

Do an experienced agent's pending deals follow them to my brokerage?

Usually not. Listing agreements and pending transactions are normally contracts with the brokerage the agent was with when they were signed, and payment follows the old independent contractor agreement. Check your state's license law and the agent's contract.

How many new licensees can one managing broker train at once?

Only as many as that broker can review file by file while still supervising the rest of the office. Count protected training hours first and size each cohort to fit them.

What should I track to judge recruiting results?

Closed sides per agent, time to first closing, file error rate, broker hours spent per recruit, tenure and exit reasons. Review them every six months.

References

  1. National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics series OEUN000000000000041902213: Real estate sales agents, annual median wage, national, May 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (2026 REALTORS® Technology Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo