Key takeaways
- Review files at four points, not one: listing or buyer agreement, contract acceptance, before closing and after closing.
- Check that a written buyer agreement exists before any tour, with compensation clearly defined, not open-ended[1].
- Treat wiring instructions as a compliance item: reported real estate fraud losses reached $275.1 million in 2025[2].
- Score every file, track error types by agent and use the patterns to plan training.
Why file review is a broker's job, not a box to tick
The designated broker is responsible for the transactions their agents handle. File review is how that responsibility becomes real. Done well, it catches a missing disclosure while it can still be fixed, spots a deadline that is about to pass and shows which agents need help before a mistake turns into a complaint.
Done badly, it becomes a scramble to collect signatures after closing so the file looks complete. That protects nobody. The checklist below is built for review at the moments when errors can still be corrected. Adapt it to your state's forms, required disclosures and record-keeping rules, which differ more than most checklists admit.
When to review
| Stage | What to review | Who reviews | Target timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agreement signed | Listing or buyer agreement, agency disclosure, compensation terms | Compliance coordinator or broker | Within one business day |
| Contract accepted | Purchase agreement, addenda, all dates, earnest money, disclosures delivered | Broker or senior reviewer | Within one business day of acceptance |
| Before closing | Contingency removals, repair agreements, final figures, wiring verification process | Broker or reviewer | At least several days before closing |
| After closing | Closing statement, commission disbursement, complete file, retention | Compliance coordinator | Within a week of closing |
Listing file checklist
- Listing agreement signed by all owners on title, with start and end dates, compensation and any offer-of-compensation instructions the seller chose.
- Agency or brokerage relationship disclosure required by your state, signed at the right moment.
- Seller's property disclosure and any required lead-based paint disclosure for older homes.
- MLS input checked against the listing agreement and public records: owner name, square footage, bedrooms, lot and tax data.
- Marketing reviewed for accuracy and fair housing language before it went live.
- Showing instructions and access notes recorded, including who may enter an occupied home.
- Any price changes, extensions or withdrawals documented with the seller's signature.
Buyer file checklist
Buyer files changed in August 2024. Buyers must now enter a written agreement before touring a home with an agent, in person or virtually, although visiting an open house alone or asking about services does not require one[1]. Compensation in that agreement must be clearly defined, for example a flat fee, a percentage or an hourly rate, and cannot be open-ended or a range[1].
- Written buyer agreement dated on or before the first tour, signed by every buyer.
- Compensation stated as a defined amount or rate, consistent with what the purchase offer asks the seller to pay, if anything.
- Agency disclosure signed at the moment your state requires.
- Pre-approval or proof of funds in the file before the first offer.
- Showing log that matches the agreement dates.
- Any dual agency or designated agency consent, signed before it applies.
Contract and deadline checks
Deals fail more often than many clients expect. In Zillow's 2026 seller survey, 47% of sellers had at least one offer fall through, and financing issues were the most common reason, cited by 44%[3]. The broker's review at acceptance is the point to make sure every deadline is visible to the agent, the client and whoever covers for the agent.
- Every page initialed and signed by all parties, with counteroffers and addenda in order.
- Effective date stated, and every deadline calculated from it and entered in the transaction system.
- Earnest money amount, holder and due date, with receipt recorded.
- Inspection, appraisal, financing and title contingency dates, plus how each one is removed.
- Required disclosures delivered, with dates of delivery.
- Closing date and possession terms that match the lender's timeline.
If a deadline falls on a weekend or holiday, check how your state form counts days. That single question accounts for a surprising share of missed contingency dates.
Money, wiring and fraud controls
Wire fraud is now a file review topic. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center reported real estate fraud losses of $275.1 million in 2025, up from $173.6 million in 2024[2]. Business email compromise, where criminals impersonate a trusted party and send new wiring instructions, is a common route.
Source: FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024 | $173,600,000 |
| 2025 | $275,100,000 |
- Wire fraud warning delivered to the client in writing at contract and again before closing, with the date recorded.
- File note that the agent told the client to confirm wiring instructions by phone using a number from an independent source.
- Earnest money handled under your trust account rules, with deposit timing documented.
- No wiring instructions sent by the agent by email. Only the title or escrow company provides them.
Fair housing and advertising
The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability[4], and many states add more protected classes. Review a sample of each agent's ads, listing remarks and client emails, not only the forms. Look for descriptions of the ideal buyer, comments about neighborhood makeup and any steering in which homes were shown.
Check training status at the same time. REALTORS must complete at least two hours of Fair Housing training in each three-year cycle, and the current cycle runs from January 1, 2025 through December 31, 2027[5]. A simple roster column for each agent's completion date avoids a suspension surprise when the cycle ends.
Referrals and settlement services
Look at how clients were sent to lenders, title companies, inspectors and other service providers. RESPA's Regulation X bars giving or accepting any fee, kickback or thing of value for referring settlement-service business on a federally related mortgage loan[6]. An agreement does not have to be written to count: it can be shown by a practice, pattern or course of conduct[6].
- Affiliated business arrangement disclosure in the file where the brokerage has an ownership interest in a provider.
- No marketing payments from providers that are really payment for referrals.
- Client given a choice of providers, documented in the file.
Pre-closing and post-closing checks
The last review before closing is about loose ends that cause delays or disputes at the table. The post-closing review is about whether the file would stand up if a client, regulator or court asked for it in three years.
- Every contingency either removed in writing or resolved by an amendment signed by all parties.
- Repair agreements, credits and any re-inspection results in the file, matching what the closing figures show.
- Final walkthrough scheduled, with the client told what to check and what to do if something is wrong.
- Commission figures on the settlement statement match the listing agreement, the buyer agreement and any referral agreements.
- Disbursement authorization sent to the title or escrow company by the broker, not the agent.
- After closing: final settlement statement, any post-closing occupancy agreement and all signed disclosures stored in the file.
- Retention date set under your state's record rules, and the file locked against edits.
If the post-closing review finds a missing document, record what is missing and why, rather than backdating or recreating it. An honest note in the file is defensible; a document signed after the fact is not.
Scoring files and tracking errors
Grade each review
Use three grades: clean, corrected (an item was missing but fixed in time) and exception (an item could not be fixed or a deadline was missed).
Record the error type
Tag each issue: missing signature, late disclosure, deadline entry, money handling, advertising or agreement terms.
Return corrections with a deadline
Send the agent a list of items with a due date. Hold commission disbursement on files that are not complete at closing, if your policy allows.
Review patterns monthly
Look at error types by agent and by office. One agent with repeated late disclosures needs coaching; ten agents with the same error need a better form or a training session.
Close the loop
Share the top three error types with the office each quarter without naming agents, and show what changed.
Example: a fictional 30-agent brokerage in Georgia starts grading files and finds that most corrected items are buyer agreements dated after the first showing. The broker adds a check in the showing tool that asks for the agreement date before a tour is booked. In this Example, the error drops out of the next quarter's reviews.
Building review capacity
File review falls behind when it depends on one broker's evenings. Give the first-pass checklist to a trained compliance coordinator and keep judgment calls, exceptions and agent coaching with the broker. Put the checklist in your transaction system so agents see the same items the reviewer will check, and make the file complete before closing the default, not the exception.
Related reading: handling agent disputes relies on the same records, and the real estate admin job description template includes compliance support duties you can assign to a coordinator.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a broker review transaction files?
At every transaction, at four points: when the agreement is signed, at contract acceptance, before closing and after closing. Spot checks alone miss deadline problems.
Can a compliance coordinator review files instead of the broker?
A trained coordinator can run the first-pass checklist. The broker should remain responsible for supervision, exceptions and coaching, as state law usually requires.
Which buyer file errors should I check for since the NAR settlement changes?
Two errors worth checking on every buyer file are an agreement dated after the first tour and compensation written as a range rather than a defined amount.
How long must brokerages keep transaction files?
It depends on state law, so check your state's real estate commission rules and set retention in your policy manual.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2025). Fair Housing Training Requirement (opens in a new tab) ↑
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). 12 CFR § 1024.14 Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (Regulation X) (opens in a new tab) ↑