Scenario profile
- Business
- Example: Tallbrook Listing Co. (one agent, 12 active listings)
- Industry
- Residential real estate, listing-side resale
- Size
- One licensed agent working under a small independent brokerage, with a transaction coordinator paid per file
- Setting
- Three neighboring suburbs of single-family homes and townhouses, priced around the national median
- Call volume
- About 35 calls a week to the sign riders, the portal listing pages and her website
Key takeaways
- In this example the agent misses about 45% of listing calls because she is inside a showing, and her callbacks mostly reach voicemail too.
- The modelled setup lets her mobile ring first, then answers from approved listing sheets, asks five set questions and marks a call urgent only when it meets her written hot-lead rule.
- Showing requests stay requests: she confirms the time and decides whether she is showing for the seller or representing the buyer.
- Every figure here is modelled from the sources listed or invented for the example, not measured at a real business.
The agent in this example
Tallbrook Listing Co. is a fictional one-agent business, made up to show how the calls and the numbers would work. The agent is licensed under a small independent brokerage, works mostly the listing side, and has 12 active listings spread across three neighboring suburbs. Most are single-family homes and townhouses priced near the national median existing-home price, which was $417,500 in September 2026[1]. Nobody answers the phone but her.
Her afternoons are spoken for. From about 1 pm to 6 pm she is letting buyers into her own listings, meeting inspectors and appraisers, or walking a house with a homeowner who is thinking of selling. Saturdays look the same, plus an open house. None of that is unusual: agents' work schedules often include evenings and weekends to fit their clients[2]. It does mean the hours when buyers are free to drive past a sign are the hours she can't talk.
In this example the 12 listings bring about 35 calls a week through the sign riders, the portal listing pages and her website. Portal form inquiries still go to her inbox; this scenario is about the phone.
What the phones looked like before
Every rider number rang her mobile. During a showing she let it ring, because taking a stranger's call in a seller's kitchen while buyers open the pantry is not a habit worth having. In this example about 45% of calls arrive while she can't pick up, most of them between 1 pm and 6 pm and on Saturdays.
Her fix was the car. Between appointments she played voicemails and returned calls, usually 40 to 70 minutes after they came in. The trouble is who picks up. In a 2020 Pew survey, eight in ten Americans said they don't generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls, and 67% said they let those calls go but check any voicemail[3]. To a stranger her mobile is one more unknown number, so her callbacks mostly reached voicemail too, and a buyer who was parked outside the house at 2:20 had moved on to the next sign by 3:10.
The calls that left no message cost more. A neighbor asking what 41 Example Way is listed for is often really asking about their own house, which is the best lead a listing agent gets. Those callers rarely leave a voicemail; they hang up and are gone.
Portal callers ask what the listing remarks leave out: HOA rental rules, whether the basement has ever taken water, when offers are due. She answered those from memory in a parked car, and in this example a few of the answers were wrong.
How the SI Employee is set up
In the modelled setup her mobile still rings first. If she declines a call or lets it ring four times, it forwards to an SI Employee that answers as Tallbrook Listing Co., day or night. She keeps her rider numbers and her portal number, so nothing on the signs changes.
Before the first live call she writes down four things.
- A listing sheet for each of the 12 homes: status, price, beds and baths, taxes, HOA dues, open house times and showing instructions for agents. Anything not on the sheet is answered as not confirmed, with a callback from her.
- Five questions, asked in this order: are you working with an agent, when do you want to move, are you pre-approved or paying cash, do you have a home to sell first, and when is the best time to reach you.
- A hot-lead rule: a buyer with no agent who is pre-approved or paying cash and wants to see the home within 72 hours, a nearby homeowner planning to sell within six months, or anyone asking how to make an offer. A hot lead becomes an urgent message, emailed at once with URGENT in the subject line so she can read it on her lock screen between rooms. Everything else is an ordinary message she reads at 6:30 pm.
- Boundaries: nothing about the seller's motivation or lowest price, no lockbox or access codes, no financing advice, and no opinions on neighborhoods or schools.
- Caller
- System
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Buyer calls the rider
Tuesday, 2:20 pm: a buyer parked outside 41 Example Way asks if it is still for sale.
02System
Mobile rings, then forwards
The agent is in a showing across town; after four rings the call forwards.
03SI Employee
Answers from the sheet
Asks which home, then gives status, price, taxes, HOA dues and Saturday's open house.
04SI Employee
Asks the five questions
No agent, pre-approved, no home to sell, would like to see it Thursday after 5 pm.
05System
Urgent alert to the agent
The call meets her rule, so it is marked urgent and emailed to her phone at once.
06Your team
Agent confirms at 3:05
Back in the car she reads it, calls the buyer and confirms Thursday at 5:30.
Example only: a fictional business, listing and rule set.
She chose an alert over a live transfer: a transfer thirty seconds after she declined would ring in the same kitchen. The subject line tells her whether a call can wait until the showing ends. The buyer is told she will call back from her own mobile within the hour, so the 3:05 call is expected, not one more unknown number. Lead alerts only work when they are rare, so the rule is strict on purpose.
Showing requests stay requests: she confirms each one, and that is when she decides what kind of showing it is. Giving an unrepresented buyer access to her own listing on the seller's behalf needs no written buyer agreement under NAR's settlement FAQs[4]. If she would also act for the buyer, as a dual agent where her state allows it, the written agreement has to come before the tour[4][5].
Neighbors get booked, not logged. A homeowner who says they are thinking of selling is asked for the address and a rough timeline, then offered one of the valuation walk-throughs she keeps open on Tuesday and Thursday mornings in her AssistCall calendar. The pricing conversation stays with her.
Buyer's agents get the approved showing instructions: book through the showing service, give 24 hours' notice, and expect the seller's dog to be crated. Most are already working that way, since 68% of REALTORS use showing scheduling tools[6]. Neighborhood questions get the school district's official boundary lookup and public facts, never a description of who lives on the street. The Fair Housing Act bars discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability[7], and the fair housing rules for call scripts spell out what that means on a call.
Example greeting: “Thanks for calling Tallbrook Listing Co. I'm the listing agent's virtual assistant, and this call is recorded. Which home are you calling about?” For 41 Example Way it goes on: “It's still active. I can give you the details, pass a showing request to the agent, or have her call you back.”
Every call leaves a recording, a transcript and a short summary. She has never kept a CRM, which is common: NAR's 2026 technology report puts CRM use at 46% of REALTORS[6]. Every caller also becomes a contact, and in this example she exports the list every Friday as her lead list.
Before and after, call by call
| Call | Before (her mobile, then voicemail) | After (modelled setup) |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer at the sign at 2:20 pm | Voicemail; her callback 50 minutes later reaches the buyer's voicemail | Answered from the listing sheet; she gets an urgent alert with the buyer's answers |
| Neighbor asking what 41 Example Way is listed for | Usually no voicemail, so no lead at all | Price given, own plans asked, valuation walk-through booked in her calendar |
| Buyer's agent wanting to show the home | Rings out; the buyer's agent waits for a callback to get the showing instructions | Approved showing instructions read out; no lockbox codes; sent to the showing service |
| Portal caller asking about HOA rental rules | Answered from memory in the car, sometimes wrongly | Answered only if it is on the sheet; otherwise marked not confirmed for her callback |
| Caller asking what the neighborhood is like | Answered off the cuff between showings | Official school-district lookup and public facts; no views on who lives there |
| One of her sellers asking for showing feedback | Mixed in with every other voicemail | Message passed to her for the evening callback, never treated as a new lead |
| Sign call at 7 pm on a Saturday | Voicemail until Sunday afternoon | Handled like a weekday call; summary waiting for her in the morning |
In this example callers get an answer while still standing at the sign, and between showings she sees which two or three calls matter instead of playing every voicemail in the car.
What the numbers would look like
The worked example estimates her own income at risk each month from calls she can't take live. The value per closed side comes from NAR's 2026 member profile: a median gross income of $59,200 in 2025 spread over the typical nine transaction sides[8], or roughly $6,600 a side. Dividing one median by another is rough, but it ties the figure to what agents take home, not to the commission on the sale price.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls a week to signs, portals and website | 35 |
| Share she can't pick up live | 45% |
| Share from new buyers or sellers | 40% |
| New-prospect calls that become a closed side | 2% |
| Agent's gross income per closed side | $6,600 |
| Unanswered calls a month | 68 |
| From new customers | 27 |
| Bookings that would have followed | 0.5 |
| Monthly value at risk | $3,601 |
How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.
Assumptions
- About $6,600 per closed side: NAR's median REALTOR gross income of $59,200 in 2025 divided by the typical nine transaction sides.[8]
- Agents' schedules often include evenings and weekends; here her afternoons and Saturdays go to showings.[2]
- Thirty-five calls a week, a 45% unanswered share, 40% new prospects and a 2% call-to-closing rate are invented for this example.
Example only: modelled, not measured. The close rate moves the result most, so a real agent would use her own records.
In this example about $3,600 a month of her income would be at risk, a little over half a closed side. Not all of it is lost today, because some callers do leave a voicemail and answer the callback. If an answer after the fourth ring saved one in three of those prospects, she would close about two more sides a year: a third of $3,600 a month over 12 months, or roughly $14,400.
The neighbor calls are the bigger lever and the hardest to model. One listing from a neighbor who would otherwise have hung up would be worth more than that monthly figure. For the callbacks themselves, she would still follow the text-then-call routine in what to do when you miss a call during a showing.
The first 30 days in this example
Day 1
She writes the 12 listing sheets, the five questions, the hot-lead rule and the greeting.
Day 3
Test calls: an active listing, a pending one, a showing request, a neighbor, an agent asking for the lockbox code.
Day 5
Her mobile set to forward unanswered calls after four rings, day and night.
Day 14
She reviews every urgent alert and every ordinary message that should have been one.
Day 30
She compares confirmed showings, booked walk-throughs and callback times with the month before.
Example timeline; a real rollout follows the agent's own schedule.
In this example she keeps two short lists through the first month: urgent alerts that could have waited, and ordinary messages that should have been urgent. A growing first list means the rule is too loose. A growing second list means it is too tight, which is the costlier mistake, because a cash buyer she reads about at 6:30 pm may already have called another agent.
Lessons from the scenario
- Write the listing sheets before anything goes live, and treat every price or status change as a same-day sheet update.
- Define a hot lead in one sentence. If every call is urgent, the alerts turn into noise and she stops reading them mid-showing.
- Ask every neighbor about their own plans. For a listing agent that question is worth more than any detail about the house on the sign.
- Judge the month by confirmed showings, booked walk-throughs and how fast hot leads got a call, not by the number of calls answered.
For the sign script itself, see turning yard sign calls into clients. For what an SI Employee handles on a live call today, see what it does.
Frequently asked questions
Is Tallbrook Listing Co. a real business?
No. It is a fictional one-agent business used to show the method. Every figure is modelled from the sources listed or invented for the example; none of it was measured.
Does the setup confirm showings on its own?
No. It takes the property, two preferred windows and whether the buyer has an agent, then the agent confirms the time and access herself. That keeps her in charge of the seller's schedule and of the buyer-agreement question.
What happens when the caller already has an agent?
The caller gets the public facts from the listing sheet and is asked to have their agent book through the showing service. Offers, terms and the seller's situation are never discussed. See when buyers call the listing agent directly.
What if a listing goes pending or the price changes?
She updates that listing's sheet the same day. The answers come only from the sheet, and there is no MLS feed connection today, so a stale sheet would mean stale answers. A pending listing is described as under contract, and the caller is offered a callback about similar homes.
Can she still answer her own phone?
Yes. Her mobile rings first on every call. The setup only picks up the calls she declines or doesn't reach within four rings.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). NAR Settlement FAQs (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide to Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle, New NAR Report Finds (opens in a new tab) ↑