Key takeaways
- Source of income is not a federal protected class[2], but 19 states, the District of Columbia and many cities protect it[3].
- PRRAC estimates over 60% of voucher holders now live where these laws apply[4].
- In NYC the rule covers real estate brokers as well as landlords[5]; in California a statement of preference is itself unlawful[6].
- Minimum-income rules that screen out subsidized renters have led to large awards and settlements[7].
- Give every rental caller the same answer about vouchers, from a written listing sheet, and review recorded calls.
One sentence can be the violation
“We don't take Section 8” takes two seconds to say on a rental inquiry call, and in a growing number of states and cities it is unlawful to say at all, whether or not the caller ever applies. California's Fair Employment and Housing Act, for example, bars any notice, statement or advertisement indicating a preference or limitation based on source of income, not just a refusal to rent[6]. The phone is where that statement usually gets made, by a leasing agent repeating what an owner said once, months ago.
The federal Fair Housing Act protects against discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability[2]. Source of income is not on that list. The protection comes from state and local law, which means the right answer to a voucher question depends on where the unit is. For a brokerage with listings in several jurisdictions, that is a script problem as much as a legal one.
This article explains where the rules apply, what testing has found and how to script rental calls so every caller hears the same thing. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm your local rules with counsel.
Where source of income is protected
The Poverty & Race Research Action Council keeps the most-cited compilation. Its March 2026 update lists 19 states plus the District of Columbia and Guam with statewide source-of-income laws, four more states where protection is weakened or narrow, and seven states that preempt cities and counties from passing their own: Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Missouri and Texas[3]. Dozens of cities and counties have local ordinances on top.
19 + DC
states plus the District of Columbia with statewide source-of-income laws[3]
7
states that preempt local source-of-income ordinances[3]
60%+
of voucher holders estimated to be covered by these laws[4]
2,189
source-of-income complaints to private fair housing groups in 2024[1]
Coverage keeps changing; check the current state and local rule for each listing.
Coverage has grown fast. About 34% of voucher holders were protected in 2018, by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities' count; PRRAC estimates the share passed 57% in 2022 and, with Michigan's law in 2025, is likely above 60%[4]. Some protections are old: New Jersey added source of income in 2002 and the District of Columbia in 2005. Others are recent: New York State has protected it since 2019, and California has explicitly covered voucher holders since 2020[8].
Local rules can be broader than state law. In New York City, source-of-income discrimination by landlords, owners and real estate brokers has been illegal since 2008, and most rental properties are covered regardless of the number of units, with exceptions for small owner-occupied buildings and units that are not publicly advertised[5]. That last point matters for brokerages: a listing you advertise is almost always covered.
What testing found when callers mentioned vouchers
The best national evidence on how voucher holders are treated at first contact comes from a HUD-sponsored pilot study by the Urban Institute. Field teams ran nearly 4,000 tests over 16 months in five cities, on advertised units that met local voucher program rent limits. Denial rates were 78% in Fort Worth, 76% in Los Angeles and 67% in Philadelphia, but 31% in Newark and 15% in Washington, DC, and the researchers noted that refusal was more common in jurisdictions without source-of-income protections[9].
Newark and Washington already had protection at the time of the study, New Jersey's dating from 2002 and the District's from 2005[8]. The study did not prove the laws caused the gap, but the pattern is the one fair housing groups use when they decide where to test. Private fair housing organizations reported 2,189 source-of-income complaints in 2024[1], and many begin with a phone call that a tester makes and a group records. If you have not seen how those calls are run, read how brokerages prepare for fair housing testing.
How a voucher works, in terms a caller can use
Agents who understand the program give better answers. Under the Housing Choice Voucher program the local housing agency pays its share of the rent directly to the landlord, and the family pays the rest, usually 30% of its adjusted monthly income and sometimes up to 40%[10]. Around 2,000 local public housing agencies run the program[10], so details such as forms and inspection timing vary from one agency to the next.
For a phone call, that translates into a few practical points. The rent on the listing and the caller's voucher size both matter, so the agent should share the rent, deposit, fees and availability exactly as they would with anyone else. Questions about inspections and paperwork timing are legitimate and can be answered from the listing sheet. What changes in a protected jurisdiction is that the voucher cannot be the reason for a no, and the agent cannot steer the caller toward “programs-friendly” listings instead of the one they asked about.
Minimum income rules are where many cases turn
Few brokerages tell a caller outright that vouchers are refused. Many more apply a minimum-income rule, such as income of three times the rent, to the full rent, which a voucher holder paying only part of the rent may never meet. That is where several large cases have landed.
In Fair Housing Justice Center v. Pelican Management, the group alleged that minimum-income policies excluded renters who receive subsidies. After a bench trial the court ruled for the group, ordered the defendants to adopt non-discriminatory rental criteria and awarded $240,540 in compensatory and $750,000 in punitive damages; the Second Circuit affirmed in January 2025. In a separate New York City case, Parkchester agreed to a $1,050,000 settlement, believed to be the largest monetary settlement in a source-of-income case, and to accept all types of rental assistance[7].
The practical step for a brokerage is to get each owner's written screening criteria before the listing goes live, and have counsel check how income tests apply to the portion of rent a voucher covers in that jurisdiction. Then the agent reads the criteria on the phone exactly as written, to every caller.
A phone script for rental inquiries
Most problems on these calls come from improvising. The table pairs common caller questions with lines to avoid and lines to use in a jurisdiction where source of income is protected.
| Caller says | Avoid | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “Do you take Section 8?” | “The owner doesn't do programs.” | “Yes, we accept all lawful sources of income. Here's how to apply.” |
| “What income do I need?” | “Three times the rent, no exceptions.” | Read the owner's written criteria exactly as approved for voucher holders. |
| “My voucher is for a two-bedroom.” | “You'd be better off at our other building.” | Give this unit's rent, size, fees and availability, then offer a showing. |
| “How fast can you do the inspection?” | “Inspections hold us up, so we prefer cash tenants.” | “We'll schedule it as soon as the housing agency sends the request.” |
| “Is it still available?” | A different answer than the last caller got | The same status, read from today's listing sheet. |
Example script for a leasing line: “Thanks for calling about 14 Alder Street. It's a two-bedroom at 1,850 a month, available December 1. We accept all lawful sources of income, including housing vouchers. Everyone applies through the same online application, and I can send you the screening criteria now. Would you like to see it this week?”
Callers sometimes volunteer details about family, disability or background. The same rule applies: do not ask about protected characteristics, and do not change the answer because of what was volunteered. Fair housing rules for call scripts and intake covers the full list, and fair housing advertising words to avoid covers listing copy, where “no vouchers” language often starts.
When an owner says “no vouchers”
The instruction usually arrives at the listing appointment or in an email after the first showing. In a protected jurisdiction, the brokerage cannot carry it out, and an agent who repeats it to callers exposes the firm as well as the owner. Handle it before the listing goes live.
- Explain the local rule to the owner in plain terms, and say that the brokerage's agents will tell every caller that lawful sources of income are accepted.
- Ask for the owner's screening criteria in writing and have the managing broker or counsel check them against the source-of-income rule, especially any minimum-income test.
- Note the conversation and the owner's agreement in the listing file.
- If the owner still insists on refusing vouchers, decline or withdraw from the listing. That decision belongs to the managing broker, in writing.
Many owners move once they understand the agent will not say the words for them. The ones who do not are the listings most likely to produce a complaint.
Where no source-of-income law applies
In a jurisdiction with no source-of-income law, an owner may be allowed to decline vouchers under state and federal law, and in the seven preemption states cities cannot add their own rule[3]. Even so, a brokerage should handle the question carefully. Get the owner's policy in writing for each listing, state it the same way to every caller who asks, and never volunteer it selectively. A no-vouchers answer given only to some callers, or tied to assumptions about who they are, can still raise questions under the federal protected classes[2].
Multi-state brokerages should keep the rule on the listing sheet rather than in agents' heads. An agent covering a colleague's listing across a state line will otherwise default to the rule they know.
Make every call sound the same
Consistency is the defense, and it is hard to achieve when whoever is free picks up the leasing line. Many rental calls come in during evenings and at weekends, which is often when the least-trained person is answering.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Caller asks about vouchers
A prospective tenant calls the listing number at 8 p.m. about a two-bedroom.
02SI Employee
Answer from listing sheet
The approved line on income sources, rent and fees is read the same way every time.
03SI Employee
Showing request taken
Property, preferred times and contact details are captured for the agent.
04Your team
Agent confirms the showing
The listing agent confirms the time the next morning, with the criteria attached.
05Your team
Calls reviewed monthly
The broker samples recordings and transcripts to check every caller heard the same answer.
Example sequence. The wording comes from the brokerage's approved listing sheet.
This is a good fit for an SI Employee on a forwarded leasing line. It answers from the listing sheet the brokerage approves, marks anything not on the sheet as not confirmed for the agent, takes showing requests for the agent to confirm, and leaves a recording, transcript and summary of every call for review (an example of a team's setup). The property management example models prospective-tenant calls getting their own path on the main line.
Put the rule on every rental listing sheet
One approved line on sources of income, plus the owner's written screening criteria, for each unit.
Train everyone who answers
Agents, assistants and anyone covering the leasing line learn the script and the reason for it.
Review a sample each month
Listen to a handful of recorded rental calls and compare the answers. Fix wording, not just people.
Check the listing copy
Search ads and portal descriptions for “no vouchers” or “no programs” and remove them.
For more on covering the leasing line itself, see turning rental inquiries into future buyers and handling calls from tenants in listed rentals.
Frequently asked questions
Is source of income a federally protected class?
No. The Fair Housing Act covers race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status and disability[2]. Source-of-income protection comes from state and local law, which covers 19 states and the District of Columbia statewide plus many cities[3].
Can a landlord require income of three times the rent from a voucher holder?
It depends on the jurisdiction and how the test is applied. Minimum-income rules that screened out subsidized renters led to a judgment with $750,000 in punitive damages in one New York case[7]. Ask counsel how income tests must treat the voucher-paid share of rent where your listing is.
Do these laws apply to brokers or only to landlords?
Often to brokers too. New York City's law names real estate brokers alongside landlords and owners[5], and California bars anyone from making a statement that indicates a source-of-income preference[6].
Can I tell callers the owner doesn't accept vouchers if my state has no law?
Possibly, if no state or local rule applies[3]. Get the owner's policy in writing, say it the same way to every caller who asks, and check for city or county ordinances before relying on the state answer.
How do fair housing groups test for this?
Often by calling or visiting about an advertised unit, with a tester who mentions a voucher, and comparing the answer with what other testers hear. Denial rates in the HUD-sponsored pilot study ranged from 15% to 78% by city[9].
References
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
Poverty & Race Research Action Council (2026). Appendix B: State, Local, and Federal Laws Barring Source of Income Discrimination (updated March 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Poverty & Race Research Action Council (2026). Appendix B: coverage of voucher holders by source-of-income laws (opens in a new tab) ↑
NYC Commission on Human Rights (2026). Source of Income Discrimination (opens in a new tab) ↑
Poverty & Race Research Action Council (2026). Appendix B: California Government Code § 12955 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Fair Housing Alliance (2025). 2025 Fair Housing Trends Report: source of income cases (opens in a new tab) ↑
Poverty & Race Research Action Council (2026). Appendix B: state laws (California, District of Columbia, New Jersey, New York) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Urban Institute (for the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) (2018). A Pilot Study of Landlord Acceptance of Housing Choice Vouchers (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Choice Vouchers: Tenants (opens in a new tab) ↑