Compliance and Regulation

Seller Impersonation Fraud: Red Flags and Checks

Spot seller impersonation fraud on vacant land and absentee-owned homes: red flags, identity checks, call scripts and a stop-or-proceed table.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. How the scheme works
  2. How common it has become
  3. Red flags at first contact
  4. Identity checks before you sign a listing
  5. Scripts for the verification conversation
  6. Decision table: proceed, pause or stop
  7. Example: a vacant lot that never went live
  8. Close the remote-signing gap
  9. If you suspect fraud after listing
  10. Policy points to write down
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Compliance and Regulation: Seller Impersonation Fraud: Red Flags and ChecksArticle coverCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONSeller ImpersonationFraud: Red Flags andChecksAva for Real Estate TeamsInsightsCompliance and Regulation: Seller Impersonation Fraud: Red Flags and ChecksArticle coverCOMPLIANCE AND REGULATIONSeller ImpersonationFraud: Red Flags andChecksAva for Real Estate Teams

Key takeaways

  • Title firms reporting a seller impersonation attempt rose from 28% in ALTA's 2024 survey to 59% in its 2026 survey[1].
  • Vacant land, absentee owners, free-and-clear properties and recently deceased owners are the usual targets[1].
  • Verify the owner through sources the caller did not give you: tax mailing address, public records and an independent phone number.
  • Refusal to meet or video call, and insistence on a mail-away signing with the seller's own notary, are the strongest warning signs[1].

How the scheme works

A fraudster finds a property with little day-to-day oversight, usually a vacant lot or a house whose owner lives elsewhere. They contact a listing agent by email, text or a call from a new number, claim to be the owner, and ask for a quick sale, often priced below market to attract a cash buyer. They sign remotely, arrange their own notary, and try to have sale proceeds wired to an account they control. The real owner finds out after the deed has been recorded.

The American Land Title Association names vacant land as the top target, followed by properties with absentee owners, properties owned free and clear, and properties linked to recently deceased owners[1]. Each has the same weakness: nobody is checking the mailbox or the title on a regular basis, and there is no mortgage lender whose payoff process might expose the fraud.

The listing agent is often the first professional who talks to the impostor. A five-minute identity check at intake is cheaper than any claim that follows a fraudulent sale.

How common it has become

In ALTA's 2026 survey of title insurance professionals, 59% of firms reported at least one seller impersonation attempt in the prior calendar year, up from 28% in its 2024 survey, and the share reporting an attempt in the prior month rose from 19% to 45%[1]. The two surveys used different samples, so treat the change as a direction of travel rather than an exact growth rate.

Title firms reporting seller impersonation attemptsShare of surveyed title firms; samples differ between surveys
Title firms reporting seller impersonation attemptsColumn chart. Attempt in prior calendar year: 2024 survey 28%, 2026 survey 59%; Attempt in prior month: 2024 survey 19%, 2026 survey 45%.0%20%40%60%Attempt in prior calendar year · 2024 survey: 28%28%Attempt in prior calendar year · 2026 survey: 59%59%Attempt in prior calendar yearAttempt in prior month · 2024 survey: 19%19%Attempt in prior month · 2026 survey: 45%45%Attempt in prior monthTitle firms reporting seller impersonation attemptsColumn chart. Attempt in prior calendar year: 2024 survey 28%, 2026 survey 59%; Attempt in prior month: 2024 survey 19%, 2026 survey 45%.Attempt in prior calendar yearAttempt in prior calendar year · 2024 survey: 28%28%Attempt in prior calendar year · 2026 survey: 59%59%Attempt in prior monthAttempt in prior month · 2024 survey: 19%19%Attempt in prior month · 2026 survey: 45%45%
  • 2024 survey
  • 2026 survey

Source: American Land Title Association, 2026[1]

Show the data
Item2024 survey2026 survey
Attempt in prior calendar year28%59%
Attempt in prior month19%45%

Federal complaint data points the same way. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, up from 9,359 in 2024[2]. That figure covers more than seller impersonation, but it shows how much criminal effort is aimed at property transactions.

12,368

real estate fraud complaints received by the FBI's IC3 in 2025[2]

Red flags at first contact

  • The property is vacant land or an absentee-owned home with no mortgage on record.
  • The seller wants to list below likely market value and close fast, often with a preference for cash buyers.
  • Contact is by email or text only, and the seller avoids meetings, phone calls or video calls.
  • The seller asks for a mail-away signing or wants to use a notary they choose themselves.
  • The seller says they are overseas, deployed or travelling and cannot be reached by phone.
  • The phone number or email does not match anything in public records or prior transaction files.
  • Requests to change where proceeds go arrive late in the transaction or by a new channel.
  • The seller cannot answer simple property questions that a real owner would know, such as how they bought it or who pays the tax bill.

ALTA's respondents identified avoiding meetings or calls and requesting a mail-away signing or seller-chosen notary as the leading red flags[1]. One flag alone does not prove fraud. Two or more on a vacant or absentee-owned property should move the file into enhanced verification.

Identity checks before you sign a listing

  1. Pull the ownership and tax records yourself

    Look up the owner of record and the tax-bill mailing address from the county. Do not rely on documents the caller sends.

  2. Contact the owner through an independent channel

    Mail a letter to the tax mailing address, or call a number found in public records or an old transaction file, and ask the owner to confirm the listing request.

  3. Hold a live video call

    Ask the seller to appear on video with a government ID next to their face. Compare the name and photo with what records show.

  4. Ask knowledge questions

    How and when did they acquire the property? Who handled that closing? Which bank pays the tax bill? Real owners answer easily.

  5. Bring title in early

    Tell the title or escrow company the file has red flags before you sign. Ask whether they will require in-person or approved remote notarization.

  6. Record what you did

    Save each check, date and outcome to the transaction file so a supervisor can see why the listing went ahead or stopped.

ALTA respondents rated ID verification, direct seller contact and multifactor authentication as the most helpful tools[1]. Multifactor authentication matters for your own systems too: a hijacked agent email account is another route into a fraudulent closing.

Scripts for the verification conversation

Real owners rarely object to checks when you explain the reason. Most Americans already expect impostors: nine in ten adults think people often (49%) or sometimes (42%) pretend to be someone else to steal personal information[3].

Opening: “Before we list any vacant or out-of-area property, our office confirms the owner's identity directly. It protects you from someone selling your land without your knowledge. Can we set up a ten-minute video call this week?”

If they refuse: “I understand. Our policy does not allow us to list without a live identity check or confirmation from the owner of record by mail. If that does not work for you, we will not be able to take the listing.”

Do not argue or accuse. A firm, polite policy statement protects the agent and gives the real owner a reason to trust the brokerage.

Decision table: proceed, pause or stop

Example decision rules a brokerage can adapt for vacant and absentee-owned listings
SignalWhat it may meanAction
Owner confirms by mail and video, ID matches recordsLow riskProceed and file the checks
Email-only contact, but owner agrees to a video callUnverified, not suspicious yetPause until the call happens
Seller wants their own notary and a mail-away signingHigh riskTell title, require an approved notary or in-person signing
Contact details do not match any public recordHigh riskSend a letter to the tax mailing address before any listing work
Seller refuses every live contactLikely fraudDecline the listing and notify your broker
Real owner says they did not ask to sellConfirmed attemptStop, preserve records, report it

Example: a vacant lot that never went live

Example (fictional): An agent receives a text from someone claiming to own a two-acre lot outside town. The sender wants it listed at a price well under recent land sales, says they are working abroad, and asks to sign through a notary they will arrange. The agent checks the county records: the lot has no mortgage and the tax bill goes to an address in another state. She mails a letter there and calls the number from a ten-year-old deed record.

The real owner calls back two days later, surprised, and confirms he never contacted anyone. The agent saves the texts, notifies her broker and the title company the brokerage uses, and the owner files a report. No listing was published, no buyer was harmed, and the file shows exactly what the agent did and when.

Close the remote-signing gap

Remote work is normal in real estate. In NAR's 2026 technology report, 79% of REALTORS use e-signature tools[4]. Convenience is not the problem. The problem is an unverified signer on the other end. Agree with your title partners which remote notarization platforms and identity-proofing steps they accept, and write that into your office procedure so agents are not negotiating it file by file.

Pair this with your wire fraud procedures: any change to payout instructions should be confirmed by phone using a number from the file, never one supplied in the same email.

If you suspect fraud after listing

  1. Pause marketing and showings, and tell the broker of record the same day.
  2. Notify the title or escrow company so it can hold funds and flag the property.
  3. Contact the owner of record through the independent channel you verified.
  4. Preserve every email, text, call log and document the impostor sent. Do not delete the thread.
  5. Report the attempt to the FBI's IC3 and local police, and ask the owner whether they want to alert the county recorder.
  6. Review how the file passed intake and update your checklist so the gap is closed for the next agent.

Keep the evidence under your record retention policy, and treat the impostor's documents as sensitive data in line with your privacy obligations.

Policy points to write down

Checks only work when every agent runs them the same way. Put these points in the office manual and in new-agent training, and ask the transaction coordinator to confirm them before any vacant or absentee-owned listing goes live.

  • Which property types trigger enhanced verification: vacant land, no mortgage of record, owner mailing address out of the area, or a recently deceased owner.
  • Which checks are required, who performs them, and where the proof is saved.
  • Who can approve an exception, and that exceptions are recorded with a reason.
  • Which notary and remote signing options the brokerage and its title partners accept.
  • What agents say when a seller refuses checks, using the approved script.
  • How and to whom a suspected attempt is reported internally, and the time limit for doing it.

Review the list once a year with your title partners. Fraud patterns change, and the people who see attempted closings first are often the escrow officers, not the agents.

Frequently asked questions

What is seller impersonation fraud?

A criminal poses as the owner of a property, usually vacant land or an absentee-owned home, lists it with an agent, signs remotely and collects the sale proceeds. The real owner learns of the sale later[1].

Which properties are most at risk?

ALTA's 2026 study names vacant land as the top target, followed by absentee-owned properties, properties owned free and clear and those linked to recently deceased owners[1].

What should an agent do if a seller refuses a video call?

Verify ownership another way, such as a letter to the tax mailing address. If the seller refuses every live or independent check, decline the listing and tell your broker.

Where do we report a suspected attempt?

Tell your broker and the title company first, then report to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center and local police. Keep every message the impostor sent.

References

  1. American Land Title Association (2026). Seller Impersonation Fraud Study (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Association of REALTORS® (2026). REALTORS® Adopt Technology to Save Time and Improve the Client Experience, NAR Report Finds (2026 REALTORS® Technology Report) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo