Key takeaways
- Zillow sells agent leads two ways: market-based advertising shared by ZIP code, and a pay-for-performance model where you pay when a deal closes[1].
- The pay-at-close fee can apply to closings that happen long after the first contact, so read the term in your agreement[1].
- Most sellers contact only one agent, so the program only pays off for agents who answer and follow up fast[2].
- Run the numbers with your own conversion rate and average commission before you join or renew.
What Premier Agent is today
Premier Agent is Zillow's paid program for agents and teams. In its quarterly filing for the period ending September 30, 2026, Zillow describes Premier Agent advertising products as the delivery of validated customer connections, or leads, and lists its agent offerings as Zillow Preferred, Premier Agent market-based pricing and Zillow Showcase[1]. Many agents still call the pay-at-close model Flex; in the filing that pay-for-performance offering appears under the Zillow Preferred name. Confirm the current program name and terms for your market directly with Zillow, because they change.
215 million
average monthly unique users of Zillow's apps and sites in the third quarter of 2026[3]
The audience behind those leads is large. Zillow reported 215 million average monthly unique users in the third quarter of 2026, down 3% from a year earlier, and 2.3 billion visits; it also said it drew 77% of average monthly unique visitors in the real estate category, according to Comscore[3]. Large traffic does not mean cheap or easy deals. It means many buyers will reach you through someone else's brand, and your job is to turn that first contact into a relationship with you.
The two ways to pay
The two pricing models put risk in different places. Under market-based pricing, Zillow distributes connections to Premier Agent partners in proportion to their share of voice, meaning a partner's share of total advertising purchased in a particular ZIP code[1]. Under the pay-for-performance model, partners pay a performance advertising fee when a real estate transaction closes with one of the leads, generally within two years[1].
| Question | Market-based pricing | Pay-for-performance (Flex, Zillow Preferred) |
|---|---|---|
| When do you pay? | Up front, for advertising in chosen ZIP codes | When a transaction with a Zillow lead closes |
| What decides your lead share? | Your share of total advertising in each ZIP | Program rules and your performance standing |
| Who carries the risk of no closing? | You | Mostly Zillow |
| What hurts margin most? | Slow follow-up on paid leads | A large fee on every closed deal |
| How long does the obligation last? | Your advertising term | The fee window in your agreement |
| Best fit | Agents with steady cash flow and strong conversion | Teams that want no upfront cost and can staff fast response |
Neither model is better in general. Market-based pricing rewards agents who convert well, because the cost is fixed whether or not deals close. Pay-at-close rewards agents who are unsure of their conversion rate or cannot spare cash up front, at the price of giving up a share of every deal the program touches.
What a connection becomes
A connection is usually a buyer who asked to tour a home or talk to an agent about one. Since August 2024, buyers working with a REALTOR are asked to sign a written agreement before touring a home with that agent, in person or virtually, while visiting an open house alone or asking about services does not require one[4]. Compensation in that agreement must be clearly defined, for example a flat fee or a percentage, not open-ended or a range[4].
That means the first conversation has two jobs: help with the home they asked about, and explain how working together will be set up before the tour. Agents who skip the second part lose the lead at the door or create confusion later.
Script: “Happy to show you 22 Birch on Saturday. Before any tour I ask buyers to sign a short written agreement that spells out what I do and how I’m paid. It takes five minutes and you can ask me anything about it. Want me to send it now so we can lock in a time?”
Speed decides who gets the client
Paid connections reward the agent who responds first and best. Zillow's 2026 seller survey offers a useful parallel: 67% of agent-using sellers contacted only one agent, up from 62% a year earlier[2], and only 1% contacted five or more[2]. The same survey found that 77% of those sellers rated an agent's first impression of responsiveness as very or extremely important[2].
Source: Zillow Research, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2025 survey | 62% |
| 2026 survey | 67% |
Phone habits make speed harder. Pew found that 80% of Americans generally don't answer calls from unknown numbers[5], so a single call is not a response plan. Call, leave a short voicemail, and send a text that names the property they asked about.
Within 5 minutes
Call from a local number. If there is no answer, leave a 15-second voicemail naming the home and your name.
Right after the call
Send a text: the address, two tour times and a link to your agreement summary.
Same day
Email the listing details plus two similar homes, and log every attempt in your CRM.
Days 2 to 7
One touch a day across call, text and email, each with something new: a price change, a nearby open house or a payment estimate from their lender.
After day 7
Move them to a weekly listing alert and a monthly check-in. Many buyers come back after their first tour elsewhere.
Do the math before you join
Use your own numbers. The example below shows the shape of the calculation, not Zillow's actual fees or anyone's real results.
Example: a four-agent team expects 40 connections a month and closes 3% of them, or about 1.2 deals a month. Its average gross commission is $9,000. Under a pay-at-close agreement with an assumed 35% fee, each closing costs $3,150, leaving $5,850 before the agent split. Under an assumed $2,500 a month in market-based advertising for the same volume, each closing costs about $2,080, but the team pays the $2,500 even in a month with no closings.
- If your conversion rate is uncertain or low, pay-at-close limits downside but costs more per closing once you improve.
- If you convert consistently, fixed advertising often costs less per closing, and every improvement in follow-up goes to your margin.
- Count the closings that come later: repeat sales and referrals from a program lead may also fall under the fee window, depending on your agreement.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the fee or advertising cost in my ZIP codes and price bands, in writing?
- How long after a connection does a closing still trigger the fee?
- Which performance standards apply, and what happens if we miss them?
- How do leads move into our CRM, and who owns the contact record if an agent leaves?
- What reporting is required after a lead closes, and by when?
- How much notice do we get before pricing or terms change?
Track the program every month
Portal programs are easy to keep paying for and hard to judge without a scorecard. Set one up on day one and review it at the same meeting each month, by agent and by ZIP code.
- Speed: median minutes from connection to first live conversation, and the share of connections reached within the first hour.
- Contact rate: connections that reached a real conversation, not just a voicemail or a text that was never answered.
- Agreements: signed written buyer agreements per 100 connections, which tells you whether the first-call script works.
- Tours and offers: tours booked and offers written per 100 connections.
- Closings and cost: closings by month of first contact, total fees or advertising paid, and cost per closing.
- Lost reasons: already working with an agent, just browsing, financing not ready, or never reached.
Review the lost reasons as carefully as the wins. If most lost leads were never reached, the fix is staffing and response, not a different portal. If most were not ready to buy, the fix is a longer nurture plan with listing alerts and lender check-ins. If agents sign agreements but lose clients after the first tour, coach the tour itself. Keep the scorecard for at least two quarters before you renew, because closings lag first contact by months.
Signs the program fits
- You can answer every connection within minutes, including evenings and weekends.
- You have a written follow-up plan of at least 30 days and a CRM that enforces it.
- Your average commission leaves room for a fee or ad cost and still covers agent splits.
- Your agents are comfortable explaining written buyer agreements on the first call.
If two or more of those are missing, fix them first. A team that misses calls during showings can staff a rota, or use an SI Employee such as Ava to answer, take the property and preferred times, ask whether the buyer already has an agent, and hand a summary to the agent to confirm. For alternatives and context, compare the main portals side by side and review lead sources you own.
Frequently asked questions
Is Zillow Flex the same as Zillow Preferred?
Many agents use Flex for Zillow's pay-at-close model. Zillow's quarterly filing for the third quarter of 2026 lists Zillow Preferred as its pay-for-performance offering. Ask Zillow which program and terms apply in your market.
Do I pay anything if a pay-at-close lead never closes?
Under the pay-for-performance model the fee is due when a transaction closes with a Zillow lead. Read your agreement for any other obligations, reporting duties and the length of the fee window.
How does Zillow decide who gets leads under market-based pricing?
Zillow says connections are distributed in proportion to each partner's share of voice, meaning their share of total advertising purchased in a ZIP code.
Can a newer agent join Premier Agent?
Access and terms vary by market and team. Newer agents often join through a team that already participates, where they can learn the follow-up process before taking on their own spend.
References
Zillow Group, Inc. (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing) (2026). Zillow Group, Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Group, Inc. (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing) (2026). Zillow Group third-quarter 2026 results (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑