Phones and Call Handling

Handling Calls From Other Agents About Your Listing

What to share with cooperating agents who call about your listing, what needs seller approval, scripts for common questions and how to log every inquiry.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why these calls matter to your seller
  2. What to share, what needs approval and what never to share
  3. Get the seller's instructions at listing
  4. Scripts for the questions agents ask
  5. Log every agent inquiry
  6. When the buyer calls you directly
  7. Example: a week of agent calls on one listing
  8. Mistakes that cost sellers money
  9. Keep the team consistent
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Phones and Call Handling: Handling Calls From Other Agents About Your ListingArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHandling Calls FromOther Agents About YourListingAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsPhones and Call Handling: Handling Calls From Other Agents About Your ListingArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHandling Calls FromOther Agents AboutYour ListingAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Agree with the seller at listing what can be said about offers; the Code of Ethics ties offer disclosure to the seller's approval[1].
  • Share listing facts freely, share offer information only as authorized, and never share the seller's motivation or bottom line.
  • Log every agent inquiry; the list becomes your backup-buyer pipeline if a deal falls through[2].
  • Use the same answers for every agent who calls, and keep a written record of what you said.

Why these calls matter to your seller

When a buyer's agent calls about your listing, the call is not a courtesy. It is often the earliest sign of a showing, an offer or a backup buyer. How you handle it affects how quickly the home sells and what it sells for. It also tests your discipline, because the agent on the other end is doing their job well when they try to learn as much as possible about your seller's position. The window is short, too: the median existing home spent 33 days on the market in September 2026[3], so most agent calls on a listing arrive in its first few weeks, when consistent answers matter most.

Most listings get more than one interested party. Zillow found the median US seller received two offers, and 16% received at least four[2]. Deals are also fragile: 47% of sellers had at least one offer fall through, most often because of financing[2]. Every cooperating agent who calls is a potential second buyer, and the way you treat them on the phone decides whether they come back when you need them.

Sellers who had at least one offer fall through
Sellers who had at least one offer fall throughColumn chart. 2025: 54%; 2026: 47%.0%20%40%60%2025: 54%54%20252026: 47%47%2026Sellers who had at least one offer fall throughColumn chart. 2025: 54%; 2026: 47%.0%20%40%60%2025: 54%54%20252026: 47%47%2026

Source: Zillow Research, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
202554%
202647%

What to share, what needs approval and what never to share

A simple disclosure framework for cooperating agent calls.
CategoryExamplesRule
Share freelyStatus, price, showing instructions, disclosures available, HOA and tax figures, days on marketGive the same information to every caller
Share only with seller approvalThat offers exist, how many, whether an offer deadline is set, whether offers came from your own firmFollow the written instructions you agreed at listing
Never shareThe seller's motivation, financial situation, lowest acceptable price, terms of other offersDecline politely and consistently
Route elsewhereQuestions about compensation, dual agency or brokerage policyTo the listing agent or managing broker

The middle row is where the Code of Ethics comes in. Standard of Practice 1-15 says that REALTORS, in response to inquiries from buyers or cooperating brokers, shall, with the sellers' approval, disclose the existence of offers on the property, and where disclosure is authorized, shall also disclose, if asked, whether offers were obtained by the listing licensee, another licensee in the listing firm or a cooperating broker[1]. In practice that means you need the seller's instruction before the phone rings, not during the call.

Get the seller's instructions at listing

Add a short section to your listing appointment checklist and record the answers in the listing file. The seller can change them later, but you will always have a current, written answer to give.

  1. May we tell agents who ask that we have received an offer? Yes or no.
  2. If yes, may we say how many offers we have?
  3. If yes, may we say whether an offer came from our own brokerage?
  4. Will we set an offer deadline if multiple parties are interested, and how should we announce it?
  5. Are there terms you want us to mention as preferred, such as a closing date or rent-back?
  6. Who may we tell about a price change before it is published?

Confirm the answers by email to the seller and save the email. If an agent later questions how offers were handled, the written instruction protects both you and the seller.

Scripts for the questions agents ask

  • Is it still available? Yes, it's active. Showings are through the scheduling app, and disclosures are in the MLS attachments. Is your client looking to see it?
  • Do you have any offers? (With approval) We have received one offer. The sellers have asked for any other offers by Monday at 5 p.m. (Without approval) I'm not able to comment on offers, but I'm happy to take yours whenever it's ready.
  • Where's the seller at on price? The sellers are focused on the list price and terms. If your client has a number in mind, the best way to find out is a written offer.
  • Why are they selling? They're ready for their next chapter. What else can I help with on the property itself?
  • Will they take a quick close or a long one? I'll check with the sellers on timing and call you back by tomorrow noon.
  • Is the offer from your office? (With approval) Yes, one offer came from another agent in our firm. (Without approval) I'm not able to share details of offers.

Notice the pattern: every answer ends by moving the conversation toward a showing or a written offer. That keeps the call useful for both sides and avoids long, speculative discussions about what the sellers might accept.

Log every agent inquiry

A simple log turns scattered phone calls into a list you can use. When a deal falls through, the agents who called but did not write are the first people to contact. Keep the log in the listing's CRM record or a shared sheet.

  1. Who called

    Agent name, brokerage, phone and email. Note whether they have shown the property.

  2. What they asked

    The specific questions, in their words, and what you answered. This is your record of consistent treatment.

  3. Their client's position

    Anything they volunteered: pre-approved, cash, contingent on a sale, timing needs.

  4. Follow-up promised

    What you said you would send or check, and by when.

  5. Outcome

    Showed, wrote, passed or still interested. Tag the strongest as possible backups.

When the buyer calls you directly

Sometimes a buyer who is already represented calls the listing agent directly, hoping for a better deal or faster answers. The Code of Ethics says REALTORS shall not engage in any practice or take any action inconsistent with exclusive representation or exclusive brokerage relationship agreements that other REALTORS have with clients[1]. If a caller says they are working with an agent, give them listing facts and suggest their agent contact you for anything further.

Buyers who are not represented are a different conversation. Under the rules that followed the 2024 settlement, buyers working with a REALTOR are asked to sign a written agreement before touring a home with an agent[4], so explain the options and your brokerage's policy on working with unrepresented buyers. See when buyers call the listing agent directly for scripts and the dual agency questions that follow.

Example: a week of agent calls on one listing

Example: a fictional listing agent takes a four-bedroom home live on a Thursday with the seller's written approval to disclose the existence and number of offers, but not whether any came from her own firm. By Monday she has logged nine agent calls. Four show the home, two write. When a third agent calls on Monday afternoon, she says: We have two offers, and the sellers have asked for any further offers by Wednesday at noon. When asked whether either is from her office, she says she cannot share details of offers.

The sellers accept one offer. Three weeks later the buyer's financing fails. The listing agent opens her log, calls the agent whose client wrote the second offer and two agents whose clients showed and said they were interested, and has a new contract within the week. The log, not her memory, made that possible.

Mistakes that cost sellers money

  • Hinting at the seller's flexibility to keep a friendly agent interested, which weakens your seller's negotiating position before any offer is written.
  • Telling one agent about a deadline and forgetting to tell another who called earlier, which looks like favoritism and invites complaints.
  • Sharing the terms of one offer to encourage a higher one, which breaks the confidentiality the seller and that buyer are relying on.
  • Letting calls go to voicemail for a day while the listing is new, so agents with ready clients move on to the next property on their list.
  • Answering from memory instead of the listing file, so different callers hear different versions of the facts.

Each of these is easy to avoid with the written instructions, the scripts and the log described above. Review all three whenever the seller changes the price or the offer strategy.

Keep the team consistent

If a coordinator, front desk or teammate also answers agent calls, give them the seller's written instructions and the scripts above. Inconsistent answers are where complaints start, and the person who picks up the phone may not be the person who took the listing. A short shared note on each listing, updated whenever instructions change, keeps everyone saying the same thing. The front desk scripts include a short version for staff who should route these calls rather than answer them.

Frequently asked questions

Can I tell another agent how many offers we have?

Only with your seller's approval. The Code of Ethics links disclosing the existence of offers to the seller's approval[1], so agree on what you may say at the listing appointment and record it in writing.

Do I have to tell agents if an offer came from my own firm?

Where the seller has authorized disclosure of offers, the Code of Ethics says you shall also disclose, if asked, whether offers came from the listing licensee, another licensee in the firm or a cooperating broker[1].

What should I say when an agent asks what the seller will accept?

Keep the focus on the list price and terms, and invite a written offer. Never share the seller's bottom line or motivation.

Why keep a log of agent calls?

It gives you a list of possible backup buyers and a record that every agent received the same information. Offers fall through often enough that the list is worth keeping[2].

References

  1. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). 2026 Code of Ethics & Standards of Practice (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo