Compliance and Regulation

Rental Listing Scams: Handling Calls From Victims

What to say when a renter calls about a hijacked listing, what to record, where to send them, and how brokerages spot copied listings before calls start.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Why the victims call you
  2. The first two minutes of the call
  3. When the caller has not paid yet
  4. What to record on every victim call
  5. What the brokerage does next
  6. Catch copied listings before the calls start
  7. Covering the phone when it happens after hours
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Compliance and Regulation: Rental Listing Scams: Handling Calls From Victims$65M: reported lost to rental scams since 2020, across nearly 65,000 reports to the FTCCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONRental Listing Scams:Handling Calls From Victims$65Mreported lost to rental scams since 2020, across nearly65,000 reports to the FTCAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsCompliance and Regulation: Rental Listing Scams: Handling Calls From Victims$65M: reported lost to rental scams since 2020, across nearly 65,000 reports to the FTCCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONRental Listing Scams:Handling Calls FromVictims$65Mreported lost to rental scams since2020, across nearly 65,000 reports tothe FTCAva for Real Estate Teams
Figure source: Federal Trade Commission, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • Scammers copy real listings, often homes that are actually for sale, and swap in their own contact details[1], so the victims end up calling the listing brokerage.
  • Open the call with the fact (the home is not for rent and nobody here took money), then the person, then the details.
  • Send the caller to their payment provider first; the FTC says to report the payment immediately and ask for it to be reversed[2].
  • Report the ad, tell the seller, check lockbox codes and post a β€œnot for rent” notice inside the home; warnings inside homes have tipped people off[1].

Why the victims call you

The call often comes on a weekend. A young couple are standing in the driveway of one of your listings with a moving truck booked, a lease they signed online and a receipt for a deposit sent to someone who said he owned the house. The house is for sale, not for rent, and the β€œowner” has stopped answering. Your sign is the only real phone number they can find.

The FTC has counted nearly 65,000 rental scam reports since 2020, with about $65 million in losses and a median loss of $1,000[1]. The usual method is to copy a real listing and swap in the scammer's contact details, and many renters report that the copied ad was for a property that was really for sale[1]. About half of the reported scams in the year to June 2025 started with a fake Facebook ad, and another 16% with a fake Craigslist listing[1].

Who reports losing money to rental scams, by ageShare of rental scam reports with a money loss, July 2024 to June 2025, adjusted for each age group's population. Ages 80 and over: under 1%.
Who reports losing money to rental scams, by ageColumn chart. 18–29: 46%; 30–39: 23%; 40–49: 13%; 50–59: 9%; 60–69: 6%; 70–79: 2%.0%20%40%60%18–29: 46%46%18–2930–39: 23%23%30–3940–49: 13%13%40–4950–59: 9%9%50–5960–69: 6%6%60–6970–79: 2%2%70–79Who reports losing money to rental scams, by ageColumn chart. 18–29: 46%; 30–39: 23%; 40–49: 13%; 50–59: 9%; 60–69: 6%; 70–79: 2%.18–2918–29: 46%46%30–3930–39: 23%23%40–4940–49: 13%13%50–5950–59: 9%9%60–6960–69: 6%6%70–7970–79: 2%2%

Source: Federal Trade Commission, 2025[1]

Show the data
Age groupShare of loss reports
18–2946%
30–3923%
40–4913%
50–599%
60–696%
70–792%

The people who lose money skew young. Renters aged 18 to 29 were three times more likely than other adults to report losing money to a rental scam[1]. Renters search on their phones, yet most still want to see the place: 85% of recent renters attended at least one in-person tour[3]. Scammers get around that by refusing to meet, or by copying listings from landlords who use self-tour services and sending a lockbox code[1].

Most victims never report at all. The FTC points to a study finding that only 4.8% of people who experienced mass-market fraud complained to a Better Business Bureau or a government agency[1]. The calls that reach your office may be the only record anyone makes, which is a good reason to handle them well.

The first two minutes of the call

The caller is embarrassed, angry or both, and some will assume you are part of it. Get the order right: the fact, then the person, then the details. Scripts help, because whoever answers will be tempted to either over-apologize or argue.

  1. Lead with the fact

    β€œThis home is listed for sale through our brokerage. It isn't available to rent, and nobody here offered a lease or took a deposit.” Say it once, calmly, before anything else.

  2. Then the person

    β€œI'm sorry. Copied listings like this are a known scam, and calling us was the right move.” No hint that they should have known better.

  3. Ask what happened

    How much they paid, how, when and to whom; where they saw the ad; the names, numbers and email addresses the scammer used; and whether they shared a Social Security number or ID.

  4. Send them to the payment provider first

    The FTC tells victims to report a payment immediately to the bank, payment app, wire company, gift card issuer or crypto exchange they used and ask for it to be reversed[2]. Speed matters more than anything you can do.

  5. Give them the reporting list

    Local police, the website where the ad ran, ReportFraud.ftc.gov and their state attorney general[4]. If they shared a Social Security number, IdentityTheft.gov[2].

  6. Close without promises

    Offer a short email confirming the home is for sale through your brokerage and was never offered for rent, which helps with a police report. No refunds, no guesses about who did it, no legal advice.

  • Not β€œyou should have known”. It is true of nobody and it ends the useful part of the call.
  • Not β€œwe'll make this right”. It sounds like an offer to pay, and it is not yours to make.
  • Not a guess about who did it, whether the owner was involved or whether the police will act.
  • Not the seller's name, phone number or plans. The caller has already been lied to about who owns the home; do not add real details to the pile.

Keep it consistent. Every caller gets the same questions in the same order, whoever they are and however they sound; the Fair Housing Act covers people renting a home as well as buying one[5], and fair housing rules for call scripts and intake applies here as much as anywhere. If the caller is shouting, handling angry callers has de-escalation lines that work.

When the caller has not paid yet

The best version of this call comes from someone who is about to pay and something feels off. The rent is low, the β€œowner” is overseas and wants the deposit before a viewing, and a quick search turned up your sign. Treat it as a gift: you stop a loss instead of documenting one.

Confirm the facts the same way, then name the tells so they recognize the next one. A lease offered before anyone has shown the home, a landlord who cannot meet in person, a deadline that only gets shorter and a request for payment by wire, gift card, crypto or a payment app are all on the FTC's list[4]. Ask them to send you the ad's link so you can report it, and ask whether they would like to see homes that really are for rent.

That last question is not opportunism. Someone who nearly lost a deposit is still looking for a home, and many renters are thinking further ahead: 62% of recent renters at least thought about buying during their search[3]. Turning rental inquiries into future buyers covers how to follow up without pressure.

What to record on every victim call

One incident record per call. The same fields feed the platform report, the FTC report and the note to the seller.
FieldWhy it matters
Property address and the ad's web addressThe platform needs the exact ad to remove it, and the listing agent needs to know which listing was copied
Names, phone numbers and emails the scammer usedRepeat details link calls together and go in every report
Amount, payment method and dateDecides how urgent the call to the payment provider is
ID, Social Security number or pay stubs sharedIdentity theft risk for the caller; point them to IdentityTheft.gov
Lockbox code, keys or entry to the homeA security problem for your seller: change the code the same day
Where the caller is nowSomeone on the doorstep with a truck needs different help from someone calling from work
Callback number and permission to share detailsLets the broker follow up and attach their details to your own report

Example: a caller says the β€œowner” sent a code that opened the lockbox on a vacant listing, and she has already walked through the house twice. That is no longer just her problem. The listing agent changes the code within the hour, checks the house, tells the seller and notes the visit. Copied self-tour listings are a pattern the FTC has seen[1], and a code that works for a scammer's victim works for anyone the scammer sends.

What the brokerage does next

Example: from victim call to takedown
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • System
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Renter calls the sign number

    A deposit went to someone who claimed to own the listed home.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Facts given, details taken

    Not for rent, nobody here took money; ad, payment and contact details captured.

  3. 03System

    Urgent summary by email

    Listing agent and broker get the recording, transcript and summary.

  4. 04Your team

    Ad reported, seller told

    Platform takedown request filed; seller and lockbox checked the same day.

  5. 05Your team

    Warnings posted, FTC report

    Notice inside the home and in the listing; report filed as the brokerage.

Example sequence. The answering step only gives approved facts and takes details; agents and the broker do the rest.

Report the ad on the platform where it ran, through its scam or fake listing option, and save the case number. Tell the seller what happened and what you have done; they may get visitors at the door. File your own report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov as well as encouraging the victim to file theirs. When the scam uses your brokerage's name rather than just the address, it is business impersonation, which the FTC's 2024 rule lets the agency pursue in federal court[6]; the FTC impersonation rule explains what that does and does not do for you.

Then put warnings where renters will see them. The FTC notes that scam warnings posted inside some of these homes have helped tip people off[1]. A notice taped inside the front door or a front window, β€œThis home is for sale, not for rent. Call Harbor Lane Realty with questions”, costs nothing. Add a line to the listing remarks too, if your MLS allows it.

Catch copied listings before the calls start

Scammers copy what is easy to copy: homes with good photos and nobody at the door to contradict them, and rentals with self-tours[1]. A short weekly check per listing is the cheapest defense a brokerage has.

  • Search each active listing's street address with the words β€œfor rent” every week, and the day after the listing goes live or the price changes.
  • Run a reverse image search on the main exterior photo; copied ads often reuse it unchanged.
  • Check the big marketplace and classified sites for your town; the FTC data shows where most reported scams begin[1].
  • Put your brokerage name and main number on the listing photos as a small watermark, so a copied photo carries the real contact.
  • For rentals you do manage, publish how your real application works: where to apply, the fee and how it is paid. The median recent renter submitted two applications and 79% paid an application fee, with a median fee of $50[3], so renters expect a fee; they should also know yours is never paid by gift card, wire or payment app to a private person.

Payment method is the clearest tell, and it is worth repeating in every rental ad. The FTC says that anyone who insists you can only pay by wire transfer through Western Union or MoneyGram, gift cards or cryptocurrency is a scammer, and that fake owners often claim to be out of the country to avoid showing the home[4].

Covering the phone when it happens after hours

Victims call when they discover the problem, and that is often a Saturday morning or a Sunday evening. A voicemail box at that moment loses the one thing that helps most: getting them to their bank or payment app within the hour. It also leaves a frightened person with nothing to do but call the scammer again.

An SI Employee answering the listing or office line can give the approved answer from your listing sheet, that the home is for sale and not for rent, take the details in the table above and mark the call urgent so the listing agent and broker have the summary by email straight away. It asks which ad the caller saw, because a forwarded call does not say, and it gives no legal advice and makes no promises about money. The property manager example shows renter calls answered from an approved vacancy sheet in a modelled scenario, and what the SI Employee does covers the rest. For calls from people who rent one of your listings rather than people scammed over one, see handling calls from tenants in listed rental properties.

Frequently asked questions

Should the brokerage refund a victim's deposit?

Your brokerage never received the money, so a refund is not yours to give, and offering one can read as accepting responsibility. Send the caller to their payment provider at once[2] and take any liability question to your broker and attorney.

Can the renter get their money back?

Sometimes, if they move fast. The FTC says to report the payment straight away and ask the provider to reverse it[2]. Money sent by wire, gift card or cryptocurrency is hard to get back, the FTC warns, so the first call matters[4].

Which agency handles rental scams?

Victims report to local police, the website where the ad appeared, the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and their state attorney general[4]. The FBI's complaint center counts fraud involving rental property under real estate fraud[7], so a victim who lost money can file there too.

How do we get the fake listing taken down?

Report it on the platform where it appears, using its fake listing or scam option, and keep the case number. About half of reported rental scams in the year to June 2025 started with a Facebook ad[1], so check there first.

Do we have to tell the seller?

Yes, the same day. They may get strangers at the door, the lockbox code may be compromised, and they will want to know what you have done about it.

References

  1. Federal Trade Commission (2025). Rental scams hit home with $65 million in reported losses (Data Spotlight) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Federal Trade Commission (Consumer Advice) (2026). What To Do if You Were Scammed (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Zillow Research (2026). Renters: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Federal Trade Commission (Consumer Advice) (2026). Rental Listing Scams (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Federal Trade Commission (2024). FTC Announces Impersonation Rule Goes into Effect Today (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2026). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo