Key takeaways
- Decide first whether you need an inbound, outbound or hybrid ISA; the job description, schedule and compliance training differ.
- Test call skill live: a role play and a voicemail exercise reveal more than any résumé.
- Most people do not answer unknown numbers, so persistence and good voicemails matter: 80 percent of Americans say they generally do not pick up[1].
- Any ISA who calls out must know federal calling-hour and Do Not Call rules before the first dial[2][3].
Why the ISA hire is different
An inside sales agent sits between a lead and an agent's calendar. The ISA's job is to make contact, qualify, and hand a booked appointment to the right agent with enough context that the first meeting starts well. It is a phone-heavy, metrics-driven role, and the people who thrive in it are not always the people who interview well.
The stakes are high because buyers and sellers rarely shop around. Zillow found that 67 percent of agent-using sellers contacted only one agent, up from 62 percent a year earlier, and 77 percent rated an agent's initial responsiveness as very or extremely important[4]. The first conversation is often the only one, and the ISA is the person having it.
At the same time, reaching people by phone is harder than it used to be. In Pew Research Center's survey, 80 percent of Americans said they generally do not answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers, and only 19 percent said they generally do[1]. An ISA has to be good at the call, at the voicemail and at the text that follows, and patient enough to keep going.
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally do not answer | 80% |
| Generally answer | 19% |
Decide which ISA you are hiring
| Type | Main work | Best for | Hardest part |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inbound ISA | Calls back web, portal and sign-call leads; answers the team line | Teams with steady paid or portal lead flow | Speed: the first reply has to be fast, including evenings |
| Outbound ISA | Calls expired listings, past clients, sphere and aged leads | Teams with a large database and few new leads | Rejection, compliance and consent rules |
| Hybrid ISA | Inbound first, outbound in the gaps | Smaller teams that need one person to do both | Context-switching and protecting outbound time |
Be honest about which one you need. If most of your leads come from your own website and sign calls, an inbound ISA with strong follow-up habits will produce more than a cold caller. If your CRM holds years of past clients nobody calls, an outbound ISA with good consent practices can turn that database into listings. Many teams start inbound and add outbound once the process is stable.
Job description you can adapt
Keep the post plain and specific. Strong candidates want to know what a day looks like, how they will be measured and how they will be paid. Vague posts attract vague applicants.
- Role summary: you will be the first voice our buyers and sellers hear. You will call new inquiries quickly, learn what each person needs, and book qualified appointments with our agents.
- Daily work: call and text new leads as they arrive, follow up with leads who have not yet responded, update every conversation in the CRM, confirm appointments the day before, and pass agents a short written summary.
- Schedule: state the real hours, including which evenings and weekend shifts are required and how they rotate.
- Measures: contacts made, appointments set, appointments held, and accurate CRM notes. Say that these are reviewed weekly.
- Requirements: clear phone voice, comfort with scripts and with going off-script, CRM experience or quick learning, reliable internet if remote, and willingness to follow calling rules exactly.
- License: say whether a real estate license is required or will be sponsored. Teams often require one when the ISA discusses property details or terms.
- Pay basis: describe the structure (base, per-appointment bonus, per-closing bonus) without hiding the base. Our guide to ISA compensation models covers the options.
For a wage benchmark, the closest federal occupation is customer service representatives, whose median annual wage was $44,770 in May 2025[5]. ISA pay often sits above that once bonuses are included, but local markets vary, so check job boards in your metro.
The interview process, step by step
Phone screen instead of a résumé screen
Call every plausible applicant at the time they said they were available. Ten minutes on the phone tells you about tone, pace and listening. Note whether they called back if you reached voicemail.
Voicemail exercise
Ask the candidate to leave a voicemail for a fictional seller who requested a home value online. Listen for a clear name, a reason to call back and a specific time window.
Live role play
Play a lead and have the candidate run a qualifying call. Change the script halfway, for example by mentioning that the caller already has an agent, and see how they respond.
CRM and writing test
Give them call notes and ask for a two-line agent summary and a follow-up text. You are testing accuracy and judgment.
Compliance check
Ask what they know about calling hours, Do Not Call lists and opt-out requests. You will train them, but attitude matters: you want someone who takes rules seriously.
Reference calls
Ask former managers about reliability, coachability and how the candidate handled a bad week of numbers.
Interview questions and what good answers sound like
| Question | Listen for |
|---|---|
| Walk me through how you would call back a buyer who asked about a listing 20 minutes ago. | Speed, a short reason for the call, a question about the buyer's situation, and a clear next step |
| What would you do if a lead says they are already working with an agent? | Respect for the existing relationship, a polite close, and accurate notes |
| Tell me about a week when your numbers were bad. What did you change? | Ownership, specific adjustments, no blaming the leads |
| How do you decide when to stop following up with someone? | A planned cadence and respect for opt-outs, not endless calling |
| A caller asks whether the seller will take a lower offer. What do you say? | They do not speculate; they route pricing and terms questions to the agent |
| How do you keep CRM notes useful for the agent? | Short, factual notes: timeline, motivation, financing, best time to talk |
Score each answer as you go rather than at the end, and use the same questions for every candidate so you are comparing like with like.
Example: a role-play script for the interview
Example (fictional). You play Dana, who filled in a home value form last night. The candidate calls. A good opening sounds like: “Hi Dana, this is Sam with the Harbor Team. You asked for a value estimate on Maple Street last night, and I wanted to make sure you got it. Are you thinking about selling, or just keeping an eye on the market?”
Halfway through, Dana says: “Honestly, my cousin is an agent.” Strong candidates do not argue. They ask whether Dana would still like the estimate and a short market update, offer to send it by text, note the cousin in the CRM and ask permission before scheduling any follow-up. Weak candidates either give up abruptly or push for an appointment the caller has just declined.
Record the role play only with the candidate's consent, and check your state's call-recording rules first. Some states require every party's consent.
Score candidates the same way
Hiring managers tend to remember the candidate they liked most, not the one who performed best. A simple weighted scorecard, filled in during each step, keeps the decision tied to the job. Agree on the weights before the first interview so nobody adjusts them to fit a favorite.
| Area | Weight | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Phone presence and listening | 25% | Phone screen and role play |
| Adaptability when the call changes | 20% | Role-play twist |
| Persistence and follow-up habits | 20% | Voicemail exercise, whether they returned your missed call |
| Accuracy in writing and CRM notes | 15% | Writing test |
| Attitude to rules and coaching | 10% | Compliance questions, references |
| Schedule fit | 10% | Availability for evening and weekend shifts |
Set a minimum score for the role-play and voicemail areas. A candidate with a great résumé who cannot hold a conversation when the script changes will struggle, however much training you give. A candidate with no real estate background who scores well on listening and follow-up often learns the market quickly.
Plan the first month before you make the offer. In week one the new ISA listens to calls and learns the CRM and the compliance rules. In week two they make supervised calls with a coach on the line. By week three they work their own queue, with a daily review of five calls. At the end of the month, compare their contact and appointment numbers with the targets you set in the job description and agree on next month's goals together.
Compliance basics every ISA must know
- Federal rules bar telephone solicitations to residential subscribers before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time at the called party's location[2].
- Sales robocalls are illegal whether or not a number is on the Do Not Call Registry unless the caller has the consumer's written permission[3].
- Registrations on the National Do Not Call Registry must be honored indefinitely or until cancelled, so outbound lists must be scrubbed[2].
- Opt-out requests by call or text are logged immediately and respected across the whole team.
State rules can be stricter, and your brokerage may have its own policy. Build these into the ISA's onboarding and into the CRM so the system blocks calls it should block. Once the ISA is hired, track their work with the scorecard in ISA daily metrics and scorecards, and see where the role sits among other hires in when to hire your first assistant and transaction coordinator: in-house vs outsourced.
Frequently asked questions
What does an ISA do in real estate?
An inside sales agent contacts and qualifies leads by phone and text, books appointments for agents, keeps CRM notes current and confirms appointments. Some ISAs focus on new inbound leads, others on outbound calls to past clients or aged leads.
Does an ISA need a real estate license?
It depends on your state and on what the ISA discusses. Many teams require a license when the ISA talks about property details, terms or pricing. Check your state's rules and your broker's policy.
What is the best interview test for an ISA?
A live role play with a twist halfway through, plus a voicemail exercise. Together they show tone, listening, adaptability and persistence better than interview answers.
How quickly should an ISA call a new lead?
As fast as possible during working hours, and with a planned after-hours response. Sellers often contact only one agent, so the first prompt, helpful reply matters.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics series OEUN000000000000043405113: Customer service representatives, annual median wage, national, May 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑