Key takeaways
- A home warranty is a service contract for repairing covered systems and appliances, not homeowners insurance and not a builder's warranty.
- Exclusions, per-item caps and service fees matter more than the headline list of covered items.
- Federal rules bar payments for referring settlement-service business, and HUD has said referrals are not compensable services[1][2].
- Offer clients several warranty options, disclose any business relationship, and let them choose.
What a home warranty is, and is not
A home warranty is a service contract. For an annual fee, plus a service fee on each claim, the warranty company arranges repair or replacement of covered home systems and appliances that fail from normal wear. It is not homeowners insurance, which covers sudden damage such as fire or storm, and it is not a builder's warranty on new construction, which covers defects in workmanship or materials for set periods.
Agents meet warranties in two places. Sellers sometimes buy one during the listing to reassure buyers, and buyers sometimes ask the seller to pay for a first-year plan in their offer, or buy one themselves at closing. Either way, clients look to the agent to explain what they are getting, and the explanation has to be accurate and free of any hidden incentive.
Why clients ask about warranties
Homes change hands after long ownership. NAR's 2026 Profile found sellers had owned their homes for a median of 12 years before selling, an all-time high[3]. That means more homes come to market with water heaters, furnaces and appliances well into their working lives, and buyers want to know what happens if one fails in the first year.
First-time buyers, who made up 22% of buyers in the same Profile[4], often stretch to buy and have little cash left for surprise repairs. For them, a predictable service fee can feel safer than an unknown repair bill, even if the plan would not cover every failure. Sellers, meanwhile, may see a warranty as a small cost that answers an inspection-related worry before it becomes a negotiation.
Coverage: what is usually in and out
| Area | Often covered | Often excluded or limited |
|---|---|---|
| Heating and cooling | Furnace, central air components that fail from normal wear | Units not maintained, undersized systems, refrigerant or code upgrades |
| Plumbing | Leaks and breaks in interior supply and drain lines, water heater | Sewer lines outside the foundation, fixtures, slab leaks unless added |
| Electrical | Interior wiring, panels, switches and outlets | Upgrades to meet code, smart home devices, solar |
| Kitchen appliances | Dishwasher, range, built-in microwave, garbage disposal | Cosmetic parts, high-end brands above caps |
| Add-on options | Pool and spa equipment, well pump, septic, extra refrigerator | Usually extra cost, often with lower caps |
| Any item | Repair or replacement at the company's choice | Pre-existing conditions, improper installation, permits, per-item dollar caps |
Disputes usually come from the right-hand column. A failed system the company says was pre-existing, poorly maintained or installed without a permit may be denied. A covered repair may still leave the owner paying the difference if the cost exceeds the per-item cap. Tell clients to read the sample contract, not the brochure.
How to compare plans
Get the sample contract
Ask each company for its full contract for the client's state. Coverage and terms can vary by state.
Check the money terms
Annual price, service fee per claim, per-item caps, any aggregate limit and what happens when a repair exceeds the cap.
Read the exclusions
Pre-existing conditions, maintenance requirements, code and permit upgrades, and items such as roofs, sewer lines and slab leaks.
Understand timing
When coverage starts, any waiting period for buyer-purchased plans, and whether the plan transfers if the home sells again.
Ask how claims work
Who picks the contractor, how fast service is promised, whether the owner can use their own contractor, and how replacements are valued.
Look at the record
Check state regulator information where it exists, Better Business Bureau complaints and recent reviews, paying attention to how the company responds.
Reviews deserve a careful read. Pew Research Center found 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before a first-time purchase[5], and 54% of review readers pay more attention to extremely negative reviews than to extremely positive ones[6]. Reviews carry real weight in decisions: 40% of Americans nearly always rely on them when buying[7]. Encourage clients to look at patterns, such as repeated complaints about denied claims or slow service, rather than a single angry post.
Referral relationships and RESPA
Warranties bought around a closing raise questions under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, the federal law on settlement services. Its Regulation X bars giving or accepting any fee, kickback or thing of value for referring settlement-service business on a federally related mortgage loan[1]. A referral agreement does not need to be written or spoken; it can be shown by a practice, pattern or course of conduct[8].
HUD addressed warranties directly in a 2010 interpretive rule. Its response to public comments states that section 8 of RESPA prohibits payments for referrals and unearned fees, that referrals of settlement-service business are not compensable services, and that payment for additional services actually performed must be reasonably related to the value of those services[2]. In practice, that means:
- Do not accept any payment, gift or credit from a warranty company for steering clients to it.
- Treat any marketing or service arrangement with a warranty company as a compliance matter for your broker and counsel, not something an agent sets up alone.
- Disclose any business relationship your brokerage has with a warranty company, in writing, before the client chooses.
- Give clients more than one option and let them decide.
Scripts for the warranty conversation
For a buyer asking whether to get one:
“A warranty can help with repair costs when covered systems or appliances wear out, but it has exclusions and limits, and you'll pay a service fee each time you call. Here are three companies' sample contracts. Look at what's excluded and the caps for the heating system and water heater, since those are the oldest items in this house. We can ask the seller to pay for a first-year plan, or you can decide after the inspection.”
For a seller deciding whether to offer one:
“Some sellers offer a warranty to reassure buyers about older systems. It won't replace a fair price or a clean inspection, but it can make a buyer more comfortable. If you'd like to offer one, choose the plan yourself from a few options; I don't receive anything from any warranty company.”
Decision criteria to share with clients
- More likely to be worth it: several major systems or appliances near the end of their expected life, a buyer with little cash after closing, a seller offering it at no cost to the buyer.
- Less likely to be worth it: new or recently replaced systems, a buyer with a healthy repair fund, or a contract with low caps on the items that matter most.
- Always weigh it against: a price credit for known issues, a repair before closing, or setting aside the same money in savings for repairs.
- Never treat it as a substitute for an inspection or as cover for disclosure obligations.
Example: a fictional buyer compares two first-year plans for a home with an older furnace. Plan A costs less but caps heating repairs at a low amount and excludes code upgrades. Plan B costs more, has a higher cap and covers some code work. Because the furnace is the main worry, the buyer asks the seller to fund Plan B in the offer, and the seller agrees in exchange for no other repair requests.
After closing: helping clients use the plan
A warranty only helps if the owner knows how to use it. Many claims are denied, or delayed, because the owner called their own contractor first, could not show maintenance or waited too long to report a problem. Include a short note in your closing follow-up:
- Save the contract, the plan number and the claims phone line or app somewhere easy to find.
- Call the warranty company before calling a contractor, unless it is a genuine emergency and the contract allows it.
- Keep receipts for filter changes, servicing and any repairs, because maintenance records help with claims.
- Report failures promptly and describe the symptoms, not a diagnosis.
- If a claim is denied, ask for the reason in writing and the contract clause relied on, then escalate through the company's appeal process.
- Diary the renewal date and decide then whether the plan is still worth keeping.
If a client tells you about repeated problems with a company, note it. That record helps you give better, more balanced information to the next client who asks.
Frequently asked questions
What does a home warranty cover?
Typically repair or replacement of covered home systems and appliances that fail from normal wear, such as heating, cooling, plumbing, electrical and kitchen appliances, subject to exclusions, caps and a service fee per claim.
Is a home warranty the same as homeowners insurance?
No. Insurance covers sudden damage such as fire or storms. A warranty is a service contract for wear-and-tear failures of covered items. Lenders require insurance; a warranty is optional.
Should the seller pay for the buyer's home warranty?
It is negotiable. Some sellers offer one to reassure buyers, and some buyers request one in their offer. Compare it against a price credit or a repair before closing.
Can real estate agents get paid for recommending a home warranty?
Federal RESPA rules bar payments for referring settlement-service business, and HUD has said referrals are not compensable services. Any arrangement with a warranty company needs broker and legal review, and relationships should be disclosed.
References
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (Federal Register) (2010). RESPA: Home Warranty Companies' Payments to Real Estate Brokers and Agents, Interpretive Rule: Response to Public Comments (75 FR 74620) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑