Key takeaways
- The TCPA allows $500 per violating call or text, up to three times that if willful, and a do-not-call claim needs only two calls in 12 months[2].
- Real estate settlements have run from $400,000 over one agent's texts to $40 million over calls across a franchise system[1][3].
- The defendants were brokerage and franchisor companies, sued over calls and texts their agents made[4][3].
- Class periods reached back four years before filing[4][5], so today's dialing habits are evidence for years.
Three settlements, one pattern
Three real estate TCPA settlements show the range: $40 million over prerecorded calls in a national franchise system, $20 million over agents' dialer calls and recorded messages, and $400,000 over texts sent by a single agent[1][4][3]. The defendants denied the allegations in the two federal cases[4][3], and a settlement is not a finding that anyone broke the law. The pattern is still worth studying. In each case, ordinary prospecting done one call or one text at a time was logged by software, counted, and turned into a class.
$40M
Prerecorded and registry calls; Florida state court; about two million class members[1]
$20M
Agents' dialer calls and prerecorded messages, 2015 to 2020; federal court in California[4]
$400K
One agent's texts to 1,019 registered numbers; federal court in New York[3]
$53,088
Maximum FTC civil penalty per Telemarketing Sales Rule violation[6]
Settlement funds include fees and administration. Defendants denied wrongdoing.
How the damages add up
The TCPA puts a price on each violation rather than on harm. A consumer can recover actual losses or $500 per violation, whichever is greater, and a court can raise that to as much as three times for willful or knowing violations. For do-not-call claims the trigger is low: more than one telephone call within any 12-month period by or on behalf of the same business, in violation of the rules[2]. Every text counts as a call for this purpose, and every call after the first is another violation.
Source: U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, 2025[3]
Show the data
| Measure | US dollars |
|---|---|
| Settlement fund | $400,000 |
| Example: $500 per text, two texts per number | $1,019,000 |
| Example: trebled for willful violations | $3,057,000 |
Example: take the New York texting case. The class covered 1,019 registered numbers that each received more than one text from the agent[3]. At the statutory $500, two texts per number is $1,019,000 of potential damages, and $3,057,000 if a court trebled it[2]. The case settled for $400,000[3]. Settlements usually land well below the theoretical maximum, because both sides carry risk at trial. The theoretical maximum is still what the brokerage's lawyers have to price.
The same statute gives the brokerage its main defense. In a do-not-call suit, it is an affirmative defense that the defendant established and implemented, with due care, reasonable practices and procedures to prevent violating calls[2]. That defense lives or dies on records: a written policy, training logs, scrub dates and a working internal do-not-call list.
A Saturday call block, priced
Big settlements make the risk feel distant. The same arithmetic applies to a small team on an ordinary weekend, and the second call is what turns an annoyance into a claim.
Example: a four-agent team works a list of 600 expired and FSBO numbers on Saturday without scrubbing it. Suppose 200 of the numbers are registered, and each of those homeowners gets a second call or a follow-up text within the month. That is 200 people who each meet the two-calls-in-12-months trigger, with up to $1,000 each at $500 per call, or $200,000 of theoretical exposure from one list[2]. If a court found the calls willful, the ceiling triples.
Nothing about that team is unusual. Expired and FSBO lists are full of registered numbers, follow-up is what good prospecting coaches teach, and dialers make the second touch automatic. The fix is equally ordinary: scrub before the first dial, record any exemption, and let a do-not-call request stop every tool at once. Dialer choice matters less than how the lists feed it, covered in power dialer vs parallel dialer and calling expireds and FSBOs on the Do Not Call list.
Why one complaint becomes a class
Few consumers would hire a lawyer over two unwanted calls worth $1,000. A class of thousands changes the math, and real estate prospecting produces classes naturally, because the software that makes dialing efficient also records every call. In the $20 million case, the classes were defined by the dialers' own records: calls with a non-zero duration or a disposition other than no answer, and recorded messages identified by the dialers' disposition codes[4]. In the New York case, the 1,019 numbers were identified from records produced by a real estate CRM company[3].
Time works against the defendant too. Federal claims under statutes passed after December 1, 1990 generally have four years from when the claim accrues, unless another law says otherwise[7]. The TCPA dates from 1991. In the $20 million case, the suit was filed on June 11, 2019 and the class period began on June 11, 2015[4]. In the New York case, the suit was filed on June 24, 2024 and the class covered texts from June 24, 2020[5]. A team's dialing habits this year can be counted in a complaint filed four years from now.
The three cases side by side
| Case | What was alleged | Who was in the class | Fund | Practice changes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DeShay v. Keller Williams (Florida state court, filed 2022) | Unsolicited prerecorded calls, including to registered numbers | About two million people; up to $20 per claim | $40 million, including $10.2 million for administration, fees and costs | TCPA task force; more visible Do Not Call resources and materials for franchisees (about $7.8 million allotted) |
| Bumpus v. Realogy (N.D. Cal., filed 2019) | Calls by affiliated agents on three dialers to registered numbers, and prerecorded messages | Two or more registry calls in 12 months, or a recorded message, 2015 to 2020 | $20 million, all costs and fees included | Do Not Contact Manual, agent compliance certificate, TCPA warnings in training, periodic reminders |
| Nicotra v. Bayside NY Homes (E.D.N.Y., filed 2024) | Texts by one agent to registered numbers | 1,019 numbers texted more than once in 12 months | $400,000, paying administration, fees and a service award first | Not described in the class notice |
Look at what the claims were built on. All three involved the National Do Not Call Registry, and two involved recorded messages[1][4][3]. As described, the claims rested on registry status and recorded messages rather than on proving what kind of dialing equipment was used. That is where a brokerage's exposure usually sits: not in exotic technology, but in calling and texting registered numbers without a current exemption, and in recorded messages sent without written consent.
Where the money goes
Headline numbers are not what consumers receive. In the $40 million case, about two million class members could claim up to $20 each, $10.2 million went to administration, attorneys' fees and costs, and roughly $7.8 million was allotted to changing business practices[1]. In the $20 million case, every payment to class members, every fee award and all administration costs came out of the one fund[4]. In the New York case, administration, fees and a service award were paid first and the rest split among class members who claimed[3].
None of those figures include the defendant's own legal bills, the staff time spent producing years of call records, or the compliance programs that followed. For a mid-sized brokerage without a franchisor behind it, a case the size of the New York settlement is a serious year.
Who gets named
Agents often assume that as independent contractors they carry their own risk. The cases say otherwise. The do-not-call claim reaches calls made by or on behalf of a business[2], and the $20 million case named the parent real estate company and its brokerage arm over calls by agents affiliated with one of its brands[4]. The New York case was brought against the brokerage over one agent's texts sent on its behalf[3]. The FTC's rule treats both the seller and the telemarketer as potentially liable, with civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation[6].
Outsourcing the dialing does not move the risk either. When an ISA service or calling vendor works your lists, the calls are still made on the brokerage's behalf, and a do-not-call request the vendor records but fails to honor is the brokerage's failure under the FCC's rule[8]. Contracts should say how the vendor scrubs, how it receives your internal list and how fast it returns new requests.
The practical point for a broker of record: supervision of agents' prospecting is not optional, and a policy nobody enforces will not help. Errors and omissions coverage is not something to assume either; read the exclusions in your policy, and see E&O insurance for agents.
Why outcomes are harder to predict now
Two 2025 decisions moved the ground. In January, the Eleventh Circuit vacated the FCC's one-to-one consent rule before it took effect, covered in the FCC one-to-one consent rule: what happened. In June, the Supreme Court held that district courts in enforcement cases are not bound by an agency's interpretation of a statute[9]. Judges now read the TCPA for themselves. For defendants that means fewer FCC rulings to point to as settled answers, and more variation from court to court. State statutes add another layer; Florida's, for example, has its own rules for text solicitations[10], and the main ones are in state mini-TCPA laws.
Habits that keep a brokerage out of court
Approve every calling and texting tool
No personal dialer accounts, no free trials of new texting apps. Each tool is approved, connected to the brokerage's lists and logged.
Scrub on a 31-day cycle
Use a copy of the registry no more than 31 days old for every prospecting list, and keep the scrub records[8].
Run one internal do-not-call list
Every request, in any words, logged the same day and pushed to every tool and vendor.
No recorded or synthetic voices without written consent
Prerecorded and artificial-voice telemarketing needs prior express written consent[8]. That covers voicemail drops; see ringless voicemail rules.
Prove every exemption
Past-client and inquiry calls to registered numbers need a dated relationship in the CRM; see established business relationships.
Respect calling hours
No solicitations before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the consumer's location under federal rules[8]; some states are stricter. See calling hours and frequency limits.
When a demand letter arrives, stop contacting the consumer, preserve every call log, text thread, consent record and list entry for the number, and bring in counsel before replying. The records you keep now are the ones that answer the letter.
Inbound calls carry far less of this risk
Every case above began with an outbound call or text. A consumer calling you is the opposite situation: they chose to call, and answering is not a telephone solicitation. In the solo listing agent example, about 35 calls a week come in from sign riders, portal pages and her website, and the work is making sure they get answered during showings.
An SI Employee answers forwarded calls, with a greeting that can carry an automated-assistant disclosure and a recording notice the business approves, and it does not dial prospecting lists (what it does). Recording rules vary by state, covered in call recording consent rules by state. For the outbound side, the broader legal framework is in TCPA rules for real estate agents.
Frequently asked questions
Can an individual agent be sued, or only the brokerage?
Both can be at risk. The do-not-call claim covers calls made by or on behalf of a business[2], and the settlements above were with real estate companies, not individual agents, over calls and texts their agents made[4][3].
How far back can a TCPA claim reach?
Federal claims under laws passed after December 1, 1990 generally have four years[7]. In two federal real estate cases, the class periods began exactly four years before filing[4][5].
Do texts count the same as calls?
Yes for these purposes. The New York settlement was built entirely on texts to registered numbers sent more than once in 12 months[3].
Is a settlement an admission of wrongdoing?
No. In the two federal cases the defendants denied the allegations and settled to end the litigation[4][3].
What records help most if a claim arrives?
The ones behind the statutory defense of reasonable practices and procedures[2]: the written do-not-call policy, training records, registry scrub dates, the internal list with request dates, and consent or relationship evidence for each number called.
References
Manatt, Phelps & Phillips (2023). $40M TCPA Settlement for Real Estate Company (TCPA Connect) (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 47 U.S. Code Β§ 227, Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York (2025). Notice of Class Action Settlement, Nicotra v. Bayside NY Homes LLC, No. 1:24-cv-04459 (E.D.N.Y.) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (court filing) (2025). Settlement Agreement, Bumpus v. Realogy Holdings Corp., No. 3:19-cv-03309-JD (N.D. Cal.) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York (court filing) (2025). Class Action Settlement Agreement, Nicotra v. Bayside NY Homes LLC, No. 1:24-cv-04459-FB-SDE (E.D.N.Y.) (opens in a new tab) β
Federal Trade Commission (2026). Q&A for Telemarketers & Sellers About DNC Provisions in TSR (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code text) (2026). 28 U.S. Code Β§ 1658, Time limitations on the commencement of civil actions (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (eCFR text) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200, Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., No. 23-1226 (2025) (opens in a new tab) β
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 501.059, Telephone solicitation (opens in a new tab) β