Key takeaways
- Plan the first five minutes as one sequence: call, voicemail, text, then a short email if the request is detailed.
- Expect the call to ring out; only a minority of Americans generally answer unknown numbers, but most check voicemail[1][2].
- Answer the buyer's actual question before you ask yours, then offer one concrete next step.
- A tour with an agent needs a written buyer agreement first, so have one ready to send the same day[3].
What a portal lead expects in the first minutes
A buyer who taps “contact agent” on a listing usually wants one of three things: to see the home, to learn something the listing does not say, or to check whether it is still available. They are often on their phone, often looking at several homes, and sometimes contacting more than one agent. The first five minutes decide whether you become their agent or one of several missed calls.
The playbook below assumes a lead arrives with a name, a phone number, an email address and the property they asked about. It works for Zillow, Realtor.com, Homes.com and your own IDX site. Adjust the wording to your market, but keep the order.
Set up before the next lead arrives
Five minutes is only possible if nothing has to be invented in the moment. Spend an hour once to prepare the pieces below, and every portal lead after that becomes a routine you can run from a parked car between showings.
- Push notifications for new leads on your phone, with sound, for the portal app and your CRM. Email alerts alone are too slow.
- Saved text templates for the first message, the second-day message and the “still available?” answer, each with a blank for the address.
- A voicemail outline written on a card or in your notes app so you never ramble.
- An approved buyer agreement template ready to send by e-signature from your phone.
- A short list of lenders you trust, with permission to share their contact details, for buyers who ask about financing on the first call.
- Showing instructions for your own listings stored where you can find them in seconds.
If you work on a team, also agree who takes the lead when the assigned agent is busy. A lead that waits for an agent who is in a closing loses the advantage the portal paid for.
The minute-by-minute sequence
Minute 0: open the listing, not the CRM
Pull up the property so you can answer the obvious questions: status, price, beds and baths, HOA, showing instructions. You need one fact to open the call, not a full profile of the lead.
Minute 1: call and let it ring
Dial from a number that will show your business name if your carrier supports branded caller ID. Let it ring until voicemail picks up. Hanging up early and calling again looks like spam.
Minute 2: leave a short voicemail
Fifteen seconds is enough. Name yourself, name the property, give one useful fact and say you are sending a text.
Minute 3: send the text
The text connects your number to a name and lets the buyer reply without a call. Ask one easy question.
Minute 4: send an email only if it adds something
If they asked a detailed question, such as HOA rules or school boundaries, email the answer or say when you will have it. If not, skip email for now.
Minute 5: log everything and set the next attempt
Log the call, voicemail and text in your CRM with times. Schedule a second call attempt for later the same day, at a different hour.
The reason for the bundle is simple. Pew Research Center found that only 19% of US adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers[1]. Most of the rest check voicemail if one is left, while a smaller group ignores voicemail too[2]. A call alone reaches a minority; a call plus voicemail plus text reaches most people through at least one channel.
- Generally answer 19%
- Don't answer, but check voicemail 67%
- Don't answer and ignore voicemail 14%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally answer | 19% |
| Don't answer, but check voicemail | 67% |
| Don't answer and ignore voicemail | 14% |
Scripts for each touch
Voicemail script: “Hi Priya, it's Marcus with Lakeview Homes about 2210 Birch Lane. It's still active and there's a showing window Thursday evening. I'll text you from this number so you can reply whenever is easy.”
Text script: “Hi Priya, Marcus with Lakeview Homes. Just left you a quick voicemail about 2210 Birch Lane. It's still available. Would you like to see it this week, or should I send the details first?”
Email subject and body, for detailed questions: subject “2210 Birch Lane: HOA rules you asked about”. Body: two or three sentences answering the question, the source of the answer, and one line offering a showing time. No long signature blocks, no attachments in the first email.
What to avoid in all three: asking for pre-approval before you have answered anything, sending a list of ten other homes they did not ask about, and generic openers such as “I saw you were interested in real estate.” The buyer asked about one home. Talk about that home first.
If they pick up
Younger adults are more likely than older ones to take calls from unknown numbers[4], so first-time buyers sometimes answer on the first try. When they do, the order is answer, ask, offer.
- Answer: “Yes, it's still available. It's listed with the HOA included and the seller is open to showings this week.”
- Ask one or two questions: “Is this the area you're focused on, or are you looking at a few neighborhoods?” and “Are you hoping to move in the next few months?”
- Offer one step: a showing time, a call with a lender, or a short list of similar homes. Pick the one that fits what you just heard.
Keep the first call under five minutes unless the buyer wants to keep talking. A fuller qualifying conversation can come once they trust you; the guide on qualifying a buyer lead on the first call covers the questions.
When the buyer wants a tour today
Since August 17, 2024, many buyers working with a REALTOR are asked to sign a written buyer agreement, a requirement that came out of NAR's settlement of commission litigation[5]. NAR's consumer guide says a written agreement is needed before touring a home with an agent, in person or virtually, while visiting an open house alone or asking about services does not require one[3].
In practice that means a same-day tour request needs a ready process. Keep a short, plain-language agreement template your brokerage has approved, with the compensation clearly defined. NAR notes that compensation must be stated clearly, for example as a flat fee or a percent, not left open-ended, and that it is negotiable[6].
| Buyer says | Good response | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| “Can I see it this afternoon?” | Offer a time, explain the agreement in one sentence and send it by e-signature | Touring first and sorting the paperwork later |
| “I don't want to sign anything yet.” | Offer a single-property or short-term agreement if your brokerage allows it, or point to the next open house | Pressure or making the agreement sound like a formality |
| “I already have an agent.” | Thank them and suggest they ask their agent to book the showing | Asking about their agreement terms or offering a better deal |
| “I just want to know the price history.” | Answer the question; no agreement is needed to share information | Holding information back to force a meeting |
If a buyer says they already have an agent, the guide on handling “I already have an agent” explains the ethics and the respectful exit.
After the first five minutes
If you did not connect, the next touches should come at different times of day. A sensible pattern is a second call that evening, a text the next morning with something new, such as a price change or a similar listing, and a third call the following afternoon. The 30-day follow-up plan lays out the rest.
- Change the message each time. Repeating “just checking in” teaches the buyer to ignore you.
- Stop texting immediately if they reply STOP or ask you to, and note it in the CRM.
- If they reply at 11 p.m., answer briefly and offer to talk the next day rather than starting a long thread.
- Record the property they asked about as a tag so later listings alerts are relevant.
Example: a fictional agent receives a portal inquiry at 6:42 p.m. while finishing a showing. She calls at 6:45, leaves a voicemail at 6:46, texts at 6:46, gets a reply at 7:10 asking for Saturday, sends the agreement at 7:15 and books an 11 a.m. tour. The whole exchange took fewer than ten minutes of her time.
Frequently asked questions
Should I call or text a new portal lead first?
Call first, then leave a voicemail and text within a minute. The call shows effort and catches the buyers who do answer; the text reaches those who don't and connects your name to your number.
What if the lead's phone number is wrong?
Email immediately with the answer to their question and a short line asking for the best number. Many portal leads mistype numbers on mobile. Keep emailing on the normal follow-up schedule.
How soon should the second attempt be?
Later the same day at a different hour, for example early evening if the first call was mid-afternoon. Then try the next morning and the following afternoon.
Do I need a buyer agreement to answer questions by phone?
No. NAR's guidance says asking about services or getting information does not require a written agreement. One is needed before touring a home with an agent. Follow your brokerage's forms and your state's rules.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑