Key takeaways
- License laws turn on what the person does and how they are paid, not on the job title; Florida counts a single act of procuring prospects for pay as broker activity[2].
- Arizona lets unlicensed staff answer phones and take callers' details, but not give advice, pricing or opinions of value, or negotiate[3].
- Arizona exempts broker-employed telemarketers who only solicit interest in a licensee's services or gather information[4], an exemption written for ISAs.
- Paying an unlicensed ISA for prospects or a share of commission is the clearest risk; Florida disciplines licensees who do it[5].
Same desk, different answer
Two inside sales agents can sit at the same desk, use the same dialer and call the same lead list, and one can be working within the law while the other is practicing real estate without a license. The difference sits in three places: what they say on the phone, who employs them and how they are paid. The title “ISA” settles none of it.
License laws define broker activity broadly. Florida's definition of a broker includes anyone who, for compensation, “takes any part in the procuring of sellers, purchasers, lessors, or lessees” or “directs or assists in the procuring of prospects”[2]. The same statute says a single such act is enough to be operating as a broker[2], and operating as a broker or sales associate without a license is a third-degree felony in Florida[6]. Read literally, that wording reaches a great deal of what ISAs do all day.
Other states draw the line more precisely, and Arizona is the clearest example. Its Department of Real Estate says an unlicensed assistant may answer phones, forward calls and transcribe callers' information for a licensee, but may not provide advice, pricing or opinions of value, negotiate, or assist in procuring prospects unless an exemption applies[3]. The exemption it points to is written almost exactly for an ISA: people employed by an employing broker who do telemarketing limited to soliciting interest in a licensee's services, or gathering information a licensee will use to follow up[4].
This article explains how two states' laws approach the question so you can spot the issues. It is not legal advice. Your state's statute, your commission's guidance and your broker's written policy decide what your ISA may do.
ISA tasks, from safe to licensed
| ISA task | Unlicensed ISA? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Answering calls and taking name, number and what the caller wants | Generally fine | Arizona lists answering phones and transcribing callers' information as permitted |
| Asking whether the caller wants to talk to an agent and booking that call | Often fine when limited to that | Arizona's telemarketing exemption, for people employed by the broker |
| Gathering timeline, area and basic needs for the agent | Often fine | Arizona's exemption covers gathering information a licensee will use |
| Reading list price or open-house times from an approved sheet | Gray zone | Arizona bars unlicensed staff from providing “pricing”; other states treat public facts differently |
| Saying what a home is worth or what to offer | License needed | Opinions of value and pricing advice are licensed activity in Arizona |
| Explaining or negotiating buyer agreement terms or commission | License needed | Negotiation is reserved for licensees |
| Discussing an offer, counter or terms with the other side | License needed | Negotiating with anyone about a property or transaction |
| Being paid per closing or a share of commission | High risk | Florida disciplines licensees who pay unlicensed people for prospects |
The gray row is where most trouble starts. A buyer on a sign call asks the price; the ISA reads it from the listing sheet; the buyer asks whether the seller would take less, and the ISA says “probably, it's been sitting”. The first answer is a public fact that many brokers allow from a written sheet. The second is an opinion about price and negotiating position, which no unlicensed person should give anywhere.
Pay plans that create license problems
How an ISA is paid can matter as much as what they say. Florida lets the commission discipline a licensee who shares a commission with, or pays a fee or other compensation to, an unlicensed person for referring business, clients, prospects or customers, or for any of the services in the broker definition[5]. Arizona's general exemption for unlicensed clerical staff applies only when their employment is not conditioned on or designed around duties that need a license[7].
Put those together and the pattern is plain. A wage for hours worked, perhaps with a bonus for activity the ISA controls such as calls made or appointments held, keeps the role administrative. A share of the commission on deals the ISA sourced looks like paying an unlicensed person for prospects. If your plan pays per closing, that is the strongest sign you need a licensed ISA, or a different plan. ISA compensation models compares structures; run your choice past your broker and an attorney before the offer letter goes out.
Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Group | Median sales volume |
|---|---|
| Team-based brokerage specialists | $17,500,000 |
| Brokerage specialists working individually | $2,700,000 |
Teams are where this question usually comes up. In NAR's 2026 member profile, 21% of REALTORS worked on a team, teams averaged four members, and team-based brokerage specialists reported a median of $17.5 million in sales volume, against $2.7 million for those working individually[1]. That volume is a lot of phone calls, which is why teams hire ISAs in the first place.
Who employs the ISA matters too
Arizona's telemarketing exemption covers people employed by an employing broker[4], and its policy statement makes the employing broker responsible for written policies that keep unlicensed assistants away from licensed acts[3]. Yet 86% of REALTORS are independent contractors at their firms[1], and plenty of team leaders hire an ISA directly, as their own contractor or employee. Whether that arrangement fits your state's exemption is a question for the designated broker before the ISA's first call, not after a complaint.
Supervision follows the same logic. The broker answers for what unlicensed staff do under the license, so the broker should see the ISA's script, the pay plan and a sample of recorded calls. Broker supervision duties in practice covers how to set that review up without micromanaging.
Scripting an unlicensed ISA
The safest script hands every licensed question to a licensee without making the caller feel stonewalled. The ISA's job is to keep the caller warm and get them to an agent fast. These lines do both.
- “What do you think it's worth?” “That's exactly what Dana does in a valuation visit, and she'll want to see the house. I can book her for Tuesday or Thursday morning. Which suits you?”
- “Would the seller take less?” “I'm not able to speak to price or the seller's position; that's for the listing agent. Can I have him call you within the hour?”
- “Do I have to sign something to see it?” “The agent who shows you the home will go through that with you before the tour. Buyers working with an agent usually sign a written agreement before touring, and the agent explains it.”
- “What's your commission?” “Agents set and explain their own fees, and they're negotiable. I'll make a note so Dana covers it on your call.”
The buyer agreement line is there for a reason. Since August 2024, buyers working with a REALTOR are asked to sign a written agreement before touring a home, in person or virtually[8], and the compensation in it has to be clearly defined, not open-ended[8]. Explaining and negotiating those terms is agent work. An ISA can set the expectation and book the conversation; the licensee has it.
- Caller
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Owner asks about value
A neighbor of a listing wants to know what their own house might sell for.
02Your team
Details gathered
Address, timeline and reason for moving; no price talk.
03Your team
Valuation visit booked
A licensed agent's consultation slot is booked and confirmed back.
04Your team
Agent prices the home
The licensee gives the opinion of value at the visit.
05System
Call logged for review
Recording and notes are kept for the broker's spot checks.
Example sequence. The ISA collects and books; every opinion about price comes from a licensee.
Example: a team in a state that follows Arizona's approach hires a broker-employed ISA at an hourly wage, with a small monthly bonus for appointments that actually happen. Her script asks four questions, offers a call with an agent and books it. When a caller asks about price she uses the valuation line above. Her broker listens to ten recorded calls a month and signs the script off each quarter. Nothing in that setup asks her to do a licensee's job.
Software answering the phones follows the same line
The rules do not change because the voice on the line is software. If an SI Employee answers your calls, treat its script the way you would an unlicensed ISA's. As set up for real estate, it answers listing questions only from the listing sheet you approve and marks anything else “not confirmed” for the agent, takes showing requests for an agent to confirm, and books seller leads into a listing consultation instead of discussing value. Have the broker sign that script off, keep pricing, advice and negotiation with licensees, and review recordings the same way you would a person's.
The team lead-response example shows how a modelled team splits that work between an answering line and its agents, and the brokerage front-desk example shows the same boundary written into a routing sheet. For the people side, hiring an ISA and what unlicensed assistants can and cannot do cover the job description and the wider assistant role.
When a licensed ISA earns its cost
A license widens what the ISA can say. A licensed ISA can take the value question on the first call, walk a buyer through the agreement they will sign before touring and keep a seller talking about price instead of booking a callback. For a team whose callers mostly ask exactly those questions, that can be worth more than the extra pay.
The wage gap at the median is real but not enormous. In May 2025 the median hourly wage was $17.04 for telemarketers[9] and $25.40 for wage-and-salary real estate sales agents[10]. The bigger differences are structural: a licensed ISA's license sits with your broker, brings continuing education requirements and opens the door to commission-based pay that an unlicensed ISA should not receive.
A workable split for many teams: an unlicensed ISA covers first contact, qualifying questions and booking, and a licensed agent on a daily rotation takes the calls that need a license within the hour. The ISA's script names that agent, so the caller hears who will ring them and when, and nobody is tempted to answer a pricing question just to keep the conversation going.
Licensed or unlicensed: how to decide
List what the ISA will say
Write down the ten questions callers ask most and the answer the ISA will give to each. Any answer involving value, terms or negotiation points to a licensed ISA.
Decide how they will be paid
Per hour or salary, with activity bonuses, fits an unlicensed role more comfortably. Commission splits or per-closing pay point to a license.
Settle who employs them
If your state's exemption depends on employment by the broker, as Arizona's does, a team-level contractor arrangement needs the broker's review.
Check outbound rules separately
A license does not cover calling rules. Telephone solicitations to homes are barred before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time[11], and TCPA rules for agents apply licensed or not.
Get it in writing
Put the answer in the broker's policy manual: the permitted script, the pay plan and the review schedule. That document is your best evidence if a regulator asks.
Frequently asked questions
Can an unlicensed ISA tell a caller the list price?
It depends on the state. Arizona's policy statement bars unlicensed assistants from providing “advice, pricing, or opinions of value”[3], so clear even quoting price with your broker there. Elsewhere many brokers allow public listing facts read from an approved sheet.
Can an unlicensed ISA earn a bonus per closed deal?
That is the riskiest structure. Florida can discipline licensees who pay unlicensed people for referring prospects or for broker services[5]. Activity bonuses on calls or appointments held are the more common alternative; check your state.
Can an ISA have a buyer sign the buyer agreement?
Buyers working with a REALTOR sign a written agreement before touring[8], but explaining and negotiating its terms is agent work. Let the ISA set the expectation and the agent handle the agreement.
What happens if an unlicensed ISA crosses the line?
In Florida, operating as a broker or sales associate without a license is a third-degree felony[6], and the licensee who paid for the prospects can face discipline[5]. In Arizona the employing broker is expected to have written policies preventing it[3].
Does a licensed ISA need to work under a broker?
Generally, yes. Florida, for example, defines a sales associate as someone who performs broker acts under the direction, control or management of another person[2]. A licensed ISA's license sits with a broker like any agent's; check your state's rules.
References
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 475.01: Definitions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Arizona Department of Real Estate (2025). Substantive Policy Statement No. 2025.02: Unlicensed Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
Arizona State Legislature (2026). A.R.S. 32-2121: Applicability of article; exceptions (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 475.25: Discipline (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 475.42: Violations and penalties (opens in a new tab) ↑
Arizona State Legislature (2026). A.R.S. 32-2121: Applicability of article; exceptions (clerical staff, paragraph 9) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Telemarketers, median hourly wage (May 2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Real estate sales agents, median hourly wage (May 2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200: Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑