Key takeaways
- Agreements among competitors that restrain trade are illegal under the Sherman Act, with fines of up to $100 million for a corporation, $1 million for an individual and up to 10 years in prison[1].
- Commissions are negotiable and not set by law[2]; any conversation with a competing firm about what to charge is a risk.
- 44% of agent-using sellers in Zillow's 2026 survey negotiated their agent's commission[3], so pricing is set deal by deal, not by the market.
- Never agree, or appear to agree, with other brokerages to avoid working with a competitor, a business model or a type of client.
Why antitrust is a brokerage topic
Real estate is a market of competitors who cooperate every day. Agents from rival firms show each other's listings, negotiate across the table, sit on the same association committees and share coffee at open houses. That closeness is useful for clients and risky under antitrust law, because conversations that would be normal between colleagues can look like agreements between competitors.
There are a lot of competitors. NAR counts more than 300,000 real estate firms operating in the United States[4]. Commission litigation and the practice changes that followed have made regulators and plaintiffs' lawyers pay close attention to how those firms talk to each other about pricing and cooperation.
The core rule
Section 1 of the Sherman Act makes every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade illegal. It is a felony, punishable by a fine of up to $100,000,000 for a corporation, up to $1,000,000 for any other person, or imprisonment of up to 10 years, or both[1]. The agreement does not need to be written or even explicit. A nod, a pattern of matching behavior after a meeting, or an email saying “we're all holding at the same rate” can be used as evidence of one.
$100 million
maximum Sherman Act fine for a corporation, per offense[1]
Most brokerages will never face a criminal case. The practical risk is civil litigation, regulator investigations and the cost of defending them, which can be severe even when the brokerage did nothing wrong but said something careless.
Topics never to discuss with competitors
| Topic | Why it is risky | Safe alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Your commission rates or fee plans | Looks like price coordination | Set your fees independently and discuss them only with clients |
| What other firms should charge | Invites an agreement to raise or hold prices | Decline and change the subject |
| Compensation offered to cooperating agents | Coordinating offers can restrain competition | Decide per listing with the seller, in writing |
| Refusing to work with a discount or new-model brokerage | Group boycott risk | Decide independently based on the client's interest |
| Dividing territories, clients or listing types | Market allocation is a classic violation | Compete everywhere you choose to operate |
| Agent pay splits and recruiting terms | Wage-fixing and no-poach concerns | Set your own terms without consulting rivals |
The common thread is any conversation about future prices, terms or who you will or will not deal with. Information already public, such as a listing's price or a closed sale, is usually fine to discuss. Plans and intentions are not.
Group boycotts
A boycott does not need a formal vote. Several firms agreeing, even informally, not to show a discount brokerage's listings, not to cooperate with a flat-fee agent, or not to work with a new portal can be an illegal group boycott. Each brokerage is free to decide on its own whether to work with someone, based on what is best for its clients. The problem arises when the decision is coordinated.
- Never suggest at a meeting that firms should stop showing a competitor's listings.
- Never forward a message urging colleagues to avoid a particular firm or business model.
- Never steer clients away from homes because of the compensation offered or the listing firm's model.
- Document independent business reasons when you decline to work with someone.
What to say when a competitor raises pricing
Example script: “I don't discuss our fees with other firms. Each of our agents sets terms with their clients. Let's talk about the listing instead.” Then move on, and make a note of the date and the conversation.
If the conversation continues, leave. In a meeting, ask for your objection to be recorded in the minutes and step out. A brokerage that can show it refused to take part is in a very different position from one that sat quietly while others agreed.
Talking to clients about compensation
Antitrust risk also lives in how agents describe pricing to clients. Compensation in a written buyer agreement must be clearly defined and is negotiable and not set by law[2]. Agents should never say a rate is “standard”, “what everyone charges” or “required by the MLS”, because those phrases suggest a fixed market price. Sellers are already negotiating: in Zillow's 2026 survey, 44% of agent-using sellers negotiated their agent's commission and 76% said the commission they paid was fair[3].
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Negotiated the commission | 44% |
| Said the commission was fair | 76% |
Explain your fee, what it covers and the alternatives. Negotiation is normal and lawful, and handling it confidently is better for the client relationship than pointing to a supposed norm. Our guide on talking about compensation with sellers has scripts.
Association meetings, groups and social media
Association meetings are a legitimate place to discuss market data, legislation, ethics and education. They are not the place to discuss what members charge. Keep agendas in writing, stick to them, and keep minutes. Online agent groups carry the same risk with less supervision: a post asking “who else is refusing to work with Firm X?” and a string of agreeing replies is exactly the kind of evidence a plaintiff looks for.
- Do not post or reply to threads about fee levels, boycotts or how to respond to a competitor's pricing.
- Leave groups where those discussions are routine.
- Remind agents that private messages and group chats can be produced in litigation.
Recruiting, splits and no-poach deals
Antitrust law protects competition for workers as well as for customers. Two brokerages agreeing not to recruit each other's agents, or agreeing on the splits and caps they will offer, can raise the same concerns as agreeing on commission rates. These deals are tempting in small markets where owners know each other well and recruiting wars feel destructive. Resist them. Compete for agents on your own terms, set your own compensation plans, and if a departing agent's contract has restrictions, enforce them through the contract rather than through an understanding with the other firm. The same goes for staff: no informal promises between owners not to hire each other's assistants or transaction coordinators.
MLS rules are not a cover
Following your MLS's rules is normal and expected. Using an MLS or association meeting to agree on something the rules do not require is not. If a group of brokers wants a policy change, the safe route is to propose it through the organization's formal process, with written agendas and counsel involved, and to leave each firm free to decide its own pricing and business model. When a rule changes, make sure your agents hear the new rule from the brokerage, accurately, rather than from a competitor's interpretation in a group chat.
An office antitrust policy
State independence
Say in writing that the brokerage sets fees, splits and cooperation decisions independently, and that agents set terms with their clients.
List forbidden topics
Include the table above in the policy manual and in onboarding.
Give the script
Teach every agent what to say and do when a competitor raises pricing or a boycott.
Require reporting
Ask agents to tell the broker about any such conversation the same day, with notes.
Review marketing language
Remove phrases such as “standard commission” from scripts, websites and listing presentations.
Train yearly
Run a short annual session, and keep the attendance record with your training files.
Example: a lunch that went wrong, then right
Example (fictional): At an informal lunch, the owner of a competing firm says rates are slipping and suggests everyone in town agree to hold the line. The broker says she does not discuss fees with other firms, finishes lunch on other topics and writes a short note to her file when she gets back to the office. A month later, a group chat she was added to starts discussing which firms will stop showing a flat-fee brokerage's listings. She leaves the chat, tells her agents not to participate, and forwards the note to the brokerage's counsel. Her firm continues to show those listings whenever they suit a client.
Cooperation without coordination
None of this means stopping cooperation. Showing each other's listings, sharing accurate property information and negotiating hard for clients are what the market depends on. The line is coordination of competitive decisions. Keep those decisions inside your own firm, base them on clients' interests and write down the reasons. The same discipline helps with lead buying, AI tools and email marketing, where policies set by one firm are fine and pacts between firms are not.
Frequently asked questions
Can brokers talk about commission rates with each other?
Avoid it. Discussing future fees with competing firms can be treated as evidence of an agreement in restraint of trade, which the Sherman Act prohibits[1].
Is it illegal to refuse to work with a discount brokerage?
Deciding independently, based on a client's interest, is generally lawful. Agreeing with other firms to refuse is a group boycott risk.
Are commissions set by law?
No. Compensation is negotiable and not set by law[2], and many sellers negotiate it[3].
What are the penalties for antitrust violations?
Under the Sherman Act, fines of up to $100 million for a corporation and $1 million for an individual, and up to 10 years in prison[1], plus civil damages.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 15 U.S. Code § 1 - Trusts, etc., in restraint of trade illegal; penalty (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Profile of Real Estate Firms (opens in a new tab) ↑