Key takeaways
- Offer disclosure depends on the seller's approval, so agree the policy in writing before the first offer arrives[1].
- Give every agent the same information at the same time, by the same channel, and log each call.
- Never reveal the price or terms of another offer; describe the process, not the competition.
- Multiple offers are less common than in recent years, so treat each one carefully and keep backup buyers warm[2].
Where fairness gets tested
Multiple-offer situations generate a wave of calls. Buyers' agents want to know how many offers there are, whether they are over list, whether one is cash, when the seller will decide and what it will take to win. Each question is reasonable from their side. Each one is also a chance for the listing agent to give one caller more than another, and that is where complaints, lost trust and ethics issues come from.
Competition for listings has eased. Zillow's 2026 seller research found the median seller received two offers, and the share receiving four or more fell to 16% from 21% a year earlier[2]. Market activity was also slowing in the autumn of 2026: pending home sales fell 7.3% from August to September[3]. When multiple offers do arrive, they matter more to the seller, and handling them cleanly protects a result that may not repeat.
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2025 | 21% |
| 2026 | 16% |
Set the policy with the seller first
The Code of Ethics sets the frame. Standard of Practice 1-15 says that, in response to inquiries from buyers or cooperating brokers, REALTORS shall, with the sellers' approval, disclose the existence of offers on the property, and where disclosure is authorized, shall also disclose, if asked, whether offers were obtained by the listing licensee, another licensee in the listing firm or a cooperating broker[1]. The seller decides; the listing agent carries out the decision consistently.
Decide disclosure
Ask the seller whether you may confirm that offers exist and how many. Record the answer in writing, with the date.
Decide the process
Will the seller review offers as they arrive, or set a deadline? Will there be a highest and best round? Agree it before the first offer, not after.
Decide preferred terms
If the seller cares about a closing date, a rent-back or a short inspection period, agree that you may mention these to every agent who asks.
Decide who answers
Name one person, usually the listing agent, who speaks about offers. Teammates and the front desk route these calls rather than answer them.
Decide the channel
Announce deadlines and process changes by email to every agent who has shown or asked, followed by a call or text noting the email was sent.
What to say at each stage
| Stage | With seller approval to disclose | Never say |
|---|---|---|
| First offer received | We have received one offer. The sellers will review it by Friday. | The offer is over list, or it is cash. |
| More than one offer | We have three offers. The sellers have asked for any offers by Sunday at 6 p.m. | The highest offer is around a certain number. |
| Highest and best | The sellers have asked all parties for their highest and best by Monday at noon. | You're close, just go a bit higher. |
| Seller reviewing | The sellers are reviewing all offers tonight and I'll call every agent by 10 a.m. | It's between you and one other. |
| Decision made | The sellers have accepted another offer. Would your client like to submit a backup? | You lost by a small amount. |
Without approval to disclose, the answers are simpler still: I'm not able to comment on offers. If your client is interested, the best thing is to submit your strongest offer, and I'll present it promptly. Say exactly that to every caller, including agents you know well and agents in your own office.
Running the highest-and-best round
- Write one message with the deadline, the format for offers, how the seller will decide and when agents will hear back.
- Send it by email at the same time to every agent who has submitted an offer, and to agents who have shown and asked to be kept informed, as the seller has approved.
- Call or text each agent to confirm they received the email. Use the same words for each.
- Log every call that follows, with the question asked and the answer you gave.
- After the deadline, present all offers to the seller together, in the format agreed.
- Tell every agent the outcome by the time you promised, including the ones who were not successful.
The round only works if everybody hears the same thing at the same time. A quick call to one favorite agent before the email goes out undoes all of it, and the other agents usually find out.
Answering the hard questions
- Is anyone cash? I can't share terms of other offers. If your client is paying cash or has strong financing, put that clearly in the offer.
- What will it take to win? The sellers will consider price and terms together. They've mentioned that a closing around the end of the month would suit them.
- Are you representing one of the buyers? (With approval) Yes, one offer came from our firm. The sellers know that, and every offer gets the same review.
- Can I see the other offers? No, those are confidential to the sellers and the buyers who made them.
- Can my client have a few more hours? I'll ask the sellers and let every agent know if the deadline changes.
Agents often press on cash because it matters to certainty. In September 2026, all-cash sales were 27% of existing-home transactions[4], and financing problems were the most common reason offers fell through, cited by 44% of sellers who had one fail[2]. That is a good reason to help your seller compare the strength of financing across offers; it is not a reason to tell anyone what the other offers contain.
Complaints you can prevent
Most disputes after a multiple-offer round are about process rather than price. The losing agent rarely argues that the seller chose the wrong offer; they argue that they were not told something in time, or that someone else was told more. Each of the situations below is common, and each is preventable with the records you are already keeping.
- An agent who called on Friday was never told about Sunday's deadline. Fix: send the announcement to everyone who has shown or asked, not only to agents who have already written.
- An agent in your own office appeared to get an early warning. Fix: hold internal agents to the same email and the same time as everyone else, and say so in the announcement.
- The seller changed the deadline and some agents heard by text while others heard nothing. Fix: every change goes out the same way as the original message.
- An unsuccessful agent heard the result from the MLS before hearing it from you. Fix: call or email every agent by the time you promised, before the status changes.
- A teammate answered a status call differently from you. Fix: route every offer question to the one named person, and give the team the exact wording to use.
If a complaint does arrive, answer it with the record: the seller's instruction, the announcement and the call log. A calm, documented reply usually ends the matter. If it does not, pass it to your managing broker with the file attached rather than debating it by phone.
Example: three offers on a starter home
Example: a fictional listing agent receives three offers in the first weekend. The sellers have approved disclosing the existence and number of offers, and that one came from her own brokerage. On Sunday evening she emails all three agents and two others who had shown and asked to be told: there are three offers, one from an agent in our firm, and the sellers ask for highest and best by Tuesday at noon. She texts each agent that the email has gone out.
On Monday six agents call. Every one hears the same answers, and she logs each call in the listing file in two lines. On Tuesday afternoon she presents the offers together; the sellers choose one with a smaller price but a larger down payment and a shorter inspection period. By 10 a.m. Wednesday, as promised, she calls the other two agents and asks whether their clients would like to stay on as backups. One says yes.
Keeping backups and records
The end of a multiple-offer round is the start of risk management. Ask unsuccessful agents whether their clients would consider a backup position, and keep their contact details in the listing file. Save the seller's written disclosure instruction, the announcement email and the call log together; if anyone questions the process later, the record speaks for itself. The approach for single inquiries before offers arrive is covered in handling calls from other agents about your listing, and for the seller's side of the decision see how to present multiple offers to sellers.
Frequently asked questions
Can a listing agent tell other agents how many offers there are?
Only with the seller's approval. Standard of Practice 1-15 ties disclosing the existence of offers to the seller's approval[1], and state law or brokerage policy may add rules, so check both.
Should I tell agents if an offer is above asking?
No. The price and terms of an offer are confidential to the seller and that buyer. Describe the process and deadline, not the competition.
What is a fair way to call for highest and best?
Send one written message to every participating agent at the same time, confirm receipt the same way with each and give the same deadline and decision time to all.
What should I do after the seller accepts an offer?
Tell every other agent promptly, ask whether their clients want a backup position and keep the records together in the listing file.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). 2026 Code of Ethics & Standards of Practice (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑