Key takeaways
- Screen every new caller the same way before a first meeting; consistency protects agents and keeps you on the right side of fair housing[1].
- Verify identity with a call back to the number given, a full name and email, and photo ID at the first in-person meeting.
- Share every first meeting’s address, time and caller details with someone who will check in.
- Treat urgency, refusal to give details and pressure to meet alone at a vacant home as red flags, and slow down.
Why the first phone call is a safety step
Agents meet strangers in empty houses for a living. They do it in the evening and at weekends, because that is when clients are free[2], and they often do it alone. The typical REALTOR is 57 years old and two in three are women[3]. None of that makes the job unsafe by itself, but it does mean the few minutes on the phone before a first meeting are the cheapest safety tool an agent has.
Screening is not only about physical danger. Real estate is also a target for fraud. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center logged a sharp rise in real estate fraud complaints between 2024 and 2025[4], and nine in ten Americans believe people often or sometimes pretend to be someone else to steal personal information[5]. A caller who will not say who they are may be a risk to you, to your seller or to the next buyer.
Source: FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), 2025[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024 | 9,359 complaints |
| 2025 | 12,368 complaints |
One routine for every caller
Apply the same screening to every new caller who wants to meet, whatever their name, voice, accent or story. The Fair Housing Act bars treating people differently based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability[1]. A written routine applied to everyone is both safer and fairer than gut feel.
Write the routine down and give it to everyone who answers the phones, including assistants and any answering service. Then follow it even when the caller sounds friendly, the listing is busy and you are in a hurry. Most incidents begin with a shortcut taken on a busy day.
The screening steps
Get the basics
Full name, mobile number, email address and the property they want to see. Ask how they found the listing.
Call back to verify the number
Hang up and call the number they gave. It confirms the number is real and reaches them. Be wary of numbers that only accept texts.
Ask a few natural questions
Timeline, where they live now, whether they have spoken with a lender, whether they are working with another agent. Real buyers answer these easily.
Explain the next steps
A written buyer agreement before touring, and photo ID at the first meeting. Say it as a standard practice, which it is.
Meet first somewhere public
Offer the office or a coffee shop for a first conversation, especially for vacant homes, evening showings and callers you could not verify.
Share the plan
Send the address, time, the caller’s name and number and your expected finish time to a colleague or family member who will check in.
Check ID at the meeting
Look at a photo ID, and where your office policy allows, photograph it or have the visitor sign in at the office first.
Before you tour with a buyer, you will need a written buyer agreement anyway; NAR’s rules require one before touring a home with an agent, in person or virtually[6]. Signing it at the office gives you a natural first meeting place and a record of who the client is.
Scripts that sound professional, not suspicious
Callers rarely object to screening when it is framed as a normal business practice. Keep the tone friendly and matter-of-fact.
- “I’d be glad to show it. For every new client, I start with a quick meeting at our office and a copy of a photo ID. It takes ten minutes, and then we can go straight over.”
- “Let me call you right back from my office line so you have my number saved.”
- “Our brokerage asks every buyer for the same few details before a first showing. Can I grab your email and how you heard about the home?”
- “I’ll be bringing a colleague on Saturday, so you’ll meet two of us.”
If someone pushes back hard against ordinary steps that every buyer is asked to follow, that tells you something too.
Red flags and what to do
| Red flag | What it can mean | Response |
|---|---|---|
| Will not give a full name or a working number | Not a serious buyer, or something worse | No meeting until verified |
| Insists on meeting alone at a vacant home, often at dusk | Seeking isolation | Offer the office or bring a colleague |
| Unusual urgency: must see it tonight, cash, no lender | Possible pressure tactic or fraud | Slow down; verify before any meeting |
| Story changes between calls | Inconsistent identity | Ask again; do not meet until it is clear |
| Claims to be the owner of vacant land or a rental and wants to list fast, by email only | Possible seller impersonation | Verify ownership independently with title and public records |
| Refuses ID at the meeting | Unknown identity | Do not enter the property |
Seller impersonation deserves extra care. Criminals sometimes pose as the owners of vacant land or rentals and try to sell property they do not own, communicating only by email or text. Verify the owner through public records, the title company and a call to a number you found yourself, not one provided in the email.
Share your plan every time
The single most useful habit is telling someone where you are. It takes thirty seconds and removes the worst-case scenario of nobody knowing where to look.
- Use a shared calendar or a safety app that holds the address, the client’s name and number and your end time.
- Agree a check-in: you text when you arrive and when you leave. If the second text does not come, your contact calls.
- Agree a distress phrase you can say on a call that sounds normal, such as “Can you pull the red file for me?”, and what your contact does when they hear it.
- Park on the street facing out, not in the driveway where you can be blocked in.
- Walk behind visitors, not in front of them, and keep your phone and keys on you.
- Leave if anything feels wrong. You do not need to explain.
What brokers should put in place
Individual habits are not enough when the brokerage’s phone is the front door. Brokers and team leaders can make the safe path the easy path for every agent, including the newest ones who most want to say yes to any appointment.
- A one-page screening policy that every agent and assistant signs, with the steps and scripts above.
- A visitor sign-in at the office with photo ID for first meetings, kept for a set period and then deleted.
- A shared showing calendar or safety app that office staff can see, so someone always knows where agents are.
- A buddy rule for vacant homes, evening showings and any caller who could not be verified.
- An incident log where agents report uncomfortable calls or meetings, reviewed monthly and shared without blame.
- Annual training that covers safety and fair housing together, so agents learn to screen behavior, not people.
Put the screening questions into whatever handles your calls when agents are busy, from the front desk to an answering service. If every new caller already has a verified name, number and email in the CRM before the agent calls back, the agent starts from a safer place and the client sees an organized brokerage rather than a suspicious one.
Example: an evening request on a vacant listing
Example: at 4:30 p.m. a fictional caller asks to see a vacant listing at 7 p.m. that evening and says he is paying cash. The agent takes his name and number, calls him back and reaches a voicemail with a different name. She texts that she starts every new client with a short meeting at the office and a photo ID, and offers 10 a.m. the next day. He replies that he is only in town tonight and stops answering. The agent logs the call, tells the listing agent and moves on with her evening. The next caller, a couple who were happy to come to the office, signs a buyer agreement at 10 a.m. and tours the home at 11.
Screening did not cost the agent a real client. It cost one evening appointment with someone who would not say who he was. For the rest of your phone process, see measuring answer and missed-call rates, and for securing properties, lockbox access and showing security.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to ask a buyer for ID before a showing?
Many brokerages ask every new client for photo ID before a first showing. Apply the policy to everyone the same way and follow your state’s rules on storing ID copies.
What if a caller refuses to meet at the office first?
Offer a public place or bring a colleague to the property. If they refuse every reasonable option, do not meet them.
Does screening put off real buyers?
Rarely. Framed as standard practice, most buyers expect it, and it fits naturally with signing the written buyer agreement required before touring[6].
Should an answering service or assistant screen callers too?
Yes. Give them the same written routine so every caller is asked the same questions, and have them pass on anything that seems off.
References
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2026). Housing Discrimination Under the Fair Housing Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2026). Experienced REALTORS® Anchor the Industry as Housing Affordability Remains Top Hurdle (2026 Member Profile) (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2025). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Association of REALTORS® (2024). Consumer Guide: Written Buyer Agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑