Seller Leads and Listings

Handling Sellers Who Want Too Much for Their Home

Find where a seller's number comes from, answer it with market data, agree a pricing test with review dates, and know when to walk away.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why sellers anchor high
  2. Diagnose the anchor first
  3. Bring today's market, not last year's
  4. Scripts for the most common situations
  5. Explain what overpricing costs
  6. If you take the listing: agree a pricing test
  7. Let buyers' feedback do some of the talking
  8. Put your advice in writing
  9. Worked example
  10. When to walk away
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Seller Leads and Listings: Handling Sellers Who Want Too Much for Their HomeArticle coverSELLER LEADS AND LISTINGSHandling Sellers WhoWant Too Much for TheirHomeAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsSeller Leads and Listings: Handling Sellers Who Want Too Much for Their HomeArticle coverSELLER LEADS AND LISTINGSHandling Sellers WhoWant Too Much forTheir HomeAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Ask where the seller's number came from before arguing with it; the source shapes the response.
  • Use current market data, such as falling pending sales, to show why yesterday's prices may not hold[1].
  • If you take an ambitious price, agree review dates and triggers in writing before launch.
  • Price reductions cluster in the fall, so overpricing late in the year carries extra risk[2].

Why sellers anchor high

Few sellers pick a number at random. It usually comes from somewhere: a neighbor's sale, an online estimate, what a friend's agent said, what they need to net to buy their next home, or a memory of the market at its peak. National listing prices peaked at a median of $440,000 in May 2025, according to Realtor.com[3], and many owners still remember the headlines from that period.

Arguing with the number directly rarely works. It feels like an attack on the seller's home and judgment. A better approach is to find out where it came from, respect the reasoning, and then put the evidence beside it so the seller can see the gap for themselves.

Emotion plays a part too. Owners value the years they spent in a home, the work they put into it and the memories attached to rooms a buyer will see only as square footage. Acknowledge that openly. Saying “I can see how much care has gone into this house” costs nothing and makes the pricing conversation that follows feel like advice rather than criticism.

Diagnose the anchor first

Common sources of high price expectations and how to address each.
Where the number came fromWhat to askHow to respond
A neighbor's saleWhich house, and when did it sell?Compare size, condition, updates and timing honestly, with photos
An online estimateWhich site, and what range did it show?Explain that automated estimates cannot see condition or updates; show your adjusted comps
Another agent's figureDid they show you comparable sales?Ask to see the evidence; compare it with yours without criticizing the agent
What they need to netWhat is the number for, and is it fixed?Show a net sheet and discuss options for the next purchase
What they paid plus upgradesWhich upgrades, and when?Explain the difference between cost and what buyers pay for
Peak-market memoriesWhen did you last look at sales nearby?Show the trend in local sales since then

Ask the question neutrally: “That's helpful. Can you tell me how you arrived at that number?” Then listen to the end. Sellers often reveal the real constraint, such as a down payment target, which opens a more useful conversation than price alone.

Bring today's market, not last year's

The market cooled through the second half of 2026. NAR reported pending home sales fell 7.3% from August to September and 11.3% from a year earlier[4]. Zillow's preliminary data showed existing-home sales down 8.7% year over year in October, with newly pending listings down 16.8%, the biggest drop since August 2023[1].

Year-over-year decline in US home sales activity, October 2026Zillow October 2026 market report; values are declines
Year-over-year decline in US home sales activity, October 2026Bar chart. Decline in newly pending listings: 16.8%; Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary): 8.7%.Decline in newly pending listingsDecline in newly pending listings: 16.8%16.8%Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary)Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary): 8.7%8.7%Year-over-year decline in US home sales activity, October 2026Bar chart. Decline in newly pending listings: 16.8%; Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary): 8.7%.Decline in newly pending listingsDecline in newly pending listings: 16.8%16.8%Decline in existing-home sales(preliminary)Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary): 8.7%8.7%

Source: Zillow Research, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Decline in newly pending listings16.8%
Decline in existing-home sales (preliminary)8.7%

Prices have not collapsed: the national median existing-home price was $417,500 in September 2026, up 1.3% year over year[5]. But fewer buyers are signing contracts, which means less competition for overpriced homes and more leverage for buyers. Show the local version of these numbers: pending sales, days on market and the share of listings with price cuts in the seller's area.

Scripts for the most common situations

When the number comes from a neighbor's sale:

“That sale is a great reference point. Let's look at it side by side with yours. It had the renovated kitchen and the extra bathroom, and it sold in the spring when buyer demand peaks. After adjusting for those, here's where it lands for your home. Does that comparison seem fair to you?”

When the seller needs a certain net figure:

“Let's work back from the number you need. At the price the evidence supports, here's your estimated net. The gap is this much. We can look at ways to close it, such as timing, a few targeted repairs or negotiating terms on your next purchase, but pricing above the market usually costs more than it gains.”

When another agent quoted higher:

“I'd encourage you to ask them for the sales that support it. If they have evidence I've missed, I'd like to see it too. If not, a higher list price doesn't create a higher sale price. Buyers and appraisers will look at the same sales we're looking at.”

Explain what overpricing costs

  • Fewer showings in the first weeks, when a new listing gets the most attention.
  • Buyers using the home to make competing listings look like better value.
  • Longer days on market, which buyers read as a sign something is wrong.
  • Price reductions that arrive later, often in a weaker season.
  • Appraisal risk if a buyer does agree to a high price.

Timing compounds the risk. Realtor.com's seasonal research shows price reductions peak in the fall, while late winter and spring see the lowest share of cuts[2]. A home that launches high in October may face its first reduction in the slowest part of the year. Market pace matters too: inventory stood at a 4.8-month supply in September 2026[6], so buyers have alternatives.

If you take the listing: agree a pricing test

Sometimes the right answer is to list at the seller's number, with a written plan. That respects their choice and protects both of you.

  1. Agree the starting price and the evidence

    Record your recommended range and the seller's chosen price in writing, with the comps attached.

  2. Set review dates

    For example, after the first two weekends and again after four weeks on the market.

  3. Define the triggers

    Agree what would prompt a change: fewer showings than similar listings, consistent price feedback, or no offers by the second review.

  4. Agree the size of any change

    Decide in advance how large a reduction would be, so it is meaningful when it happens.

  5. Report honestly

    Send weekly numbers on views, showings and feedback, and quote buyer agents' comments accurately.

Let buyers' feedback do some of the talking

Once a home is on the market, the most persuasive evidence comes from buyers, not from you. Collect feedback after every showing with the same three questions, so the answers can be compared week to week: what did the buyer like, what concerned them, and how did the price compare with other homes they have seen?

Share the answers with the seller exactly as given, including the positive ones. A seller who hears from six different buyer agents that the home is priced above two competing listings is hearing the market, not their agent's opinion. Pair the feedback with numbers: online views and saves compared with similar listings, showings booked, second showings and disclosure requests. When the numbers and the comments point the same way, the conversation at the review date is short.

Put your advice in writing

Whatever the seller decides, send a short email after the appointment that records your recommended range, the evidence behind it and the price they chose. Attach the CMA. If you agreed a pricing test, include the review dates, triggers and planned reduction.

This is not about protecting yourself against the seller. It gives both of you a shared reference point when emotions run higher a few weeks later, and it shows the seller you took their decision seriously enough to plan around it.

Worked example

Example: a fictional seller insists on $499,000 because a neighbor sold for $505,000 in April. The agent's CMA supports $460,000 to $475,000; the neighbor's home was larger and fully renovated. The seller agrees to list at $489,000 with review dates after two and four weeks, and a trigger of fewer than eight showings by the first review. After two weekends there are five showings, and three buyer agents cite price. The agreed reduction to $474,000 happens on schedule, without a fight, and the home goes under contract within three weeks.

When to walk away

Not every overpriced listing is worth taking. Consider declining politely when:

  • The seller will not agree to any review dates or triggers.
  • The price is far beyond any evidence and the seller dismisses all data.
  • The seller expects you to pay for extensive marketing with little chance of a sale.
  • Your brokerage's reputation in the area would suffer from a stale listing.

“I want to be honest with you. At that price, I don't believe I can sell your home, and I don't want to take your time or mine on a plan I don't think will work. If anything changes, I'd be glad to talk again.”

Send a short note afterwards with your CMA and the offer to help later. Sellers who test the market with another agent often call back.

Frequently asked questions

How do you tell a seller their price is too high?

Ask where their number came from, respect the reasoning, then show adjusted comparable sales, current competition and market trends side by side so they can see the gap themselves.

Should I take an overpriced listing?

Only with a written plan: agreed review dates, triggers for a price change and the size of any reduction. Without those, an overpriced listing often goes stale.

What happens when a home is overpriced?

It usually gets fewer showings in its most important first weeks, sits longer, helps competing listings look better and often needs a price reduction later, sometimes in a weaker season.

Are online home value estimates accurate?

They are a starting point. Automated estimates cannot see condition, updates or layout, so a CMA based on adjusted comparable sales is usually more reliable for setting a list price.

References

  1. Zillow Research (2026). Newly Pending Listings Fell 17% In October (Zillow October 2026 Market Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Realtor.com Economic Research (2026). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Realtor.com Economic Research (2025). The Best Time To List a Home: The Week of April 12-18 (2026 analysis) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Pending Home Sales Decreased 7.3% in September (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo