Brokerage Operations and Staffing

First Team Hire: Admin Assistant or ISA?

Choose your first real estate team hire by where hours leak: paperwork and listing work, or unworked leads and missed calls. A two-week audit and the math.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing8 min read

On this page
  1. Hire for the leak, not the title
  2. What each hire takes off your plate
  3. Find the leak with a two-week audit
  4. Price the paperwork leak
  5. Price the lead leak
  6. Decision rules
  7. Signs the first hire was aimed at the wrong leak
  8. Write the first 90 days before you post the job
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Brokerage Operations and Staffing: First Team Hire: Admin Assistant or ISA?$36.73: average employer cost per hour worked for office and administrative support staff, June 2026BROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGFirst Team Hire: AdminAssistant or ISA?$36.73average employer cost per hour worked for officeand administrative support staff, June 2026Ava for Real Estate TeamsInsightsBrokerage Operations and Staffing: First Team Hire: Admin Assistant or ISA?$36.73: average employer cost per hour worked for office and administrative support staff, June 2026BROKERAGE OPERATIONS AND STAFFINGFirst Team Hire:Admin Assistant orISA?$36.73average employer cost per hour workedfor office and administrative supportstaff, June 2026Ava for Real Estate Teams
Figure source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]

Key takeaways

  • Pick the first hire by where your hours leak: paperwork and listing work point to an admin assistant; unworked leads and missed calls point to an ISA.
  • Run a two-week audit that prices both leaks in the same unit, dollars a month, before writing the job description.
  • Employer cost runs well above the wage: office and administrative support staff cost $25.22 an hour in wages plus $11.51 in benefits in June 2026[1].
  • If unanswered calls are most of the lead leak, call coverage may fix it without a hire and leave the first hire for the paperwork.

Hire for the leak, not the title

The first hire on a growing team is usually made in a hurry, after a week when a contract deadline nearly slipped or a seller lead sat in voicemail over a weekend. Whichever crisis came last tends to write the job description. That is how teams end up with an assistant who spends half the day on phones nobody trained them for, or an ISA buried in disclosure packets.

There are two leaks to compare. One is administrative: transaction paperwork, listing launches, showing coordination, client updates and the CRM entries agents put off. The other is on the lead side: calls that ring out during showings, web leads that wait until evening for a first call, and follow-up that stops after the second attempt. An admin assistant plugs the first. An ISA plugs the second. Measure both before deciding which one costs more.

On most teams the choice carries weight. NAR's 2026 member profile found that 21% of REALTORS work on a team and that teams average four members[2]. On a four-person team, one hire is a quarter of the headcount and a large share of the budget.

What each hire takes off your plate

Typical split. State license law limits what unlicensed staff in either role may say or do.
WorkAdmin assistantISA
Contract-to-close paperwork and deadlinesCore of the jobNo
Listing launch: photos, measurements, MLS input draftsYes, within what unlicensed staff may doNo
Showing coordination and feedbackYesSometimes, for buyer leads
Client updates during a dealYesNo
New lead calls and web-lead first touchOnly if phones are added to the jobCore of the job
Follow-up on leads not ready yetRarely gets doneCore of the job
CRM hygieneData entry and clean-upNotes, stages and next steps on leads
How you measure itDeadlines met, files completeAppointments held

Both roles run into license law. Unlicensed staff generally cannot give opinions on price or negotiate terms, and where the line sits varies by state; what unlicensed assistants can and cannot do walks through it. If the first hire will talk to buyers about properties, read that before writing the job description.

Find the leak with a two-week audit

Example: a two-week first-hire audit
  • Your team
  • System
  1. 01Your team

    Log every task

    Each agent notes admin work and lead work in 15-minute blocks for ten working days.

  2. 02System

    Pull lead response data

    Time to first attempt, attempts per lead and leads never reached, from the CRM.

  3. 03System

    Count calls that rang out

    Unanswered calls by hour from the phone system, sign and office numbers included.

  4. 04Your team

    Price both leaks

    Admin hours at agent value; missed and slow leads as commission at risk.

  5. 05Your team

    Hire for the bigger leak

    Write the job description around the larger number, not the latest crisis.

Example process. Use two ordinary weeks, not a holiday week or a slow stretch.

Agents hate time logs, so keep it crude: a shared sheet with two columns, admin and leads, filled in at lunch and at the end of the day. Precision is not the goal. A gap of ten hours a week between the columns is.

What goes in each column, so agents log the same things:

  • Admin: contract and disclosure paperwork, deadline tracking, listing input and photo scheduling, showing coordination, client update calls and emails, CRM data entry.
  • Leads: first calls to new leads, callbacks to missed calls, follow-up attempts on leads not ready yet, appointment confirmations, voicemails and texts to leads.
  • Neither: anything else, so the two columns stay honest. Errands, meetings and personal admin go here.

Add one more column if you can: the tasks only an agent should do. Listing appointments, buyer consultations, negotiations and showings are what the hire is meant to free time for. If those hours are already full and the admin and lead columns keep growing, the team is past due for help.

Price the paperwork leak

Admin hours cost what an agent hour is worth, because an agent doing paperwork is not prospecting, showing or listing. The median REALTOR's gross income was $59,200 in 2025[2]. Over about 2,000 working hours that is roughly $30 an hour, and a producing team lead's hour is worth more.

Example: the team lead and two agents log 26 hours of admin work a week between them. At $30 an hour that is $780 a week, or about $3,380 a month, spent on tasks an assistant could do. Moved to prospecting and listing appointments, those hours are where the hire pays back.

Now the other side of the ledger. The median hourly wage for secretaries and administrative assistants was $22.86 in May 2025[3], and customer service representatives, the usual benchmark for inside sales pay, earned a median of $21.53[4]. Wages understate the bill. In June 2026 private employers paid $25.22 an hour in wages and $11.51 in benefits for office and administrative support workers, and $26.99 in wages plus $8.86 in benefits for sales workers[1].

Employer cost per hour worked, June 2026Private industry averages by occupational group: wages and salaries plus benefits.
Employer cost per hour worked, June 2026Column chart. Office and admin support: Wages and salaries $25.22, Benefits $11.51; Sales and related: Wages and salaries $26.99, Benefits $8.86; All private industry: Wages and salaries $32.82, Benefits $14.07.$0$10$20$30$40Office and admin support · Wages and salaries: $25.22$25.22Office and admin support · Benefits: $11.51$11.51Office and admin supportSales and related · Wages and salaries: $26.99$26.99Sales and related · Benefits: $8.86$8.86Sales and relatedAll private industry · Wages and salaries: $32.82$32.82All private industry · Benefits: $14.07$14.07All private industryEmployer cost per hour worked, June 2026Column chart. Office and admin support: Wages and salaries $25.22, Benefits $11.51; Sales and related: Wages and salaries $26.99, Benefits $8.86; All private industry: Wages and salaries $32.82, Benefits $14.07.$0$10$20$30$40Office and admin support · Wages and salaries: $25.22$25.22Office and admin support · Benefits: $11.51$11.51Office andadminsupportSales and related · Wages and salaries: $26.99$26.99Sales and related · Benefits: $8.86$8.86Sales andrelatedAll private industry · Wages and salaries: $32.82$32.82All private industry · Benefits: $14.07$14.07All privateindustry
  • Wages and salaries
  • Benefits

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]

Show the data
Occupational groupWages and salariesBenefits
Office and admin support$25.22$11.51
Sales and related$26.99$8.86
All private industry$32.82$14.07

At the office-support average of $36.73 an hour[1], a full-time admin working 2,080 hours costs roughly $76,000 a year before software, equipment and the hours you spend training. Part-time is a common first step. When to hire your first real estate assistant covers part-time and remote options, and pay structures for non-agent staff covers the pay plan.

Price the lead leak

Lead hours are priced differently, because the loss is the deal rather than the time. A buyer who calls a sign number during a showing and reaches voicemail often calls the next sign instead. Callbacks struggle: 80% of Americans say they don't generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls[5]. And the calls come when agents are busiest, since agents' schedules often run into evenings and weekends to fit clients[6].

ExampleExample: the lead leak at a four-agent team
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Lead calls a week to sign and office numbers25
Share that ring out or reach voicemail35%
Unanswered calls from new customers (%)40%
New callers who would book (%)4%
Gross commission per closed side$9,000
Unanswered calls a month38
From new customers15
Bookings that would have followed0.6
Monthly value at risk$5,456

How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.

Assumptions

  • Missed share: calls that ring out during showings and evenings, taken from the audit. Callbacks rarely connect because most people don't answer unknown numbers[5].[5]
  • Average value: $9,000 gross commission per side, about 2.2% of the $417,500 median existing-home price in September 2026[7]. Replace it with your own.[7]
  • New-business share and closing rate are illustrative; take them from your CRM.

Example only: commission at risk each month from lead calls nobody answers.

Put the two numbers side by side. In this example about $3,400 a month of agent time goes to paperwork, and about $5,500 a month of commission is at risk from unanswered lead calls. That team's first hire leans toward the lead side. Change the inputs and the answer can flip: a team with few inbound calls and a stack of pending transactions should hire the admin.

Decision rules

  • Hire an admin first when the audit shows more than about ten hours a week of agent admin work, contract deadlines are slipping, and leads already get answered reasonably fast.
  • Hire an ISA first when leads wait hours or days for a first call, follow-up stops after two attempts, and paperwork is under control, perhaps with a transaction coordinator paid per file.
  • Fix the phones before either hire when the lead leak is mostly calls that ring out. Call coverage is a smaller decision than a hire, and it leaves the first hire for the paperwork.
  • Wait when neither leak is large. Re-run the audit next quarter; two ordinary weeks are better evidence than one bad one.

The third rule is the one teams skip. When most of the lead leak is unanswered calls, forwarding those calls on no-answer to an SI Employee gets every caller answered in the team's name: sellers are asked for the address and timeline and booked for a consultation, buyers leave a showing request for an agent to confirm, and each call's summary lands in the CRM. That can push the ISA decision back a year and make the first hire an admin. The solo listing agent example pairs exactly that with a transaction coordinator paid per file. More on how the line works is on assistcall.ai, and transaction coordinator in-house vs outsourced covers the paperwork side.

Signs the first hire was aimed at the wrong leak

A good hire in the wrong seat looks like a bad hire, so check the job before judging the person. These patterns usually show up within the first 60 days.

  • The admin spends most mornings returning lead calls. The lead leak was bigger than the audit showed, or nobody covers the phones while agents show homes.
  • The ISA keeps getting pulled into contract deadlines and listing input because nobody else will do them. The paperwork leak was bigger, and lead follow-up has quietly stopped again.
  • Agents still log as many admin hours as before. The handoffs were never written, so work drifted back to the people who used to do it.
  • Appointments rose but closings did not. The ISA is booking meetings the agents are too busy to run well, which points to agent capacity, not lead response.

The fix in each case is a job change before a people change: move the phones to coverage, add a per-file coordinator, or write the handoffs that were skipped. Then re-run the audit.

Write the first 90 days before you post the job

  1. List the handoffs

    Write the ten tasks the hire takes over first, who hands each one over and by what date.

  2. Set two numbers

    For an admin: files closed on time and hours of agent admin a week. For an ISA: speed to first attempt and appointments held.

  3. Decide employee or contractor

    Classification follows how the work is directed and controlled, not the label on the agreement; see independent contractor vs employee.

  4. Book the 90-day review

    Re-run the two-week audit at day 90. If the leak you hired for has not shrunk, change the job before you change the person.

Whichever hire comes first, the audit sheet is the brief for the second one. The leak you did not hire for this year is usually next year's job description.

Frequently asked questions

Should my first hire be licensed?

Only if you need licensed work done. A licensed assistant can discuss properties and terms in ways an unlicensed one cannot, and usually costs more. For paperwork and coordination, unlicensed is common.

Can one person do admin and ISA work?

At low volume, yes, but the two jobs pull against each other: paperwork deadlines win and lead follow-up slips. If you combine them, protect daily calling blocks and forward calls when the assistant is busy.

What does an admin assistant cost an employer?

Start with wages plus benefits. In June 2026 private employers paid an average of $36.73 per hour worked for office and administrative support staff, of which $11.51 was benefits[1].

Is a transaction coordinator a substitute for an admin?

For contract-to-close work, often yes, and paid per file the cost scales with volume. It does not cover listing launches, scheduling or the CRM, which is where an admin earns the rest of the salary.

How do I know the hire is working?

Re-run the two-week audit at 90 days. The leak you hired for should be smaller in hours or dollars, and agents should be spending the freed time on appointments.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: Private industry workers by occupational and industry group (June 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Secretaries and administrative assistants (except legal, medical and executive), hourly median wage, May 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Customer service representatives, hourly median wage, May 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo