Phones and Call Handling

Handling Calls and Leads Tied to Agents Who Left

A brokerage policy for calls, leads and clients tied to agents who left: routing rules, scripts, a departure checklist and how to respect client choice.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Departures are normal; the confusion is optional
  2. Who owns what: settle it in writing
  3. Routing rules for each kind of call
  4. Scripts for the first thirty seconds
  5. The departure checklist
  6. Reassigning open leads fairly
  7. Example: a top producer leaves in March
  8. Prevent the next scramble
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Phones and Call Handling: Handling Calls and Leads Tied to Agents Who LeftArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHandling Calls andLeads Tied to AgentsWho LeftAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsPhones and Call Handling: Handling Calls and Leads Tied to Agents Who LeftArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHandling Calls andLeads Tied to AgentsWho LeftAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Agent departures are routine, so the policy for their calls and leads should exist before anyone resigns[1].
  • Separate four groups: active listings and pending deals, past clients, open leads, and personal calls.
  • Callers decide who they work with; the brokerage decides how calls are routed and how fast they are answered.
  • Use a two-sentence script that confirms the agent has moved on, offers help now and records the caller’s choice.

Departures are normal; the confusion is optional

Agents change firms all the time. The typical REALTOR has been with their current firm for a median of six years[1], and most are independent contractors who can move when it suits them[1]. Employment at offices of real estate agents and brokers also fell over the past year[2], which means some brokerages are absorbing departures faster than they are hiring.

Jobs at offices of real estate agents and brokersWage-and-salary employees, September of each year (2026 preliminary)
Jobs at offices of real estate agents and brokersComparison. September 2025: 380.4 thousand; September 2026: 372.7 thousand.380.4 thousandSeptember 2025September 2025: 380.4 thousand372.7 thousandSeptember 2026September 2026: 372.7 thousandJobs at offices of real estate agents and brokersComparison. September 2025: 380.4 thousand; September 2026: 372.7 thousand.380.4 thousandSeptember 2025September 2025: 380.4 thousand372.7 thousandSeptember 2026September 2026: 372.7 thousand

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
September 2025380.4 thousand
September 2026372.7 thousand

When an agent leaves without a plan, the phone keeps ringing for them. A seller whose listing is still under the brokerage calls the old agent’s cell and gets no answer. A buyer lead from last month’s open house calls the office and nobody knows the history. A past client calls to refer a friend and is told the agent is gone, with nothing else offered. Each of those calls is a client relationship the brokerage can either keep or lose in the first thirty seconds.

Who owns what: settle it in writing

The rules come from three places: state license law, your independent contractor or employment agreement, and the client’s own contract. In many states listing agreements and buyer agreements are made with the brokerage rather than the individual agent, but this varies, so have your broker of record and counsel confirm how it works for you. Put the result into the agreement every agent signs on day one.

  • Active listings and buyer agreements: who services them after a departure, and who decides whether the client is released.
  • Pending transactions: whether the departing agent finishes them and how compensation is split, set out in writing.
  • Past clients and the sphere: what the agent may take, what stays in the brokerage CRM and what neither side may do.
  • Phone numbers: whether calls to a brokerage-issued number stay with the brokerage, and how long it forwards.
  • Leads from brokerage-paid sources: whether open leads are reassigned, and when.

The client chooses. Whatever your agreement says about the brokerage’s rights, never tell a client they are not allowed to talk to their former agent, and never imply the agent did something wrong. Offer help, explain their options and record what they decide.

Routing rules for each kind of call

Once the policy is set, turn it into routing your front desk and phone system can follow without asking anyone.

Routing after a departure. Confirm every row against your own agreements and state rules.
Who is callingRoute toWhat to say firstRecord in CRM
Seller with an active listingBroker or assigned replacement agent, same dayConfirm the listing is still being marketed and who their contact is nowNew agent assigned; client informed date
Buyer or seller in a pending dealAgent handling the closing per the departure planGive the name and number of the person handling the closingClosing owner and next deadline
Past clientOffice manager or assigned agentThank them, explain the agent has moved on, offer helpCaller’s choice and any referral
Open lead from brokerage marketingNext agent in the lead rotationAsk what they were looking for and continueOriginal source and new owner
Caller asking for the agent’s new contact detailsFront deskShare only what the agent agreed in writing could be sharedRequest logged
Personal call for the agentFront deskTake a message for forwarding if agreed; otherwise say they no longer work hereNothing

Scripts for the first thirty seconds

The goal is to be honest, brief and useful. Do not leave a caller on hold while someone figures out what to say.

Active client: “Alex has moved to another brokerage. Your listing is still with us, and I’m the person looking after it now. I have your file open. What can I help with today?”

Past client or lead: “Alex is no longer with Example Realty. I’d be glad to help you myself, or if you’d like to reach Alex, I can tell you how. Which would you prefer?”

That second script does two things. It respects the caller’s right to choose and it gives the brokerage a fair chance to keep the relationship. Clients who are happy with an agent tend to use them again or recommend them[3], and among sellers who also bought, most hired the same agent for both sides[4]. Some callers will follow the agent. Those who do not should get a fast, competent answer from someone who already knows their history.

The departure checklist

  1. Day the notice arrives

    Confirm the departure date in writing. List every active listing, buyer agreement, pending transaction and open lead assigned to the agent. Agree who handles each pending deal.

  2. Within 48 hours

    Reassign active listings and inform each seller by phone, then in writing. Update listing agent details on the MLS and syndicated sites as your rules allow.

  3. Before the last day

    Change call routing for any brokerage-issued number. Update the website roster, email auto-reply and voicemail greeting with the name of the new contact.

  4. Last day

    Collect keys, lockbox access and showing service permissions. Remove the agent from shared inboxes and lead routing. Export a list of open leads with their notes.

  5. First week after

    Call every open lead and past client who reaches out, using the scripts above. Note each caller’s choice in the CRM.

  6. Day 30

    Review calls received for the agent, leads kept, leads lost and any client complaints. Adjust the policy for the next departure.

Lockbox and showing access deserve special care. A former agent should not keep codes or app access to listings they no longer represent; see lockbox access and showing security for key control steps.

Reassigning open leads fairly

Open leads are where disputes start. The departing agent may feel the leads are theirs because they worked them; the brokerage may feel the leads are its own because it paid for the marketing. Settle it with rules that everyone saw before the question came up.

  1. Sort open leads by source: brokerage-paid marketing, the agent’s own sphere, open houses on brokerage listings, and referrals.
  2. Apply the agreement to each source. A common pattern is that leads from brokerage marketing and listings stay with the brokerage, and the agent’s personal sphere goes with the agent.
  3. Reassign brokerage leads within a few days, while the history is fresh, to agents who have capacity rather than to whoever asks first.
  4. Give the new agent the full notes and the date of last contact, so the first call sounds like a continuation, not a cold call.
  5. If a lead asks for the departed agent by name, record it and follow the client-choice script instead of pushing them to stay.

Check one more thing before anyone calls: consent. If a lead only agreed to be contacted by a specific agent, or opted out of texts, that preference travels with the record. A reassigned lead is still a person who can say no, and the new agent should introduce themselves and the reason for the call in the first sentence.

Example: a top producer leaves in March

Example: a fictional agent with four active listings, two pendings and a pipeline of buyer leads gives notice two weeks before the spring market. The broker meets the agent the same day and they agree in writing that the agent will finish both pendings and that the four listings will be serviced by the team lead. Each seller gets a call from the broker within two days and is told they can stay, move with the agent if the listing agreement allows a release, or ask questions first. Three stay and one asks to follow the agent; the broker handles that request under the release terms. The agent’s brokerage number forwards to the team lead for ninety days with a new voicemail greeting. Every caller in the first month is asked whom they would like to work with, and the answers are logged.

No client was surprised and no call went into a dead voicemail box. That is the whole goal of the policy.

Prevent the next scramble

Most of the pain in a departure comes from information that lived only in the agent’s phone. Keep lead notes, client preferences and call history in a shared system, even a simple one. Fewer than half of REALTORS use a CRM[5], and in brokerages where agents keep records privately, the office learns about a client relationship only when the client calls asking for someone who has gone.

Using a brokerage business number on listings rather than personal cells also helps. Calls stay routable after any change, and the same setup makes day-to-day phone coverage during closings and showings easier. Pair it with a callback queue so calls for an agent who has left are returned as fast as any other.

Frequently asked questions

Can a brokerage keep a client when their agent leaves?

It depends on the client’s contract, your agreements with the agent and state law. In every case, the client should be told the facts and allowed to choose, and the choice should be recorded.

Should we give callers the departed agent’s new number?

Only if the agent agreed to it in writing. Otherwise, take the caller’s details and offer to pass on the message, or offer to help them directly.

How long should a departed agent’s number forward?

Long enough to catch past clients and late leads, often several months, with a greeting that names the new contact. Decide the period in the agent agreement.

Who handles a pending deal when the agent leaves?

Whoever your departure agreement names, often the departing agent for deals close to closing. Put the decision and any compensation split in writing before the last day.

References

  1. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Current Employment Statistics series CES5553120001: Offices of real estate agents and brokers, all employees (thousands, SA) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (2026 REALTORS® Technology Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo