Key takeaways
- Track the full funnel daily: attempts, contacts, appointments set, appointments held, and the ratios between them.
- Define every metric in writing so ISA, agents and team lead count the same thing.
- Voicemail and text follow-up matter: 67 percent of Americans who skip unknown calls still check voicemail[1].
- Add speed and compliance measures, such as time to first attempt and abandoned-call rate, to the scorecard[2].
Why ISAs need a daily scorecard
An inside sales agent's results show up weeks later as signed agreements and months later as closings. That lag makes it hard to coach from outcomes alone. A daily scorecard tracks the activities and conversion steps that lead to those outcomes, so the ISA and the team lead can see a problem on Tuesday instead of at the end of the quarter.
The scorecard also protects the ISA. When agents complain that appointments are weak, numbers settle the argument faster than opinions. When leads dry up, the scorecard shows that activity stayed steady and the drop came from marketing. Both conversations are easier with a shared record.
Many teams still lack the basics for this. NAR's technology survey found that only 46 percent of REALTORS use a CRM[3]. A scorecard works best when it is filled in automatically from the CRM and phone system, but a disciplined spreadsheet is better than nothing while the team sets up its tools.
Define each metric before you count it
| Metric | Definition | Common counting mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Attempt (dial) | Any outbound call, text or email to a lead, logged in the CRM | Counting a text and a call to the same person in one minute as two attempts |
| Contact | A two-way conversation with the lead, by phone or by text exchange | Counting a voicemail or an automated reply as a contact |
| Appointment set | A specific date and time agreed with the lead for a consultation or showing with an agent | Counting a vague “call me next week” as a set |
| Appointment held | The consultation took place with the decision-makers present | Counting a rescheduled meeting as held |
| Agreement signed | A buyer agreement or listing agreement signed after a held appointment | Crediting the ISA for agreements with leads they never spoke to |
| Time to first attempt | Minutes from lead arrival to the first attempt | Measuring only during office hours and ignoring evenings |
The contact definition matters most. If voicemails count as contacts, contact rates look excellent and tell you nothing. Pew Research Center found that 80 percent of Americans generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers[1], so an honest contact rate will be lower than many teams expect, and that is fine as long as it is measured the same way every day.
Example scorecard
Example (fictional targets). The targets below suit a full-time ISA working a mix of new inbound leads and older leads. Set your own from three months of your team's history rather than borrowing someone else's.
| Measure | Daily target (Example) | Weekly target (Example) | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attempts | 120 | 600 | ISA |
| Contacts | 20 | 100 | ISA |
| Appointments set | 3 | 15 | ISA |
| Appointments held | n/a | 10 | Agents confirm |
| Median time to first attempt (new leads) | Under 5 minutes in shift | Under 5 minutes | ISA and team lead |
| New leads attempted 6+ times in first 7 days | n/a | 90% of new leads | ISA |
| CRM notes complete within 1 hour | 100% | 100% | ISA |
| Opt-out requests processed same day | 100% | 100% | ISA |
Notice that only the first three lines are daily activity targets. The others are weekly conversion and quality measures. Judging an ISA on daily held appointments creates noise; a single cancellation makes a good day look bad.
The four ratios that tell the story
Contact rate = contacts ÷ attempts
Low contact rates usually point to timing (calling when people are at work), weak voicemails or poor lead data. Try shifting calling blocks into early evening and weekends.
Set rate = appointments set ÷ contacts
Low set rates point to the conversation itself: weak questions, no clear reason to meet, or offering an appointment too early. Review recorded calls, with consent.
Show rate = appointments held ÷ appointments set
Low show rates point to weak qualification or poor confirmation. Confirm the day before by text and call, and set the appointment no more than a few days out.
Signed rate = agreements ÷ appointments held
This is shared between the ISA and the agent. If it is low across all agents, qualification is the issue; if it is low for one agent, coaching that agent is the fix.
Example (fictional figures). In one week an ISA makes 600 attempts, has 84 contacts, sets 14 appointments and 9 are held. Contact rate is 14 percent, set rate 17 percent and show rate 64 percent. The show rate is the weak point, so the team lead adds a same-day confirmation text and a reminder call the evening before, then checks the show rate again after two weeks.
Speed and follow-up measures
Speed matters because sellers in particular do not shop widely. Zillow reports that 77 percent of agent-using sellers rate an agent's initial impression of responsiveness as very or extremely important[4]. Track two numbers: median minutes to first attempt on new leads, and the share of new leads that receive a planned sequence of attempts in their first week.
- Don't answer, but check voicemail 67%
- Don't answer and ignore voicemail 14%
- Generally answer 19%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Don't answer, but check voicemail | 67% |
| Don't answer and ignore voicemail | 14% |
| Generally answer | 19% |
Because most people let unknown calls ring out but still listen to voicemail, each attempt should include a short, specific voicemail and a text that tells the lead who is calling and why. A voicemail that names the property they asked about and offers two callback windows does more work than three silent hang-ups.
Inbound calls need their own measure. If the team line rolls to voicemail while the ISA is busy on outbound calls, track missed inbound calls separately and set a callback target. An SI Employee such as Ava can answer those calls, capture the caller's details and route them, which keeps inbound response steady while the ISA works the outbound queue.
Compliance measures belong on the scorecard
- Calls inside the permitted window: federal rules bar telephone solicitations to residential subscribers before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time at the called party's location[2].
- Abandoned-call rate: telemarketers may not abandon more than 3 percent of live-answered calls in a campaign over 30 days, and unanswered calls must ring for at least 15 seconds or four rings[2]. This matters if the team uses a dialer.
- Do Not Call scrubs: the date each outbound list was last checked against the national and internal lists.
- Opt-outs processed the same day across calls and texts.
If your scorecard rewards attempts without measuring compliance, you are paying for risk. Keep at least one compliance line on every ISA review.
Build the scorecard so it fills itself
A scorecard that depends on the ISA typing totals into a spreadsheet at six in the evening will drift. The numbers get rounded, forgotten or quietly improved. Wherever possible, pull the counts from the systems the ISA already uses, and keep manual entry for the few things only a person can judge.
- Give every lead a source and a status in the CRM, with a fixed list of statuses that match your metric definitions: new, attempted, contacted, appointment set, appointment held, agreement signed, closed, not interested, opted out.
- Log calls and texts automatically from the phone system into the CRM, so attempts and talk time are counted without typing.
- Ask agents to mark appointments held or not held within a day, from their phone, with a short reason when not held.
- Build one saved report per ratio and one for time to first attempt, filtered to the ISA and the date range.
- Send the daily report to the ISA and team lead at the same time each morning, before the huddle.
Review the definitions every quarter. As the team adds lead sources or changes its process, statuses tend to multiply and drift away from what the scorecard measures. A short clean-up session keeps the numbers trustworthy.
When numbers drop, resist the instinct to raise activity targets first. Check lead volume and source mix, then the contact rate by hour of day, then a sample of recorded calls. Most dips have a specific cause, such as a portal sending fewer leads, a calling block that moved into working hours, or a new script that skips the qualifying questions. Fix the cause, and the activity numbers usually recover on their own.
Running the daily huddle
- Five minutes, same time every day, standing or on a short video call.
- Yesterday's numbers on screen: attempts, contacts, sets, and any shows from the day before.
- One win: a call worth sharing, with the lead's permission if a recording is played.
- One fix: the ratio that slipped and the single change to try today.
- Today's priorities: hot leads, confirmations to make, and any agent availability changes.
Keep the huddle about the funnel, not about blame. Weekly, look at trends and lead sources with the team lead. Monthly, compare the scorecard with the pay plan in ISA compensation models so the targets and the incentives point the same way. If the team is still filling the role, start with hiring an ISA, and for the wider operations view see office manager responsibilities at a brokerage.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most important ISA metrics?
Attempts, contacts, appointments set and appointments held, plus the ratios between them: contact rate, set rate and show rate. Add time to first attempt on new leads and at least one compliance measure.
What is a good ISA contact rate?
It depends on lead source, data quality and calling times, so compare against your own history rather than a published benchmark. Make sure voicemails are not counted as contacts, or the number will be inflated.
Should ISAs be judged on dials?
Dials show effort and are useful for coaching, but they should not be the main measure. Appointments held and signed agreements are closer to what the team needs, and compliance must be part of the review.
How often should ISA metrics be reviewed?
Activity daily in a short huddle, conversion ratios weekly, and the full funnel including closings monthly or quarterly alongside the pay plan.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (2026 REALTORS® Technology Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑