Compliance and Regulation

Can Realtors Text Without Consent? Scenarios Explained

Lead forms, open house sign-ins, past clients, FSBOs and expireds: which real estate texts need consent, which need a registry check, and what to send.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Texting is the channel buyers want
  2. A text is a call
  3. Three questions before any text
  4. Common scenarios, one by one
  5. When it goes wrong: one agent, 1,019 numbers
  6. Write the team's texting rules down
  7. Checks before the first text
  8. First texts that hold up
  9. Let the phone call do the asking
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Compliance and Regulation: Can Realtors Text Without Consent? Scenarios Explained1,019: registered numbers in a class settlement over one agent's texts for a New York brokerageCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONCan Realtors Text WithoutConsent? Scenarios Explained1,019registered numbers in a class settlement over oneagent's texts for a New York brokerageAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsCompliance and Regulation: Can Realtors Text Without Consent? Scenarios Explained1,019: registered numbers in a class settlement over one agent's texts for a New York brokerageCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONCan Realtors TextWithout Consent?Scenarios Explained1,019registered numbers in a classsettlement over one agent's texts fora New York brokerageAva for Real Estate Teams
Figure source: U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • A text is a call under the TCPA[2], and the registry rules cover texts to cell phones[3][4].
  • Replying to a consumer who texted you first is the safest text there is; carrier guidance expects no extra permission for that reply[5].
  • Marketing texts to a registered number need an exemption: a current business relationship, signed written permission naming you, or a genuine personal relationship[4].
  • Sending from your own phone does not change the answer: one agent's texts to 1,019 registered numbers became a $400,000 class settlement[1].

Texting is the channel buyers want

Text is how most buyers would rather hear from their agent: 43% of recent buyers named it their preferred channel, ahead of phone calls at 31%[6]. Agents know this, which is why the first instinct after an open house, a sign call or a new portal lead is to fire off a text. That preference describes clients who already chose you. It says nothing about a stranger whose number came off a sign-in sheet or an expired listing.

How buyers prefer to talk with their agentShare of recent US buyers naming each as their preferred channel; other channels not shown.
How buyers prefer to talk with their agentComparison. Text message: 43%; Phone call: 31%.43%Text messageText message: 43%31%Phone callPhone call: 31%How buyers prefer to talk with their agentComparison. Text message: 43%; Phone call: 31%.43%Text messageText message: 43%31%Phone callPhone call: 31%

Source: Zillow Research, 2026[6]

Show the data
ChannelShare of buyers
Text message43%
Phone call31%

Whether a given text needs consent depends on three things: who started the conversation, whether the number is on the National Do Not Call Registry or your own do-not-call list, and whether the text is marketing sent through an automated platform. The scenarios below run each common real estate situation through those questions.

A text is a call

Agents sometimes treat texting as a gray zone because the TCPA talks about telephone calls. The Supreme Court settled that years ago: a text message to a cell phone qualifies as a call under the statute[2]. The FCC went further in its December 2023 order and codified that National Do Not Call Registry protections apply to text messages[3]. The regulation itself says its registry and company do-not-call rules apply to anyone sending telephone solicitations or telemarketing texts to wireless numbers[4].

So the registry question is the same for a text as for a cold call. A marketing text to a registered number is a telephone solicitation unless an exemption applies, and the do-not-call rules do not care whether it went out from a platform, a CRM or the agent's own phone.

Three questions before any text

  1. Has this person asked your brokerage to stop? A reply of stop, quit, end, revoke, opt out, cancel or unsubscribe is a reasonable way to revoke consent[4], and the request must be honored within ten business days at the outside[4]. Nothing else on this list matters if the answer is yes.
  2. Is this a marketing text to a registered number? Then you need an exemption: an established business relationship (a purchase or transaction within 18 months, or an inquiry within three months), signed written permission that names your brokerage and the number, or a personal relationship between the consumer and the person texting[4].
  3. Is it marketing sent through an automated system? Autodialed or prerecorded telemarketing needs prior express written consent[4]. Whether a texting platform counts as an autodialer now turns on its capacity to use a random or sequential number generator[7]. Do not build a program on winning that argument in court.

There is a fourth gate that is not law but behaves like it: the carriers. Industry messaging guidance sorts texts into three kinds. Conversational texts, where the consumer texts first and you simply respond, need no additional permission. Informational texts need consent given when the consumer hands over the number for that purpose. Promotional texts need the consumer's written agreement[5]. Business texting platforms register your traffic against those categories, which is covered in 10DLC basics for agents.

Common scenarios, one by one

General federal position. State laws can be stricter, and a consumer's stop request overrides every row.
ScenarioRegistry questionConsent questionPractical answer
Buyer texts you about a listingYou are replying, not solicitingConversational; no extra permission expected for the replyAnswer what they asked; ask before adding them to any campaign
Website form that names your brokerageSigned written permission can cover registered numbersWritten consent if the wording covers marketing textsText within what the form described; keep the form version and timestamp
Portal or purchased leadOnly if the consent names youSameRead the consent record before the first text
Open house sign-in sheetA visitor's inquiry may support a three-month relationshipNone for marketing texts unless the sheet askedAdd a texting line to the sign-in; otherwise call or follow up by email
Past client, closed 10 months agoRelationship covers solicitationsAutomated marketing still needs written consentPersonal texts are fine; get written consent before a drip campaign
Past client, closed three years agoRelationship has lapsedSameRegistered number: written permission first, or a letter or email
FSBO yard signNo relationshipNoneRegistered: no marketing text. Unregistered: one personal text that names you and offers a way out
Expired listingNo relationship with your brokerageNoneSame as a FSBO
Client under contractTransaction updates are not solicitationsInformational; they gave you the number for thisText freely about the deal; keep promotions out
Friend or relativePersonal relationship exception, for the person who knows themNone for personal textsOnly you, personally; not the team's ISA or a campaign

Open house sign-ins cause the most arguments. A visitor who signs in and asks about the home has arguably made an inquiry, which supports calls and texts to a registered number for three months[4]. That is a do-not-call exemption, not consent to marketing texts from a platform, and it ends the moment the visitor asks you to stop. The simple fix is a line on the sign-in form or tablet asking whether they would like texts from your brokerage about this home and similar listings; see open house sign-in options.

Past clients run on a clock. The 18-month window after a closing lets you call or text a registered number about new business, and then it lapses[4]. Anniversary texts sent by hand are low risk inside that window. A quarterly market update blasted from a texting platform is marketing through an automated system, and it needs written consent no matter how warm the relationship feels. The clock rules are covered in detail in established business relationships under the TCPA.

FSBOs and expireds are the hard cases because there is no relationship at all. The sign in the yard invites buyers, not agents, and most FSBO sellers are not waiting for one: 62% of FSBO sellers already knew their buyer[8]. If the number is registered, a marketing text is off the table. If it is not, a single personal text that names you, your brokerage and why you are writing, with an easy way to say no, is the most you should send. Calling expireds and FSBOs on the Do Not Call list has the daily routine.

When it goes wrong: one agent, 1,019 numbers

The case agents should know is small, which is the point. A New York brokerage settled a class action for $400,000 over texts that one agent sent on its behalf. The class covered people tied to 1,019 phone numbers that had been on the National Do Not Call Registry for at least 30 days and received more than one text from that agent within a 12-month period; the brokerage denied the allegations[1]. The numbers were identified from records produced by a real estate CRM company[1].

The claim, as the notice describes it, turned on registry status rather than on how the texts were sent: registered numbers, texted on behalf of the brokerage, more than once in a year[1]. State law can add more. Florida's statute reaches real estate texts, and before suing over a text solicitation the recipient must reply stop, after which the sender has 15 days to stop[9]. Texas expanded its definition of telephone solicitation to include text messages from September 1, 2025[10].

Write the team's texting rules down

Most texting problems on a team come from good intentions applied unevenly: one agent asks before texting, another assumes the open house sheet was enough, and the ISA loads last year's sign-in list into a drip. A one-page texting rule, signed by every agent and assistant, removes the guesswork. It also gives the broker something to supervise against.

  • Personal phones are for replies and one-to-one texts with clients and people who texted first. Anything sent to more than one person at a time goes through the brokerage's platform.
  • No marketing text goes to a number until the CRM shows its registry status, internal list status and the source of any consent.
  • Open house and event sign-ins carry a texting opt-in line. Without a tick, visitors get a call or an email, not a campaign.
  • Past-client campaigns run only to contacts with written texting consent on file. Anniversary notes sent by hand are the exception.
  • Every stop, no or wrong-number reply is added to the brokerage list the same day, by whoever sees it first.
  • New agents and assistants read the rule and sign it before they get access to the texting platform.

Supervision is where this usually breaks. A broker who reviews a sample of agent texts each month, especially first texts to new contacts, catches the habits that turn into class definitions later.

Checks before the first text

Example: deciding whether a first text can go out
  • Caller
  • System
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Who started it?

    If the consumer texted first, a direct reply to that request is conversational.

  2. 02System

    Check your own list

    Anyone who asked your brokerage to stop stays off, whatever else applies.

  3. 03System

    Registered number?

    Marketing needs an exemption: relationship, signed permission or a personal tie.

  4. 04Your team

    How is it sent?

    Automated marketing texts need prior express written consent on file.

  5. 05Your team

    Send it clean

    Your name, brokerage, the reason for the text and how to stop.

Example sequence for a team's texting policy. It does not replace advice on a specific state's law.

Build these checks into the tools rather than the agent's memory. A CRM that holds the registry status, the relationship date and the consent source for each contact can block a campaign before it reaches a registered number. Agents texting from personal phones are the gap, and a written rule about which texts may go from a personal phone closes most of it.

First texts that hold up

A clean first text names a real person and the brokerage, says why you are writing, and makes stopping easy. It should read like a person wrote it, because a person should have.

  • Example, reply to a buyer who texted about a listing: “Hi, this is Dana with Northgate Realty. Yes, 14 Birch Lane is still available. Saturday 11 to 1 is open house, or I can set a private showing. Which works?”
  • Example, asking permission after an open house: “Hi, Dana from Northgate Realty, we met at 14 Birch Lane today. Would you like texts when similar homes list nearby? Reply YES to opt in. No reply, no texts.”
  • Example, past client within the relationship window: “Hi Sam, Dana at Northgate Realty. Two homes on your street sold this month. Happy to send the numbers if useful. Reply STOP and I won't text again.”

When someone opts out, the opt-out belongs to the brokerage, not just the agent who got it. A request applies to the business on whose behalf the message went out[4], so a second agent texting the same person next month is a second violation waiting to happen. Opt-out and revocation rules covers how to sync one stop list across every tool.

Let the phone call do the asking

The best texting consent comes from a conversation the consumer started. A buyer who calls a sign or a listing ad has made an inquiry, and the call is the natural moment to ask whether they would like listing details by text. In the solo listing agent example, sign calls that arrive during showings are answered rather than sent to voicemail.

An SI Employee answering forwarded sign and office calls can ask that question if your approved script includes it, and the caller's answer sits in the recording, transcript and summary your agent receives (a team lead response example shows the handoff). The agent then texts by hand, with the consumer's own words on file. For the wording of written consent on web forms, see express written consent for real estate texts and calls and TCPA consent language for lead forms.

Frequently asked questions

Can I text someone who called my listing sign?

Their call is an inquiry, which supports follow-up about it for three months even if the number is registered[4]. Ask on the call whether text is fine, and get written consent before adding them to any automated campaign.

Are texts from my personal cell phone exempt?

No. The registry and company do-not-call rules apply to telemarketing texts to wireless numbers however they are sent[4], and a $400,000 class settlement involved texts sent by a single agent[1].

Do I need consent to text a client about their transaction?

A client who gave you their number for the deal has asked for those messages. Industry guidance treats them as informational texts covered by that consent[5]. Keep promotions and referral asks out of the transaction thread.

If someone replies STOP to one agent, can another agent at the brokerage text them?

No. A do-not-call request applies to the business on whose behalf the message was sent[4]. Put it on the brokerage's shared list the same day.

Do state laws change any of this?

Often. Florida's statute reaches real estate texts and gives a sender 15 days to stop after a stop reply before a suit[9]; Texas added text messages to its telephone solicitation rules in 2025[10]. See state mini-TCPA laws.

References

  1. U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York (2025). Notice of Class Action Settlement, Nicotra v. Bayside NY Homes LLC, No. 1:24-cv-04459 (E.D.N.Y.) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2016). Campbell-Ewald Co. v. Gomez, 577 U.S. 153 (2016) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Federal Communications Commission (2023). Second Report and Order, Targeting and Eliminating Unlawful Text Messages (FCC 23-107) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200, Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. CTIA (2023). Messaging Principles and Best Practices (May 2023) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Zillow Research (2026). Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026: Buyers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2021). Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid, 592 U.S. 395 (2021) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 501.059, Telephone solicitation (opens in a new tab) ↑

  10. Texas Legislature Online (2025). Texas SB 140 (89th Legislature), enrolled text (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo