Key takeaways
- State license laws set file minimums of three to five years, and Texas names substantive communications with the parties as records[2][3][4][5].
- Sort calls and texts by what they say: deal-changing messages join the transaction file, consent proof is kept 5 years[1][6], and routine calls get a short clock.
- Keeping everything is a risk of its own; California expects a stated retention period per category and nothing kept longer than reasonably necessary[7].
- A hold stops deletion the moment a complaint, claim or regulator letter arrives[8].
Phones are where the file goes missing
A brokerage can keep a spotless transaction file and still lose the one message that mattered. The repair credit agreed by text at 10 pm. The voicemail in which the buyer's agent asked for two more days on financing. The recorded call where the seller said to take the second offer. None of it reaches the file unless someone moves it there.
License law already reaches some of this. Texas requires brokers to keep records for at least four years from closing, termination of the contract or the end of the transaction, in a format readily available to the Commission, and its list includes substantive communications with parties to the transaction[2]. California sets three years from closing and says brokers need not keep electronic messages of an ephemeral nature[3]. Florida sets at least five years from receipt of entrusted funds, or from execution of the agreement when no funds were entrusted[4]. New York requires three years of records for each residential transaction[5].
| State | Minimum | Clock starts | Note for phones and texts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | 4 years[2] | Closing, termination of the contract or end of the transaction | Substantive communications with parties are listed records |
| California | 3 years[3] | Closing, or the listing date if it never closes | Ephemeral electronic messages need not be kept |
| Florida | 5 years[4] | Receipt of entrusted funds, or execution of the agreement | Records used in litigation: 2 more years after the case ends |
| New York | 3 years[5] | Check the rule for the start date | Paper or electronic records both count |
California's carve-out is narrower than it looks. The state's Civil Code also says a text or instant message, on its own, is not enough to form a contract to convey real property without a conforming written confirmation[9]. A text being optional to keep is not the same as a text being irrelevant in a dispute. The general file rules are in record retention requirements for brokerages; this article covers the phone and the text thread.
Sort by what a message says, not where it lives
A schedule that says “keep texts for four years” fails in both directions. It keeps thousands of “running five minutes late” messages and still misses the voice note in which the seller accepted. Sort by content instead. Three tiers cover almost everything a phone produces.
| Tier | What goes in it | Example | Keep for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Transaction record | Anything that changes price, terms, deadlines, repairs, access or representation | A seller's text accepting a repair credit | With the transaction file, for the longest state minimum that applies |
| 2. Compliance proof | Consent to calls and texts, opt-outs, do-not-call requests, recording notice versions | A lead's opt-out reply, logged with the date | 5 years[1][6] |
| 3. Routine traffic | Ordinary inquiries, scheduling chatter, wrong numbers, vendor calls | “Is the open house still on?” | A short period you choose, then delete |
The tier 2 period comes from federal rules. Under the Telemarketing Sales Rule, sellers and telemarketers keep call detail records, scripts and records of consent for 5 years from the date each record is produced[1]. A company-specific do-not-call request must be honored for 5 years from when it is made[6], so the record of that request has to last at least as long.
Tier 3 is where offices hoard. A routine recording with no deal content has no license-law reason to exist once the inquiry is handled, and every month it sits in storage it is one more file of names, numbers and life details. Pick a period and hold to it. Example: 90 days for routine recordings and transcripts, long enough to settle who called about what.
Texts on agents' own phones
Texting is how buyers want to talk. In Zillow's 2026 survey, 43% of buyers said text was their preferred way to communicate with their agent, ahead of phone calls at 31%[10]. That puts tier 1 records on devices the brokerage does not own, in threads mixed with family photos, inside apps it cannot search.
- Use a business texting number for client work where possible, so threads live in an account the brokerage controls. Texting from a business number covers registration.
- When a text changes the deal, the agent exports it into the transaction file the same day and notes the decision beside it.
- Ban disappearing-message settings and apps for client business, without exceptions for “quick questions.”
- When an agent leaves, check their open files for missing message exports before access is removed. The BYOD policy guide covers the agreement language.
An export beats a screenshot when the tool offers one, because it keeps the date, time and numbers on every message. When a screenshot is all an agent can manage, it should show the contact name or number and the timestamps, and it goes into the file with a one-line note saying what was agreed. A cropped image of two bubbles proves very little two years later.
Recordings and transcripts from answering tools
An answered call now leaves copies in several places. With an SI Employee on the line, each call produces a recording, a transcript and a summary in the account, the summary also lands in the inbox of the person the brokerage chose, and a webhook can send it on to the CRM. That is four copies of one conversation, each with its own default lifespan.
Map the copies before setting periods. For each tool, write down what it stores, where, for how long by default, and who can delete a single call. Ask each vendor whether you can set a retention period, whether deleting a call also removes the transcript and backups, and what happens to the data when you leave. If a tool keeps calls until someone deletes them, the schedule needs a named person and a monthly date. How summaries reach a CRM matters too: a summary copied into CRM notes takes on the CRM's retention, not the phone tool's.
Timestamps earn their keep. In the property management example, every overnight call is recorded and summarized with the time it came in, which matters when a repair deadline runs from notice. A routine call graduates to tier 1 the day someone disputes when they reported the problem.
Source: FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), 2026[11]
Show the data
| Year | Complaints |
|---|---|
| 2024 | 9,359 complaints |
| 2025 | 12,368 complaints |
Hoarding has a cost. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center logged 12,368 real estate fraud complaints in 2025, up from 9,359 in 2024[11]. Old recordings and text threads hold what fraudsters want: closing dates, lender names, and how the people in a deal talk and write. The FTC's guidance for businesses is plain: keep only what you need, keep it only as long as necessary, and properly dispose of what you no longer need[12]. California adds a disclosure duty: tell consumers how long you intend to keep each category of personal information, and do not keep it longer than reasonably necessary for the purpose you disclosed[7].
Holds beat schedules
Deletion stops as soon as a dispute is reasonably expected. Federal courts can act when electronically stored information that should have been preserved in anticipation of litigation is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it[8]. Florida's license law keeps records used as evidence in litigation for at least two years after the civil action ends, and never less than five years in total[4].
- A complaint to the brokerage, the license regulator or a fair housing agency. The fair housing complaint process covers what follows.
- A demand letter, a call from an attorney, or a claim about calls or texts under the TCPA.
- A claim on the brokerage's errors and omissions policy.
- A regulator's audit or inquiry; handling license complaints covers the response.
When a trigger hits, flag every record for the people and properties involved, including routine recordings due for deletion that week, and tell agents in writing not to delete texts. Lift the hold in writing too, so routine deletion can resume.
A schedule you can adopt
- System
- Your team
01System
Call ends
Recording, transcript and summary saved; the summary is emailed to the agent.
02Your team
Agent tags the tier
Transaction, compliance or routine, within one business day.
03Your team
Tier 1 copied to the file
Summary and recording reference attached to the transaction record.
04Your team
Hold check before deletion
Any open complaint, claim or audit on these parties stops deletion.
05Your team
Routine copies deleted
On the scheduled date, from every system, with a deletion log entry.
Example flow. Tagging takes seconds when the summary already says what the call was about.
List the states
Every state where the brokerage holds a license, with its retention rule and the event that starts the clock.
Map every system
Phone system, answering tool, texting platform, email, CRM, transaction platform and agents' phones.
Set the three tiers
The longest applicable state minimum for tier 1, five years for tier 2, a short fixed period for tier 3.
Name owners
One person per system runs deletion on a fixed date each month and writes the log.
Write the hold rule
Who can place a hold, what it covers, how agents are told and who lifts it.
Tell clients
Add retention periods for recordings, transcripts and texts to the privacy notice. Consumer data privacy laws for brokerages covers the notice.
Test once a quarter
Pick a closed file and check every tier 1 message is in it; pick a routine recording past its date and check it is gone everywhere.
Deleting so it stays deleted
Deletion that leaves copies behind is not deletion. A routine recording removed from the phone system may still sit in the answering tool, in an email attachment, in a CRM note and in a backup. When the date comes, the person who owns each system deletes the item there, and the log records what was deleted, from where, on what date and on whose approval.
Check backups separately. Ask each vendor how long deleted items survive in its backups and say so in your schedule, rather than promising clients a deletion date the vendor cannot meet. The data breach response plan is the other half of this: whatever you still hold on the day of an incident is what you may have to report.
Example: a 12-agent office in Texas
Example: a fictional 12-agent brokerage licensed only in Texas takes about 600 calls a month across its main and listing lines, all recorded and transcribed. Keeping everything for four years would mean about 28,800 recordings on file at any time, nearly all of them routine. Under the three tiers, agents tag roughly one call in twenty as tier 1, about 30 a month, and those go into transaction files for four years from closing. Consent and opt-out records go to a compliance folder for five years. Everything else is deleted after 90 days, which leaves about 1,700 routine recordings on hand at any time instead of 28,800.
Example: the broker also adds one line to the privacy notice, “routine call recordings and transcripts are kept for 90 days,” and one to the agent manual, “texts that change a deal go into the file the same day.” Those two sentences carry most of the policy. The rest is a monthly calendar reminder and somebody who actually runs it.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a brokerage keep text messages with clients?
By content. Texts that change price, terms or deadlines belong in the transaction file for your state's minimum, such as four years in Texas[2] or five in Florida[4]. Routine texts can follow a short schedule.
Do we have to keep every call recording?
No general rule requires recording every call or keeping every recording. Once you record, a recording that captures a substantive communication can be part of the file in states that list those communications as records[2]. The TSR's call detail records are logs, not audio, kept for 5 years[1].
A client asked us to delete their call recordings. Can we?
Usually, for routine recordings, unless the recording is a transaction record you must keep or a hold applies. Your privacy notice should already say how long recordings are kept[7].
Are voicemails records?
Treat them like recordings. A voicemail extending a deadline is tier 1; a voicemail asking about parking at the open house is tier 3.
What about an agent who leaves with client texts on their phone?
The duty to keep records stays with the broker. Require message exports into the file during the deal, and check open files before the agent's access ends.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 16 CFR § 310.5 - Recordkeeping requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 22 Tex. Admin. Code § 535.2 - Broker Responsibility (opens in a new tab) ↑
Public.Law (California Business and Professions Code) (2026). California Business and Professions Code § 10148 - Retention of records (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes § 475.5015 - Brokerage business records (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 19 NYCRR § 175.23 - Records of transactions to be maintained (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Public.Law (California Civil Code) (2026). California Civil Code § 1798.100 - General duties of businesses that collect personal information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 37 - Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Public.Law (California Civil Code) (2026). California Civil Code § 1624 - Statute of frauds (opens in a new tab) ↑
Zillow Research (2026). Buyers: Results from the Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) (2026). Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2026). Protecting Personal Information: A Guide for Business (opens in a new tab) ↑