Key takeaways
- Most sellers contact only one agent, so the first impression often decides the listing[1].
- Sellers find agents online and by referral in similar measure; both channels need attention[2].
- Trustworthiness and responsiveness top sellers' criteria, ahead of reputation and local knowledge[3][4].
- Sellers increasingly use AI to learn the process and many suspect their agent uses it too, so be open about your tools[5].
Most sellers talk to one agent
The idea that sellers interview three agents and pick the best presentation does not match how most of them behave. In Zillow's 2026 seller research, 67% of agent-using sellers contacted only one agent, up from 62% in 2025, and the median seller contacted just one[1]. Only 1% contacted five or more[6].
For agents, that changes where the competition happens. The contest is usually decided before any listing appointment: in whether the seller thinks of you first, finds you when they search and gets a fast, trustworthy response when they reach out. The appointment then confirms or undoes that first impression.
Where sellers find their agent
Sellers who used an agent most often first found them online, 35% in total, including 20% on a real estate website or app; 30% found their agent by referral[2]. Those two routes overlap more than they seem. A seller given your name by a friend will usually look you up before calling, and a seller who finds you online will often ask someone they know whether you are any good.
- Referral sellers check your reviews, website and recent sales before they call. Make sure what they find matches what their friend said.
- Online sellers judge you on your profile, your listings' photos and how quickly you reply. Your response time is part of your marketing.
- Both groups want proof you know their area: recent sales nearby, neighborhood knowledge and a clear explanation of the market.
What sellers weigh most
Two qualities top the list. 80% of agent-using sellers rate trustworthiness as very or extremely important, and 77% say the same about the agent's initial impression of responsiveness[3]. Close behind, 75% value market or neighborhood knowledge and 74% a positive reputation in the community[4].
Notice what is missing from the top: flashy marketing or sales volume on its own. Sellers care about those, but they are judging something more basic first: will this person tell me the truth, and will they pick up the phone?
Responsiveness is the first test
For most sellers, responsiveness is not judged at the appointment. It is judged by how the first call, text or form is handled. A seller who calls from a sign on a Saturday afternoon and reaches voicemail may simply call the next name. Practical habits that pass the test:
- Reply to new seller inquiries within minutes during working hours, and set a clear expectation for evenings and weekends.
- Return missed calls personally the same day, with a specific reason for calling back rather than a generic “just following up.”
- Use a consistent first message that confirms the address, asks one useful question and offers two times to talk.
- Make sure calls to your office or sign number are answered after hours, by a person or a service, with a real next step booked.
An SI Employee such as Ava can answer those after-hours seller calls, ask for the address, timeline and plans, and book a listing consultation in your calendar, so the seller's first impression is a prompt, useful answer rather than a voicemail.
Trust signals sellers check
| Signal | How sellers check it | What agents can do |
|---|---|---|
| Honesty about price | Compare your range with online estimates and other opinions | Show the comps behind your range; never inflate to win |
| Reviews | Read reviews on search engines and portals | Ask real clients for reviews; never fake or incentivize them |
| Local results | Look at your recent sales and active listings | Keep your profile and website current and specific |
| Clear fees | Ask what you charge and what it covers | Explain fees and choices plainly, with a net sheet |
| Follow-through | Notice whether you do what you said | Send what you promised, when you promised |
Reviews deserve particular care. The FTC's 2024 rule bans fake reviews and testimonials, including AI-generated ones[7]. Real reviews, answered courteously when they are critical, build more trust than a perfect but thin record.
What confirms the choice at the appointment
If most sellers meet only one agent, the appointment is less a competition and more a confirmation. The seller arrives half-decided and is looking for reasons to feel sure, or for warning signs. The things that tend to confirm the choice are simple and visible:
- You arrive on time, having clearly researched the home and the street.
- You ask about their goals before talking about yourself, and repeat back what you heard.
- Your price range comes with evidence they can follow, even if it is lower than they hoped.
- You explain fees, timelines and what you will do each week without being asked twice.
- You say what you do not know, and promise a written answer by a specific time.
The warning signs are the reverse: a price that sounds too good, vague answers about fees, a long talk about awards, and slow follow-up after the meeting. Sellers who see those signs are the ones who go looking for a second agent.
Why some sellers choose no agent at all
A small group of sellers go it alone. NAR's 2026 Profile put for-sale-by-owner sales at a historic low of 5% of sellers, and 62% of those FSBO sellers already knew their buyer[8]. In other words, most owners who skip an agent do so because a buyer is already in hand, often a relative, tenant or neighbor.
For agents, that suggests a respectful approach to FSBO owners: ask whether they already have a buyer. If they do, offer limited help, such as a contract review referral or a pricing check, where your brokerage allows it. If they do not, the conversation about reaching buyers and managing the transaction is far more relevant to them.
Repeat and referral business
The best predictor of being chosen next time is being chosen last time. 81% of seller-buyers who used an agent hired the same agent to sell their old home and buy their new one, up from 73% in 2025[9]. And because the median seller thinks seriously about selling for three to four months before listing[10], past clients and their friends are often deciding long before they call.
Stay in touch with past clients in ways that are useful: an annual home value review, a note when a nearby home sells, and help finding contractors. When they start thinking about selling, you want to be the obvious first call, not one of several names.
Sellers, AI and transparency
Sellers are using AI themselves. Zillow found 84% of sellers use AI, and about two-thirds of AI-using sellers used it during their sale, mostly to learn the process and get market insights[11]. Among sellers who hired an agent, 21% knew and 36% suspected their agent was using AI tools[5].
That means sellers arrive better informed and more curious about how you work. Be open: explain which tools help you write listing drafts, answer calls or analyze comps, and that you check everything before it reaches them. Transparency about tools is part of the trustworthiness sellers rank so highly.
A self-audit: would a seller choose you?
Search yourself
Look up your name and your team as a seller would. Check that reviews, profiles and recent sales are current and consistent.
Test your response
Have a colleague call your sign number on a weekend evening and fill in your valuation form. Time the response and judge its quality.
Review your price honesty
Compare your last ten list price recommendations with sale prices. Were you close? Sellers notice.
Check your past-client touch points
Count how many past clients heard something useful from you in the last year.
Ask recent sellers
Ask a few recent clients why they chose you and what nearly made them choose someone else. Act on the answers.
Example: a fictional agent runs this audit and finds her sign calls go to voicemail after 6 p.m., and her online profile still lists sales from three years ago. She updates the profile with recent sales, arranges evening call coverage and starts an annual value review for past clients. The changes cost little and address the two things sellers rank highest.
Frequently asked questions
How many agents do sellers interview?
Fewer than many agents assume. In Zillow's 2026 research, 67% of agent-using sellers contacted only one agent, and only 1% contacted five or more.
How do sellers find a listing agent?
Most often online, including real estate websites and apps, or by referral from someone they know. Many do both: they hear a name and then look the agent up.
What do sellers look for in a listing agent?
Trustworthiness and a responsive first impression rank highest, followed closely by market or neighborhood knowledge and a positive reputation in the community.
Do sellers mind agents using AI?
Many sellers use AI themselves and many suspect their agent does. Being open about which tools you use and how you check their output supports the trust sellers value most.
References
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑