Key takeaways
- Zillow reports the largest audience, Realtor.com and the Homes.com Network follow, but each measures traffic differently[1][2][3].
- Compare portals on lead model, exclusivity, contract terms and ZIP-level volume, not on national traffic.
- Buyers and sellers still overwhelmingly use agents, so portals are a source of introductions, not a replacement for you[4].
- Run a 90-day test with your own tracking before you commit budget to any portal.
The three portals at a glance
Most US agents who buy online leads end up comparing the same three names. Each is owned by a public company that reports audience numbers in its earnings releases, which gives agents a better starting point than sales decks. The table pulls those figures together with how each company measures them. The audience numbers come from different quarters and methods, so read the next section before you rank them.
| Portal | Reported audience | How it is measured | What it sells agents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zillow | 215 million average monthly unique users, Q3 2026[1] | Company count of app and site users; separately, 77% of category unique visitors per Comscore[1] | Premier Agent connections under market-based or pay-at-close terms |
| Realtor.com | 66 million average monthly unique users, quarter to September 30, 2026[2] | Company count of web and mobile users; 263 million monthly average visits per Comscore[2] | Buyer and seller lead products; ask a rep for current options in your ZIP codes |
| Homes.com Network | 115 million average monthly unique visitors, Q3 2025[3] | Google Analytics, network includes Homes.com, the Apartments Network and the Land Network[3] | Paid agent memberships; over 26,000 Members reported in October 2025[3] |
The direction of travel matters too. Zillow's users fell 3% year over year in the third quarter of 2026[1]. Realtor.com's fell 8% and its lead volumes fell 11%, which the company attributed mainly to broader economic trends and a focus on higher-quality leads[2]. CoStar said it added 7,000 Homes.com Members in the third quarter of 2025 alone[3]. A shrinking audience does not automatically mean worse leads, and a growing membership does not mean more leads for each member.
Why the traffic numbers don't line up
Agents often quote these figures as if they were measured the same way. They are not. Three differences matter when you compare them.
- Method: Zillow and Realtor.com report their own counts of unique users, while CoStar reports Google Analytics figures for the Homes.com Network.
- Scope: the Homes.com Network figure includes rental and land sites, so it is not the number of people searching homes for sale.
- Timing: the latest figures available in this comparison cover different quarters, and housing traffic is seasonal.
- Unique users versus visits: one buyer can visit many times; a visit count can rise while the number of people falls.
The national number tells you little about your market. What you need is the number of buyer inquiries in your ZIP codes and price bands, the share of those you would receive, and the cost. Ask every portal for that in writing before you sign.
Portals introduce clients; agents still close them
Portals have not replaced agents. NAR's 2026 Profile found that 90% of buyers used a real estate agent or broker, the highest share in four decades[4]. On the seller side, Zillow's 2026 survey found that 20% of agent-using sellers first found their agent on a real estate website or app[5]. That is a meaningful channel, but smaller than referrals and general online search combined.
Portals also matter in listing appointments. In the same survey, 74% of sellers said it was very or extremely important that their listing reaches the largest possible audience[5]. Be ready to explain where your listings appear, how quickly, and how buyer inquiries from each portal reach you.
What sellers judge you on
Whatever portal brings the first contact, the client decides on you. When Zillow asked agent-using sellers what mattered, trustworthiness, responsiveness, neighborhood knowledge and community reputation all scored above 70% as very or extremely important[5].
Use that list to judge a portal's product. Does it let you respond fast, from your own number? Does it show your reviews and your name, or the portal's brand? Does it let you show local knowledge on your profile? A product that hides you behind the portal brand makes it harder to earn trust in the first call.
Criteria for comparing portal offers
Lead model
Do you pay up front for advertising, per lead, by membership or a fee at closing? Each moves risk between you and the portal.
Exclusivity
Is each inquiry sent only to you, to a few agents, or to whoever answers first? Shared leads need faster response and cost more effort per deal.
Routing and speed
Can leads ring your phone instantly, reach your CRM within a minute and be reassigned if the first agent misses them?
Contract terms
Minimum term, cancellation notice, automatic renewals and how long any closing fee applies after first contact.
Listing attribution
When a buyer contacts the portal about your listing, who receives the inquiry: you, a paying agent or both?
Reporting
Can you see every inquiry, its source listing, response time and outcome, and export it?
Which portal fits which agent
There is no single winner. The right choice depends on your stage, your cash flow and how much follow-up capacity you have. These patterns are a starting point for the conversation with your broker or team leader.
- Solo agents with limited cash: favor models where you pay only when a deal closes or where the commitment is short, and keep the ZIP footprint small.
- Teams with an inside sales agent or a lead manager: fixed advertising can cost less per closing because the team can work every inquiry hard for months.
- Listing-heavy agents: focus on how buyer inquiries about your own listings are routed, and how your name and photo appear on those listings.
- Agents in luxury or rural markets: ask for inquiry counts in your exact price band and area, because national traffic says little about thin markets.
- Brokerages: negotiate at the office level, set one follow-up standard and decide who owns the contact if an agent leaves.
Write down the questions you want answered before any sales call: expected inquiries per month in your ZIP codes, the share you would receive, whether inquiries are exclusive, the minimum term, renewal and cancellation terms, and how data reaches your CRM. Ask each portal the same questions so the answers are comparable, and keep the written replies with your test results.
Run a 90-day portal test
Treat a portal like any new source. Pick one, define success before you start and keep the test long enough for a few tours and offers to happen.
- Set a fixed budget and a single ZIP group for the test.
- Create a unique source tag in your CRM and, if possible, a dedicated tracking number.
- Record response time, contact rate, signed buyer agreements, tours and offers for every lead.
- At day 90, project closings from offers in progress and compare cost per signed agreement with your other sources.
- Keep, renegotiate or cancel; do not let the contract auto-renew without this review.
Example: a two-agent team tests one portal in three ZIP codes. Over 90 days it receives 54 inquiries, reaches 38, signs 9 buyer agreements and has 3 offers accepted. It compares that with its open houses over the same period, which produced 6 agreements at lower cost but needed every Saturday. The team keeps the portal for weekday leads and open houses for weekends.
Common mistakes when choosing a portal
- Buying more ZIP codes than you can serve well. Leads in an area you don't know convert worse and cost the same.
- Judging after three weeks. Buyer timelines run for months; early numbers mostly measure luck.
- Ignoring nights and weekends. Inquiries keep arriving when you are at showings or asleep, and the first agent to reply usually gets the conversation.
- Forgetting the written buyer agreement. Plan how you will explain it on the first call so leads don't stall before the first tour.
- Letting each agent use a different follow-up plan. A shared plan is the only way to compare agents fairly.
Before you sign with any portal, read the detailed guide to Zillow's agent programs and the playbook for handling Realtor.com and Homes.com leads.
Build an audience you own as well
Portal spend works best next to channels you control: a Google Business Profile with steady reviews, neighborhood pages on your own site and a database you contact every month. Those channels keep producing after a portal contract ends, and they make every portal lead easier to convert because the buyer can find proof of your work in one search.
Frequently asked questions
Which portal has the most traffic?
Zillow reports the largest audience of the three, at 215 million average monthly unique users in the third quarter of 2026. Realtor.com and CoStar measure their audiences differently, so compare inquiry volume in your own ZIP codes before deciding.
Is Homes.com better for listing agents?
It depends on how inquiries on your listings are routed and what a membership includes in your area. Ask for a written explanation of who receives buyer inquiries on your listings and test it for at least 90 days.
Should a new agent pay for portal leads?
Only if you can respond within minutes and follow up for months. Many new agents do better learning conversion on open houses and their sphere first, then adding a portal.
Can I use more than one portal at once?
Yes, but tag each source separately and compare cost per signed buyer agreement. Running several at once without tracking makes it impossible to tell which one pays.
References
Zillow Group, Inc. (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing) (2026). Zillow Group third-quarter 2026 results (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) (opens in a new tab) ↑
News Corp (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing) (2026). News Corporation reports first quarter results for fiscal 2027 (Form 8-K exhibit) (opens in a new tab) ↑
CoStar Group, Inc. (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing) (2025). CoStar Group third quarter 2025 earnings press release (Form 8-K exhibit) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Top 10 Takeaways from NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑