Key takeaways
- Most same-day requests fail on process, not seller refusal: nobody could reach the seller in time.
- Agree pre-approved windows and a notice threshold with the seller at listing, so many short-notice requests confirm without a phone call.
- Reach sellers by the channel they actually check, usually the showing app or a text, not a call from an unknown number.
- Buyer's agents get more yeses with complete requests: confirmed agreement, pre-approval, two time options and a realistic window.
Why short-notice showings matter
A buyer sees a new listing at lunch and wants to see it after work. If the answer takes until tomorrow, they may have seen two other homes by then. The median seller received two offers, and only 16% received four or more[1]. For most listings, each serious buyer counts, and the one who wanted to see it today is often the most motivated.
Buyers' availability makes short notice common. Only 30% of employed people work on an average weekend day, against 81% on a weekday[2], so many buyers decide on a weekday evening or a Saturday morning. A listing that can only be seen with 24 hours' notice misses some of them.
Why same-day requests get declined
| What goes wrong | Sign it is happening | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Seller did not see the request in time | Requests sit unanswered for an hour or more | Pre-approved windows and app or text notifications |
| Seller is working from home or has a meeting | Declines cluster in working hours | Daily windows that avoid their regular schedule |
| Home not show-ready | Seller asks for tomorrow instead | A 15-minute reset checklist and a minimum notice of one or two hours |
| Pets cannot be moved at short notice | Declines mention the dog or cat | A pet plan, such as a crate, for unplanned showings |
| Listing agent unreachable | Buyer's agents call the office instead | A backup contact or coverage for listing calls |
| Seller simply prefers notice | Same answer whatever the time | Ask once, then honor it |
Contact is the biggest problem. 80% of Americans say they don't generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls[3], and many will not see a voicemail for hours. A buyer's agent calling a seller, or a listing agent calling from a new office line, often gets nothing back in time.
- Generally answer 19%
- Don't answer, check voicemail 67%
- Don't answer, ignore voicemail 14%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally answer | 19% |
| Don't answer, check voicemail | 67% |
| Don't answer, ignore voicemail | 14% |
Only 19% of US adults say they generally answer calls from unknown numbers[5]. Ask each seller how they want to be reached for showing requests, and test it: send a test notification from the showing app before the listing goes live and confirm they saw it.
Set the rules with the seller at listing
The best time to agree short-notice rules is before the first request arrives. Ask the seller four questions and write the answers into the showing instructions.
- Which windows can be confirmed automatically, without asking you? For example, weekdays 4 to 7 p.m. and Saturdays 10 to 4.
- What is the minimum notice you need? One hour, two hours or same morning?
- How do you want to be asked for anything outside those windows: app notification, text or call?
- Who can approve if you cannot be reached, such as a spouse or the listing agent?
Use plain wording to explain the trade-off: 'Most buyers decide quickly. If we can say yes to a 5:30 showing with two hours' notice, we'll see buyers who would otherwise have gone elsewhere. If that's hard for you, let's agree the times that work so I can confirm those without calling you.'
A workflow for short-notice requests
Request arrives
Through the showing system, a call or a text. Record the property, the time requested, the buyer's agent and whether the buyer has a signed agreement.
Inside a pre-approved window with enough notice
Confirm at once through the showing system. The seller gets a notification, not a question.
Outside a window or short of the notice threshold
Text the seller with the time, the agent's name and a yes or no question. Copy the backup approver.
No answer in 20 minutes
Offer the buyer's agent the next pre-approved time instead of leaving them waiting.
Confirmed
Send access instructions, including pets and alarm details, and remind the seller of the 15-minute reset list.
Afterwards
Request feedback the same evening and tell the seller how it went.
Seller text script: 'Showing request for today 5:30 to 6:00, from an agent with a pre-approved buyer. Reply Y to accept or N to decline, or suggest another time. If I don't hear by 4:00, I'll offer them tomorrow at 5:30.'
The 15-minute reset for sellers
Many sellers decline short notice because the home is not ready. Give them a short list they can do in a quarter of an hour, and the answer often changes from no to yes.
- Dishes into the dishwasher, counters cleared.
- Beds made, laundry into a closed hamper.
- Bathroom towels straightened and toilet lids down.
- Toys and shoes into one basket in a closet.
- Lights on, blinds open, thermostat at a comfortable setting.
- Pets crated or taken out, as the showing instructions say.
- Valuables, medications and mail put away.
Sellers who work from home need one more rule: which room is the office during showings and whether it is shown. That decision, made once, removes most of their objections to short-notice windows.
When the answer is no
Some sellers will still decline short notice, and that is their right. How the listing agent handles the no decides whether the buyer comes back or moves on.
- Reply to the buyer's agent within minutes, not hours. A fast no with an alternative beats a slow maybe.
- Offer the next available time in the same message: 'Seller can't do today. Tomorrow at 5:30 or 6:15 are both open. Want one?'
- If the buyer cannot make those, ask what times they can do this week and check them with the seller in one message.
- Send the video walk-through, floor plan and disclosures while they wait, so the buyer stays engaged.
- Tell the seller how many requests they declined that week. Sellers often agree to wider windows once they see the number.
Keep a note of declined requests in the listing file. If a home is not getting the showings its price should attract, those declines are part of the explanation, and part of the pricing conversation later.
For buyer's agents: requests that get a yes
- Confirm the paperwork first. A written buyer agreement must be in place before you tour a home with a buyer[6]. Listing agents are more willing to rush a showing for an agent who is ready to go.
- Say the buyer is pre-approved, if they are, and roughly when they could write.
- Offer two times, not one, and keep each to a 30-minute window.
- Use the listing's preferred channel. Requests outside the showing system slow everyone down.
- If the answer is no, ask for the next available time and take it. Keep the relationship for the offer.
Speed on your side matters as much as on the listing side. If your buyer messages at noon, request the showing by 12:15, not after your afternoon appointments.
Short-notice calls from signs and portals
Some same-day requests come straight from buyers calling the number on a sign or a portal listing, often in the evening. Those calls need the same information captured every time: which property, the times they would like, their name and number, and whether they already have an agent. An SI Employee such as Ava can answer those calls when your team is busy, take those details and pass the request to your agent to confirm, so the buyer hears back the same evening.
If the caller has no agent, follow your brokerage's process for unrepresented buyers, including the written agreement before any tour. If they have one, give their agent the showing request details.
Measure your yes rate
Track two numbers for each listing: the share of same-day requests confirmed and the median time from request to confirmation. Review them with the seller each week alongside feedback.
Example: In its first week, a listing receives nine showing requests, four of them for the same day. Only one of the four is confirmed, each after more than an hour. The agent sets two pre-approved weekday windows and a two-hour notice rule, and switches seller contact from calls to the showing app. The next week, five of six same-day requests are confirmed, most within minutes.
Related guides: documenting pets, alarms and special access needs, best times to show a house, handling showings when the seller stays home and using showing activity to advise sellers on price.
Frequently asked questions
Can you schedule a showing on the same day?
Often yes, if the seller has agreed windows and a minimum notice period. Many short-notice requests can be confirmed automatically inside those windows.
How much notice do sellers need for a showing?
It varies. Agree it at listing: one or two hours is workable for many sellers if they have a short reset checklist and a pet plan.
Why do same-day showing requests get declined?
Usually because nobody could reach the seller in time, the seller was working from home or the home was not ready. Pre-approved windows and app or text notifications fix most of these.
How should a buyer's agent request a last-minute showing?
Through the listing's showing system, with two time options, confirmation that the buyer has a signed agreement and pre-approval, and a willingness to take the next available slot.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey - 2025 Results (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑