Compliance and Regulation

The FCC One-to-One Consent Rule: What Happened

The FCC one-to-one consent rule was vacated before it took effect. What it required, why the court struck it, and consent habits brokerages should keep.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. The rule that never took effect
  2. What the FCC wrote in 2023
  3. Why the Eleventh Circuit threw it out
  4. What the regulation says now
  5. What it means if you buy leads
  6. Consent habits worth keeping anyway
  7. Calls that start with the consumer
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Compliance and Regulation: The FCC One-to-One Consent Rule: What Happened5,000+: potential callers on a hidden list in an FCC robocall enforcement case the appeals court citedCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONThe FCC One-to-One ConsentRule: What Happened5,000+potential callers on a hidden list in an FCCrobocall enforcement case the appeals court citedAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsCompliance and Regulation: The FCC One-to-One Consent Rule: What Happened5,000+: potential callers on a hidden list in an FCC robocall enforcement case the appeals court citedCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONThe FCC One-to-OneConsent Rule: WhatHappened5,000+potential callers on a hidden list inan FCC robocall enforcement case theappeals court citedAva for Real Estate Teams
Figure source: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • The FCC adopted one-to-one consent in December 2023, and the Eleventh Circuit vacated it on January 24, 2025, before it ever applied to a call[2][1].
  • The working definition is the 2012 one again: signed written consent that clearly authorizes the seller, with a clear disclosure[3][4].
  • Calling a registered number on written permission still needs an agreement saying the consumer agrees to be contacted by this seller[4].
  • Courts now read the TCPA for themselves rather than deferring to FCC interpretations[5], so tidy consent records matter more, not less.

The rule that never took effect

For most of 2024, whoever ran a brokerage's lead program had the same item at the top of the list: rebuild the consent forms before the FCC's one-to-one rule arrived. The order was adopted on December 13, 2023 and gave businesses 12 months from Federal Register publication to comply[2]. Publication came on January 26, 2024[3]. Then, on January 24, 2025, the Eleventh Circuit vacated the consent section of the order[1]. The rule never governed a single call or text.

The rule is gone. The problem it went after is still here, and so are the older rules that decide most real estate TCPA disputes. A brokerage that buys leads needs to know what the FCC tried to require, why the court rejected it, what the regulation says now, and which consent habits to keep regardless.

What the FCC wrote in 2023

The target was the comparison-shopping website. A consumer fills in one form, ticks one box, and that box authorizes calls and texts from a long list of marketing partners. The lead is then sold, sometimes many times over. The FCC called this the lead generator loophole and closed it by requiring written consent for robocalls and robotexts from one seller at a time[2].

Two more conditions came with it. The consent had to follow a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the consumer would get robocalls or robotexts from that seller, and the calls had to be logically and topically associated with the website where consent was given[2]. The example the FCC used: consent given on a car loan comparison site did not cover calls about loan consolidation[1]. One reading for real estate was that a home-search form would not have covered calls from a moving company or a solar installer, however the checkbox was worded.

Who one consent could reachAn FCC enforcement case described by the Eleventh Circuit, against the limit in the vacated rule.
Who one consent could reachComparison. Potential callers on the hidden list in an FCC enforcement case (more than): 5,000; Sellers one consent could cover under the vacated rule: 1.5,000Potential callers on the hidden list in anFCC enforcement case (more than)Potential callers on the hidden list in an FCC enforcement case (more than): 5,0001Sellers one consent could cover under thevacated ruleSellers one consent could cover under the vacated rule: 1Who one consent could reachComparison. Potential callers on the hidden list in an FCC enforcement case (more than): 5,000; Sellers one consent could cover under the vacated rule: 1.5,000Potential callers on the hidden listin an FCC enforcement case (morethan)Potential callers on the hidden list in an FCC enforcement case (more than): 5,0001Sellers one consent could coverunder the vacated ruleSellers one consent could cover under the vacated rule: 1

Source: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, 2025[1]

Show the data
ConsentCallers or sellers covered
Potential callers on the hidden list in an FCC enforcement case (more than)5,000
Sellers one consent could cover under the vacated rule1

The scale of the abuse explains the bluntness. In a footnote on an earlier FCC enforcement action, the Eleventh Circuit described a company that made student loan robocalls after seeking consent about unrelated topics, and that had hidden a list of more than 5,000 potential callers on a secondary website[1]. Against that, the FCC's limit was one seller per consent.

Why the Eleventh Circuit threw it out

The challenge came from the Insurance Marketing Coalition, a consortium of more than twenty entities representing insurance industry stakeholders, with lead generators among its members[1]. The argument that won was about the words of the statute. The TCPA requires the called party's prior express consent for autodialed and prerecorded calls and never defines the phrase. The court held that the FCC's two new restrictions conflicted with the ordinary meaning of prior express consent, so the FCC had exceeded its authority[1].

The reasoning fits in a sentence. A consumer who clearly and unmistakably says, before the call, that they are willing to receive it has consented[1]. A rule that voids that consent because other companies sat on the same form, or because the topic looks unrelated to the website, adds a condition Congress did not write. At oral argument the FCC's counsel agreed that, without the 2023 order, the statute would let a consumer who ticked boxes for three mortgage companies also consent to calls from a home repair business on the same page[1].

The court vacated Part III.D of the order, the consent section, and sent the matter back to the FCC[1]. The coalition challenged only that part, so the rest of the 2023 order, including its text message rules, was not before the court.

How the rule rose and fell
  1. Dec 13, 2023

    FCC adopts one-seller-at-a-time consent for robocalls and robotexts[2]

  2. Jan 26, 2024

    Order published in the Federal Register; the 12-month compliance clock starts[3]

  3. Jan 24, 2025

    Eleventh Circuit vacates the consent section before it applies[1]

  4. Jun 20, 2025

    Supreme Court: district courts are not bound by an agency's reading of the statute[5]

  5. Aug 29, 2025

    eCFR text is back to the 2012 consent definition[3]

Dates from the FCC order, the court opinions and the eCFR version history.

What the regulation says now

The eCFR carried the one-seller wording into 2025: the text dated April 11, 2025 still limited consent to no more than one identified seller[6]. The version dated August 29, 2025 is back to the 2012 definition and lists a Federal Register amendment published that day[3].

That 2012 definition is the working rule. Prior express written consent for autodialed or prerecorded telemarketing is a written agreement, signed by the person called, that clearly authorizes the seller to deliver those calls to a stated number. It must include a clear and conspicuous disclosure, and it must say that signing is not a condition of buying anything. Electronic signatures count where federal law or state contract law recognizes them[4]. Nothing in it caps the number of sellers, and nothing in it tests whether the topic matches the website.

Put side by side, the difference is narrower than the 2024 panic suggested. Both definitions demand a signed, written agreement and a clear disclosure. The vacated version added two automatic disqualifiers: more than one seller on the consent, or a topic unrelated to the page. Without them, a weak consent is not void by rule; it is just weak, and a court decides how weak on the facts in front of it.

Two developments since 2023 shape how courts apply it. The rule that registry protections cover text messages, codified in the same 2023 order, was outside the challenge[2][1]. And in June 2025 the Supreme Court held that district courts in enforcement cases are not bound by an agency's interpretation of a statute[5]. Judges now read the TCPA for themselves. For a brokerage, that means fewer settled answers to lean on and more room for courts to disagree.

State law did not move with the vacatur either. Florida's Telephone Solicitation Act counts real property as consumer goods or services, so it reaches real estate sales calls and texts[7]. The main state statutes are covered in state mini-TCPA laws.

What it means if you buy leads

Losing a bright-line test did not make bulk consent good. A brokerage that calls or texts a purchased lead with an autodialer, or leaves a prerecorded message, still has to show that the consumer clearly authorized that brokerage to do it[4]. A partner list of hundreds of names behind a link the consumer never opened is exactly the exhibit a plaintiff's lawyer wants to show a jury.

Registered numbers raise a separate question that has nothing to do with the vacated rule. Calling a number on the National Do Not Call Registry needs an exemption, and the written-permission route requires a signed agreement stating that the consumer agrees to be contacted by this seller, including the number[4]. Consent to unnamed partners rarely meets that test for your brokerage.

Example: a team buys seller leads from a home-valuation site. The form says the consumer agrees to calls from the site “and its partners” and links to a list of 140 companies, with the team's brokerage at number 97. Under the vacated rule that consent would have been worthless to the team. Today it is not automatically void, but it is thin: the brokerage's name was never in front of the consumer, and for registered numbers it does not show agreement to be contacted by this seller. The fix is upstream. Ask the vendor for forms that name the brokerage beside the checkbox, scrub every lead against the registry and your internal list, and skip registered numbers the consent does not cover.

Co-marketing pages deserve the same scrutiny. A joint landing page with a lender, a builder or a relocation company often carries one consent line for everyone on it. The vacated rule would have forced a separate checkbox for each business. Nothing forces it now, but a shared line makes it harder to show that the consumer agreed to hear from your brokerage in particular.

  1. Who is named?

    Your brokerage's name, or the team name consumers know, should appear beside the checkbox, not on a linked page.

  2. What was the consumer doing?

    A home-value request supports a listing conversation. It is weak support for calls about insurance, moving or solar.

  3. Which number, and when?

    The record should show the number entered and the date and time of submission, not just the date the lead was sold.

  4. Is the number registered?

    Scrub it against the registry and your internal list before the first dial or text, whatever the consent says.

  5. Can the vendor prove it fast?

    Ask for the consent record on a sample lead and time the answer. A vendor that needs two weeks will not help you after a demand letter.

The wider vendor checklist is in buying leads safely. Live transfer programs, where a vendor's caller hands the consumer to your agent mid-call, carry the same consent question one step removed, so put it on the list when you evaluate a lead vendor before signing.

Most of what the FCC asked for in 2023 is simply good evidence. A consent that names you, matches what the consumer was doing and sits in the file with a timestamp is easy to defend in any court, under any reading of the statute. Keep these habits whether or not anyone revives the rule.

Six consent habits that survive the vacatur, and the evidence each one leaves.
HabitWhy it still mattersWhat to check in the lead file
Your brokerage named at the checkboxConsent must clearly authorize the seller who calls; registry permission must name this sellerThe exact form text, with your legal or trade name visible before submit
Topic matches the inquiryConsent that plainly covers the call is the easiest kind to proveThe page or ad the consumer used and what they asked for
Proof stored per leadCourts decide the meaning of consent case by case nowTimestamp, form version, the words shown, the phone number entered
Registry and internal list scrubVague consent is not the signed permission the registry exemption needsScrub date, result, and which exemption applies
Opt-outs honored fastRevocation must be honored within ten business days at the outsideDate of the stop request and date the number was suppressed
State law checkedSome state statutes reach real estate texts and calls directlyThe consumer's state and its rules

The ten-business-day ceiling for honoring a revocation comes from the FCC's current rule[4]. Consent wording itself is covered in express written consent for real estate texts and calls, and the records to keep in proof of consent.

Calls that start with the consumer

The cleanest consent is the consumer picking up the phone first. A call a buyer or seller makes to your office is not a telephone solicitation, and the conversation can settle what they want to hear about next and how. That makes inbound calls worth answering properly, especially when outbound rules shift. In the modelled setup of the 40-agent brokerage example, evening and weekend calls to the main line are answered and routed rather than left on voicemail.

An SI Employee answering forwarded office or sign calls keeps a recording, transcript and summary of each one, so the date and the caller's own words are on file when an agent follows up (see what it does). It answers; it does not dial lists. For the outbound side, TCPA rules for real estate agents sets out the full framework, and can realtors text without consent walks through the texting scenarios.

Frequently asked questions

Is the FCC one-to-one consent rule in effect?

No. The Eleventh Circuit vacated it on January 24, 2025, before it applied[1], and the regulation text now carries the 2012 definition of prior express written consent[3].

Can one consent form cover several agents or brokerages?

The federal rule no longer limits consent to one seller, but the consent must still clearly authorize the seller who calls, and written permission to call a registered number must say the consumer agrees to be contacted by this seller[4]. Naming each brokerage beside its own checkbox remains the easiest consent to prove.

Did the court decision change the rules for texting?

Not the text message rules. The coalition challenged only the consent section, and the 2023 order's codification that registry protections apply to texts was outside the case[2][1].

Could the FCC bring the rule back?

The court sent the matter back to the FCC[1]. Any new version would have to fit the court's reading of prior express consent, and since June 2025 district courts interpret the TCPA for themselves rather than deferring to the agency[5].

Do state laws still matter after the vacatur?

Yes. State telemarketing statutes were untouched. Florida's, for example, treats real property as consumer goods or services, so it covers real estate sales calls and texts[7].

References

  1. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (2025). Insurance Marketing Coalition Ltd. v. FCC, No. 24-10277 (opinion of January 24, 2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Federal Communications Commission (2023). Second Report and Order, Targeting and Eliminating Unlawful Text Messages (FCC 23-107) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (National Archives) (2025). 47 CFR 64.1200, point-in-time text as of August 29, 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200, Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., No. 23-1226 (2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (National Archives) (2025). 47 CFR 64.1200, point-in-time text as of April 11, 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 501.059, Telephone solicitation (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo