Key takeaways
- Most sellers say a life event shaped their move, so ask what is changing before you ask about price[1].
- Expect a long runway: the median seller considered selling for three to four months before listing[2].
- Many sellers talk to only one agent, so a thoughtful first conversation can decide the listing[3].
- Ask where they are going next; most seller-buyers use the same agent for both sides[4].
What the first seller conversation should achieve
A seller lead might come from a valuation request, a sign call, a referral or a neighbor who met you at an open house. Whatever the source, the first conversation has three jobs: understand why and when they might sell, learn what they expect, and agree on a next step. That next step is usually a listing appointment, but for many sellers it is a dated follow-up months away.
The stakes are high because sellers do not shop around much. Zillow's 2026 seller research found that 67% of sellers who used an agent contacted only one agent, up from 62% the year before[3]. The agent who has the first good conversation is often the only one who gets a chance.
Keep the first conversation to about fifteen minutes. You are not pricing the home yet. You are earning the right to see it.
The core questions
| Question | What it reveals | Follow-up if the answer is vague |
|---|---|---|
| “What has you thinking about selling?” | Motivation and life event | “Is something changing at home or at work?” |
| “When would you ideally be moved?” | Real timeline | “Is that date fixed, or flexible?” |
| “Where are you heading next?” | Buy-side opportunity, contingency risk | “Will you need to sell before you buy?” |
| “What do you think the home might sell for?” | Price expectation | “What's that number based on?” |
| “What have you updated since you bought?” | Condition and pricing story | “Anything you've been meaning to fix?” |
| “Who else is involved in the decision?” | Decision-makers | “Should they join our next conversation?” |
| “Have you talked with any other agents?” | Competition | “What did you like about those conversations?” |
| “What would make this sale a success for you?” | Priorities: price, speed, ease, privacy | “If you had to pick one, which matters most?” |
You do not need all eight on every call. Motivation, timeline, next move and price expectation are the minimum before booking a listing appointment.
Start with what is changing
Sellers rarely move for no reason. In Zillow's 2026 report, 77% of sellers said a life event influenced their move, most often a change in household size (47%), a new job (30%) or remote work (27%)[1]. Opening with “What has you thinking about selling?” lets the seller tell you which of these it is, in their own words.
Listen for the event and its date. A new job that starts in March creates a deadline. A household change, such as children leaving home, often has no fixed date and a longer runway. Remote work can mean a move to a different area entirely, which opens a referral or relocation conversation.
Keep these questions about plans, not personal circumstances. Asking “Is something changing at home?” is fine; asking about marital status, pregnancy or health is not, and familial status is a protected characteristic under fair housing law.
Pin down the timeline
Many seller leads are earlier than they sound. The median seller in Zillow's research thought seriously about selling for three to four months before listing, and 27% thought about it for at least six months[2]. A valuation request in the fall may be for a spring listing.
- “When would you ideally like to be in your next home?” works better than “When do you want to list?” because people think in moves, not listings.
- “Is that date fixed or flexible?” separates hard deadlines from preferences.
- “Is there anything you need to do before listing, such as repairs or finding the next place?” surfaces the hidden steps that push timelines out.
If the answer is six months or more, that is not a brush-off. It is a nurture track with a date. The guide on following up with seller leads who aren't ready yet covers how to stay useful until then.
Signals that tell you how ready the seller is
Two sellers can give the same answer to “When would you like to move?” and be in very different places. Listen for the details around the answer. They tell you whether to book an appointment this week or set a date in your calendar for next season.
- Ready now: they mention a fixed date, such as a job start or a closing on their next home; they have started decluttering or repairs; they ask about the listing process, photos or showings.
- Getting close: they ask what the home would sell for after costs; they want to know what to fix and what to leave; both owners are engaged in the conversation.
- Early: they want “a rough idea” of value; the move depends on something undecided, such as a partner's job; they ask few questions about the process.
- Probably not selling: they are refinancing, settling an argument about value, or checking an online estimate. Help anyway; they may remember you later.
Write the signal you heard into your notes in the seller's own words. “Said ‘we need to be out before school starts’” is more useful to your future self, or to a teammate, than a vague rating such as “hot.”
If a seller sounds ready but cannot name a date, ask what would have to happen before they list. The answer usually reveals the real obstacle, such as finding the next home, finishing a repair or agreeing with a co-owner, and gives you a way to help with it.
Explore price expectations without arguing
Sellers often have a number in mind from an online estimate, a neighbor's sale or what they paid plus improvements. Sellers in NAR's 2026 Profile had owned their homes for a median of 12 years, an all-time high[5], so many are working from memories of a very different market.
Ask for their number and, more importantly, what it is based on. Then do not correct it on the first call. Say: “That's helpful. I'll look at the most recent sales nearby and what's changed in your home, and I'll show you how the numbers compare when we meet.” Debating price before you have seen the home rarely wins the listing.
Ask about updates too: “What have you changed since you bought?” The answer gives you the condition story you will need for pricing and marketing, and it shows the seller you care about the details of their home.
Ask where they are going next
Most sellers are also moving somewhere. In Zillow's research, 81% of seller-buyers who used an agent hired the same agent to sell their old home and buy their new one, up from 73% the year before[4]. Asking “Where are you heading next?” on the first call opens both sides of the move.
- Buying locally: discuss whether they need to sell first, buy first or do both at once, and introduce a lender early.
- Moving out of the area: offer a referral to an agent in the destination market and keep the listing conversation going.
- Renting next, or not sure: ask whether they have considered keeping the home as a rental. In Zillow's research, 66% of sellers at least thought about renting out their home before selling, and 24% seriously considered it[6].
Handle the fee question honestly
Commission comes up earlier than it used to. Zillow found that 44% of agent-using sellers negotiated their agent's commission, and 76% said the commission they paid was fair[7]. If a seller asks on the first call, do not dodge it. Explain that commissions are negotiable, that you will walk through your fee and exactly what it covers at the appointment, and that you will put everything in writing.
Then bring the conversation back to outcomes: what the seller wants from the sale and how you plan to get it. Sellers who rate an agent on value usually care more about the plan than the percentage.
Book the next step
End with a specific appointment or a dated follow-up. “Could I come by Thursday at 5 or Saturday at 10 to see the home? It takes about 45 minutes, and I'll bring the recent sales.” If both decision-makers are not on the call, ask for a time when they can both be there.
Example: a fictional seller requests a valuation. On the call the agent learns the couple's youngest child leaves for college in August, they want to be in a smaller home nearby by fall, they think the house is worth more than recent sales suggest, and they have spoken to no other agents. The agent books a walk-through with both owners for the following Saturday and adds a buy-side search for single-level homes in the same school district they already know well.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important question to ask a seller lead?
“What has you thinking about selling?” The answer reveals the life event behind the move, which usually tells you the timeline, the urgency and what the seller cares about most.
Should I give a price on the first call?
Give a range only if they requested a valuation, and explain how it was built. Avoid committing to a list price before you have seen the home and reviewed recent sales with the seller.
How do I ask about other agents without sounding defensive?
Ask plainly and with curiosity: “Have you talked with any other agents? What did you like about those conversations?” The answer tells you what the seller values.
What if the seller is a year or more away?
Agree on a check-in date, ask what would be useful in the meantime, such as quarterly sales updates, and move them to a seller nurture track.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑