Key takeaways
- Every New York broker must publish whether homebuyers need identification, an exclusive buyer agreement or mortgage pre-approval before receiving services[2].
- The procedures are date-stamped, notarized, posted on broker, team and agent websites and apps, and reposted within 30 days of any change[2].
- Agents and teams cannot run their own stricter version; the broker's procedure binds everyone under the license[3].
- The phone line is where uneven treatment shows up first, so the three questions belong in the intake script, asked the same way of every caller.
Why New York put buyer prerequisites in writing
Two buyers call the same Long Island office on the same Saturday about the same split-level. The agent who takes the first call books a showing and mentions a lender later. The agent who takes the second call says the office needs a pre-approval letter before anyone opens a door. Neither agent thinks of it as policy, and neither wrote anything down. Since April 20, 2022, New York has required brokers to decide that question once, publish the answer and hold every licensee to it[4].
The law grew out of Newsday's Long Island Divided investigation. Across 86 paired tests, agents engaged in potentially unequal treatment of minority homebuyers in 40% of tests, and Black testers were treated unequally in 49% of their tests, Hispanic testers in 39% and Asian testers in 19%[1]. The State Senate report that reviewed the work is careful to say these rates reflect the judgment of two fair housing experts, not legal findings[1]. The examples it describes are exactly the gatekeeping this law targets: an agent who demanded mortgage pre-approval from a minority tester before showing listings but not from the white tester, and an agent who asked a Black tester for identification but not the white tester[1].
The Senate committees recommended making brokers standardize those prerequisites for all home seekers without telling them what the standard should be[1]. The legislature amended Real Property Law § 442-h on December 21, 2021, dropped a filing requirement in March 2022, and set April 20, 2022 as the date procedures had to be in place and public[4]. Federal fair housing law already barred discrimination on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability[5]. The SOP rule adds something different: a written, public yardstick that a tester, a complainant or the Department of State can hold your agents against.
The three questions every procedure must answer
Section 442-h(4)(a) requires each broker to set procedures for the prerequisites prospective homebuyers must meet before receiving any services. At minimum they state whether clients must show identification, whether an exclusive broker agreement is required and whether pre-approval for a mortgage loan is required[2]. The Secretary of State can add items by regulation after a public hearing[2], but the Department has said it is not considering expanding the list[4].
| Question in the law | Your published answer | What it means on the first call |
|---|---|---|
| Must prospective clients show identification? | Requires or does not require | If required, every caller hears the same ID step at the same point, before any showing is booked. |
| Is an exclusive broker agreement required? | Requires or does not require | If not required, no agent may refuse a buyer who declines to sign one, though the agent can still offer it. |
| Is mortgage pre-approval required? | Requires or does not require (NYSAR's sample pairs it with proof of funds) | If not required, pre-approval can be recommended to everyone but demanded of no one. |
The rule is about consistency, not about picking the buyer-friendly answer. A broker may require all three. What a broker may not do is let individual licensees decide. NYSAR's guidance says associated licensees and teams are prohibited from having their own procedure, that a broker who does not require an exclusive buyer agreement can still offer one as an option, and that a broker who does not require pre-approval can still suggest its benefits[3]. It also notes that a seller may require identification and pre-approval as a condition of showing or of an offer, which is a seller's instruction, not your prerequisite[3].
Written buyer agreements complicate the second question. Many New York brokers now ask buyers to sign a written agreement before touring, a practice that came out of NAR's settlement[6]. Whether that agreement is exclusive is what your SOP has to answer. If your form is exclusive and you require it before tours, the honest answer is “requires”, and every caller should hear that early. If you accept a non-exclusive agreement, say so. A published “does not require” next to a desk that insists on an exclusive form is the gap an investigator will notice. For the money side of that conversation, see buyer agent compensation conversations after the settlement.
Posting, notarizing and keeping every version
Date stamp and notarize
The broker date-stamps and notarizes the procedures and keeps that signed original on file for as long as the license is active[2].
Post them wherever the public finds you
Every public website and mobile app the broker maintains carries the procedures. Team and salesperson sites post the broker's version or link directly to it[2]. NYSAR suggests a pinned post with the required disclosures where a social profile has no other place for them[3].
Keep a copy at each office
Anyone who walks in and asks gets a copy[2]. Put it in the same binder as your fair housing notice so the front desk can find it.
Repost within 30 days of any change
A changed procedure is date-stamped, notarized and posted within 30 days, and the old version is archived[2]. Keep every version; a complaint about a 2023 call is judged against the 2023 text.
Example (fictional): “Harbor Lane Realty LLC does not require prospective buyer clients to show identification, does not require an exclusive buyer broker agreement, and does not require pre-approval for a mortgage loan or proof of funds before providing services. A seller may require identification, pre-approval or proof of funds before a showing or as part of an offer. Effective March 1, 2026.” The posted web text can be a copy of the notarized original; the notarized page itself stays on file[3].
These procedures are not the internal playbooks most teams call SOPs, the checklists for listing launches and closing files covered in standard operating procedures for teams. Keep the two apart. The public document should be short enough that a caller can read it in thirty seconds, and nothing in your internal manual should contradict it. Your policies and procedures manual is the right place to say who maintains the public version and who checks the team sites.
Where the phones come in
The law covers what buyers must do before receiving any services, and for most buyers the first service is a phone call. Someone sees a sign rider, rings the number and asks to see the house on Thursday. Whoever answers is applying your SOP in that moment, whether they know it or not. If the answer depends on which agent picked up, how busy the office was or what time of night it is, then the real procedure is whatever was said, not what was notarized.
Count the people who answer buyer calls in a typical office: the front desk, two or three agents on floor time, an inside sales agent, the listing agents' own cell phones and whatever covers nights and weekends. Each needs the same three answers in the same words. The script is where that consistency lives, and the fair housing rules for call scripts and intake apply to every one of those people.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Caller asks for a showing
A buyer calls the sign number about a listing and asks to see it on Thursday evening.
02SI Employee
Same questions, same order
Property, preferred times, whether the buyer has an agent, contact details. Every caller.
03SI Employee
Policy in approved words
“We don't require pre-approval to start. Many buyers find it helps with an offer.”
04System
Summary and recording saved
The listing agent gets the summary by email; recording and transcript stay in the account.
05Your team
Agent confirms the showing
No extra hurdle added at callback. If the seller requires pre-approval, it applies to all.
Example call path. The intake questions and policy wording are the broker's, approved before any call is forwarded.
This is where an SI Employee on the overflow or after-hours line helps with compliance rather than just coverage. It answers from the script and listing sheet you approve, takes the showing request with the same questions every time, and passes anything outside the script to an agent instead of improvising. The recording and transcript of every call give the broker something to audit (see what it does). The front desk routing example walks through how a brokerage might split calls between its desk and that coverage.
A phone script that matches your procedure
Write one line for each of the three questions, for the answer you actually published. Here is a set for a broker whose SOP requires none of the three, which is a common choice:
- Identification: say nothing about ID unless the seller requires it for showings. If the seller does, tell every caller for that listing at the same point: “The owner asks every visitor to show ID at the door.”
- Buyer agreement: “Before a tour we'll ask you to sign a written agreement that sets out our services and compensation. It doesn't have to be exclusive.” Adjust the last sentence to match your form.
- Pre-approval: “We don't require pre-approval to get started. If you'd like, we can introduce you to a lender, and many buyers find it helps when they make an offer.” The handoff itself is covered in pre-approval handoffs to a lender.
- Questions about schools, safety or who lives nearby: point to public sources and move on, the same way for every caller.
If your SOP requires pre-approval, the line changes but the discipline does not: “Before we schedule showings, we ask every buyer for a pre-approval letter or proof of funds. I can connect you with a lender today if that helps.” Asked of every caller, that is a lawful prerequisite. Asked only of some, it is the pattern the Senate report described[1].
Watch the soft versions too. “You'll want to be pre-approved before we go out” sounds like a requirement to a buyer even when the SOP says otherwise. Agents who believe pre-approval saves wasted Saturdays tend to drift into this phrasing, which is why recorded calls matter more than training slides.
Checking that the procedure is what callers hear
The Department of State told its Real Estate Board that whenever Enforcement investigates a complaint, it will also check whether the broker's procedures are available and posted on its website, and that random website checks were under discussion[7]. A broker or salesperson who fails to follow the procedures faces the penalties in § 441-c[2], which include suspension, revocation or a fine of up to $2,000, half of which goes to the state's anti-discrimination in housing fund[8].
- Monthly, pull ten recorded buyer calls from different agents and times of day. Score each on whether the three SOP answers matched the published text.
- Check that every team and agent website posts or links to the broker's current version, not a copy from two years ago.
- Compare the notarized original on file with what is posted. They should carry the same effective date.
- Read your listing-specific seller instructions. If a seller requires ID or pre-approval, confirm every caller for that listing heard it.
- Add the SOP lines to new-agent onboarding and to the renewal-cycle training that already includes two hours of implicit bias instruction[7].
Example: a 25-agent office that scores ten calls a month reviews 120 calls a year. If two of the ten in March show an agent telling buyers they “need” pre-approval under a “does not require” SOP, that is a coaching conversation in April rather than a pattern a fair housing tester documents in June. The fair housing testing guide covers what testers look for, and broker supervision in practice covers documenting the review.
The SOP is one of two New York fair housing duties that start at the first conversation. The other is the state's disclosure form, which has its own timing and delivery rules, explained in the NY Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure Form. Rental calls carry separate risks around vouchers and income rules; see source-of-income discrimination on rental calls.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to file our standardized operating procedures with the Department of State?
No. A March 2022 amendment removed the filing requirement[4]. You still date-stamp, notarize, post and archive them, and affirm compliance at each renewal[2].
Can an agent require pre-approval if the broker's procedure does not?
No. Associated licensees and teams must follow the broker's procedure and cannot set their own[3]. The agent can recommend pre-approval to every buyer but cannot make it a condition of service.
What if our procedure requires ID and a buyer refuses?
NYSAR's guidance says a broker may continue to provide services to a buyer who declines a required item, as long as it handles every buyer the same way[3]. Decide your answer in advance and write it into the script.
Does the rule apply to brokerages that only do rentals or commercial work?
The statute speaks of prospective homebuyers[2]. NYSAR reads it as applying to every brokerage with no carve-out by practice type, so a commercial or leasing broker should still adopt and post a procedure[3].
How quickly must a changed procedure go online?
Within 30 days, date-stamped and notarized, with the old version archived[2]. Change the call scripts on the same day the new version takes effect.
References
New York State Senate Standing Committees (2021). Final Investigative Report: Fair Housing and Discrimination on Long Island (January 27, 2021) (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Senate (Consolidated Laws) (2025). N.Y. Real Property Law § 442-H, Rules of the secretary of state (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Association of REALTORS (2022). Real Estate Broker Standard Operating Procedures (April 2022 Legal Update) (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York Department of State, Division of Licensing Services (2022). Standardized Operating Procedures (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York Department of State (2022). NYS Real Estate Board meeting summary, April 19, 2022 (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Senate (Consolidated Laws) (2025). N.Y. Real Property Law § 441-C, Revocation and suspension of licenses (opens in a new tab) ↑