Key takeaways
- Offers of compensation can no longer appear on the MLS, but sellers can still choose to make one through other channels or at offer time[1].
- Start from the seller's goals, then lay out the options and their trade-offs. Do not present any amount as standard.
- Separate compensation offers from seller concessions; they are different things with different effects.
- Many sellers negotiate their own agent's commission, and most still call it fair, so transparency builds trust[2].
What changed in the listing conversation
Two practice changes reshaped how compensation comes up with sellers. Since August 17, 2024, many buyers working with a REALTOR sign a written buyer agreement before touring[3], and that agreement must define the buyer agent's compensation clearly, such as $0, a flat fee, a percentage or an hourly rate, rather than leaving it open-ended or as a range[4]. At the same time, NAR's consumer guide states that offers of compensation cannot be listed on MLSs; they can be shared through other marketing such as flyers, signs or brokerage websites, or negotiated in the purchase agreement[1].
So sellers now hear about buyer-side compensation as a choice rather than as an automatic line in the listing. That gives you a clearer, more honest conversation to lead. It also means you need a simple way to explain the options without pushing a number or implying there is a standard rate.
The options a seller can choose from
| Option | How it works | When it can fit | What to tell the seller |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offer compensation to buyer brokers | Seller authorizes an amount, shared off-MLS with written approval | Seller wants to reach buyers who need help covering their agent's fee | The amount, wording and channels are the seller's decision |
| Make no advance offer | Seller waits to see what buyers ask for in their offers | Strong-demand homes or sellers who prefer to negotiate case by case | Some buyers may still ask for help in their offer |
| Offer seller concessions | Seller agrees to cover some buyer costs, such as closing costs | Buyers stretching on cash to close | A concession is not the same as an offer of compensation |
| Decide at offer time | Seller reviews each request as part of the whole offer | Most sellers who want flexibility | Compare net proceeds, not headline price |
NAR's guide draws the line clearly: a seller concession is different from an offer of compensation, and covering closing costs is an example of a concession[1]. Keep that distinction in your own language so the seller understands which decision they are making.
Prepare before the appointment
Sellers will ask what other sellers do. Be ready with honest, local, non-numeric context rather than a rate you claim is normal. Before the appointment:
- Read your brokerage's current policy on discussing and documenting compensation, and any state-specific forms.
- Review recent offers your office has seen in that area: how often buyers asked for help with their agent's fee or with closing costs, and how sellers responded.
- Prepare a net sheet that shows proceeds under two or three scenarios with blank lines for compensation and concessions, so the seller can see the effect of each choice.
- Know what you will not say: that any amount is standard, required or set by law. Compensation is negotiable and not set by law.
A five-part conversation framework
Ask about goals first
Price, timing, certainty, convenience. A seller who needs to close by a certain date may weigh buyer requests differently from one who can wait.
Explain how buyers pay their agents now
Buyers sign written agreements that set their agent's compensation. Some buyers pay it themselves, some ask the seller to contribute, and some use a mix.
Lay out the options
Use the table above: an advance offer off-MLS, no advance offer, concessions, or a decision at offer time. Keep it neutral.
Show the trade-offs on the net sheet
Run each scenario so the seller sees net proceeds, not just price. Ask which outcome matters most.
Record the decision in writing
Document what the seller chose, the amount if any and where it may be shared. Revisit it when offers arrive or the market shifts.
Worked example
Example: a fictional seller couple, the Ortegas, need to move for a job within three months. Their home is in good condition in a neighborhood with steady first-time buyer demand. During the listing appointment they ask whether they should offer anything to buyer agents.
The agent asks about their priorities. They say speed and certainty matter more than squeezing out the last dollar. The agent explains the options, then shows a net sheet with three scenarios: no advance offer, an advance offer at an amount the Ortegas choose, and no advance offer with a willingness to consider closing-cost concessions. The Ortegas decide to make no advance offer but to tell the agent they are open to buyer requests at offer time. The agent records the decision, and the listing marketing says nothing about compensation.
When the first offer arrives with a request for the seller to cover part of the buyer's agent fee, the agent compares it with a second offer that asks for nothing but has a later closing date. Because the Ortegas set priorities early, they decide quickly: the faster closing wins, even after the requested contribution.
Scripts for the questions sellers ask
“Do I have to pay the buyer's agent?”
“No. It's your choice. Buyers now agree their agent's pay in writing before they tour. Some will ask you to help with it as part of their offer, and you can say yes, no or something in between, just like any other term. My job is to show you how each choice affects what you walk away with.”
“What do most sellers do?”
“There is no standard, and I won't tell you there is. What I can show you is what buyers in this area have asked for recently and how sellers handled it, then we'll pick what fits your goals.”
“Can we decide later?”
“Yes. Many sellers choose to wait and judge each offer as a whole. We'll keep the net sheet ready so you can compare offers quickly when they arrive.”
Your own commission: be open about it
Sellers also negotiate the listing side. In Zillow's 2026 seller research, 44% of agent-using sellers negotiated their agent's commission, and 76% said the commission they paid was fair[2]. Those two findings sit together: sellers expect to discuss fees, and a straightforward discussion does not make them feel worse about the result.
Explain what your fee covers, which services are included and which are optional, and how it is paid. Sellers rely heavily on agents, with 92% using one in NAR's 2026 Profile[5], and most of them want reassurance that the price buys real work. Sellers also tend to want broad exposure: 74% say it is very or extremely important that their listing reaches the largest possible audience[6]. Connect your marketing plan to that goal rather than to a percentage.
Revisit the decision as the listing ages
A compensation decision made on listing day is not permanent. Agree with the seller when you will review it, for example after the first two weekends of showings or at the first price conversation. Bring evidence, not opinions: showing numbers, feedback from buyer agents, how many offers or requests arrived and what they asked for.
If buyers keep asking for help with closing costs or their agent's fee, the seller may decide to signal openness earlier through permitted off-MLS channels, or to adjust price instead. If offers arrive without requests, the original decision is probably working. Either way, the seller makes the call with facts in front of them, and you record any change in writing with the date and their approval.
What to put in writing
- The seller's decision on any advance offer of compensation, including the exact amount or formula if they make one.
- Where it may be shared, such as the brokerage website or flyers, and confirmation it will not appear in the MLS.
- The seller's approach to concessions and to buyer requests at offer time.
- Your own listing compensation, the services it includes and any optional extras.
- The date the decision was made and the date it will be reviewed.
Keep this summary with the listing agreement. If the seller later asks why a decision was made, or a dispute arises at closing, a dated written record answers the question without relying on anyone's memory.
Pitfalls to avoid
- Describing any compensation amount as standard, typical or required.
- Suggesting buyer agents will avoid the home if the seller offers less. Agents have a duty to show homes that fit their clients.
- Putting compensation information into the MLS, including in remarks or attachments.
- Mixing up concessions and compensation in the listing agreement or marketing.
- Agreeing to share an offer of compensation without the seller's written approval of the amount.
Frequently asked questions
Do sellers still pay the buyer's agent after the NAR settlement?
They can choose to. Offers of compensation cannot appear on the MLS, but a seller may authorize an offer shared through other channels, agree to a buyer's request in a purchase offer, or offer concessions such as closing costs.
Is there a standard commission for buyer agents?
No. Compensation is negotiable and not set by law. Buyer agreements must state a clearly defined amount, and each seller decides whether and how to contribute.
What is the difference between a seller concession and compensation?
An offer of compensation is directed to the buyer's broker. A concession is a seller contribution toward the buyer's costs, such as closing costs. NAR's consumer guide treats them as different things.
Can a seller wait until offers come in to decide on compensation?
Yes. Many sellers evaluate buyer requests as part of each offer and compare net proceeds rather than committing in advance.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Consumer Guide: Offers of Compensation (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑