Key takeaways
- Your voicemail is often the only part of the call a lead hears: just 19% of US adults generally answer unknown numbers[1].
- Use one formula: name and brokerage, a reason specific to them, one useful detail, one easy action and your number said twice.
- Change the message on each attempt and end the sequence with a polite “should I close your file?” voicemail.
- Cold numbers carry legal rules: calling hours, the Do Not Call Registry and consent for prerecorded or AI voice messages[2][3].
- Never leave private details on a voicemail; someone else may hear it.
The voicemail is the call now
When you call a new lead, the odds are that they will not pick up. Pew Research Center found that only 19% of US adults say they generally answer calls from unknown numbers, while 80% say they generally do not[1]. Younger adults, ages 18 to 29, are more likely than older groups to take those calls[1], but most leads of any age will see your number and let it ring.
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally answer | 19% |
| Generally do not answer | 80% |
That does not make calling pointless. The same research found 67% of Americans do not answer unknown numbers but check voicemail if one is left[1]. In practice, your voicemail is the conversation. It needs to do in 25 seconds what a live call would do in two minutes: tell them who you are, why you called and why calling or texting back is worth their time.
A formula that earns callbacks
| Part | What to say | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Who | Your first name and brokerage | About 3 seconds |
| Why them | The specific home, request or conversation that prompted the call | About 5 seconds |
| One useful detail | Something they would want to know: a status, a price change, an answer | About 7 seconds |
| One easy action | Text or call back, with a reason | About 5 seconds |
| Number, twice | Slowly, in groups of digits | About 6 seconds |
Notice what is missing: no request for a meeting, no description of your services and no “just checking in”. The aim is a reply, not a sale. Once they call or text back, you can have the real conversation.
Scripts for new leads
Portal or website inquiry: “Hi Jordan, it’s Casey with Example Realty. You asked about the three-bedroom on Walnut Street this morning. Good news: it’s still available and there’s a showing slot open Saturday. Text me at 555-0142 if that’s easier than calling. Again, 555-0142. Talk soon.”
Sign call you missed: “Hi, Casey with Example Realty returning your call about the house on Fifth Avenue. I have the disclosure package and the HOA details ready. Call or text me back at 555-0142, that’s 555-0142, and I’ll send them right over.”
Open house sign-in: “Hi Priya, Casey from the open house on Maple yesterday. You asked about the school boundary; I checked, and the home is in the Lincoln Elementary zone. If you’d like a second look or similar homes, text me at 555-0142.”
Scripts for aged leads
Thirty to ninety days old: “Hi Sam, it’s Casey with Example Realty. We spoke in the spring about moving closer to your office. Two homes in that area came on this week under your budget. I’ll text you the links now. If the plan has changed, just reply ‘not now’ and I’ll check back later.”
Six months or older: “Hi Lee, Casey with Example Realty. It’s been a while since you looked at homes in Eastside, and prices there have shifted. If you’re still thinking about it, I can send a quick update. Text me at 555-0142. If not, no problem at all.”
Aged leads respond better to a change in the world than to a reminder that they went quiet. Mention something new: a price change, a rate movement, a new listing, a school decision. Never imply they did something wrong by not replying.
Scripts for seller leads
Sellers move slowly. In Zillow’s 2026 seller survey, the median seller thought seriously about selling for three to less than four months before listing, and 27% thought about it for at least six months[4]. Your voicemails to seller leads should feel patient.
Home value request: “Hi Ana, it’s Casey with Example Realty. You asked what your home on Ridge Road might be worth. I’ve pulled three recent sales on your street and nearby, and I’ll text you a short summary now. If you’d like a more exact number, I’d need about 30 minutes to see the inside. Call or text 555-0142.”
“Someday” seller: “Hi Mark, Casey here with Example Realty. You mentioned you might sell next year. A home like yours two streets over just sold, and I thought you’d want to know what it went for. I’ll text you the details. No need to call back unless it’s useful.”
A three-attempt voicemail sequence
Attempt 1: the reason and the detail
Use the formula above, then send a text within a minute that repeats the key detail in writing.
Attempt 2, two or three days later: something new
Lead with a different fact: another home, an answer to a question they asked on the form, a change in the market. Keep it shorter than the first.
Attempt 3, about a week later: permission to close
“Hi Jordan, Casey again. I don’t want to keep filling your voicemail. If you’re still looking, text me ‘yes’ and I’ll keep sending homes. If not, I’ll close your file and you can reach me anytime.”
The third message often gets the most replies, because it gives the lead an easy, low-pressure way to answer. Whatever they say, record it and stop the sequence.
Delivery: how you sound matters
A strong script read badly still fails. Stand up, smile and speak slightly slower than you would in conversation. Say the lead’s name at the start, warmly, as if you know they will be glad to hear from you. Drop your pitch at the end of sentences rather than rising, which sounds more confident. And end cleanly: a simple “Talk soon” is better than trailing off while you look for the hang-up button.
Record yourself leaving three practice voicemails on your own phone and listen back. Most agents find they talk too fast, say the number too quickly and add filler such as “so, um, yeah”. Fixing those three habits does more for callbacks than any new script.
Rules for cold numbers and automated messages
Calls to people who asked you to contact them are ordinary follow-up. Calls to numbers who did not, such as expired listings or for-sale-by-owner sellers, are telephone solicitations and carry federal rules. Telephone solicitations to residential subscribers are barred before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the called party’s location, Do Not Call Registry registrations must be honored indefinitely or until cancelled, and artificial or prerecorded voice telemarketing calls to residential lines need the called party’s prior express written consent[2]. The registry is large: it held 259 million active registrations as of September 30, 2025[5].
Do not use prerecorded, “ringless” or AI-generated voicemail drops without consent your counsel has reviewed. The FCC ruled in February 2024 that AI-generated voices are “artificial” under the TCPA[3], and the TCPA lets a person recover actual losses or $500 per violation, trebled for willful or knowing violations[6]. Leave every voicemail in your own live voice.
Mistakes that kill callbacks
- Rushing the phone number. Say it slowly, in groups, twice.
- Long pitches. If the message runs past 30 seconds, cut it.
- Fake urgency, such as claiming “another buyer is interested” when you do not know that.
- Private details. Never mention finances, divorce, health or a sale price someone has not shared publicly; family members or coworkers may hear the message.
- No text option. Many people who will not call back will reply to a text.
- The same message three times. Each voicemail should bring something new.
Example: rewriting one voicemail
Example, before: “Hi, this is Casey from Example Realty. Just following up on your inquiry. Give me a call back when you get a chance. Thanks.” It gives the lead no reason to call, no detail to remember and no number.
Example, after: “Hi Jordan, Casey with Example Realty. You asked about 18 Walnut this morning. It’s still available, and the seller just added a showing slot Saturday at 11. Text me at 555-0142 if you want it. Again, 555-0142.” Same length, but with a specific reason, a useful fact, an easy action and a number they can catch.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a voicemail to a real estate lead be?
About 20 to 30 seconds. Say who you are, why you are calling them specifically, one useful detail, one easy action and your number twice.
Should I leave a voicemail every time I call a lead?
On most attempts, yes, but change the message each time. Most people screen unknown calls but check voicemail, so a hang-up wastes the attempt.
Can I use ringless or prerecorded voicemail for leads?
Only with consent your counsel has reviewed. Prerecorded and AI-voice telemarketing messages generally need prior express written consent, and violations carry statutory damages.
What should my last voicemail to an unresponsive lead say?
Offer an easy way out: ask them to text “yes” if they want you to keep in touch, and say you will close their file otherwise. It often earns a reply.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑