Key takeaways
- RESPA Section 8 bars giving or accepting anything of value for referring settlement-service business on a federally related mortgage loan, and splitting fees for work not performed.
- A 'thing of value' is broad, from cash and gifts to discounts, paid marketing and free technology, and an agreement can be inferred from a pattern of conduct.
- Agent-to-agent referral fees, payments for services actually performed at market value and promotional activities not tied to referrals are allowed.
- Penalties include fines, prison and liability for three times the settlement charge, so document every vendor relationship.
What Section 8 prohibits
The Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act applies to settlement services on federally related mortgage loans, which covers most home purchases with a mortgage. Most buyers finance: 74% of US home buyers financed their purchase in NAR's latest generational trends report[1]. Section 8 has two main prohibitions.
- Kickbacks: no person may give or accept any fee, kickback or thing of value under an agreement or understanding that business incident to a federally related mortgage loan will be referred to a particular person[2]. The CFPB's Regulation X restates this ban for referrals of settlement-service business[3].
- Unearned fees: no person may give or accept any portion, split or percentage of a settlement-service charge other than for services actually performed[2].
Settlement-service providers include real estate agents and brokers, lenders and mortgage brokers, title and escrow companies, and others involved in the closing. The rule works in both directions: an agent cannot accept something of value for steering clients to a lender, and an agent cannot give something of value to a lender or title company for sending clients their way.
Key definitions that catch agents
| Term | What Regulation X says | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| Thing of value | Includes, without limitation, monies, things, discounts, salaries, commissions and fees; payment does not require a transfer of money[4] | Free technology, paid ads, event costs, gifts and trips can all be things of value |
| Referral | Any oral or written action directed to a person that has the effect of affirmatively influencing the selection of a provider[4] | Recommending, pushing or requiring a lender or title company is a referral |
| Agreement | May be established by a practice, pattern or course of conduct; it need not be written or spoken[5] | A lender who pays for your events only while you send clients may be enough to show an agreement |
| Payment for services | Must bear a reasonable relationship to the market value of goods or services; the excess is not for services[4] | Overpaying, or being overpaid, for real work can still be a kickback |
Regulation X also notes that when a thing of value is received repeatedly and is connected to the volume or value of referred business, that is evidence of an agreement to refer[4]. That is the pattern regulators look for in co-marketing and similar programs.
What is allowed
- Cooperative brokerage and referral arrangements between real estate agents and brokers, such as a referral fee paid by one brokerage to another for a client[2]. This applies only when all parties are acting in a real estate brokerage capacity[4]. See paying referral fees legally between agents.
- Payments for goods or facilities actually furnished or services actually performed, at market value[2].
- Normal promotional and educational activities that are not conditioned on the referral of business, such as a title company running a class open to all agents[4].
- Affiliated business arrangements that meet the disclosure, no-required-use and return-on-ownership conditions[2]. See affiliated business arrangements explained.
- Bona fide salaries or compensation paid by an employer to its own employees[2].
Common arrangements and how risky they are
| Arrangement | Where the risk is | Safer approach |
|---|---|---|
| Co-marketing a flyer, ad or mailer with a lender | Lender pays more than its share of space or cost | Each party pays its own pro-rata share, documented with invoices |
| Lender or title company pays for an open house or event | Payment linked to the agent sending clients | Each pays for its own presence; no payments tied to referral volume |
| Marketing services agreement paying the agent for promotion | Payment exceeds the market value of real services, or tracks referrals | Avoid, or have counsel confirm market value and real services |
| Lender rents desk space in the brokerage | Rent above market, or space never used | Market-rate written lease for space actually used |
| Vendor pays for the agent's CRM, website or leads | Free or discounted tools are a thing of value | Pay for your own tools |
| Gifts, tickets or trips from providers | Repeated value connected to referrals | Decline anything beyond modest, unconditional courtesies; check broker policy |
| Agent-to-agent referral fee | Generally allowed between licensees acting as brokers | Written referral agreement through the brokerages |
Five questions before any new provider relationship
Before you agree to anything with a lender, title company or other settlement-service provider, answer these questions in writing. If any answer is uncomfortable, talk to your broker before going further.
- What exactly is each side giving and receiving, including things that are not money, such as leads, ads, space, software or events?
- Would the provider offer the same thing to an agent who never sends it a client?
- Does the value go up or down with the number of clients you refer, or could it look that way from the records?
- If you are being paid for a service, what is the service, who performs it, and what would an unrelated business pay for it?
- Would you be comfortable explaining the arrangement, in full, to your client at the closing table?
The fifth question is the most practical test. Arrangements that agents would rather clients did not hear about are usually the ones that create risk.
Referrals still drive the business
None of this means agents should stop recommending good lenders or title companies. Referrals and recommendations are how consumers find professionals. Among sellers who used an agent, 30% found that agent through a referral, and 35% first found them online[6]. Clients want recommendations from you too. The rule is about what flows back to you for making them.
Script for recommending providers: 'Here are three lenders other clients have used. I don't receive anything from any of them for recommending them, and you're free to choose anyone you like. I'd suggest talking to at least two and comparing their loan estimates.'
Red flags in provider offers
- An offer framed as 'we take care of your marketing' or 'we cover your open house costs' with no clear split.
- A lead program where the provider sends you buyer or seller leads and expects you to send it the resulting loans or closings.
- A 'marketing services agreement' that pays a monthly amount for promotion that is hard to define or measure.
- Payments that are reviewed or adjusted based on how many files you send.
- Free or heavily discounted technology, such as a CRM, website or transaction platform, offered by a provider you refer to.
- Invitations to trips, dinners or events that are offered only to agents who send business.
None of these is automatically unlawful, but each needs a closer look. When in doubt, pay your own way. It costs little compared with the exposure a pattern of free benefits can create, and it keeps your recommendations clean in your clients' eyes.
Penalties
Section 8 carries criminal and civil penalties. A violator can be fined up to $10,000, imprisoned for up to one year, or both[2]. Violators are also jointly and severally liable to the person charged for the settlement service for three times the amount of any charge paid for that service[2]. Regulators and plaintiffs' lawyers look at patterns across many closings, so exposure can add up across a brokerage's whole book of business.
Supervision when agents are independent contractors
Most agents are independent contractors, and many build their own relationships with loan officers and title reps. That makes Section 8 a supervision issue for brokers. An agent's private arrangement with a lender becomes the brokerage's problem when it appears across many of the brokerage's closings.
- Require agents to disclose to the broker any arrangement with a settlement-service provider that involves anything of value, before it starts.
- Make the vendor register part of onboarding, and ask every agent to confirm their entries each year.
- Review co-marketing pieces before they go out, including who paid for what.
- Watch for concentration: if most of one agent's buyers use one lender, ask why, and make sure the answer is client choice.
- Include RESPA in annual compliance training with real examples from your market.
The aim is not to stop agents from building professional relationships. It is to make sure those relationships run on service and reputation rather than on payments that follow the referrals.
A compliance checklist for brokerages
Keep a register
List every relationship with a lender, title or escrow company, insurer, warranty company or other provider that involves money, space, marketing or anything else of value.
Document market value
For every payment in either direction, keep the agreement, invoices and evidence that the price matches the market value of real goods or services.
Break any link to volume
No payment, discount or benefit that rises or falls with the number of clients referred.
Let clients choose
Recommend more than one provider where you can, tell clients they are free to choose, and never require a particular provider unless an exception applies.
Disclose affiliations
If the brokerage or an agent has an ownership interest in a provider, use the required affiliated business disclosure.
Review annually
Have counsel review the register and any new program before it starts.
Example: a co-marketing mailer done right
Example (fictional): an agent and a loan officer want to send a joint 'first-time buyer workshop' mailer to renters in a neighborhood. The original plan has the lender paying the full printing and postage because 'the agent brings the list'. Their brokerage's compliance review flags it: a lender paying the agent's share of marketing could be a thing of value given for referrals.
The revised plan splits the mailer by space: each takes half the panel and pays half the cost, invoiced separately. The workshop is open to anyone, with no requirement to use either party, and the slides tell attendees to compare lenders. Everything is filed in the brokerage's vendor register. This article is general information, not legal advice; RESPA questions depend on facts, so have counsel review arrangements before they start.
Frequently asked questions
Can a lender pay for my marketing?
Generally not for your share. A lender paying more than its own pro-rata share of joint marketing can be a thing of value given for referrals. Each party should pay its own share, documented.
Are referral fees between agents a RESPA violation?
No. RESPA allows cooperative brokerage and referral arrangements between real estate agents and brokers, when all parties are acting in a brokerage capacity. State license law still applies.
What counts as a thing of value under RESPA?
Almost anything: money, gifts, discounts, free services, paid advertising, technology, trips or event costs. A transfer of money is not required.
What are the penalties for a RESPA Section 8 violation?
A fine of up to $10,000, imprisonment of up to one year, or both, plus civil liability for three times the amount of the settlement charge involved.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Home Buyers and Sellers Generational Trends Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 12 U.S. Code § 2607 - Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (RESPA Section 8) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14(d)-(g) - thing of value, agreement, referral and permitted payments (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑