Lead Response and Follow-Up

How to Handle Leads From Realtor.com and Homes.com

Portal leads arrive under different programs: listing inquiries, paid buyer leads and pre-screened referrals. How to follow up each one and keep them.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The source label hides the real difference
  2. Three arrangements, three first moves
  3. The first 15 minutes for any portal inquiry
  4. Why the first reply carries so much weight
  5. Inquiries on your own listings
  6. Pre-screened referrals: do not start from zero
  7. When the first call fails
  8. When the home they asked about is gone
  9. Get leads out of the portal inbox
  10. Questions to ask before you renew a portal program
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Lead Response and Follow-Up: How to Handle Leads From Realtor.com and Homes.comArticle coverLEAD RESPONSE AND FOLLOW-UPHow to Handle LeadsFrom Realtor.com andHomes.comAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsLead Response and Follow-Up: How to Handle Leads From Realtor.com and Homes.comArticle coverLEAD RESPONSE AND FOLLOW-UPHow to Handle LeadsFrom Realtor.com andHomes.comAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Find out which program each portal lead came through before you plan the follow-up; a listing inquiry, a paid lead and a pre-screened referral expect different first calls.
  • Homes.com describes its model as showing only the listing agent on each home for sale, so its inquiries usually reach you through your own listings[1].
  • One in five agent-using sellers first found their agent on a real estate website or app, and most contact only one agent, so the first reply often decides it[2].
  • A buyer must sign a written agreement before touring with you, so plan that conversation into the first showing request[3].

The source label hides the real difference

Most CRMs tag these leads simply as “Realtor.com” or “Homes.com”. That label tells you where the consumer clicked, but not how the lead reached you, what the consumer was promised or what you owe anyone if the deal closes. Those details decide what your first call should sound like.

Realtor.com runs more than one lead program for agents, and the terms that matter (who receives the inquiry, whether a person screened it by phone first and whether a fee is due at closing) are set in your own agreement. Homes.com describes its approach as “your listing, your lead”: the company says it presents the listing agent, and only the listing agent, on any home for sale on its site[1]. Before changing your follow-up, open each agreement and write one line per program on what the consumer has already experienced.

Three arrangements, three first moves

Portal lead arrangements and how the first conversation should differ
ArrangementHow it reaches youWhat the consumer expectsYour first move
Inquiry on your own listingBuyer contacts the listing agent from the listing pageFacts about that home and a chance to see itAnswer the question about the home, then offer a showing
Paid buyer leadYou pay for placement in an area and receive inquiriesA quick reply from whoever answersRespond within minutes and confirm the home and timing
Pre-screened referralA program team speaks to the consumer, then connects or introduces youAn agent who already knows their situationRefer to what they told the program and skip repeat questions

If you are unsure which arrangement a lead belongs to, ask your portal representative to show you how leads are labelled in the notification email. Then set up a CRM rule so each lead is tagged by arrangement as well as by portal.

The first 15 minutes for any portal inquiry

  1. Read the inquiry properly

    Note the exact property, the question asked and anything the consumer typed. Half of a good first reply is showing you read it.

  2. Check the listing status

    If the home went under contract, have two similar active homes ready before you call. Buyers who ask about a home that is no longer available still want to move.

  3. Call, then text

    Call first. If there is no answer, text within a minute: your name, the property and one question about their timing.

  4. Answer the question they asked

    If they asked about HOA fees or school boundaries, answer it, or say exactly when you will have the answer. Do not open with a request for a meeting.

  5. Log and set the next step

    Record the arrangement tag, the conversation and a dated next step in your CRM before you pick up the next lead.

Why the first reply carries so much weight

In Zillow’s 2026 seller survey, 35% of sellers who used an agent first found that agent online, including 20% on a real estate website or app, and 30% found their agent through a referral[2]. The same survey found the median seller contacted only one agent, and 67% of agent-using sellers contacted just one[2]. For a meaningful share of clients, the portal inquiry is the only contact they will make. If that contact goes unanswered for a day, there may not be a second chance.

Buyers lean on agents just as heavily. In NAR’s 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, 90% of buyers used an agent or broker, the highest share in four decades[4]. A portal lead is not someone deciding whether to use an agent; it is someone deciding which one.

Where agent-using sellers first found their agent, 2026“Other online sources” and “All other ways” are worked out from the published totals (35% online, 20% on a real estate website or app, 30% referral)
Where agent-using sellers first found their agent, 2026Stacked bar chart. Real estate website or app: 20%; Other online sources: 15%; Referral: 30%; All other ways: 35%.Real estate website or app: 20% (20%)Other online sources: 15% (15%)Referral: 30% (30%)All other ways: 35% (35%)Where agent-using sellers first found their agent, 2026Stacked bar chart. Real estate website or app: 20%; Other online sources: 15%; Referral: 30%; All other ways: 35%.Real estate website or app: 20% (20%)Other online sources: 15% (15%)Referral: 30% (30%)All other ways: 35% (35%)
  • Real estate website or app 20%
  • Other online sources 15%
  • Referral 30%
  • All other ways 35%

Source: Zillow Research, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Real estate website or app20%
Other online sources15%
Referral30%
All other ways35%

Inquiries on your own listings

A buyer who asks about your listing may not have an agent, and that buyer is valuable to you. Treat these calls with care. Answer factual questions about the home, offer to arrange a showing and be clear about who you represent. Your brokerage’s policy on representing both sides, and your state’s disclosure rules, apply before any substantive advice.

Since August 2024, buyers working with a REALTOR must sign a written agreement before touring a home with that agent, in person or virtually; attending an open house alone or asking about services does not require one[3]. Build that into your script: “I’d be glad to show it to you. Before a private tour I’ll go over a short written agreement with you, which explains how I work and how I’m paid. It takes about ten minutes.”

Pre-screened referrals: do not start from zero

When a program team has already spoken with the consumer, the worst thing you can do is ask the same five questions again. Read the notes, then open with them: “I understand you’re looking for a three-bedroom near the river and hoping to move by spring.” Ask only what is missing.

  • Accept or decline the lead quickly so it is not passed on.
  • Update the program’s status fields on the schedule your agreement sets, and note the date of each update in your CRM.
  • Keep a copy of the referral terms with the lead record so the fee due at closing is not a surprise to your transaction coordinator.

A strong opening for a pre-screened referral sounds like this: “Hi Alex, this is Sam with Example Realty. The team you spoke with this morning passed on that you’re hoping to buy a two-bedroom condo downtown before your lease ends in March. I’ve pulled three that fit. Would it help to walk through them by phone tonight or tomorrow at lunch?” It proves you listened before you asked for anything.

When the first call fails

Most portal leads do not answer the first call. A short, varied cadence over a week gives you several fair chances without becoming a nuisance:

  • Day 1: call, text and email, each referring to the specific home.
  • Day 2: call at a different time of day and leave a voicemail that mentions one new detail about the home.
  • Day 4: text two similar homes and ask whether either is worth seeing.
  • Day 7: email a short note asking whether they would like updates or would rather not hear from you.

After day 7, move the lead into a monthly nurture plan. A buyer who was not ready this week may be ready after their lease renewal or a rate change, and a monthly note keeps your name in front of them when that happens.

When the home they asked about is gone

Portal listings sometimes lag behind the MLS, so you will regularly get inquiries on homes that are already under contract. Treat that as an opening, not a dead end. Say what happened, explain what it tells you about the market for that kind of home and offer two alternatives that match what they asked about. Ask what drew them to the home: the yard, the school, the price. Their answer gives you a better saved search than any portal filter.

Get leads out of the portal inbox

Portal dashboards are built to make you check the portal. Your follow-up should live in one system. Only 46% of REALTORS say they use a CRM[5], which means many portal leads are being managed from email notifications and phone notes. Forward every portal notification into your CRM automatically, tag it by portal and arrangement, and run your follow-up plan from there.

Example: an agent receives inquiries from two portals and her own website. She sets a forwarding rule for each portal’s notification address, maps the fields into her CRM and adds a tag for arrangement. Her weekly review now shows reply time and appointments by source in one view instead of three inboxes.

Questions to ask before you renew a portal program

  1. How are leads labelled, and can the notification include the arrangement type?
  2. Are leads shared with other agents, or sent only to you?
  3. What status updates does the program require, and how often?
  4. Is any fee due at closing, and how is it calculated and invoiced?
  5. Can you see your own response time as the program measures it?

Write the answers into the same note you created for each program. They also tell you whether a slow month is a lead problem or a follow-up problem.

Frequently asked questions

Are Homes.com leads exclusive to the listing agent?

Homes.com says it presents only the listing agent on any home for sale on its site and describes listing leads as belonging to that agent. Check your own membership terms for the details that apply to you.

Do I need a buyer agreement before showing a portal lead a home?

Yes, if you are a REALTOR touring with the buyer. Since August 2024 a written agreement is required before touring a home with an agent, in person or virtually. An open house visited alone does not require one.

How fast should I respond to a Realtor.com or Homes.com inquiry?

Within minutes. Most sellers contact only one agent, and buyers on portals are often comparing options, so a same-day reply can already be too late.

Should I treat a referral-fee lead differently from a paid lead?

Yes. A pre-screened referral has already told someone about their situation, so open with what you know, ask only what is missing and keep the program’s status updates current.

References

  1. HousingWire (2024). Your listing, your lead: The principle driving Homes.com’s agent-friendly portal (sponsored article by Homes.com) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (2026 REALTORS® Technology Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo