Key takeaways
- All 50 states, the District of Columbia, Guam, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands have breach notification laws for private businesses[1].
- California now requires notice within 30 calendar days of discovering a breach, and a sample copy to the Attorney General when more than 500 residents are notified[2].
- The FBI's IC3 received 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, up from 9,359 in 2024[3]; email compromise is the usual way in.
- Take affected systems offline but do not turn them off before forensic experts arrive, and do not destroy evidence[4].
Why brokerages are targets
A brokerage holds exactly what criminals want: names, addresses, phone numbers, ID scans, bank details, closing dates and the email threads where money is about to move. Total losses reported to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center passed $20 billion in 2025, with business email compromise the second-largest component after investment fraud[3]. Real estate is a favored target because a single redirected wire can be worth a year of commissions.
Source: FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), 2025[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024 | 9,359 |
| 2025 | 12,368 |
Most brokerage incidents start small: an agent's email password reused from another site, a phishing link clicked on a phone, a shared login that never changed when someone left. A breach response plan does not prevent those, but it decides whether the brokerage contains the damage in hours or discovers it weeks later from a client.
What counts as a breach
State laws define a breach in their own words, but the common core is unauthorized access to or acquisition of personal information such as a name combined with a Social Security number, driver's license number, or financial account number with a code that allows access. Many states also cover online account credentials. Every state has some version of this law: all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Guam, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands require private businesses to notify people when their personal information is breached[1]. Because clients and agents may live in several states, the brokerage may owe notice under more than one law.
- A compromised agent mailbox containing ID scans and pre-approval letters.
- A lost unencrypted laptop with transaction files.
- A transaction platform account accessed with a stolen password.
- A vendor reporting that its system holding your client data was breached.
- Paper files thrown away without shredding.
Build the team before you need it
| Role | Who in a brokerage | First tasks |
|---|---|---|
| Incident lead | Broker of record or operations director | Calls the team together, makes decisions, keeps the timeline |
| Technical lead | IT provider or managed security firm | Contains the incident, preserves evidence, resets access |
| Forensics | Outside forensic investigator | Determines what was accessed and how |
| Legal counsel | Lawyer experienced in privacy and data security | Advises on notification duties and communications |
| Communications | Broker or marketing lead | Prepares messages for agents, clients and partners |
| Insurance contact | Whoever manages E&O and cyber policies | Notifies insurers and uses their response panels |
| Transaction lead | Managing broker | Checks open deals for wire risk and warns title and escrow partners |
The FTC recommends mobilizing the breach response team right away, including forensic investigators and legal counsel with privacy and data security expertise[4]. Write the names, phone numbers and backup contacts on one page, stored somewhere that works even if email is down.
The first 24 hours
Contain
Take affected equipment offline immediately, but do not turn machines off until forensic experts arrive[4].
Reset access
Change passwords and credentials for affected accounts and anyone who may share them, and turn on multifactor authentication if it was not already on[4].
Protect open deals
Call title and escrow partners on every open transaction, using known phone numbers, and warn clients not to act on payment instructions received by email.
Preserve evidence
Do not destroy evidence; document what happened, when it was found and who found it, and interview the people involved[4].
Remove exposed data
If personal information was posted on your website or elsewhere, take it down and ask search engines to remove cached copies[4].
Call law enforcement
Contact local police and, for significant cases, the FBI or U.S. Secret Service; report to IC3[4].
Notify insurers
Report to your cyber and E&O insurers early; many require prompt notice and offer response vendors.
Notification duties
Once you know what was accessed and whose data it was, counsel can work through each state's rules: who must be notified, how fast, in what form, and whether regulators or credit bureaus must also be told. Deadlines are tightening. California, for example, requires disclosure within 30 calendar days of discovering or being notified of the breach, allowing delay for law enforcement needs or to determine scope[2]. If more than 500 California residents are notified as a result of a single breach, a sample copy of the notice must be submitted to the Attorney General within 15 calendar days of notifying consumers[2].
The FTC also advises notifying other businesses affected, such as banks holding affected accounts, and the major credit bureaus if Social Security numbers were taken[4]. If a vendor that holds your data is breached, its contract should say how fast it must tell you; California requires a business that maintains data it does not own to notify the owner immediately following discovery[2].
30 days
California deadline to notify residents after a breach is discovered[2]
What to tell clients
California prescribes the format: a notice titled “Notice of Data Breach” with the headings What Happened, What Information Was Involved, What We Are Doing, What You Can Do and For More Information[2]. It is a good model everywhere. The FTC adds that the letter should explain the steps the business has taken, the steps people can take, such as fraud alerts or credit freezes, and how the business will contact them in future so they can recognize legitimate messages and avoid phishing[4].
Example opening: “Notice of Data Breach. What Happened: On [date], we learned that an unauthorized person accessed one agent's email account between [dates]. What Information Was Involved: Messages in that account included names, addresses and, for some clients, copies of driver's licenses.” Continue with what you are doing, what clients can do and a single contact for questions.
Clients are primed to distrust messages like this: nine in ten US adults think people often (49%) or sometimes (42%) pretend to be someone else to steal personal information[5]. Send notices from a known address, avoid links where possible, give a phone number clients already know, and tell agents what to say when clients call.
When the breach is a wire fraud attempt
In real estate, the breach and the theft often happen together. If an agent's mailbox is compromised, assume the criminal has read every thread and may already be sending fake wiring instructions. Phone every client with a pending closing using a number from the file, phone the title and escrow officers, and ask the banks involved to watch for changes. If money has already been sent, the client should call their bank immediately to request a recall and report to IC3. Speed matters more than anything else in recovering funds. See wire fraud prevention for the preventive side.
Fix the cause
- Close the hole the forensic team found: patch, remove access, replace the compromised device.
- Review what vendors and service providers can access, and narrow their privileges[4].
- Check whether network segmentation contained the incident, and change it if not[4].
- Turn on multifactor authentication everywhere client data lives.
- Remove client data from personal email and devices, and set retention so old files are destroyed on schedule.
- Update training with what actually happened.
Example: a tabletop drill
Example (fictional): A brokerage runs a one-hour drill. The scenario: an agent reports on Friday afternoon that clients received emails from her account she did not send, and two of her buyers close next week. The team finds three gaps. Nobody had the IT provider's emergency number, the cyber policy required notice within 72 hours but nobody knew, and there was no list of open transactions by agent. They add the numbers to a printed contact sheet, put the insurer's notice rule in the plan, and set the transaction platform to produce an open-deals report in one click.
Plan checklist
- Named response team with phone numbers and backups, stored offline.
- Contacts for IT, forensics, counsel, insurers, title partners and local law enforcement.
- Steps for containment and evidence preservation.
- A list of where client data lives, including vendors.
- State notification rules summarized by counsel for the states where your clients live.
- Template notices and client call scripts.
- A wire fraud playbook for open transactions.
- A yearly drill and a review after every incident.
The plan belongs in your policy manual, alongside onboarding steps such as verifying new hires and the privacy program covered in consumer data privacy laws.
Frequently asked questions
Do brokerages have to report data breaches?
Yes, when personal information covered by state law is breached. Every state, plus DC, Guam, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, has a notification law[1].
How fast must clients be notified?
It depends on the state. California requires notice within 30 calendar days of discovery, with limited delays allowed[2].
What should a breach notice say?
What happened, what information was involved, what you are doing, what clients can do and how to get more information[2], plus how you will contact them in future[4].
Should we turn off a hacked computer?
Take it offline but do not turn it off until forensic experts arrive, and preserve evidence[4].
References
National Conference of State Legislatures (2022). Security Breach Notification Laws (opens in a new tab) ↑
Public.Law (California Civil Code text) (2026). California Civil Code § 1798.82 - Data breach notification (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2026). Data Breach Response: A Guide for Business (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑