Key takeaways
- The Texas Real Estate Commission received 2,488 complaints from the public in fiscal 2025, most tied to buying, leasing or inspecting a home[1].
- About four in five closed Texas complaints were dismissed rather than sanctioned[1], but each one still needed a full written response.
- Silence starts most complaint stories; offers, disclosures, deposits and copies of signed papers are where they become rule breaches[2].
- Every complaint type has a cheap control and a record that defends it. Build both into the file before anything goes wrong.
What regulators actually see
Ask a managing broker what clients complain about and the same stories come back: the agent who went quiet after the inspection, the seller who learned about a fee at the closing table, the buyer who never got a copy of the counteroffer. Regulators' numbers point the same way. Texas publishes detailed enforcement numbers every year, which makes it a useful baseline for any brokerage.
The Texas Real Estate Commission received 2,488 complaints from the public in fiscal 2025, up from 2,006 two years earlier[1]. The commission says most public complaints relate to the purchase, lease or inspection of a home, with allegations that run from misleading advertising to criminal history to unlicensed activity[1]. Complaints have to be signed and in writing, and the agency cannot take anonymous ones[1]. Every file has a named client behind it who was annoyed enough to fill in a form.
Source: Texas Real Estate Commission, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Fiscal year | Public complaints |
|---|---|
| FY2021 | 2,365 |
| FY2022 | 2,111 |
| FY2023 | 2,006 |
| FY2024 | 2,331 |
| FY2025 | 2,488 |
Most of those complaints do not end in discipline. In fiscal 2025 the commission dismissed 2,232 complaints and resolved 535 by action[1], so roughly four in five closed files ended without a sanction. That is no reason to relax. A dismissed complaint still means a written response, a pulled transaction file and several hours of the broker's week, and whatever caused it tends to happen again. How to answer a regulator is covered in handling license complaints and regulator inquiries. This guide is about causes, and the controls that keep a client's frustration from reaching a regulator at all.
1. Communication: the agent who went quiet
Many complaints begin with silence rather than a broken rule. A seller leaves two messages about the appraisal and hears nothing for a day. A buyer's agent stops answering texts once the offer is accepted. By the time the client writes to the broker, the original question has picked up a second one: what else is my agent not telling me?
Clients judge responsiveness from the first contact. In Zillow's 2026 seller research, 77% of sellers who used an agent rated the agent's initial impression of responsiveness as very or extremely important, and 80% said the same of trustworthiness[3]. After hiring, 42% of buyers say they talk with their agent daily, and text is the channel buyers most prefer (43%), ahead of phone calls (31%)[4]. A client used to daily contact notices a two-day gap, and starts keeping notes.
Silence can also become an ethics matter. Standard of Practice 1-6 of the NAR Code of Ethics requires REALTORS to submit offers and counter-offers objectively and as quickly as possible[2]. An offer that sat in an inbox over a weekend because nobody was watching the phone is how a service complaint turns into an ethics complaint.
- Agree a contact rhythm at signing: which channel, how often, and the longest a reply will take. Put it in the welcome email so it exists in writing.
- Name a cover agent for every listing and buyer client before any day off, and tell the client who it is.
- Answer the listing and office lines every hour they ring. A callback the next day often fails: 80% of Americans say they don't generally answer calls from unknown numbers[5].
- Log every client call and text in the transaction file the same day, with what was promised and by when.
Evenings and weekends are where most brokerages leak. Some forward the listing line to an answering service. Others forward it to an SI Employee that answers in the brokerage's name, takes the question, marks anything time-sensitive as urgent and emails the agent a summary with the recording and transcript (see what it does). Either way the client gets a real answer and a callback time, and the agent starts the morning knowing what is waiting. The 40-agent brokerage example shows one front desk routing those calls by listing and team.
Example: an evening call that never becomes a complaint
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Seller calls after hours
Wants to know why the buyer's side hasn't answered the repair request.
02SI Employee
Call is answered
The listing line forwards after 6 p.m.; the question and best callback time are taken.
03SI Employee
Flagged urgent
Closing is in four days, so the summary goes out as an URGENT email.
04Your team
Agent reads the summary
Recording, transcript and summary are waiting before the agent's first showing.
05Your team
Callback by 9 a.m.
Agent confirms the repair status in writing and notes the call in the file.
Example sequence. Nothing here replaces the agent: the call is captured, the urgency is visible and the reply is on record.
The difference between this seller and a complaint is about fourteen hours. Without coverage, the seller's question waits overnight in a voicemail box nobody checks, the morning starts with a second, sharper message, and the broker hears about it from the seller first. With coverage, the same question arrives in the agent's inbox marked urgent and gets a written answer before the seller has time to draft a complaint.
2. Disclosure: what the client was told, or not told
The second big group of complaints is about facts: a square footage that was off, a known leak that never reached the disclosure form, an HOA fee quoted from an old listing. Article 2 of the Code of Ethics asks REALTORS to avoid exaggeration, misrepresentation or concealment of pertinent facts about the property or the transaction[2]. State license law usually says something similar, enforced by the regulator rather than a local association.
These complaints are often born on the phone. A buyer calls the sign number, someone answers from memory, and the answer becomes the thing the buyer relied on. Whoever answers sign calls, a person or an automated assistant, should answer only from an approved listing sheet and mark anything else as not confirmed for the listing agent.
- Keep a one-page listing sheet for every active listing, signed off by the listing agent, and update it the same day price, status, fees or showing instructions change.
- Answer phone and text questions about a listing only from that sheet. Anything not on it gets a promise to confirm and a note to the agent, not a guess.
- When a seller mentions a defect, repair or insurance claim, email it back the same day and ask whether it belongs on the disclosure.
- Deliver disclosures before an offer is written, and keep the dated acknowledgment.
The seller's own duties are set out in seller disclosure obligations agents should know, and the claims that follow a missed disclosure are in common claims against agents.
3. Money: deposits, fees and wires
Money complaints move fastest, because the client can point to a number. They come in three kinds: earnest money disputes after a deal falls apart, fee surprises, and wire fraud.
Article 8 of the Code requires REALTORS to keep money held in trust for others, such as escrows and clients' monies, in a special account separated from their own funds[2]. State law adds the detail on deposit deadlines, releases and records. The complaint usually comes from the release, not the deposit: a buyer who walked away inside a contingency, a seller who believes the buyer defaulted, an agent who told one side they would get the money back before anyone read the contract.
On fees, most clients are content. In Zillow's 2026 buyer research, 78% of buyers who used an agent said the commission was fair for the service, while 15% said it was too high[4]. Since the NAR settlement changes, compensation in a written buyer agreement must be clearly defined, for example $0, a flat fee, a percentage or an hourly rate, rather than open-ended or a range[6]. A fee complaint is usually a complaint about a conversation that never happened at signing.
Wire fraud is a growing share of the money problem. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, up from 9,359 in 2024, and reported real estate losses reached $275.1 million[7]. When a client loses a down payment to a spoofed email, the agent copied on the thread is often named in the first complaint. The controls are in wire fraud prevention for real estate transactions.
- Agents never tell a party what will happen to a deposit. They say who decides under the contract and when, and pass the question to the broker.
- Walk every client through who pays what, using the signed agreement, before the first showing or listing appointment ends.
- Send wiring warnings at contract, two weeks before closing and the day before, by a channel separate from the email thread.
4. Paperwork: "I never saw that"
Article 9 asks REALTORS to make sure agreements are in writing in clear and understandable language, and to give each party a copy on signing or initialing[2]. Complaints here read alike: the seller never received the signed counteroffer, the buyer did not know the option period had ended, an amendment agreed by text was never put on paper. They are the easiest complaints to defend when the file is complete and the hardest when it is not.
Many transaction platforms log delivery automatically. The gap is everything agreed outside them: a price change confirmed on a call, an extension promised in a text, a repair credit discussed at a showing. Anything that changes a term should be on the right form within one business day. Keep files for at least as long as your state requires; record retention requirements for brokerages has the detail.
5. Advertising and who is speaking
Advertising complaints often come from competitors or the regulator's own staff rather than clients. Texas lists misleading advertising among the allegations it sees[1], and Article 12 requires REALTORS to present a true picture in their advertising, marketing and other representations[2]. Typical files: a team name that hides the brokerage, a sold post for a home the agent did not sell, a listing photo edited to remove a power line. The rules are covered in Code of Ethics Article 12.
The complaint map: cause, control and record
| Complaint | What the client says | Rule it touches | Control | Record that defends you |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unanswered calls and texts | "I couldn't reach my agent for two days" | License duties; SoP 1-6 when an offer is involved | Contact rhythm in writing, cover agent, every line answered after hours | Call log, call summaries, callback times |
| Late or missing offer | "Our offer was never presented" | SoP 1-6 and 1-7 | Offer log with time received and time presented | Timestamped emails, seller acknowledgment |
| Wrong or missing facts | "Nobody mentioned the roof" | Article 2; state disclosure law | Signed listing sheet; same-day disclosure emails | Disclosure with dated acknowledgment |
| Deposit release | "They kept my earnest money" | Article 8; state trust account rules | Broker decides releases; scripted answer for agents | Trust ledger, signed release forms |
| Fee surprise | "I didn't know I'd pay my agent" | Written buyer agreement terms | Fee walk-through at signing | Signed agreement, walk-through note |
| Missing copies | "I never saw the counter" | Article 9 | Copies sent at every signature | Platform delivery log |
| Misleading ad | "That listing wasn't theirs" | Article 12; state advertising rules | Ad review before anything is published | Archive of approved ads |
Use the map in two directions. When a complaint arrives, find its row and check whether the control existed and the record is there. When nothing has gone wrong, pick the row with the weakest record and fix it this month. Supervision expectations for brokers are set out in broker supervision duties in practice.
A 30-minute monthly complaint-risk review
Pull ten files at random
Five active, five closed last month. Check that copies, disclosures and the offer log are complete.
Listen to five after-hours calls
Did the caller get an answer and a callback time, and did the agent call back when promised?
Check the money
Reconcile the trust ledger and confirm every release this month has a signed authorization.
Scan last month's ads
Brokerage name present, claims accurate, sold credits correct.
Write down one fix
Name the gap you saw most often and the control you will add. Check it again next month.
Example: a 25-agent office runs this review on the first Monday of each month. In one month it finds three files with no record that the seller received the signed counteroffer, all from agents who sign on their phones. The fix is a single platform setting that sends copies to every party automatically, and the next month's sample is clean. That is the pattern to aim for: one gap, one control, checked again.
When a complaint does come in, handle the conversation first and the file second. Handling client complaints gracefully covers the first call and the written reply.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common complaint against real estate agents?
Regulators rarely publish a single ranking. Texas says most public complaints relate to the purchase, lease or inspection of a home[1]. In brokerage files, many start with poor communication and grow into disputes about disclosures, deposits or paperwork.
Where can a client file a complaint about a realtor?
With the brokerage first, then the state real estate regulator for license law issues, and the local REALTOR association for Code of Ethics matters. Fraud involving wired money can also be reported to the FBI's IC3[7].
Do most license complaints lead to discipline?
No. In fiscal 2025 the Texas commission dismissed 2,232 complaints and resolved 535 by action[1]. A dismissal still takes a complete written response and the transaction file.
Can the broker be named in a complaint about an agent?
Yes. Complaints often name the sponsoring broker for supervision as well as the agent. The broker's answer should show the policy, the training and the file review that applied.
Does answering the phone after hours really reduce complaints?
It removes a common trigger: a client who could not reach anyone. Sellers weigh responsiveness heavily when choosing an agent[3], and that expectation does not switch off at 6 p.m.
References
Texas Real Estate Commission (2025). Self-Directed Semi-Independent Agency Report (FY2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). 2026 Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Sellers: Results from the Zillow Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Buyers: Results from the Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑