Key takeaways
- Ask one question first: does the caller already have an agent? The answer decides everything that follows.
- Talking to a buyer on behalf of the seller does not require a buyer agreement, but representing them does, before any tour[1][2].
- Decide your brokerage’s routing rule in advance: stay seller-only, pass to a teammate, offer dual or designated agency where allowed, or refer out.
- Answer quickly and outside office hours; buyer activity is slower this year, so each inquiry counts[3].
Why buyers call the listing agent
Buyers call the listing agent for simple reasons. The number is on the sign or the listing, it feels like the fastest route to information, and some buyers believe they will get a better price by going straight to the seller’s side. After the settlement, a few also hope to avoid signing a buyer agreement. Whatever the reason, the call is both a service moment for your seller and a potential new client for your business.
Handled well, these calls protect the seller, treat the buyer fairly and create opportunities. Handled badly, they create confused buyers who think you represent them, missed showings and, occasionally, complaints. The difference is usually the first thirty seconds.
The first thirty seconds
Answer the property question
Give the basic facts the caller asked for, such as price, status and open house times, from the approved listing information.
Ask about representation
“Are you working with an agent on your search?” Ask it early and neutrally, before the caller shares anything confidential.
State whom you represent
“Just so you know, I represent the seller of this home.” Say it before giving any opinion.
Choose the path
Based on the answer, follow your brokerage’s rule: involve their agent, offer the options available to an unrepresented buyer, or route the call.
Confirm in writing
Send a short follow-up with any showing details and the state disclosures your state requires.
Caller types and what to do
| Caller | What to say | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Has an agent | “Great. I’ll happily set up a showing through your agent.” | Contact their agent; do not discuss terms with the buyer directly |
| No agent, wants information only | “I can give you the facts about the home. I represent the seller.” | Send the listing details and any required state notice |
| No agent, wants to see it | “I can show it to you on the seller’s behalf, or connect you with an agent who can represent you.” | Book the showing on the seller’s behalf, or route to a buyer agent |
| No agent, wants you to represent them | “Let me explain how that works here, because I already represent the seller.” | Follow your state and broker rules on dual or designated agency |
| Neighbor or curious caller | “Happy to share what’s public about the listing.” | Note the contact; offer a valuation conversation if they own nearby |
Your options under the rules
NAR’s settlement FAQ distinguishes between agents who simply market their services or talk to a buyer, and agents who are working with a buyer by arranging tours, negotiating or presenting offers for them[1]. A listing agent working only for the seller, including one who gives an unrepresented buyer access to a home they have listed, is not working with the buyer and does not need a written buyer agreement[1].
Once you start representing the buyer, the position changes. Authorized dual agents work with both buyer and seller, and a written buyer agreement is required in both dual and designated agency scenarios[1]. It must be in place before the buyer tours a home with you, in person or virtually[2]. State law decides whether dual or designated agency is allowed at all and which consents it needs.
- Stay seller-only and show the home on the seller’s behalf.
- Pass the buyer to a buyer agent on your team, under designated agency where your state allows it.
- Act as a dual agent, only where your state allows it and with the written consents it requires.
- Refer the buyer to an agent outside your brokerage.
Write your brokerage’s preferred order into a one-page policy so every agent answers the same way. The details of each relationship type are in dual agency and designated agency explained.
When the caller already has an agent
Represented buyers call listing agents more often than you might expect, usually because they saw the sign before telling their own agent. Treat the call as a courtesy to a colleague. Answer basic public facts, then steer the conversation back to the buyer’s agent.
- Ask for the agent’s name and brokerage, and contact them the same day with showing options.
- Do not discuss price, terms or the seller’s situation with the buyer directly.
- Send any seller disclosures through the buyer’s agent, not to the buyer.
- If the buyer says they want to switch agents, do not encourage it; suggest they talk to their agent and review their agreement first.
Buyers remember agents who respect their existing relationships, and so do the agents who represent them. That reputation brings more cooperative showings on your future listings than any single poached client would.
Scripts for the hard moments
When the buyer asks what the seller will take: “I represent the seller, so I can’t share that, and I wouldn’t share your number with them either. What I can tell you is what’s public: the price, how long it’s been listed and any price changes.”
When the buyer says they don’t want to sign anything: “You don’t need to sign anything to see this home with me on the seller’s behalf. If you want someone to advise you and negotiate for you, that’s where a written agreement comes in, with me or with another agent.”
Keep both scripts close to the phone. Most problems with direct buyer calls come from agents improvising answers to questions about price and representation.
Speed and coverage
Listing calls do not arrive on a schedule. Real estate agents’ work often includes evenings and weekends to fit clients’ schedules[4], and buyers calling a sign on a Sunday afternoon expect someone to pick up. A missed call is often a buyer who calls the next sign instead.
Buyer activity is softer this year, which raises the value of each inquiry. Zillow’s preliminary measure of existing-home sales fell 8.7% year over year in October 2026, and newly pending listings fell 16.8%, the biggest drop since August 2023[3]. When fewer buyers are writing offers, a well-handled call on your listing matters more to your seller.
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Existing-home sales (preliminary) | 8.7% |
| Newly pending listings | 16.8% |
If you use an SI Employee such as Ava on listing lines, it can answer from your approved listing sheet, ask whether the caller already has an agent and route the call by listing or team rule, with a warm transfer when someone is free. Your agent still confirms every showing.
Recording and notes
Call notes protect you if a buyer later claims you represented them. Record what the caller asked, whether they had an agent and what you said about representation. If you record calls, check consent rules first. Federal law allows recording with one party’s consent[5], but some states require all parties to consent; Florida, for example, permits recording only when all parties have given prior consent[6]. A short announcement at the start of the call covers most situations.
Example: a Sunday sign call
Example. On a Sunday a fictional caller, Mia, rings the sign number on a townhouse and says she has no agent. The listing agent answers the price question, states that she represents the seller and asks whether Mia would like to see it on the seller’s behalf or speak with a buyer agent on her team. Mia chooses the buyer agent. Under the brokerage’s designated agency policy, the teammate calls her within the hour, explains the state disclosure and the buyer agreement, and books a showing for Tuesday once the agreement is signed. The listing agent records the call and the handoff.
Example, continued. The listing agent never discussed price strategy with Mia, and the buyer agent never discussed the seller’s position. Both files show who said what, and when.
Tracking direct inquiries
- Log every direct buyer call with the listing, source and whether the caller had an agent.
- Track how many became showings, buyer clients or offers.
- Review response times weekly, including evenings and weekends.
- Share a summary with your sellers; it shows the activity on their listing.
- Feed unrepresented buyers who did not convert into a gentle follow-up plan.
For the follow-up itself, see calling buyers back after a listing inquiry, and for the rules once a buyer chooses to go it alone, working with unrepresented buyers as a listing agent.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a buyer agreement to talk to a buyer who calls my listing?
No. Talking to a buyer on behalf of the seller, or giving an unrepresented buyer access to your listing, does not require one under NAR policy[1].
Can I represent a buyer who calls my own listing?
Only where your state allows dual or designated agency and with the consents it requires. A written buyer agreement is required in those scenarios[1].
What should I do if the caller already has an agent?
Arrange the showing through their agent and avoid discussing terms with the buyer directly.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). NAR Settlement FAQs (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Newly Pending Listings Fell 17% In October (Zillow October 2026 Market Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 18 U.S. Code § 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes § 934.03 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑